Can You Give Up Your Car?

 
Sponsored by
 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

 

The key to making it go, though, is having the cars and the complex logistical system to keep track of them. Griffith puts the challenge succinctly: "How do you manage 225,000 people randomly accessing 5,500 cars, 24 hours a day, seven days a week?" Griffith contends his company's edge is the tracking technology it has developed through the years. He compares Zipcar's logistical expertise to Amazon and Netflix.

The big rental agencies, though, have relationships with automakers that can provide them with a steady stream of new cars. Zipcar adds to its fleet just like the rest of us do--by going to a dealer and buying a car. What's more, the rental agencies already have a nationwide network. "We've got a footprint across the country," says Michael Coleman, program manager of U-Haul's U Car Share, which is already operating in 10 cities. "We can grow and expand into new markets faster than other car-sharing companies."

Better yet, when the new sharing services roll into town, they just might set off a price war. U Car Share charges just a one-time $50 membership fee, not an annual fee or a sign-up charge like Zipcar. WeCar's annual membership cost just $35 when it launched in St. Louis last year. (Enterprise declined to provide additional details on WeCar, other than to acknowledge it is now operating in Boston and "plans to expand the program into other markets in the coming months.").

But there's one price problem all the car-rental services share. The same $4 gas that's driving commuters to share cars is also pushing up rental rates. The hourly rate that was once as low as $7 now averages around $10 and is on the rise. Zipcar hiked prices in January and is about to boost them again, resulting in an hourly rate increase of up to 10 percent this year. Gas prices, however, are just one tenth of Zipcar's overall costs. Bigger expenses include the cost of buying cars and paying for parking. As car services take up more parking spaces, they hope they'll have more leverage to cut better deals with cities and private parking-lot companies.

And they plan to fill a lot of parking spaces. Ultimately, car-sharing providers contend they can replace car ownership. Coleman envisions entire neighborhoods sharing a single pickup truck, for example, for all their home-improvement projects. "Fifteen years from now," says Griffiths, "one-car, one-driver won't work anymore."

Don't tell that to Zipcar's new customer, Sherri Fuselier. She's suffering some serious SUV cravings on her low-car diet. "I don't want to give up my SUV. I'm a die-hard, and I need to carry a lot of stuff," says Fuselier, who admits she still drives the Jeep to work once a week. Yeah, it's good to share. But sometimes you just want to say, "This is mine." 

© 2008

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: rossnewsweek @ 10/24/2008 4:20:02 AM

    This is a very competitive world we live in where everybody wants something at a discount price but how do you know that you will always the get the best deal available. Just to save time, most people are happy to believe that the company is looking after them, especially if it is saving them time. To help you sort out a good cheap car rental deal which can be hard for some people, get the SECRET on car rental at:
    http://tenerife-car-rental.blogspot.com

  • Posted By: HillBillyBill @ 08/20/2008 6:17:11 PM

    Yes, I can give up my gasoline fuelled car.
    But just renting another gasoline fuelled car is no answer at all.
    For the sake of future generations, we must move as rapidly as possible to fuelling vehicles with non-oil derived fuels.
    Future generations will need the oil for asphalt to pave their roads and shingles to cover their roofs and materials to build their computers, cell pones, ipods, blackberries and thousands of plastics and other products taken for granted today made from petrochemicals derived from oil.
    We enjoy mind boggling wonderful things made possible by what the generations that came before us made possible.
    We cannot continue to burn up the earth's oil reserves and force future generations to reverse this progress instead of being able to build upon it.
    Let may people--all people--grow!

  • Posted By: yours2share @ 08/06/2008 5:21:43 PM

    Car clubs like Zipcar work really well in certain circumstances. Either you don???t make many journeys, or they are short and you can walk instead (and, as a Brit, I appreciate that in the US it is often not easy for people to walk relatively short distances because often the environment is simply not designed for anyone to do anything but drive, this is very different than in the UK) or there are good public transport alternatives for the longer journeys.

    If you have to commute two hours a day, five days a week, then car clubs will always be more expensive than owning a car, as will hiring a car.

    Car clubs are simply one of many ways of reducing the cost of travelling. They must be considered alongside:
    ??? Public transport
    ??? Walking
    ??? Hiring cars
    ??? Taxis
    ??? More efficient cars with a higher miles per gallon
    ??? Cars that are cheaper to maintain
    ??? Car sharing / life sharing
    ??? Not actually making unnecessary journeys
    ??? Living nearer to your place of work

    All have instances where they are particularly important, and usually any one household has to rely on four or five ways of reducing costs. Over time, the two that are actually most important are more efficient cars and living nearer to places of work. The first is constantly being improved by the car manufacturers, the second occurs as people slowly move over the years to reduce their costs.

    Car clubs also only tend to exist in city areas because they need to be managing many cars to get the required economies of scale. I???m also interested in ???informal car clubs??? where a small group (3-6 people) of local people get together to buy a car together. www.yours2share.com enables people to find suitable partners.

    In the UK we are also working out the same issues, coupled with serious traffic congestion. And petrol currently costs the equivalent of $11 a gallon here, $4 a gallon sounds rather wonderful.

 

Hummer: Hot or Not?

7/27/08: NEWSWEEK’s David Jefferson and Tara Weingarten tool around the fashionable avenues of L.A. to see if the onetime-car-to-the-stars has lost its street cred (Editor: Jon Groat; Camera: Scott Thiel / Road Weary Films)

 
 
The Peek
 
 
MEDIA

Just a year after buying The Wall Street Journal, the press rapscallion has revitalized the fusty paper.

Sponsored by
 
 
 
 
Sponsored by
 
 
 
loadingLoading Menu