Burying Mitt

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: CP9800 @ 02/07/2008 9:58:13 PM

    Mr Fineman, Mitt Romney did not fail due to the reasons you mentioned. He failed because he cannot win an election when the conservative base is split into three. (Thanks, Huck and Paul) He failed because of headlines like this gem: "Mitt Romney, Mormon millionaire, coasted to victory in a largely uncontested Nevada primary on Saturday." He was given very little credit for his successes.
    Of all the candidates, Romney was the most qualified. He is brilliant, successful, moral, articulate, and civic minded. Mr. Fineman, you are a small minded, liberal journalist engaged in tearing down a giant of a man.
    Thrust out your chest and stand tall, Mr Fineman. At your full heigth, you might be able to bite Mitt's ankle.

  • Posted By: mikesmithcomic @ 02/07/2008 5:46:42 PM

    Maybe now that Mitt's sons are no longer 'serving their country' by working on his campaign, they might consider serving in Iraq, the war their father thinks so highly of.

  • Posted By: Irratical @ 02/07/2008 4:54:24 PM

    I guess Romney can go back to being pro-choice now. What a lying POS.

    • Posted By: PMcAllister @ 02/07/2008 9:45:16 PM

      Based on your logic, you must also believe that Norma McCorvey ("Jane Roe") of Roe v. Wade is also a "lying POS," since she has become vocally pro-life in the past few years. Generally speaking, the longer people live, and the more experience they gain, they have a tendency to become more conservative on the issue of abortion, unless they are lifetime politicians who know that changing their position will win them the "flip-flopper" label and destroy their careers.

    • Posted By: TiKiMaN1 @ 02/07/2008 5:02:59 PM

      I find it ridiculous that you don't believe in the power of change. Sometimes people do change. What right do have to not accept the change or to judge.

  • Posted By: saveus @ 02/07/2008 6:29:45 PM

    I lived in Utah for 6 years and whatever his credentials I would no more vote for a Mormon than i would a Muslim... You go live there and have your children told by their kids that they do not have Gods love because they are Methodist and not Mormon. They will smile at you while they stick the knife in and twist it..Not a big fan of Mccain but .. better than Mitt.

    • Posted By: orrdc @ 02/07/2008 6:37:54 PM

      I've lived in UT as well and this is simply not true. In general the Mormons are good and decent people.

      • Posted By: magic823 @ 02/07/2008 9:43:23 PM

        Yes it is true. I lived in SLC for 12 years.

  • Posted By: keepitreal2008 @ 02/07/2008 6:56:56 PM

    Howard Fineman, for as long as you've been covering politics you are so pathetically off-base in your article about Romney. Gimme a break - your description of Romney is as reliable and accurate as McCain's "straight-talk". I can't believe I'm actually living in the times when the Bible predicted that men "will call good evil, and evil good." Let's find out together Fineman, in a year or two from now, who the liberal media actually buried: Romney - or America. Good thing we Christians believe in the Resurrection. Why don't get yourself some class?!

    • Posted By: magic823 @ 02/07/2008 9:39:14 PM

      Yes he covented in the morg temple to give everything (time, talent and money) to his church under threat of death (that part was removed in 1992). I know because I was married in a morg temple in 1974. The whole ceremony is so distrubing that we quit the morg church.

  • Posted By: hdylaw @ 02/07/2008 9:37:56 PM

    This author could not be any more off base. He is exactly 180 degrees mis-directed. His inquiry should not be directed at the failings of Mitt .Romney, but rather at the structural deficiencies of a political system that weeds out exceptional managerial talent of this sort and leaves us with us with the pedestrian choices we are left with. Those who shape public opinion with the mindless, banal oerspective of this authori are of no help. The story of America has been and continues to ba a matter of failed leadership. It is no wonder that America's prominence in the World is destined to continue to deterioriate. It just amazes me how people who are ostensible so intelligent, such as this authori, are really so incredibly stupid.

  • Posted By: TogetherinParis @ 02/07/2008 9:37:43 PM

    Now Mitt Romney can concentrate all his efforts helping the anti-Hillary campaign of Barak Housein Obama.

  • Posted By: lhuff @ 02/07/2008 9:36:00 PM

    I am a big fan of Mitt Romney and strongly believe that he would have been an excellent president. I also believe strongly in some, though not all, of the conservative ideas that Romney came to defend. However, I sadly admit that I agree with most of Howard Fineman's analysis. I'm not convinced that in his heart of hearts he is the arch-conservative that his advisors seem to think he needed to become. I think he would have been a much more appealing candidate if he had focused on his real strengths and run as the can-do leader and agent of change that he was during the first two years as governor of Massachusetts and as the "savior" of the Utah Olympics. There are a number of problems that this country needs to solve and I can't think of anyone better suited to leading the charge to solve them than Mitt Romney. I sincerely hope that he runs again in 2012, but that he presents himself more as who he really is than as someone others think he needs to become.

  • Posted By: lhuff @ 02/07/2008 9:33:55 PM

    I am a big fan of Mitt Romney and strongly believe that he would have been an excellent president. I also believe strongly in some, though not all, of the conservative ideas that Romney came to defend. However, I sadly admit that I agree with most of Howard Fineman's analysis. I'm not convinced that in his heart of hearts he is the arch-conservative that his advisors seem to think he needed to become. I think he would have been a much more appealing candidate if he had focused on his real strengths and run as the can-do leader and agent of change that he was during the first two years as governor of Massachusetts and as the "savior" of the Utah Olympics. There are a number of problems that this country needs to solve and I can't think of anyone better suited to leading the charge to solve them than Mitt Romney. I sincerely hope that he runs again in 2012, but that he presents himself more as who he really is than as someone others think he needs to become.

  • Posted By: hindsfeetinhighplaces1 @ 02/07/2008 7:35:58 PM

    Thankfully The Lord forgives you ALL for being so childish and judgemental... how foolish. let's take a look at ourselves. It's amusing to see that when it's time to support a Presidential Candidate we start to throw"Christianity"around. but yet we are so quick to take prayer out of our schools, and be so accommodating to "other" religious beliefs when we know damn well it was in "What" God We Trusted when the Constitution was signed.

    • Posted By: magic823 @ 02/07/2008 9:33:48 PM

      God is not in the Constitution. Its a very secular (and liberal) document. Most of our founding fathers were deist.

  • Posted By: maxpower03 @ 02/07/2008 2:35:41 PM

    This had nothing to do with Romney's credentials, you show you know nothing about credentials when you call Huckabee the genuine article. Huckabee is Baptist and Romney is Mormon, that all that people saw or cared about. If it was an issue of their political positions then Huckabee wouldn't be an issue.

    • Posted By: richc35 @ 02/07/2008 9:31:09 PM

      you're kidding right, Huckabee was the governor of 'Arkansas for 11 years, mitt only for four, Mitt was the governor of a liberal and farily wealthy eastern state, Huckabee was the governor of a poorer southern state but brought it into the 21st century in a lot of ways, his record is way more impressive as a governor. Also, it seems many people want to deamean Huckabee for being a Baptist Preacher as somehow that is below businessmen or something you do if you can't succeed in Business, they don't have a clue, it is one of the hardest, grueling, unrewarding financially especially considering the time investment, but most rewarding spiritually if one is truly called by God to be a Preacher. Preachers do a lot more than just get in front of the congregation and speak, more than just visinting the sick and invalid, managing the church with the help of others in most cases but I tough job either way at times, and seeking God's Will and Vision for the church, need to be good judges of character and people as a church needs people to serve in many different positions, many times voluntarily and with signficant expedinture of time, and one of the greatest things about a good preacher is that he or she learn to relate to all different kinds of people and come across many different circumstances, they walk in our shoes, high and low, rich, and poor, healthy and sick, they see the issues that we deal with every day, and much of it they have to keeep to themselves and of course find the time to give it all to God. As to the article, it is true, Mitt did not come across as genuine and him and his supporters constant attacks against McCain and Huckabee and the distortion of both of their records was quite wearisome, but despite the claims by many, it had little if anything to do with the fact that he was a mormon and while I don't agree with the mormons on many things, the trinity and the extra bible they have being the two main disagreements, I would not base my vote on a candidate who was a Mormon on that issue, with Mitt it was his record and his phoni-ness which caused me to not support him. Anyway, I hope this is instructive to some, entertaining to others, and as seen as a portion of the truth, If you find any hate in what I have written then I would encourage you to seek some kind of help because you have missed the point. I will end with this, I am hoping that Huckabee can catch fire and become the nominee, but if he doesn't, I wil gladly vote for McCain because the alternatives of Hillary and Obama are not viable or in the best interest of our country, , our children, grandchildren, or even the best interests of the rest of the world which needs a strong and free America.

  • Posted By: Robert----55 @ 02/07/2008 9:30:40 PM

    Fineman is smart, but its obvious he is for the leftist european agenda for the U.S. Think
    i'll order the new book. Liberal Facism. Jonah Goldberg

  • Posted By: kumjani @ 02/07/2008 9:19:43 PM

    This article has been a complete waste fo time and energy and I cant beleive I am even wasting my time replying. I suppose it's in hopes that Howie Fingerman will read this. I just want to say that you are a soulless throat cutter yourself. why is it that you are so anti American? Mitt Romney is doing a good job as an American. He stands up for the family....anyone knows...except for idiots like you...that the family value needs to be taken care of first before we can take care of the country and no one was teachig that better than Mitt among the many other good things he stood up for. Heck, he is the only candidiate that has been married once and married for a long time. As for your comment about his Mormonism being his reason he failed...I would tend to agree because its complete jackasses like you that have no idea what the Mormons are up to. I have many friends who are Mormon and they are some of the nicest, upstanding poeple I know. You may think you know about the Mormons because your brothers uncle's sisters pet dog didn't like the Mormon missionary knocking on their door. I think it shows great class that he took time to show his respects for a religous leader that did good throughout the world by attending his funeral. Anyways, I suppose you could do better as a candidate for president, maybe you should try in 2012 when Mitt runs again...I am sure he would love to debate with a moron like you...now that would be something I would even pay for to see.

    • Posted By: kumjani @ 02/07/2008 9:29:34 PM

      Ahh, that felt good! Now I will say Howie, you are probably a fine man.

  • Posted By: Brainwav13 @ 02/07/2008 9:28:10 PM

    "Soulless throat-cutter"? Fineman, maybe you ought to get to know something about a person before you slander him in the national press. As someone who is personally familiar with the Romney family and with many of Mitt's close friends and neighbors, I can vouch for the fact that he was and still is a "classy guy", which is more than we can say for you. I can understand why some people would accuse him of "flip-flopping" in this campaign, and I myself don't agree with all of the policy statements that he's made recently or in the more distant past. But what's most pathetic about this development in the race is not that Romney's alleged phoniness finally brought him down, but rather the fact that an extremely capable and dedicated figure like Mitt can't have a chance in a primary election because the voters and the media are too stuck on their own religious or policy hobbyhorses to try and make an objective judgment about who may be most intelligent or most qualified to be president. I'm sure the future still holds good things for Mitt, including perhaps even more involvement on the national political stage. As for your future pieces, maybe they will display a little more of the class and character that you claim Mitt lacks... but for now I'm not getting my hopes up.

  • Posted By: Betty Boop @ 02/07/2008 9:26:53 PM

    Having met Romney on a number of occasions and followed his campaign closely, I fialed to detect the phoniness you insist upon. I always found him to be forthright, without deceit and impressive in his intelligence and articulation. An organized and principled man, I cannot fathom your baseless criticism of a stellar human being in the face of compelling evidence of much fruit in his accomplished and blessed life.

  • Posted By: Sempiternal @ 02/07/2008 9:26:22 PM

    This Howard Fineman is a completely unobjective reporter. He is also a cowardly bully for singling out bits and pieces of video and making fun of the statements of the public and people that support Romney, including trying to make fun of the statements of a child in his 'This Romney Guy I Guess' video. Out of all the media sources I have viewed on Romney, Fineman's page here is the most highly mirepresentative and a complete waste of time for anyone wanting a fair view on politics.

  • Posted By: i8emallup @ 02/07/2008 9:25:53 PM

    Expensive gas? Blame Dick Cheney for that. The war against "terror" misconstrues a method of battle and enemy. Clever if you have many friends who profit enormously from war in a resource rich region. That and the 2 trillion bucks burned to do it.

    The dollars that must be printed because no one has the guts to cut spending are a George Bush and Dick Cheney inflation machine. The Bush/Cheney inflation causes a less valuable dollar, and therefore higher number of dollars to buy oil.

    Terror activities are higher because Bush/Cheney created Al Qaeda in Iraq. This little group never existed before the Bush Cheney war. But, then again, no one sold more weapons to Sadam Hussain than Donald Rumsfeld!! Crazy, eh?

  • Posted By: i8emallup @ 02/07/2008 9:23:40 PM

    Expensive gas? Blame Dick Cheney for that. The war against "terror" misconstrues a method of battle and enemy. Clever if you have many friends who profit enormously from war in a resource rich region. That and the 2 trillion bucks burned to do it.

    The dollars that must be printed because no one has the guts to cut spending are a George Bush and Dick Cheney inflation machine. The Bush/Cheney inflation causes a less valuable dollar, and therefore higher number of dollars to buy oil.

    Terror activities are higher because Bush/Cheney created Al Qaeda in Iraq. This little group never existed before the Bush Cheney war. But, then again, no one sold more weapons to Sadam Hussain than Donald Rumsfeld!! Crazy, eh?

  • Posted By: rcjorgensen @ 02/07/2008 6:54:37 PM

    I think Romney did a great thing, finally bailing out of the race. Know matter how much money you have, and we have all heard over and over how weathy he is, let history show for now on our Country is not for sale!
    Finally money won't rule and maybe we will focus on the problems our Country faces as Dr. Paul advises. Mc Cain is a hero and a great American. The race ain't over til the fat lady sings! Lets be decent and move forward with horable motives to change the course of our nation for the betterment of all. rcjorgensen2008.com

    • Posted By: hillplus @ 02/07/2008 9:20:34 PM

      Mccain is a mean spirited adulterer. His nickname was MaCnasty.

  • Posted By: Kaycee23 @ 02/07/2008 1:59:23 PM

    Going to that funeral was the death of his campaign. Our country should not be ran by someone who will leave his job (his campaign) for reasons that are purely personal. American problems are just too demanding for that kind of distraction. Voters realized this and it showed on Super Tuesday.

    • Posted By: davidjbaker @ 02/07/2008 2:23:40 PM

      I hope you remember you said this comment when you die and find out that the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is the true church on the earth today and that "that funeral" was the Prophet of God on the earth today. I hope it's not a "distraction" to you then...

      • Posted By: garlint @ 02/07/2008 3:45:13 PM

        EAsy there my Mormon friend. Our dear prophet Hinckley died as a very highly respected man- even among those not of our faith. He was very gentle, kind, understanding, and respectful of other's beliefs. I think he would want us to follow his example. We invite all to learn of the our Mormon faith but we don't chastize them into belief. For any of those offended by the comments above I am sorry. I don't belive they accurately portray the feelings of our membership.

        • Posted By: mizzoufarmgirl @ 02/07/2008 9:13:29 PM

          Well said, friend. Thanks for the back-up!

      • Posted By: mizzoufarmgirl @ 02/07/2008 3:07:05 PM

        Comment: to DavidJBaker...this statement is what perpetuates a bad reputation for the LDS Church. While the teachings of the church include service, integrity, humility, forgiveness, and a love for our fellow men regardless of their religious affiliations, it's the thoughtless comments and holier-than-thou attitudes like yours that keep people from seeing us as the Christians that we are. Please think of the impact your statements make the next time you feel inclined to preach.

      • Posted By: magic823 @ 02/07/2008 2:38:30 PM

        I have a bridge for sell. You want to buy it? CULT CULT CULT

      • Posted By: joepublic @ 02/07/2008 2:33:53 PM

        Uh, I think Kaycee was being sarcastic there, bud. But since you brought it up....thanks for bringing some of the true LDS doctrine to light, as Romney and your leaders have tried to hide your controversial cult practices. Isn't amazing how the new "prophets" are always octogenarian white males?

    • Posted By: skooby @ 02/07/2008 5:09:09 PM

      I attended the funeral.. .I took the time off of my job to attend. It was a beautiful occasion to honor a man that is well respected. Being Mormon I felt it appropriate that Govenor Romney was there.

      Sometimes, life stares us in the face, and makes us prioritize things.

      I think that Mitt felt as many others that that was the right thing to do. He hardly took much time off when you really think about it. He stayed in SLC for a couple of hours and then was back at it. I think that this article is foolish to say that he threw his campaign away because of it, I took it as he has his priorities straight.

      But I can see how some might see it otherwise. Inside of me I know as I said goodbye to President Hinkley that I will miss his kind and loving soul, he has touched my heart and many others so many countless times.

      Thanks...for listening :)

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse