China Tells Trump 'This is Not How a U.S. President Should Behave' After North Korea Tweet

Updated | China has rejected President Donald Trump's accusations that it was illegally supplying oil to North Korea, criticizing Friday the Republican leader's evidence, and his demeanor.

Trump launched the allegation Thursday via a tweet in which he claimed China had been "caught RED HANDED" shipping oil into North Korea, a violation of the strict United Nations Security Council sanctions punishing the reclusive, authoritarian state for its unwillingness to abandon an increasingly powerful ballistic and nuclear weapons program. In response, the ruling Chinese Communist Party's official organ published a commentary questioning the U.S. and South Korea's interpretation of the satellite imagery allegedly showing Chinese ships transferring oil to North Korean boats in the Yellow Sea.

Related: China and Russia Train for War With U.S. If Trump Invades North Korea

"In the photos, North Korean boats appeared to be linking up with Chinese vessels. These 'Chinese vessels' are not oil tankers and are not large-tonnage. U.S. and South Korean media believe these photos prove China violated U.N. Security Council resolutions to transfer oil to North Korea, but even in the reports it is unclear where the vessels come from or whom they belong to," The Global Times wrote Friday.

"Trump's tweet is one of the strongest responses from the U.S. and South Korea. He concluded that China was caught before the truth was clarified and commented in a strong tone. This is not how a U.S. president should behave," it continued.

RTS1J67O President Donald Trump (right) and Chinese President Xi Jinping (left) arrive for a state dinner at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, on November 9. Jonathan Ernst/Reuters

The claims appeared Wednesday in the South Korean newspaper The Chosun Ilbo, which cited South Korean government sources saying U.S. reconnaissance captured Chinese ships secretly providing oil to their North Korean counterparts about 30 times since October. Just before Trump ran with the claim on his personal Twitter account, Chinese Defense Ministry spokesperson Ren Guoqiang immediately denied the U.S. and South Korea's version of events, saying, "The situation you have mentioned absolutely does not exist." The Chinese Foreign Ministry also dismissed the charges on Friday, blaming "hyped-up media reports."

"The fact is that since August, there have been no records of this ship docking, entering or leaving a China's port. Whether this ship has ever called at other countries' ports is not ours to tell. Therefore, what these reports claimed is not true," Chinese Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying told reporters.

"China has been comprehensively and strictly implementing the Security Council resolutions and fulfilling its due international obligations," she added.

Like the U.S., China is a permanent member of the U.N. Security Council and has voted in favor of sanctions against North Korea, despite being its greatest traditional ally. China too, however, has been deeply critical of the U.S.'s growing military presence and activity in Asia-Pacific, where Washington disputes Beijing's extensive territorial claims at sea and has deployed advanced missile defense systems.

Despite China's denials, South Korean government officials revealed Friday that on November 24 they seized the Hong Kong-flagged Lighthouse Winmore vessel alleged to have delivered 600 tons of refined petroleum to North Korea and the vessel's crew, which consists of 23 Chinese nationals and two from Myanmar, were being held in the southern South Korean port city of Yeosu, the official Yonhap News Agency reported. The crew would be released following an investigation and officials said crew testimonies suggested a Taiwanese company had ordered the oil transaction, according to the South China Morning Post.

Both China and its rival government in Taiwan have said they had no knowledge of the incident or the vessel's seizure.

ChinaNorthKoreaOil Images dated October 19 depict what the Department of the Treasury says was an "attempt by Korea Kumbyol Trading Company's vessel Rye Song Gang 1 to conduct a ship-to-ship transfer, possibly of oil, in an effort to evade sanctions." U.S. Department of the Treasury

Since Trump took office in January, he has attempted to adopt a hard-line stance against his North Korean rival, supreme leader Kim Jong Un, who has argued his nuclear weapons were necessary to defend against a potential U.S. invasion. Despite Trump intensifying U.S. military drills and economic sanctions against Kim's government, the young ruler has managed this year to conduct his country's first intercontinental ballistic missiles tests as well as a sixth, by far more powerful, nuclear weapons test.

Both Trump and Kim have earned international criticism for continuously threatening and insulting each other as the crisis escalated on the Korean Peninsula. China and Russia, which shared China's opposition to expanding U.S. military influence in the region, have appealed for calm and urged Trump especially to rescind his administration's warnings that military force could be used to try to disarm Kim's arsenal—something North Korea has promised would be met with nuclear destruction.

Chinese experts also warned Saturday that Trump's decision to immediately blame China for the oil shipments before the incident had been fully investigated would only hurt bilateral relations and argued his sanctions strategy was proving ineffective against North Korea.

“Smuggling is very hard to eradicate—it’s a challenge for every government. We can see that even the U.S. government can’t stop the flow of illicit drugs from Mexico over a land border," Sun Xingjie, a specialist in North Korean affairs at China's Jilin University, told the South China Morning Post.

“Trump’s tweets reflect a simplistic attitude to the North Korea issue, totally ignoring that it’s becoming increasingly more difficult to stifle Pyongyang’s [nuclear ambitions] through sanctions,” Sun added.

This story has been updated with more details about South Korea's seizure of the Hong Kong-flagged vessel alleged to have delivered oil to North Korean boats, as well as expert commentary provided Saturday to the South China Morning Post about Trump's tweet.

Join the Discussion