The Curious Lives of Surrogates

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: amarina @ 03/31/2008 6:52:58 PM

    I think it is a miracle for a woman who had hysterectomy to have a baby. I think it is very sweet thing that another woman will carry him for her... I think it is more cruel that some women give their own babies for adoption, yet society accpet that... also I think the process of pregnancy worth much more than 25000$...
    and who will do it for free unless it is for your own sister.... I accept the idea.. though I'm christian..I don't see a sin in that... there is no adultry.. and if some women need money, it is better than prostitution.. not that I am comparing the tow.. finally, congratulations to those couple. I can't imagin life without kids.

    • Posted By: KMidders @ 03/31/2008 6:59:33 PM

      I agree with you on most things..except that it is cruel to give children up for adoption. I think that there are many situations when adoption is the best option for a mother. im not saying its fair to the child, but there are certain people who are not in circumstances where they are able (financially, or otherwise) to raise their baby. the fact that they decided on adoption vs. abortion is reason enough for my respect. Besides..there are clearly many people who still think surrogacy is "cruel" and "unethical" and would rather opt for adopting a child when they cant have their own. I think its a good thing that their are options out there

  • Posted By: amarina @ 03/31/2008 6:57:18 PM

    I think it is a miracle for a woman who had hysterectomy to have a baby. I think it is very sweet thing that another woman will carry him for her... I think it is more cruel that some women give their own babies for adoption, yet society accpet that... also I think the process of pregnancy worth much more than 25000$...
    and who will do it for free unless it is for your own sister.... I accept the idea.. though I'm christian..I don't see a sin in that... there is no adultry.. and if some women need money, it is better than prostitution.. not that I am comparing the tow.. finally, congratulations to those couple. I can't imagin life without kids.

  • Posted By: amarina @ 03/31/2008 6:56:58 PM

    I think it is a miracle for a woman who had hysterectomy to have a baby. I think it is very sweet thing that another woman will carry him for her... I think it is more cruel that some women give their own babies for adoption, yet society accpet that... also I think the process of pregnancy worth much more than 25000$...
    and who will do it for free unless it is for your own sister.... I accept the idea.. though I'm christian..I don't see a sin in that... there is no adultry.. and if some women need money, it is better than prostitution.. not that I am comparing the tow.. finally, congratulations to those couple. I can't imagin life without kids.

  • Posted By: getzel @ 03/31/2008 6:53:33 PM

    Wombs to rent 50 cents, no phone, some food, no pets, she wont smoke no cigarettes and then 2 hours of pushing brings, a new 7 pound human being

  • Posted By: Hawaiinavywife @ 03/31/2008 6:53:27 PM

    THE MILITARY DOES NOT PAY FOR SURROGATES. WHY DO YOU THINK THIS?? ITS TRUE WE HAVE HEALTH INSURANCE, BUT WE PAY OUR PREMIUMS SAME AS ANYBODY ELSE. THERE IS NO CLAUSE THAT PAYS FOR SURROGACY. We are paying for our own.

  • Posted By: Hawaiinavywife @ 03/31/2008 6:53:06 PM

    THE MILITARY DOES NOT PAY FOR SURROGATES. WHY DO YOU THINK THIS?? ITS TRUE WE HAVE HEALTH INSURANCE, BUT WE PAY OUR PREMIUMS SAME AS ANYBODY ELSE. THERE IS NO CLAUSE THAT PAYS FOR SURROGACY. We are paying for our own.

  • Posted By: ma08 @ 03/31/2008 5:13:17 PM

    The military does not pay for surragates. According to the text in the articial, wives of military men are becoming more and more surrgates, which means they are the ones carrying that baby and being payed by the bio family, not being paid by the military. This means our soliders and sailors are underpaid to support a family.

    • Posted By: Hawaiinavywife @ 03/31/2008 6:47:13 PM

      Amen to that. Additionally, as a military wife with an education, moving place to place makes it so difficult to keep getting a job, it takes time to adjust to new location. I am proud of my husband and what he is doing for this country, but the pricetag for being apart for a year or two at a time, and for working sometimes 16-20 hours a day, pay doesn't match. I know there are those who will say, he chose that job, well you know, to that I say, yes, you didn't, but if he didn't you may have had to in a little thing called the draft.

  • Posted By: Gyrefalcon @ 03/31/2008 6:46:01 PM

    It's kinda sad, in a way, how many of those protesting in this response column are mentioning 'adoption' as the better option. Has it not crossed ANYONE'S mind that these people have been down the long, painful road of adoption, as well as natural childbirth? Or are we simply being reactionary here? I know this is gonna sound odd, but frankly I'd never even heard about surrogacy until "Friends". That season, while meant to put a funny angle on the whole process, was a real eye opener, and only prompted me to look more deeply into the whole issue. While it's easy to be reactionary and say something to the effect of "oh that's bad" or "why didn't you do such and such", for the most part, the people that have taken this less traveled path have tried the overly trodden ones already.

  • Posted By: youscareme @ 03/31/2008 6:35:48 PM

    wow.. it is still your child even though someone else gave birth. think about it.. it was the original 2 parents that MADE the child... i have always wanted a lot of children and i know personally i would die if a doctor told me that my body was not made to have children yet this could be a working option. of course i would look into adoption and i do not know all of the facts about either. but i would consider this option

  • Posted By: lizlizard @ 03/31/2008 6:35:27 PM

    There are many women who would never get to have a child if it weren't for surrogate mothers. Not to mention that surrogate mothers to it willingly and happily! Many couples pay the same amount to adopt children as they do for surrogates. These couples are looking at the bottom line and asking themselves, "Do I pay for this woman's medical expenses and pay to adopt this child, or pay this other womans' medical expenses and pay to have a child that is mine not just through love, but biology as well?" Tell me, which would you choose?

  • Posted By: chry24sler @ 03/31/2008 5:41:28 PM

    Is adoption passe?

    • Posted By: JailynMor @ 03/31/2008 6:31:19 PM

      If you have had a successful adoption experience, please expand on your comments and share a bit more than you have here. (Though you might want to do so in a forum that is actually discussing people who are adopting and not attempting to have a biological child.)

  • Posted By: taraflood88 @ 03/31/2008 5:38:56 PM

    I am one of those women that can not have children and have been researching having a surrogate. I have been pretty discouraged and afraid that I will not be able to find someone that can do that for me and it breaks my heart. Thank you to all the women that have posted such supporting messages, god bless you. and a HUGE thanks to all the amazing women that have given families the gift of life, you are amazing. if you have any helpful advice or information i would love to hear it!! taraflood88@yahoo.com

    • Posted By: Hawaiinavywife @ 03/31/2008 6:30:11 PM

      Why don't you go to this website, http://www.surrogacy.com/cgi-bin/classifieds/classifieds and post your story and see what happens. You have two options here, you can go with an agency, or you can go with just an attorney. Someone will find you. If not, you can go the surrogates and ask each one that seems like a good match. Keep at it, it will happen.

  • Posted By: Gyrefalcon @ 03/31/2008 6:28:04 PM

    (QUOTE: you kno wat i think that its just plain wrong to pay another person to have a baby for you..do u kno wat that person goes through..and for wat....moments after birth you take that baby..and u kno wat if that bay finds out the ral story o boy ur in big trouble....n y not adopt..maybe its just not meant to be for u...to have ur own genetic kids but theres always another way END QUOTE) In EVERY case, all parties involved know that the baby will be going home with the Intended Parents after the baby is born, not the Surrogate. Men are paid for their sperm and women are paid for their eggs, it this also wrong? These questions are most certainly 'hot topics', right up there with abortion and capital punishment, in some circles. Frankly, if all the parties in question are willing and able to go through the process, I don't see how it is, or should be, anybody's business other than the parties involved. Please try to educate yourself on this topic before you make an uninformed response. Not doing so only shows a dangerous, willful ignorance in the end.

  • Posted By: Gyrefalcon @ 03/31/2008 6:27:56 PM

    (QUOTE: you kno wat i think that its just plain wrong to pay another person to have a baby for you..do u kno wat that person goes through..and for wat....moments after birth you take that baby..and u kno wat if that bay finds out the ral story o boy ur in big trouble....n y not adopt..maybe its just not meant to be for u...to have ur own genetic kids but theres always another way END QUOTE) In EVERY case, all parties involved know that the baby will be going home with the Intended Parents after the baby is born, not the Surrogate. Men are paid for their sperm and women are paid for their eggs, it this also wrong? These questions are most certainly 'hot topics', right up there with abortion and capital punishment, in some circles. Frankly, if all the parties in question are willing and able to go through the process, I don't see how it is, or should be, anybody's business other than the parties involved. Please try to educate yourself on this topic before you make an uninformed response. Not doing so only shows a dangerous, willful ignorance in the end.

  • Posted By: derrickm7 @ 03/31/2008 6:23:50 PM

    Morally wrong to put someone else through labor pain, etc.? Well I hired a surrogate for my beautful baby girl and have another that is currently pregnant with twins. As for celebrity trends, it is embarassing and very typical of the judgemental American view that I "follow a trend" that is more appropriate with the latest color or handbag. I challenge you to put yourself in my shoes where I am single, ready for children and able to provide a home where there is love and support. Before you ride your moral high-horse, open your eyes to the possibilities that some people want to carry on their genes. May I suggest you go to Cambodia and adopt something of a trend.

  • Posted By: smw1977 @ 03/31/2008 6:22:13 PM

    I have actually thought of doing this myself. There are many women out there who can't have babies. I work from home and have two very smart, beasutiful girls of my own. My "clock" starting ticking about four years after I was married and I had always wanted children. I would have been totally devestated if I couldn't have any children. I was very lucky with both pregnancies and had no complications, besides a couple weeks of the typical "morning sickness". I haven't talked it over with my husband, but have thought of doing so in the near future, so I can help another couple have children of their own. It doesn't matter who has gone through the pregnancy and labor, what matters is who that the people who raise the child love them and do all they can for them, that is a "parent". There are many people out there that are able to have kids and do, that shouldn't.

  • Posted By: KMidders @ 03/31/2008 6:22:06 PM

    It is not wrong to pay someone to birth your child, if they are willing to do so. So many people cannot have children of their own, and in my opinion, surrogacy is a great option. Im glad to see that there are so many women willing to go through the painful and emotional process of having a child that is not theirs in the end. It takes a strong woman to do something like this. Adoption is also a great option. There are so many abandoned children in the world who need families. I am aldo glad to see that the mothers of these children have not decided on abortion and have given other people the oportunity to raise a child who needs it (and vice versa). Both situations can be dangerous, though. In some ways surrogacy is the better option and in others, adoption. I see them as equal. After reading this article, and many others on the issue, I have seriously considered being a surrogate mother in the future. The only issue I would have is the bond between myself and the child. Im not sure I could deal with the seperation.

  • Posted By: pureheart @ 03/31/2008 6:16:07 PM

    all i have to say is that its wrong morally to put someone else to labour pain and then make em carry ur child for 9 months just so u can have a child that u will call ur "own" technically thats not ur child cuz well someone else gave birth to em right? it doesnt matter if ur paying them or not..it just dont work like that....but i do get y u need a sense of feelin like a parent so i agree with u ppl who want others to carry ur mother by 1% ..why dont u adopt..u ppl always follow celebrity trends..well NEWSFLASH celebrities are adoptn nowadays so y not you pplzzz..although i strnogly feel for the ppl who cant have children of their own but maybe thats the way its suppose to be..mybe theres other things in life ur meant to do..travel,explore or just base all ur life on ur career and family..:)

    • Posted By: JailynMor @ 03/31/2008 6:18:57 PM

      Your insights into others' pain is astounding. Thank you for sharing this gift of empathy with others here.

  • Posted By: daisyful @ 03/31/2008 5:47:49 PM

    I think its a wondferful thing that women do when it comes to surrogacy.I would love to be a surrogate for someone who can not have kids of there own.I have a two month old and i think that childless couples should be able to feel the love and emotion that runs through you when you have the most precious thing in life, and that is having a child.If anyone have ideas on how to become a surrogate i would love to know.

    • Posted By: Hawaiinavywife @ 03/31/2008 6:17:52 PM

      Yes, we found our surrogate mom on a website called http://www.surrogacy.com/cgi-bin/classifieds/classifieds. Ironically, the surrogate who chose us, called about an hour after we found out we had been scammed by our last birthmother. I had placed our ad on that website back in July of this year, after our first scam and forgot about it. When she called, I was suprised and had to tell her that I was too upset to talk, she wanted to talk about what had happened and why she chose us and I am thankful to her for that. She is a true blessing. We are beginning our process in a few months and there are no words to describe the gratitude that we both feel that this wonderful person would do this great thing for us. Thank you for considering surrogacy. You will see the immense joy and happiness you are giving to a couple like us. I think we make great parents because having a baby did not come easy to us. We had to plug at it for seven years, and now, I am hopeful that it will work out. Take care, Hope this helps.

  • Posted By: sjwnurse @ 03/31/2008 6:15:01 PM

    Great article. I will be needing a surrogate one day since I had a hysterectomy three years ago due to cancer. I have twelve frozen embryos waiting for that day. I know it will be very expensive and difficult process but it will be worth it. sjwnurse@hotmail.com

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse