‘The Wild Horse Is Us’

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: epowers @ 07/02/2008 1:42:56 PM

    It is not just about greedy ranchers and corrupt government. Wild horses and burros are non-native species that have been introduced, like rabbits in Australia. They compete with native species for grazing and even water. I have seen them "take over" a waterhole in the dry west and not allow antelope, coyotes, or any other animal to drink. They are out there due to a human screw up and are not "natural." We need to manage our mistakes. Is it ok with all the folks raging here about the noble mustangs etc. that the antelopes die?

  • Posted By: bigred1 @ 07/02/2008 1:42:49 PM

    With our ( I have lived in Wyoming for 35 years) current development, livestock grasing, and wildlife usage there is just no room left for feral animals to roam over the high deserts of the west.

    The wild pigs of the south are all feral animals yet I hear no outcry for their protection and they are hunted 24/7/365 in most areas were they live.

    If people want the wild horses let them come get them and move them to their states.

  • Posted By: vixon824 @ 07/02/2008 1:42:36 PM

    What is it with our society anymore that we have no regard for anything but ourselves. How can we be so cold and uncaring about killing such a beautiful animal. The government should be euthanized, and aren't they supposed to be speaking for the people: not making these decisions on there own. Which greedy government agency is this benefiting? God help them, how can they live with themselves. This law won't pass if they were really speaking for the people they claim to represent.

  • Posted By: openyoureyes221 @ 07/02/2008 1:28:00 PM

    THE OILMAN GEORGE BUSH MUST BE AFFRAID WE ARE ALL GOING BACK TO CART AND BUGGYS PULLED BY HORSES SO HE IS TRYING TO GET RID OF THE COMPETITION.

    • Posted By: goodgunguy @ 07/02/2008 1:41:51 PM

      Oh yeah. George Bush caused every problem in the universe. It must be nice to be so niave that you can have only one enemy and blame everything on him.

  • Posted By: epowers @ 07/02/2008 1:40:18 PM

    It is not just about greedy ranchers or inept government. They compete with native species for food and water. I have seen them "claim" a waterhole in the arid west and prevent antelope, coyotes and other native species from drinking. Wild horses and burros are not "natural" in the west - they were introduced by humans, just like rabbits in Australia, and do need to be managed. Or is it OK with all the people raging here th that antelope and other native species die instead? All tings are connected. KNow before you rant.

  • Posted By: popmanifesto @ 07/02/2008 1:39:09 PM

    This is all about corporate interests having their way, as usual. Meat production is not only an environmental disaster, but if people knew how much of their tax money went towards propping up that industry and industries that feed into it, like corn producers, they'd be appalled. But here's the bottom line: corporations give campaign donations, horses don't. We're addicted to our Big Macs and Whoppers the same way we're addicted to oil - and both are leading us down the wrong path. Saving the horses is an issue, but the bigger issue is getting our country back.

  • Posted By: lrt6105 @ 07/02/2008 1:37:38 PM

    Having lived with Wild Mustangs in my yard (the Nevada Fish Springs herd), having seen them run wild wild and raise foals throughout time, having witnessed BLM helicopter chancing herds to the ground to capture, and having seen the Pyramid Lake holding facility - I am compelled to share the general comment about the ineffectiveness of BLM and the propensity to be ruled by cattle/sheep ranchers and that they've tried their best to keep everyone happy. It hasn't worked. Their capturing, maintaining, and selling attempts to manage and prevent ranchers from herding up and killing in cold blood the mustangs (I've ridden out and seen the bones of herds in dead end canyons). The current issue must be resolved without euthanasia. There are how many millions of acres under BLM control? It would seem to me, that maybe ranchers from the profits of our grocery trips should buy their own land and leave the wild to the wild?

  • Posted By: pure1 @ 07/02/2008 1:37:08 PM

    To euthanize a wild horse would be to euthanize American History. There are always solutions to problems. Lets not create a bigger one. http://www.wildmustangs.com/

  • Posted By: epowers @ 07/02/2008 1:37:07 PM

    It is not just about greedy ranchers and corrupt government. Wild horses and burros are non-native species that have been introduced, like rabbits in Australia. They compete with native species for grazing and even water. I have seen them "take over" a waterhole in the dry west and not allow antelope, coyotes, or any other animal to drink. They are out there due to a human screw up and are not "natural." We need to manage our mistakes. Is it ok with all the folks raging here about the noble mustangs etc. that the antelopes die?

  • Posted By: debbier @ 07/02/2008 1:27:08 PM

    Oh please this is just wrong, it is heresy. What is our government thinking. These beautiful and wild animals deserve our protection as does any other species. If the American people stand for this nonsense the next thing that you know they will be euthanizing the homeless because they do not know what to do with them. I think that this is just one more sick and disgusting thing that Big Brother is throwing at us. Give me a break. I have an idea this is it, why doesn't the government use the money that the ranchers give for leasing the land that the horses had a right to first and use that to manage the land. I am 1/8 native american I can not and will not abide this sick and disgusting display of Governmental control. If you are going to euthanize the horses then why don't you do something about the wetbacks coming over here millions at a time and freeloading off of our government, that is the real issue people. Not the horses. If you would do something with the wetbacks you would have millions of dollars in problems solved.

    • Posted By: goodgunguy @ 07/02/2008 1:36:35 PM

      Here, here! Let's make this a racial issue. It was those damned Spaniards who dropped off their horses in the first place.

  • Posted By: kwhorseluver @ 07/02/2008 1:35:58 PM

    y is america so ambitious in saving the wild horses? what about the mule deer. the dessert bighorn, sage grouse, and chuckar. better yet...
    WHY NOT SAVE THE AMERICAN COWBOY? you say horses represent the west? the cowboy is y they are here. talk to some oldtimers in rual areas they were around when the history of the horse was being made? they helped make them! you people would rather save a horse than someones lively hood. and you try to pass your arguments about saving lives off as intelligent. i'm only a highschool student. but i've seen hands on the situation you are talking ;about. how many of you can say that. how many of you can say you've even seen a wild horse? hwo many of you have even ridden a horse, or been in the backcountries of the west? ...hmmm?

  • Posted By: klemm @ 07/02/2008 1:35:23 PM

    Why don't we just euthanize all the lifers and other dangerous criminals imprisoned throughout America? I'm sure we spend more than $39 million on feeding, clothing & keeping them alive. If we hadn't stripped away so much open land over the years, the wild horses would have no problem surviving. And just look at ALL the animals throughout the world that are close to extinction. How sad! This does not speak well for the human species.

  • Posted By: gabbykat @ 07/02/2008 1:35:02 PM

    NO!! Should we also do the same to all the homeless people roaming the streets in this country? The government finds money for thousands of "useless" issues each year, they can certainly find the money to help support these proud, beautiful wild creatures. They are a link to the past and to the heritage of our forefathers, they should be cherised and protected.

  • Posted By: bigred1 @ 07/02/2008 1:34:52 PM

    I live in Wyoming and can tell you that the " wild horse" was not here during the ice age. In fact the Spainards brought them and therefore they are ferral animals just like the wild pigs of the south. I dont here anyone crying over the killing of wild pigs. So why the wild horse.

    The fact is that with the use of the range for livestock, actual wild animals and oil and gas developement there is little room left over for the feral wild horse.

  • Posted By: alimoss58 @ 07/02/2008 1:27:48 PM

    Why do the Wild Mustangs have to pay for what the people and livestock are doing to the lands. We should leave them alone and let them FREE like most Americans would like to do.

    • Posted By: goodgunguy @ 07/02/2008 1:34:48 PM

      Lets put them on YOUR land and let them roam free... The mustangs have to pay for what people and livestock do because the majority of the people in this country want cheap, abundant and safe food. As we get more people, who demand more food and more energy we have to make tough choices... in this case, the horses lose. Unless you can find a better way to preserve people's livelihood and private property rights.

  • Posted By: Big Bud @ 07/02/2008 12:40:22 PM

    First let me say I am and have been a hunter for many years so I have no problem with the cultivation of animals HOWEVER the mere thought of the thoughless destruction of wild horses is beyond unbelievable. There are certainly other avenues of management besides the mass destruction of a natural resource. Those who manage our wildlife (for the most part) are part of the problem, if not most of it. Perhaps its time we use this theorm of management against those who propose it. What has this country come to?

  • Posted By: klemm @ 07/02/2008 1:33:46 PM

    Why don't we just euthanize all the lifers and other dangerous criminals imprisoned throughout America? I'm sure we spend more than $39 million on feeding and clothing and keeping them alive. If we hadn't stripped away so much open land over the years, the wild horses would have no problem surviving. And just look at ALL the animals throughout the world that are close to extinction. How sad! This does not speak well for the human species.

  • Posted By: davesanrn @ 07/02/2008 1:33:40 PM

    Horses were brought to America long after the ice age. The pre ice age horses did not survive, and do not exist. The most recent ice age ended 11,000 years ago. The "wild horses" in America today came from Europe. My 2nd grader knows this much...

  • Posted By: achuprevich @ 07/02/2008 1:33:34 PM

    The Federal Bureau of Land Management is NOT managing our property correctly. There are sheep and cattle ranchers that are using this land at an extreme minimum of payment for extreme profits. Let the ranchers find a place to raise the cattle and the sheep and keep the federal land open for the federal horses.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse