FACTCHECK.ORG

McCain's Power Outage

Contradictions and misstatements short-circuit McCain's energy policy pronouncements.

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

Summary
McCain has spent the week focusing on energy policy, making some surprising, and inaccurate, statements.

Among them:
He said that ending a moratorium on offshore oil drilling "would be very helpful in the short term in resolving our energy crisis." But according to a government report, offshore oil wouldn't have much of an impact on supply or prices until 2030. (Update, June 24: At a town hall event on June 23, McCain didn't claim that offshore drilling would lower prices in the short term, but that it would provide "psychological impact that I think is beneficial.")


McCain tried to paint Obama as an opponent of nuclear power, yet Obama has said he is open to nuclear energy being part of the solution and has supported bills that contained nuclear subsidies.

He has soft-pedaled the "cap" portion of his cap-and-trade proposal for greenhouse gases, even denying that it would be a mandate. The cap is a mandatory limit, however, and McCain even says so on his Web site.

McCain's new ad, running this week, rightly says that he bucked his party in supporting action on climate change years ago. But its images of windmills and solar panels are misleading in that he supports subsidies for nuclear power, which isn't pictured, and opposes them for wind and solar energy.

McCain continues to say that a suspension of the federal gas tax will lower prices for consumers, though hundreds of economists say he is wrong.

Analysis
Sen. John McCain spent much of the week focusing on energy policy and the pain that drivers are feeling every time they fill their tanks. He outlined his solutions in speeches on Tuesday and Wednesday, and he began running an ad touting his early willingness to break with the GOP on the issue of climate change.

On Board for Offshore Drilling
On Monday, McCain told reporters that permitting offshore drilling "would be very helpful in the short term in resolving our energy crisis." Tuesday, he formally unveiled the proposal in a speech to oil industry executives.

What McCain wants to do is expand the offshore areas, commonly referred to as the "outer continental shelf" that are open to oil exploration and drilling. The OCS is composed of the "submerged lands, subsoil, and seabed" under the seas extending from 3 to 9 nautical miles from the U.S. shoreline, depending on the state, to at least 200 nautical miles outward, according to the federal government.

Since 1981, there has been a federal moratorium banning any new drilling in these areas. Any rigs that were already up were permitted to continue extracting oil, and many are still operating in the Gulf Coast.

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
Al Gore's Climate-Change Evolution
Al Gore's Climate-Change Evolution

Using emotion to convince people to change.

Heaven Can Wait
Heaven Can Wait

A new book promises proof of eternal life.

The World's Biggest Foods
The World's Biggest Foods

Monster edibles from around America.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Nins @ 07/12/2008 6:44:35 PM

    Know why McCain wants to distance himself from former Senator Phil Gramm? It's not because of Gramm's obnoxious remarks calling Americans "a nation of whiners" who are in "a mental recession." Those remarks were so ascerbic that they may've been made just to give McCain an excuse to distance himself from Gramm. This issue is a lot deeper than it looks on the surface.

    When Gramm was a Senator he was Chairman of the Banking Committee. He pushed through the legislation known as the "Enron Loophole." This loophole allowed US investment banks to bypass Federal regulations governing futures trading, and is the reason why investment banks were able to falsely inflate the prices of oil, wheat, corn and other commodities through massive futures trading, causing your costs of gas, heating oil and food to go through the roof.

    Gramm also created the Gramm-Leach-Biley Act, which got rid of the laws that seperate banking, insurance and brokerage activities in America. The Gramm Act was touted as a new way to protect consumer privacy, but the real meat on the Act's bones was banking deregulation. Essentially, this Act did away with laws written after the Great Depression to protect us from another Wall Street/Banking Industry collapse. That's right, Gramm stripped the system of it's safe guards nine years ago, and guess what? The value of the dollar has nose-dived, four major economic institutions have failed, Wall Street is unstable, and we are in a worsening recession.

    Notably, the US investment banks that gained the most from the Enron Loophole and from the Gramm Act contributed more than a million dollars to Gramm's campaign.

    Currently Gramm is Vice Chairman of UBS, the Swiss Bank that came up with the idea of "death bonds." Worse, though, UBS is involved in a scam where they sold auction rate securities to American customers. Auction rate securities are supposed to be as safe as cash, but the way UBS did it, the fees garnished by their in-house investment bankers were intentionally higher than the return on the securities, ripping off their American customers. The Massachusetts Attorney General has already filed charges against UBS, and private brokers world-wide have dropped UBS stock. UBS is forecasted to lose 82.91% of it's value in 2008. We are talking about the corporate bank where Gramm is Vice Chairman. Looking at his track record there and at the havoc he has wrought on the US economy through the Senate Banking Committee, it's clear that either Gramm is a criminal or grossly incompetent.

    Now McCain wants nothing to do with Gramm, wants us to forget Gramm has been a key player on McCain's team. Gramm was McCain's campaign CO-CHAIR and LEADING ECONOMIC ADVISOR. Previously, McCain had said that he planned to appoint Gramm as SECRETARY OF THE TREASURY.

    With Gramm as McCain's leading economic advisor, now you know why economists and analysts say that McCain's economic policy plans are untenable.

  • Posted By: ik.nha.tun@gmail.com @ 07/06/2008 8:19:10 PM

    In my opinion, just because Bush McSame3 aka John McCain has windmills and solar panels in his commercials background, FACTCHECK.ORG has done a magnificient job of informing the public that those (windmills and solar panels are just hollywood props). McCain is more for the drilling offshore regardless of what it does to the environment, drilling in Anwar regardless of what it does to that refuge, just drilling for oil anywhere. Where is America's independence from oil if we're still drilling for oil?

    I love it...McCain did a 'MAVERICK' commercial. Supposedly breaking away from his party. He is rather the chameleon. Problem is WE'RE NOT BUYING IT. Listen, if the Republican parties loyalist constituency, 'The Religious Right' can not support him because they know he isn't REAL why should we?

    This total and just FAIRYTALE like policy he 's 'dreaming up' is just the tip of the 'MELTING ICEBERG', when it comes to his policy on Global Warming. McCain is not really concerned. Anything for political expediency. Yes, America still needs oil. How do we go about getting it? Seems to me this fake 'WHITE HAT', wearing 'TWO GUN' packing, 'COWBOY BOOT wearing, MYTHOLGICAL 'Maverick' John McCain' ideolog, is totally on-board with more of this 'ROGUE' administrations policies of Covert Operations in 'OIL RICH COUNTRIES' A sort of Occupy and Steal policy. He desires to OCCUPY oil Rich Nations and call it something like , "THE WAR ON TERROR" Been there done that, got a tee-shirt, it's a LIE.

    Senator Bush McSame is for '...100+ years in Iraq, he's stated, 'It really isn't important when the troops come home....what's more important is the casualties'. I.E. enough American and coalition force trooops (over 8000 dead), haven't lost thier lives, nor (over 2 million innocent Iraqi Mothers, Fathers, brothers and sisters, and innocent babies have died) , that's still not enough. Remember he sang his 'PSTD DRUNKEN' version of, ' BombbombbomB, BombbomB, IRAN'. McSame is nothing more than a WARMONGERING 'ROGUE politician who's desire is WAR AND MORE WAR. A War on the Oil rich so we may replenish our National treasury. He doesn't have a REAL PLAN TO FIX ENRGY AT ALL. He's totally on board with a continued Bush MISUSE of our military mights, WAR effort.

  • Posted By: metzlerd @ 07/02/2008 11:38:48 PM

    "America needs energy independence and part of that is oil because we cannot move entirely away from oil."
    - America does need energy independence, and oil does not have to be part of it. Obviously it is today, and during the conversion it would be, but there is no reason we can't use alternative fuels. We just haven't had the stimulus necessary to do it. It requires significant infrastructure updates, and that can only be coordinated by our government.

    "Global warming:
    McCain did stand up against the majority of the GOP, including Bush five years go when he worked with Lieberman on the McCain-Lieberman Global Warming Bill."

    That is true although I would disagree with McCains assessment, as mentioned in the article, on sounding the alarm. The alarm was being sounded years before. Republicans especially were denying and continue to deny that it is really a problem. They are of the opinion that man can do whatever he wants and it will not affect his environment. I would commend McCain for being one of the first of the Republicans to stand up to the rest though.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

My Take

Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage
to feature your favorite columnists.

Customize Now
 

A new ad goes too far when it says Medicare will be "bankrupt" in eight years.