I am 23 years old and remember high school and middle school vividly. Waiting until a "kid" is a "tween" is waiting far too late. Even though legally speaking they are children, biologically speaking, they are not. The idea of "waiting until marriage" was created thousands of years ago when most people were married between the ages of 11-16, pretty much as soon as their hormones kicked in. There was not much of a "wait" till marriage since only children and adults existed, there was no such thing as "adolescence". Now with the necessities of further education as well as extended life expectancies, marriage this early is impracticle.
Abstinence is a perfectly sound choice and it is certainly the safest choice, there is no argument against that. But if someone makes the choice to not do so they need to know the consequences of it and ways to protect themselves. Comprehensive sex education isn't simply about "putting condoms on cucumbers and doing whatever you want". It is about navigating ones emotions, dealing with pressure, making choices, as well as communication with others. Sex is a complicated issue, even within marriage. Many adults have a hard enough time dealing with their own feelings let alone young people who are having new feelings for the first time and the have a hard enough time articulating and identifying what those feelings are. They need to know that these feelings are not "bad" or "shameful". Indeed, they can not even help having desires since it is simply programmed in their DNA to feel this way. Sexual arousal is an involunary action but people can be educated as to what they feel are the right choices for THEM.
I believe that talking to children about sex should start as early as possible. Long before hormones kick in. They need to know the proper names for anatomy and what sex is to protect themselves from sexual predators. Children of BOTH sexes need guidance as to appropriate and inappropriate touching. People as young as 8 are going through puberty so people need to know how their bodies work. (In college, I volunteered at my student's health center and it's amazing how much people don't know about their own bodies.)
Again, I would like to reiterate that abstinence is a completely valid choice, but it's not the only one. Also, abstinence is still not the end all to be all because it doesn't deal with issues that can still happen within marriage. And comprehensive sex ed does not cause people to turn into sex crazed maniacs as some posters are asserting. 2 of my best friends are still virgins (25 and 22 respectively), and both grew up with comprehensive sex ed. One of these friends actually grew up in Sweden which has one of the most highly comprehensive sexual educations in the world and still chose to stay a virgin. Sweden also has much lower rates of STDs and pregnancy.









Discuss