How to Train a Husband

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: joe07 @ 02/14/2008 3:59:54 PM

    You have got to be kidding me...... Any woose of a husband that would actually fall for this is a dunce. Nice book Amy. Try getting to know your spouce first, then decide if you want to marry him for who he is, or find another potential husband! What a JOKE!

    • Posted By: SEBesq @ 02/14/2008 4:05:26 PM

      How do you know you aren't falling for it?

      • Posted By: NormL33 @ 02/14/2008 8:19:41 PM

        How do you he is? It's called 'solipcism' Wanda!

  • Posted By: Cosmicwindsurfer @ 02/14/2008 4:07:21 PM

    This book is insulting and condescending beyond belief to men. I agree with jazzyjenny02: relationships are about respect and understanding. Amy Sutherland has been reading to much Dr. Laura Schlessenger, who believes men are "simple creatures". ( See The Proper Care and Feeding of Husbands, etc. and other diatribes) I guess Amy just wants a weak man who will roll over or catch the fish she throws him for whatever sporadic benefits she can offer. This is likely because she can't get a real man with any kind of spine who won't put up with her b.s. This book is disgusting. Any woman who reads it and believes what it has to say is living in a American woman fantasy land, and likely has read " The Rules" and believes that b.s. too. Stick to tossing fish to Shamu at Seaworld, and the men of America will thank you. Signed, a real man.

    • Posted By: NormL33 @ 02/14/2008 8:17:29 PM

      Amen to that, brother! I write 'brother' because I've read 150 Sisterhood chain emails during the last five years. Apparently National Sisterhood Day comes around once a month.

  • Posted By: Caeli @ 02/14/2008 4:04:36 PM

    Oh my, everyone seems to be very upset over the idea of using simple behavioral modification techniques on other people. Did it ever occur to any of you that your supervisors at work use the same techniques? What about your peers? The government? Or how about your parents? Everyone uses this model in training children. This is not treating others like animals. It's the same method that every civilized person in authority uses to teach others what is expected of them and there is no reason for anyone to get all huffy about it.

    As a feminist who believes in equal rights without insisting that women be the same as men, I can't believe how up in arms people get over these things. Women are different than men, physically, psychologically, emotionally. That doesn't mean they aren't people. Frankly, you men who seem to be assigning attitudes and behaviors to women in general must have had some bad experiences that you are projecting on everyone else that has the same body parts. Each individual woman is just as unique as each individual man, and it's unfair to assume that we are all alike based on your limited experience regardless of how negative that experience was. And sadly, manos69, we can't "make up our minds" because we don't have a collective mind. We each have our own personalities, opinions, and attitudes based on our personal experience of life. Some women like a man who is sensitive and lives to please. Some women like a man who acts like a neanderthal and treats her like a piece of meat. It's all individual and unique to the circumstances of the woman, and you can't expect us all to act or react in the same way.

    • Posted By: NormL33 @ 02/14/2008 8:08:45 PM

      You, Caeli, are a feminist who, like most, makes the quantum leap that our responses to this book are based on bad experiences with women. You not only make that quantum leap, you presume yourself to be correct and then proceed to lecture us. YOU are the one projecting on to others what you fail to see in yourself!

  • Posted By: chicks86 @ 02/14/2008 4:29:00 PM

    There needs to be no book on how to train women, YES GOD FORBID THAT HAPPENING, BECAUSE THAT WOULD SET WOMEN BACK 60 + YEARS YOU MORONS!!! IF MEN WOULD HAVE NEVER HAD WOMEN "PLAY A ROLE" (EX. JUNE CLEAVER) THEN MAYBE WE WOULDN'T FEEL SO COMPELLED TO MAKE SURE YOU (MEN) KNOW THAT WE ARE STRONG AND DONT NEED YOU!

    • Posted By: NormL33 @ 02/14/2008 7:33:52 PM

      Listen up Chicks 86, your accurate identification should be "Too-Butch-To- Boogey"'

  • Posted By: downboy11 @ 02/14/2008 4:36:03 PM

    I live with a girlfriend who trained me well. She makes more money than I do and works less hours than I. I make worse money and work longer hours. Still i come home, cook, clean, do dishes, laundry, clean bathroom and give her a daily massage. She decorates and owns most of the territory on the apt. She left me a little area in the corner with a doggie bed in the corner where i sleep. She even goes out late all the time leaving me wondering. She once brought a guy home and made me watch.
    I love it. I enjoy being a submissive male. She enjoys using me. Get used to it guys, girls own the world now! ENJOY!

    • Posted By: NormL33 @ 02/14/2008 7:25:14 PM

      This what the whole thing is about mookey; the dominatrix approach to life. Who knows, maybe you were cellmates in a past life.

  • Posted By: Timmyxyz @ 02/14/2008 5:12:57 PM

    Why are so many people offended by the thought of something that works for an animal will work for a human? As if we are so superior that nothing can be compared to our furry little friends. Please people, we are just mammals and our brains and bodies work very much the same. This type of psychological training and conditioning is just as effective on us. Actually more so imo...

    If everything was reversed, and the title of this story read:
    "How to Train a Dog.
    Want an obedient dog? A new book says you should coach them like people."
    Do you think these people would be offended?

    • Posted By: NormL33 @ 02/14/2008 7:12:27 PM

      Hey Timmyxyz, we were originally talking about a woman journalist who wrote about what animal training techniques taught her concerning how to deal with her husband!!!

    • Posted By: NormL33 @ 02/14/2008 7:12:24 PM

      Hey Timmyxyz, we were originally talking about a woman journalist who wrote about what animal training techniques taught her concerning how to deal with her husband!!!

    • Posted By: NormL33 @ 02/14/2008 7:12:21 PM

      Hey Timmyxyz, we were originally talking about a woman journalist who wrote about what animal training techniques taught her concerning how to deal with her husband!!!

    • Posted By: NormL33 @ 02/14/2008 7:12:16 PM

      Hey Timmyxyz, we were originally talking about a woman journalist who wrote about what animal training techniques taught her concerning how to deal with her husband!!!

    • Posted By: NormL33 @ 02/14/2008 6:58:35 PM

      Hey Timmyxyz, we were originally talking about a woman journalist who wrote about what animal training techniques taught her concerning how to deal with her husband!!!

  • Posted By: jhr8888 @ 02/14/2008 7:10:13 PM

    The author of this article is just figuring out what any dom or domina(trix) in a 24/7 TPE relationship should already know...except we do it with consent from our submissive partners. Well, after another hard workday -- goofing-off on the internet -- it's time for me to leave; I guess my boss never learned to "shamu" me. ;-P

  • Posted By: jhr8888 @ 02/14/2008 7:06:40 PM

    Lol, this lady is finally catching on to what any dom or domina in a 24/7 TPE relationship knows. Well, time to go home, another hard workday on the internet, I guess my boss never learned to "shamu" me. ;-P

  • Posted By: iamjamie0303 @ 02/14/2008 7:05:46 PM

    It is true.,,,I totally agree with this opinion.

  • Posted By: mjlasota @ 02/14/2008 3:27:02 PM

    chicks86: Yes, woman should get hired because of her skills. Also, woman should get paid equal in jobs and deserve equal respect as men. I've always been a proponent of that. But, women are not men and men are not women. By nature, men and women are very different. Therefore, my point is that many spoiled brat American women percieve feminism as an outlet to unload on men just because they have infuriority complexes, insecurities, and inadequacies. They would prefer to be the king of the house, instead of the queen. They would prefer to have all the luxuries of tradition when it benefits them, but when they are asked to do something traditional they run with their tales between their legs. And yes, women are opportunists and take advantage of many things in the work world, especially kissing a-- and being around the higher up all the time. I've seen it tons of times. I don't blame women for taking money from men at strip clubs because if men are going to be that stupid to give these sluts attention and money then they deserve to lose their money. I also have no trouble sleeping with women and moving on because women ask for it. Those very same women who cry that they got their hearts broken would act much differently if I actually fell in love with them. The challenge would be over and they wouldn't be into it anymore. So for all the immature spoiled American women who think men are dogs that you can train. Think again. Men who sleep with women and move on are smart and women have created this. I will say, however, that I have found a great women that I am very loyal to. But she is also from another country and understands the differences between men and women. She is modern and educated, but also has a grasp on tradition and old-fashioned values. She is not turned off with me wanting to be the man, she is turned on by it and would have it no other way.

    • Posted By: tboneisme @ 02/14/2008 5:41:19 PM

      WOW! You are really sick! You have some serious issues that need to be worked out in therapy! Why do you feel the need to overgeneralize about American women??? You obviously don't get out much.

    • Posted By: chicks86 @ 02/14/2008 4:00:19 PM

      mjlasota: It seems to me that you keep movng off the subject. I have seen many a man kiss a** in the workplace, but you got way off track when you started mentioning strip clubs, and women wanting to be king instead of queen, I am not getting into that nonsense I made my point.
      POINT: HUMAN BEINGS ARE EQUAL REGUARDLESS OF GENDER, AGE, OR RACE.

  • Posted By: rsmitchell13 @ 02/14/2008 5:38:43 PM

    tboneisme If this was an article about treating my woman like a dog you would be howling. You are such a sexist!

  • Posted By: kilted @ 02/14/2008 4:23:23 PM

    You know this "Pavlov's dog" method, as stated, is nothing more than learning to compromise, which is what all long-term married couples do. Divorced couples never learn how to compromise. By using a different and more pleasant method to elicit a change in his behavior, rather than nagging, she changed her own behavior first. This is compromise not animal training. Her husband is not a dog.

    • Posted By: tboneisme @ 02/14/2008 5:23:18 PM

      I think that is the whole point. The author understands that it comes down to compromise. She does not think of her husband as a dog, she is talking overall about people's behavior and how you react to it that makes the difference. It's simple psychology and applies whether you are human or another type of animal.

  • Posted By: laplap @ 02/14/2008 5:17:48 PM

    chicks86, I bet you think Liberal Billary will get the nomination.

  • Posted By: laplap @ 02/14/2008 5:07:49 PM

    chicks86, I bet you think Liberal Billary will get the nomination.

  • Posted By: tboneisme @ 02/14/2008 5:00:11 PM

    Thank you for pointing out that the book's title is not "How to Train a Husband"! I would imagine that most of the people who are outraged by this book haven't actually read it. The title is "What Shamu Taught Me About Life, Love and MARRIAGE" not what it taught her about MEN! These techniques could go either way. No person, man or woman, is perfect and if your spouse has habits that annoy you (like leaving their socks on the floor) then trying to correct them using positive reinforcement and not negativity is a wonderful, productive way to achieve harmony in your home. As other posters have said, this is nothing new, this is simple psychology.

  • Posted By: laplap @ 02/14/2008 4:58:39 PM

    chicks86, I bet you think Liberal Billary will get the nomination.

  • Posted By: bluqq @ 02/14/2008 4:19:21 PM

    I knew I had heard of this concept years ago. Did you watch the movice If a Man Answers with Sandra Dee from 1962. It is the very same idea. Nice plagiarism.

    • Posted By: DarkPhoenix @ 02/14/2008 4:57:48 PM

      Did you read the article? Particularly the section where it states "this is not a new concept" and it lists 3 or 4 previous concepts, one of which was If a Man Answers the Door?

  • Posted By: philmjr @ 02/14/2008 4:46:49 PM

    The narrow-mindedness around here astounds me...

  • Posted By: Baby Boomer @ 02/14/2008 4:44:29 PM

    Chicks86--No you dont need men!!Your mother concieved you without a man,your mother went to work to pay for the house you lived in,the food you ate,the cloths you wore,etc,etc.All without the help or love from a man Right? Yea right!! Are you Gay?? That would explain the hatred in your blog towards men

  • Posted By: snarf snarf @ 02/14/2008 4:40:37 PM

    I don't know what type of men this chick has been dating, or what planet or era she is from, but what the f__k? Times have changed sweetheart!! "Don't nag about the flithy laundry piled on the floor, but reward him when he picks up one dirty sock"?? what?? First of all, I never have a pile of dirty laundry, what era did this author grow up in? This is a disgusting form of sexism and it takes me back to that stupid Carl's Jr. commercial when that guy is shopping and can't figure out how to cook a damn sloppy joe! If a guy can'tgo to the market and fix a home made meal then he's either got down sydrome or has been dropped on his head 100 times. This author is living in a closet and needs to get out more. If I am an anomaly, which I doubt I am in today's society, then there are plenty of guys out there just like me. I cook, I clean, wash dishes, vacuum, dust, take out the trash, do my own laundry. If these are the chores women has been complaining about and say break their backs if these are the excuses to gain control and used against men in many a argument (which I am unfamiliar with since I take care of myself) then I am laughing in womens faces! These chores take little effort and hardly any time. Even after some of these daily chores I still have the energy to go to the gym 4 to 5 days a week to look and feel good. That's an extra bonus to that special woman to enjoy. I'm guessing that there are a lot more men like this in this new millenium for women to stop there bitching and open their eyes! No more excuses and what is it with women letting themselves go after they are married, and secretly fantasizing about other men when their asses aren't even in shape. Sad thing is, the tell tale sign of when a women is thinking of cheating or already is cheating, is when they do finally get their lazy butts in the gym and work on their self esteem. Like Katt Williams said, "he didn't do anything to your self esteem!" "It's called self esteem ***, tha's esteem of YOURSELF!!" Work on yourselves and I am guessing this kind of talk never comes up, and who, man or woman wants to control someone??? How is that going to benefit the goodness of your soul? Using someone and treating them like they are nothing? Sad, but I've seen it so many times and I always wonder, "why are these people putting up with this and sacrificing their well being" - take control of yourself and treat you and others with respect and you'll live life better and be happier!! I hope that this author goes broke and if I am in a discussion with or date any woman who has read this book and believes in the concept, I will feel deep sorrow for that poor sole!

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse