The Power of Images

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: kabiey @ 07/15/2008 9:43:37 AM

    Duh, in Catholic school, you study catholicism. But, nobody's saying Obama is a 'closet Catholic'. I guess we're not afraid of Catholics. A public school is NOT a madrassa! Duh again. A madrassa IS a school where you study ONLY Islam. Some of these comments just point to the ignorance of the American public & unfortunately, that is what the New Yorker 'played into'. If they were lampooning right-wing attacks & rumors, they missed the mard very badly and hit the wrong target Most peopl;e in America aren't very sophisticated or well-informed and they don't understand satire

    • Posted By: Southerner @ 07/15/2008 10:19:42 AM

      Actually, at the school Obama attended in Indonesia, only the Muslims had to study Islamic teachings. Those who were registered as Christians were taught the Bible instead. It's funny, in light of that, that Obama's own book mentions that he got in trouble for making faces in his Islam class. The Christian students DID NOT TAKE ISLAM CLASS! So, if Obama was "ALWAYS A CHRISTIAN", why was he in Quran classes?

      • Posted By: ChristineATL @ 07/15/2008 10:46:48 AM

        No, everyone studied Islam. Just as in my Catholic school in Africa, Muslim and Hindu students studied Bible knowledge with all of us other students. Also, in Islam, a step-parent cannot confirm a child as a Muslim--only a biological parent. Barack's father did not carry out the required procedures for Barack. Why do people want to wage Jihad on Barack just like the fanatics?

  • Posted By: ESTRENO @ 07/15/2008 10:41:39 AM

    I get the message they are trying to send but..... its the people who hav tunnel vision when it comes to this canidate that will have this image burned into their mind. The problem is that some people really do believe that he is a muslim but he is not , and this picture has like they say put a face to it. Its an image that is powerful and full of fear. I do believe it is a tasteless picture but it shows how distorted some peoples view point on this canidate is. I welcome the freedom of the press we have in this country its great.
    Obama 08

  • Posted By: mj it @ 07/15/2008 10:36:49 AM

    I know. I have a new cover.

    McCain in bed with the big corporations who will do anything to get and keep him in office. After all he's used to being a kept man. They need his so they can keep making money from Iraq - it goes like this:

    McCain in bed with Haliburton, KBR, BLACKWATER, BIG OIL, TELECOMS. The twist is - they're not screwing him - they're screwing us.

    They can trust McCain - he abandoned his disabled wife and 3 kids for a much younger beer heiress - only to abandon her after she had a stroke - to learn to walk on her own. He knows how to be a kept man.

  • Posted By: bluebird @ 07/15/2008 10:36:21 AM

    It was tasteless, but the media are the one blasting it as front page news everywhere. You can't blame the New Yorker. I don't think its circulation is national but the media put the cover on the national front page. Let's not forget about free speech as well. Amazing that a liberal magazine just like Newsweek did it.

  • Posted By: swils10 @ 07/15/2008 10:07:25 AM

    These pundits must think we people "out there" are just stupid. Do you think only the elite journalists can tell the difference between over the top satire and reality? I hope The Newyorker does not feel it has to dumb down its cover to meet the politically correct fears of the chattering class of elitists and their counterpart spin doctors working for the campaigns.

    • Posted By: News and Notes @ 07/15/2008 10:31:07 AM

      Obama should have gotten more national experience before running for president. People don't know him that well. What people don't know they fear. Despite his naive campaign based on hope, change, and unity, Obama's running for president only furthers to divide us.

  • Posted By: nikkismith1 @ 07/15/2008 10:29:42 AM

    Actually, Southerner, you are very wrong. When Barack Obama went to school in Indonesia, it was a state regulation that ALL kids, Christian, Muslim, or other, took classes in Islam. I did my research, do more yourself.

  • Posted By: Tx_longbow @ 07/15/2008 10:17:03 AM

    The New Yourk times should have a new cover. One with all the owners dressed in Nazi uniforms hailing the Nazi flag. Behind them put the eidtors in KKK gowns and holding up a noose. Then they can have a story inside say how they are not racests, but they do hate blacks and dont want to see a black in the presidents office. They can then rename the New York time to the New Yourk white Times. After printing, maybe they may feel imbarressed enough to admit they have turned the NYT into a tolet paper rag newspaper.

    • Posted By: News and Notes @ 07/15/2008 10:28:59 AM

      The image was not in the NY times

  • Posted By: TrueGrit @ 07/15/2008 10:27:24 AM

    The New Yorker caters to a readership of above average intelligence. Its editors fail to understand that there are people in this country who will never appreciate the nuances of the English Language. Just read some of the comments posted on the Net each day.

  • Posted By: Tx_longbow @ 07/15/2008 10:25:51 AM

    Also, why don???t they run a story on McSame about how the old fool cant even use a computer. That???s all we need in office now, somebody that has no idea how to stimulate R&D in America because he is too lazy to take the time to try it out. I hope we never return to the days of Ronald Reagan and his sleeping thru his last 4 years only to be woken up for a few media spots. Maybe if they had woken him up so he could have seen the 2 million homeless living under bridges, things might have been different. Sorry but we have learned that there is no place for geriatrics in the White house.

  • Posted By: mj it @ 07/15/2008 10:15:48 AM

    Hey Rennie -- you seem like a good Christian -- maybe you could answer my question - no one else has been able to:

    On what Christian path was McCain taking when he abandoned his disabled wife for a much younger, richer beer heiress and then abandoned her after a stroke to learn to walk on her own?

    I really am waiting for an answer.

  • Posted By: ibrhm @ 07/15/2008 10:14:19 AM

    What's wrong with having Muslim roots or any roots? Most of Americans of African origins had other religions, believes and practices including Islam. Many abandoned them either by force by their masters or were too overwhelmed by their hardship and being slaves to practice their ancestoral believs. So no black American will have the chance to be accepted as a presedential candidate in the country he helped build and defend with much more efforts and sacrifices than any other ethnity in America. Finally, The whole Universe is no more valuable to almighty Allah(God) than the wing of a mosquito, so, what will hurt Islam, the true message of God to all mankind, if Obama or anyone else denied being or refused becoming Muslim. One day he and many others like him will gravely regret it.

  • Posted By: gommy goomy @ 07/15/2008 6:58:16 AM

    Here we go again. The weenies on the left are all out of whack at the cover of the New Yorker. Frank Rich probably smeared his lipstick all over his face when he saw it. I'm surprised that Alter isn't breathing in to a paper bag in his picture up above. This is worse than the Hindenburgh. "Oh the humanity". I don't think that we've seen the little pukes in the press ever hyperventillate like this whenever such things have been drawn, or said, about PRESIDENT BUSH? Have we? What about VICE PRESIDENT CHENEY? Anyone remeber anything like this? I notice that that IDIOT on Comedy Central still has his job. Didn't he once do a bit with the Presidents picture on the screen pushing the idea of KILLING HIM? This HISSY FIT, on the Left is pathetic. You'ld think that the New Yorker had printed a cartoon of Mohammed eating a ham sandwich. I'm telling you right now, if this MORON, this Community Organizer, gets in, he's gonna have carte blanche to run this country in to the ground, because the effeminates in the Media, like comb over boy, Alter, will be too busy genuflecting to Black Jesus, that the whole country will end up like New York City, under DAVID DINKINS. MARK MY WORDS.

    • Posted By: American Fact Checker @ 07/15/2008 10:13:21 AM

      Gommy Goomy you must have a fifth grade education!!! I didn't know such ignorance existed. The New Yorker has made fun of people through out it's history however, this article crosses the line because of all the rumor's the media has portrayed of him & moron's like you who spread these rumors without checking the validality of them. I sometimes myself I'm not proud to be an american because of idiots like you & a government that has run this once great nation into the ground. What happen to WMD? Remember this country once sold the american public that Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone in assassinating President Kennedy. So it's really hard for me to trust what the media puts out there. People shoud do there homework before that make an opinion on who really these candidates are & what they stand for.

  • Posted By: Blenheim @ 07/15/2008 10:06:26 AM

    Jonathon wasn't nearly as bothered by the power of images when the images in question (including a Newsweek cover), showed the Democratic nominee with what appeared to be a Christ-like halo. But that's okay, Jon. It's comforting to know that, at least some of the time, you're looking out for me.

  • Posted By: Blenheim @ 07/15/2008 10:04:16 AM

    Jonathon wasn't nearly as bothered by the power of images when the images in question (including a Newsweek cover), showed the Democratic nominee with what appeared to be a Christ-like halo. But that's okay, Jon. It makes me feel good knowing you're looking out for me.

  • Posted By: rennie @ 07/15/2008 10:01:41 AM

    I for one agree with the cover . This man is the Anti-Christ and we as Americans
    better wake up before it is to late.

  • Posted By: MacGhil @ 07/15/2008 10:01:28 AM

    Well of course Senator Hopenchange, his rabid acolytes and media minions believe the unwashed masses are far too ignorant to understand political satire!

    The fact of the matter is, the ruckus all of you elitist snobs are causing will do more harm to the Obama campaign and his image than that cover ever could have.



    There's no ideology here. Just politicians taking care of the monied interests. Conservatives, liberals -- everyone was in on creating the conditions that led to the mortgage collapse. The bill for it all now goes to the taxpayers, party affiliation unimportant. and his media minions assume the unwashed ignorant masses

  • Posted By: bcrawf2033 @ 07/15/2008 9:55:19 AM

    The image on the cover of the New Yorker is one that sticks in the mind. While I can appreciate an occasional good satire, and I'm glad we live in a country with free speech, I think with that freedom comes a certain amount of responsibility from all of its citizens. The New Yorker missed the mark on this one. We vent frustration and anger not stopping to think before we speak uncaringly of whom it may hurt or damage. It's immature for adults to practice it and sets a really bad example for our children. It is my understanding that there is no explanation in the article about the cover referen0ing the unfounded fears of those who mistrust Senator Obama and his wife. These are good people who have chosen to give a life of service to our Nation using their expertise and intellect to help us achieve the goal of changing our country to reach its full potential and maintain leadership in a global world that is passing us by. We need to show one another more respect and civility. This is just another distraction from the real issues. Our economy looks more like its headed towards a Depression. We've been in a Recession for several months now. Gas and food prices escalating daily. More home foreclosures and higher healthcare costs. Floundering public education and kids dropping out of high school and society succombing to drugs and alcohol at an alarming rate. Kids practicing sex far too early and exposed to too many adult situations at a young age are killing our next generation. The environment has reached a critical stage where we must address global warming now before its too late. Our dependence on foreign oil and new forms of energy. This is where the focus of the American people belongs. Not on lies and half-truths about Senator Obama. Get the facts straight, and then make your decisions. If a person is ignorant, there are enough books, videos, and the Internet to educate yourself. Obama 08!

    • Posted By: tydiggs24 @ 07/15/2008 10:00:57 AM

      Comment: "there will always be haters thats the way it is..." conservatives make me laugh. as an obama supporter i must say that the magazine cover is funny. i mean how could people believe this... o ... people do. what idiots you all are. obama like most moral americans attends church with his gfamily regularly. his choice in religion is not based solely on the message delivered by rev. wright, but also the enviorment, area, and personal relationship. are you people narrowminded enough to believe that you share the same beliefs and religous philosophies as your friends. diversity in opinion leads to the greatest dialogue and increased intelligence and awareness. oh i forgot i was talking to conservatives. either way i think anyone can tell that obama as a presidential candidate is light years ahead of mccain. mccain has tyhe same accomplishments bad presidents have had for years, while obama is a great orator full of potential. somehow the phrase washed up comes to mind for mccain. obama's choice of "no comment" on this article shows his maturity over the immature ppl at the times. whats even better is there is no way to make fun of some one as uglyy, old, and inadequate as mccain. no mccain satires because he is the joke. if obama was white this election would more closely resemble Bill Clinton v. Bush.

  • Posted By: Drew22 @ 07/15/2008 10:00:50 AM

    I think the cover is disgusting If this was meantas a satireon these things . then lets see one on Mc Cain then that would be fair game for both of the canidates.

  • Posted By: moscowsteve @ 07/15/2008 9:59:21 AM

    Obama's name is a liability. No matter his actual record, position or beliefs, many Americans will inevitably connect him with radical Islam simply because of the associations raised by his name. It is also a liability that will assuredly be used by his opponents, possibly to devastating effect, through some sort of whisper campaign as election day approaches. This is an issue that the campaign must address and neutralize.

    The New Yorker cover adroitly summarizes all of middle America's secret fears about Barack Obama. It also provides the Obama campaign with an opportunity to systematically address and soothe those fears. It seems to me that the New Yorker has done Obama a great favor by making his name an open issue now, when it can be addressed in the open, rather than remaining an underground issue that will gnaw at voters until their appointment with the ballot box.

  • Posted By: News and Notes @ 07/15/2008 9:58:44 AM

    The cartoon was outrageous. However, the reason Obama is on the receiving end of this nonsense is becuase people really don't know who he is. I really wish he had stayed in the seante a couple of terms (not years) before deciding to run for president. He cannot back up his mantra of hope, change, and unity with solutions for delivery. By running for president before he was ready, the country is more polarized than ever.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse