Salmonella: Are Tomatoes From Local Farms Safer? | Newsweek Health

The Tomato Pickle

Newsweek Web Exclusive

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

SPONSORED BY

And when produce is packed and shipped over long distances, there's more time for a bacterium like salmonella to colonize. Once the germs come in contact with a tomato, it takes about 90 minutes for them to attach themselves to the surface. Then, under suitable conditions, the colonies of microorganisms will eventually cover the surface of the tomato, says Kaletunc. If the tomato has any cuts or bruises, the salmonella can also grow inside the fruit, where it can survive even if the tomato is washed thoroughly.

Locavores insist that smaller farms have a safety advantage because they avoid the lengthy multistep packing and shipping process that is used by many corporate farms. "The produce is harvested by migrant workers, shipped to a processing facility, then a packaging facility, then a delivery truck and finally to a grocery store. There are just so many steps that contamination issues can and do occur," says Gary Cox, the legal council for the Farm-to-Consumer Legal Defense Fund.

Roberts counters that there's no real evidence that smaller farms are inherently more immune to contamination. "Regrettably, mistakes can happen along the line with any size farm. It's so difficult to have generalities, to say this is bad food and this is good food. The real key is for everyone to follow good safety practices."

But exactly what those practices should be and how they should be put in place is in question. On Thursday the General Accounting Office issued a report slamming the FDA for providing little guidance on how to fund or implement the food protection plan it introduced last November. The office also says the FDA has enacted only three of 24 GAO food safety recommendations. Lisa Shames, the GAO's director of natural resources and environment, said in testimony to a House subcommittee on Thursday that her agency had sounded the alarm about the FDA's problems in enforcing food safety in 1998. "A decade later," she said, "the story remains the same and has only taken on a greater sense of urgency."

Apart from the public health concerns, a produce outbreak can be devastating for agriculture-dependent states such as Florida, which produces an annual tomato crop valued at $500 million to $700 million and provides more than 90 percent of the nation's tomatoes at this time of year. The FDA said on Thursday that Florida was not a source of the outbreak, but the two-week period when some types of tomatoes could not be sold cost the industry millions in lost revenue.

In response to the loss, Florida officials have stepped in to create stricter measures on their own. Roberts says that the state has taken the lead nationwide by introducing the first mandatory produce safety regulations and record-keeping requirements on top of the more general federal guidelines, and that California growers are considering a similar move. The Florida regulations will be backed up by state inspections as of July 1. "With several outbreaks in 2004 and 2005, the industry in Florida said, 'We don't want to wait for someone else to craft something and have further outbreaks'," Roberts says.

I read that tomato producers say that the salmonella outbreak is killing their business. What a surprise that people actually use caution in their food choices. What else did you expect? Tomato growers didn't want "country-of-origin" labelling and they had their way with the business-friendly Bush administration, so now almost all tomato crops are suspect. That's called "karma". It means that we all are affected by the good or bad results of our actions. So, now we know how the Bush food regulation system works: if your industry produces bad food - even if your farm didn't produce it - people just don't eat your product until all food poisoning cases stop for a few months. This could actually turn vegetable growers into firm believers in strict food inspection standards and swift correction of those who violate those standards. What a revelation!!! So, all those silly, stupid and boring regulations established long ago - and most recently ignored by the Bush administration - actually have a real purpose!!

Instead of arguing over people's spelling or their atrocious grammar, why don't the comments here focus on the real question. It isn't about migrants and illegals going to the bathrooms in the fields, American workers would do the same thing. Ever see someone relieving themselves on the side of the road less than a mile from a reststop? And not all migrants are illegals and not all illegals have disgusting bathroom habits. I don't think that personal hygene is in anyway related to your citizenship status. It's also not about local farms being better than corporate farms. I grew up on a small farm but I'm not against corporate agribusiness. They can be far more efficient than local farms and use far less fuel per pound of production. Does that mean I wouldn't prefer to buy local? Of course not. Bring money into local farms, get fresher, tastier produce, but don't blame corporate farms for ruining the world. Many small local farmers use many of the same fertilizing techniques as large corporate farms, just on a smaller scale. Water that's being used for washing fruit is generally taken from a municipal water supply, not from the cattle trough or from an irrigation ditch. The real question is and should be who is responsible for the out break, what should be done about it, and how can we prevent them in the future. Wash your food before you eat it, cook it thoroughly, wash your hands, these are all common sense and they'd go a long way to prevent food outbreaks, but people don't bother. It doesn't need to be irradiated or anything else. The human race has survived for millenia without irradiating their food. Americans just need to be more careful about what they eat and how they're handling it. I don't know how anyone can say that a tomato with a stem still attached is any safer than one without. The stems can droop and the tomato can still touch the ground.

Member Comments

- Reply
- Report Abuse
Posted By: smokey_joe @ 07/04/2008 11:59:11 PM

I read that tomato producers say that the salmonella outbreak is killing their business. What a surprise that people actually use caution in their food choices. What else did you expect? Tomato growers didn't want "country-of-origin" labelling and they had their way with the business-friendly Bush administration, so now almost all tomato crops are suspect. That's called "karma". It means that we all are affected by the good or bad results of our actions. So, now we know how the Bush food regulation system works: if your industry produces bad food - even if your farm didn't produce it - people just don't eat your product until all food poisoning cases stop for a few months. This could actually turn vegetable growers into firm believers in strict food inspection standards and swift correction of those who violate those standards. What a revelation!!! So, all those silly, stupid and boring regulations established long ago - and most recently ignored by the Bush administration - actually have a real purpose!!
- Reply
- Report Abuse
Posted By: davej82 @ 06/17/2008 8:40:47 PM

Who's bribing who?
- Reply
- Report Abuse
Posted By: osprey112897@msn.com @ 06/17/2008 10:17:07 AM

Instead of arguing over people's spelling or their atrocious grammar, why don't the comments here focus on the real question. It isn't about migrants and illegals going to the bathrooms in the fields, American workers would do the same thing. Ever see someone relieving themselves on the side of the road less than a mile from a reststop? And not all migrants are illegals and not all illegals have disgusting bathroom habits. I don't think that personal hygene is in anyway related to your citizenship status. It's also not about local farms being better than corporate farms. I grew up on a small farm but I'm not against corporate agribusiness. They can be far more efficient than local farms and use far less fuel per pound of production. Does that mean I wouldn't prefer to buy local? Of course not. Bring money into local farms, get fresher, tastier produce, but don't blame corporate farms for ruining the world. Many small local farmers use many of the same fertilizing techniques as large corporate farms, just on a smaller scale. Water that's being used for washing fruit is generally taken from a municipal water supply, not from the cattle trough or from an irrigation ditch. The real question is and should be who is responsible for the out break, what should be done about it, and how can we prevent them in the future. Wash your food before you eat it, cook it thoroughly, wash your hands, these are all common sense and they'd go a long way to prevent food outbreaks, but people don't bother. It doesn't need to be irradiated or anything else. The human race has survived for millenia without irradiating their food. Americans just need to be more careful about what they eat and how they're handling it. I don't know how anyone can say that a tomato with a stem still attached is any safer than one without. The stems can droop and the tomato can still touch the ground.