The Internet? Bah!

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: jdempcy @ 03/23/2008 9:46:16 PM

    I just Googled "battle of trafalgar" and followed the very first link, to the Wikipedia entry. It contained the date of the battle. I'm not sure about the other results you encountered but I assure you, the Internet is an immensely helpful research tool. While it will never replace human interaction, it can certainly facilitate ever-greater knowledge-sharing and new possibilities for learning.

  • Posted By: GJAX @ 03/23/2008 4:43:36 PM

    not sure who is dumber....the guy who wrote this or all you people commenting like it was written today...this was written in NINETEEN NINETY FIVE!!!!! In all fairness to the author, do a little searching back to 1995 and this perspective was widespread.....and in fact alot of the examples people give to refute this article are a direct result from the proliferation of this limited perspective and the challenge to disprove it.

    • Posted By: PatrynXX @ 03/23/2008 9:25:16 PM

      Can't believe this silly thing is now the number 2 article of the day. Stupid people breed more stupid people and before you know it it's number one. So are we partying like its 1995??

  • Posted By: Geminate @ 03/23/2008 9:06:38 PM

    Written almost 13 years ago by a non-visionist.

  • Posted By: indigosonic @ 03/23/2008 7:54:53 PM

    I agree with GJAX , and i would like to know how old jimglidewell is, because he should know that google didn't even exist in 1995, google wasn't founded until 1998 and was created as a direct result of internet search's not bringing back relevant data for there quarries. I guess it's hard for todays kids to imagine a time before google , youtube, and broadband high speed but back in "95" all there was, was dial-up.
    ps per sec , but

  • Posted By: samoth @ 03/23/2008 7:14:17 PM

    http://popurls.com might be a solution

  • Posted By: jimglidewell @ 03/23/2008 4:47:18 PM

    A google search of "battle trafalgar"(no quotes) gives me the date without even clicking on a link. Clearly, Mr. Stoll has an axe to grind, and is willing to bend the truth to "prove" his point.

    In less genteel circles, this is referred to as "lying".

    If this is the best example of how "useless" the Internet is, then I think he can be safely dismissed as a curmudgeon and a crank.

  • Posted By: dswinscoe @ 03/23/2008 4:38:25 PM

    Until I saw the dateline, I was in shock ... the contradiction overload was just too high. Followed by the second thought, almost as powerful: how must the author feel about this now, 13 years later? Fast-forward 2008: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Trafalgar ... copy, paste click! Although, I 'm sure this article will still resonate with many a Luddite today.

  • Posted By: dswinscoe @ 03/23/2008 4:37:26 PM

    Until I saw the dateline, I was in shock ... the contradiction overload was just too high. Followed by the second thought, almost as powerful: how must the author feel about this now, 13 years later? Fast-forward 2008: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Trafalgar ... copy, paste click! Although, I 'm sure this will resonate with many a Luddite today.

  • Posted By: monish21 @ 03/23/2008 4:00:03 PM

    misleading all the way ... The entire article. I hope I could publish an article in response to yours on the Sne website. But you talk about things that you dont like rather than things that are hit possible.

    Goodluck with what you think but Internet is having lives everyday and every second. Just dig into ebay and google to just give you a few examples. (they boy do more online business on an hour to what your local mall dies on a day)

    Dig into what cdrom education is doing to various parts of Africa where its almost impossible to get good teachers.

    Dig why Swizerland has an online embasy in second life.

    Dig why we are reading your article online instead of on a newspaper.

    Internet is not changing the entire world but its sure is changing things.

    Monish Khosla
    monish21@gmail.com

  • Posted By: anschauung @ 03/23/2008 3:57:25 PM

    Actually ... I was just being a smart-aleck, but it looks like the article actually *is* from the mid-90s.
    Whoops!

  • Posted By: dave_J @ 03/23/2008 3:56:55 PM

    You have nothing to say what the internet user already does not know. But you had to write something, so you ramble on. There are many reliable edited sources of info on the net. What the net does is make it available readily to a lot of people, just like your ramble.

  • Posted By: dave_J @ 03/23/2008 3:56:40 PM

    You have nothing to say what the internet user already does not know. But you had to write something, so you ramble on. There are many reliable edited sources of info on the net. What the net does is make it available readily to a lot of people, just like your ramble.

  • Posted By: anschauung @ 03/23/2008 3:54:30 PM

    Thank you Newsweek, for this great flashback article from the mid-90s.

    Its always great to think back to how skeptical we all were 10 years ago, before banking, investments, dating, job hunting, socializing, reading the news, and even book shopping were all done primarily online. It makes for a great reminder of how easy it is to be wrapped up in our own ideas of how things are 'supposed' to be done, to the extent that it blinds us to newer and better ways.

    However, I would recommend that you prominently mention the date this article was published. Without clearly marking it as an archived article, it looks suspiciously like some retrograde curmudgeon is trying to deny that the past decade ever occurred. How embarrassing would that be?

  • Posted By: anschauung @ 03/23/2008 3:54:13 PM

    Thank you Newsweek, for this great flashback article from the mid-90s.

    Its always great to think back to how skeptical we all were 10 years ago, before banking, investments, dating, job hunting, socializing, reading the news, and even book shopping were all done primarily online. It makes for a great reminder of how easy it is to be wrapped up in our own ideas of how things are 'supposed' to be done, to the extent that it blinds us to newer and better ways.

    However, I would recommend that you prominently mention the date this article was published. Without clearly marking it as an archived article, it looks suspiciously like some retrograde curmudgeon is trying to deny that the past decade ever occurred. How embarrassing would that be?

  • Posted By: Wist @ 03/23/2008 3:41:43 PM

    One thing I, as a 47-year-old man, have begun to understand is the ability (or susceptibility) that younger people have to adapt to new technology and integrate it into their lives, simply because it is all they have ever known. Your comments may all be true for "our" generation, but what then? (And by the way, I turned up reliable info on the Battle of Trafalgar in 15 seconds. You must not know where to look. ;)

  • Posted By: headwyvern @ 03/23/2008 3:32:37 PM

    The Battle of Trafalgar was a naval battle west of Cape Trafalgar in the province of Cádiz in south-west Spain. A British fleet of 27 ships of the line destroyed an allied French and Spanish fleet of 33 ships of the line on 21 October 1805 in the most decisive naval engagement of the Napoleonic Wars.
    I agree with you... but wouldn't trans-humanism allow for integration of community and regulation of "the net"

  • Posted By: headwyvern @ 03/23/2008 3:31:01 PM

    The Battle of Trafalgar was a naval battle west of Cape Trafalgar in the province of Cádiz in south-west Spain. A British fleet of 27 ships of the line destroyed an allied French and Spanish fleet of 33 ships of the line on 21 October 1805 in the most decisive naval engagement of the Napoleonic Wars.
    btw, i agree with you... but wouldn't trans-humanism allow for humanity to integrate and regulate the "net"?
    btw, i

  • Posted By: GustoMaybe @ 03/23/2008 3:09:35 PM

    > One or two things may have changed since the.
    e.g. the ugly (but working) Kindle by amazon.

  • Posted By: gjbloom @ 03/23/2008 3:03:58 PM

    Um... the article was copyright 1995. One or two things may have changed since the.

  • Posted By: Joe Stevens @ 03/23/2008 3:03:32 PM

    What are these newspapers that you speak of?

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse