Many years ago President Reagan was filmed quoting from what he said were the words of an admiral during world war two, who on seeing his young pilots take off from an aircraft carrier, ???where do we get these men from???? The trouble with this was the quote was not one from a real person rather it was from a war film based on a book of fiction. To top it all the book and film were set in and about the Korean War not WW2. Reagan confused what he saw on screen and spoken by a fictional character with the real thing. Years later this confusion between reality and fiction happens under the Bush administration with a television series called ???24???.
I note that some people who have written abusive comments in response to this article and I am amazed at their inability to accept anything was wrong with what officials in the Bush administration has done in the name of the American people following the example of a television show. They also seem to ignore that this confusion with reality has happened before. Some segments of American society are so out of touch they really scare the rest of us who have to live in the real world.
- 1
- 2
The Fiction Behind Torture Policy
Email To A Friend
Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.
For one thing, Jack Bauer operates outside the law, and he knows it. Nobody in the fictional world of "24" changes the rules to permit him to torture. For the most part, he does so fully aware that he is breaking the law. Bush administration officials turned that formula on its head. In an almost Nixonian twist, the new interrogation doctrine became: "If Jack Bauer does it, it can't be illegal."
Bauer is also willing to accept the consequences of his decisions to break the law. In fact, that is the real source of his heroism—to the extent one finds torture heroic. He makes a moral choice at odds with the prevailing system, and accepts the consequences of the system's judgment. The "heroism" of the Bush administration's torture apologists is slightly less inspiring. None of them is willing to stand up and admit, as Bauer does, that yes, they did "whatever it takes." They instead point fingers and cry "witch hunt."
If you're a fan of "24," you'll enjoy "The Dark Side." There you will meet Mamdouh Habib, an Australian, captured in Pakistan, abused by American interrogators with an electric cattle prod and threatened with rape by dogs. He confessed to all sorts of things that weren't true. He was released after three years without charges. Jack Bauer would have known inside of 10 minutes he was not a ticking time bomb. Our real-life heroes tortured him for years before realizing he was innocent.
That is, of course, the punch line. These lawyers who were dead set on unleashing an army of Jack Bauers against our enemies built a whole torture policy around a fictional character. Bauer himself could have told them that one Jack Bauer—a man who deliberately lives outside the boundaries of law—would have been more than enough.
Lithwick is a NEWSWEEK contributing editor and a senior writer for Slate. A version of this column also appears on slate.com.
© 2008
- 1
- 2
My Take
Each Newsweek reader is different—and now your Newsweek can be, too. Use this page to create a experience that's personalized for you and your interests. My Take: it makes Newsweek whatever you want it to be.
Discuss