Political Perils of a 'Big Sort'?

Passionate partisanship is causing Americans to self-segregate into lifestyle ghettos.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Mr.Gomez @ 09/14/2008 11:50:35 AM

    Only when we can start balancing the emotionalism and the intellectualism in America will
    be have true "cohesion". I am fortunate to live in a VERY small town, where there are million dollar homes next to mobile homes. It is a great place to live! Our town government is ALL volunteer and is made up
    of all walks of life. We have a great community! We have building guidelines that are equal to all.
    As long as you follow the community planning ordinance, build what you want.
    We're not reliant on city water, city sewar etc. When I come home I am happy to come home.
    Not because everyone thinks the way I do, but because we all value the same sunrise and sunset.
    LIVE FREE OR DIE!

  • Posted By: Keith in PA @ 09/09/2008 7:55:49 AM

    Palin also grew up in the Pentacostal church where she spoke in tongues. Her church promotes coverting jews into christians and gays into straights. She rails against spending but her record shows her running up public debt. She cut funding for unwed teenage mothers. She claims that her preacher has prophetic powers. She supported the "bridge to nowhere" and she took the money even though the bridge was killed by congress. She supports the corrupt Senator Stephens. She's way outside the mainstream of American politics.

  • Posted By: jbritt @ 08/08/2008 9:50:33 AM

    loudowsonjr, I have a computer, several in fact, and I do not know that 9/11 was an inside job. Rather than posting unrelated nonsense on this news discussion board, why don't you just turn off your computer and go smoke a bowl and eat some 'cheetos' with your best friend, Judy Wood.

  • Posted By: loudowsonjr @ 08/07/2008 3:49:17 PM

    I would like to know, why no one covering the news is reporting the truth about 9/11. Any person who has a computer, knows that 9/11 was a inside job. If we are ever to be a united nation, we must be told the truth, by those who report the news. The way things are now, few if, any really trust what we read in the news papers, or what we hear on television.

  • Posted By: loudowsonjr @ 08/07/2008 3:46:23 PM

    I would like to know, why no one covering the news is reporting the truth about 9/11. Any person who has a computer, knows that 9/11 was a inside job. If we are ever to be a united nation, we must be told the truth, by those who report the news. The way things are now, few if, any really trust what we read in the news papers, or what we hear on television.

  • Posted By: libertyfirst @ 08/06/2008 4:42:18 PM

    Steven, you just exemplified the very characture of the liberal elitist wanting to recognize, then villianize, and ultimately demand some sort of governmental action against. We all want "better education, healthcare, and economic development." Yes, even evil, big-business loving Republicans do too. The issue is that folks disagree with how to get it. I'm a conservative...so I tend to want less government manipulation of markets, less regulation, less government telling how to live, what to eat, what to drive, etc... and...yes, tougher expectations for public education (and immense financial black hole it represents). If you disagree, fine. But disagree with facts and positions supported by objective evidence, rather than simply calling me ignorant, or duped by Rush Limbaugh. Example: the evil "big business" you speak of is what provides many, many Americans a job, a career, money, a standard of living etc... So before you cast your wide net of disparage, please keep some perspective. Lastly, what does make a conservative's blood boil is the too frequently cited call to arms by the liberal elite for governement to make structural changes to how we live for the "betterment" of all. America was founded on the notion of liberty -- not a never-ending set of rules made by elected rulemakers designed to decide who wins and who loses. So please, would all the liberals out there rest their urges to regulate us to "utopia" and allow me to make my own mistakes. Let me choose the wrong foods, be unhealthy, suffer the consequences of my own actions, enjoy the fruits of my own labor, live life the way I choose and NOT according to how you would so want. Thank you.

    • Posted By: lvbartman @ 08/06/2008 6:27:36 PM

      "live life the way I choose and NOT according to how you would so want. Thank you".

      And will all you conservatives do the same for me when it comes to issues like gay rights, marriage, serving in the military? Or is liberty first only for you?

      • Posted By: libertyfirst @ 08/07/2008 1:19:16 PM

        I have no problem with citizen rights extending to all citizens...gay or not. Liberty knows no color, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation as far as I'm concerned. I will, however, scrutinize and carefully consider any proposals for legislation written in such a manner that place "special" privilages and protections on any one group of folks.

    • Posted By: lvbartman @ 08/06/2008 6:30:26 PM

      'live life the way I choose and NOT according to how you would so want. Thank you.'

      So are you willing to give me the same, in areas like gay rights?

    • Posted By: stephenprestwood @ 08/06/2008 5:00:50 PM

      What makes your blood boil is that you have been duped by big business, power-hungry politicians, and religious charlatans. Pointing out the truth doesn???t make me ???elitist??? or ???arrogant???. Those are just buzzwords used by conservatives to scare people and to try to undermine reasoned arguments without ever having to address the facts. The conservative Right certainly knows something about villainizing people though. They???ve perfected the art. But people are beginning to see through this.

      And of course I???m not against jobs or even large corporations. I???m just against an elite group of business executives and board members from rigging the system against the best interests of the American people. I think the bloated CEO salaries, outsourcing, price-gauging, and corporate corruption scandals are visible signs of a rotten core.

      • Posted By: libertyfirst @ 08/06/2008 5:15:56 PM

        Point out all the truths you wish...no problem for me. But you seem to be arguing that someone (government) should do something about these "truths." That's what disturbs me...and a lot of other folks I'm sure.

        • Posted By: stephenprestwood @ 08/06/2008 5:24:04 PM

          You're right. I am. Sorry if that's disturbing, but actually want my government to implement good policies based on the best information we have available. I want them to use science and reason and compassion for our fellow man in the process. Again, I am not afraid of the outcomes if we do that.

    • Posted By: olderwiser @ 08/06/2008 4:47:58 PM

      That's some mighty passionate partisanship.

      • Posted By: libertyfirst @ 08/06/2008 5:02:04 PM

        Perhaps...along with some lousy spelling.

  • Posted By: bluegrass101 @ 08/06/2008 6:59:27 PM

    One thing the Repig's will never do and that is to vote for anyone with a drop of Black, Oriental, or any Race that is not their own. That is why I do not understand people like Joe Watkins , Ron Cristie, or any Black Politician who thinks they are accepted in the Repig Party. I know how they talk about Blacks behind their backs.

    • Posted By: Lee Holmes @ 08/07/2008 11:52:02 AM

      No you do not. Take Ed Steele for instance,the African American chairman of GOPAC. When Steele ran for senator in Maryland,it would become Chuck Schumers DSCC who played the dirty tricks,by sending in operatives that got hold of Steeles credit records and reports and illegally[as so found by a federal judge] leaking these to the media. JC Watts, a consistant and staunch Republican is viewed as ''token'' or ''oreo'' or ''uncle tom'',by those too stupid to know any better.
      Alan Keyes,Earl Ofai Hutchinson,Thomas Sowell,James McWhorter, and other black conservtaive or libertarian voices some of which are enconsed in AM talk radio are treated to the same vile racism due to the fact that they speak and think outside of the ideological box. They have strayed ''off the reservation''and are hated for it by their black and white liberal peers. Indeed,they are in stark contrast to the ''Big Sort''.

    • Posted By: lvrplfc4l @ 08/06/2008 7:18:25 PM

      Yet another Democrat over simplification, as a Republican of the Teddy Roosevelt style of Republicanism I have vote for a Democrat black female state representative, black male Democrat for school board and a Hispanic female for county commissioner. I voted for all because they were the best candidate with the best ideas for our community. I'm more than willing to vote for anyone who has good ideas are you?

    • Posted By: lvrplfc4l @ 08/06/2008 7:17:38 PM

      Yet another Democrat over simplification, as a Republican of the Teddy Roosevelt style of Republicanism I have vote for a Democrat black female state representative, black male Democrat for school board and a Hispanic female for county commissioner. I voted for all because they were the best candidate with the best ideas for our community. I'm more than willing to vote for anyone who has good ideas are you?

  • Posted By: okie3 @ 08/07/2008 8:43:19 AM

    In Texas it's call gerrymeandering, that's when a Replican controlled legislature draws little lines up one street and down another to make sure all the blacks are in one precinct.

  • Posted By: DoctorJazz @ 08/07/2008 2:40:42 AM

    Well, you can count me in on this. I used to think that conservatism was another legitimate viewpoint and something that honorable men could disagree about. After the last 8 poisonous years, it's clear to me that there can be only two kinds of Republicans left. There are evil Republicans and there are willfully ignorant Republicans. Both types disgust me. They have destroyed my beautiful country and I don't want to spend any more time around them than I absolutely have to.

  • Posted By: C. MacLean @ 08/06/2008 10:59:17 PM

    As far as I can see, America has always self-segregated into lifestyle ghettos, it's just that the geographic borders are smaller than they used to be. Initially, we had two basic divisions; federalists vs states rights folks. That morphed into north vs south. If memory serves, we even fought a war of north against south - some folks are still fighting it.

    For a while we had east - the establishment - vs. west - the frontier. There was gold vs. silver, farmers vs city people. Immigrants vs. people who were born here - some folks are still fighting that battle, too.

    In short, the divisions have always been there - at first they were ideological divisions, then they became geographic divisions.

    As the geography gets smaller - from regions to states to counties - the electoral college becomes more outdated.

    This article firms up the case for going with a popular vote, rather than the obsolete electoral college. And now that senators are voted on by popular vote, rather than by state legistative bodies, one could argue that we no longer need two houses of congress, either - one ought to be able to get the job done.

  • Posted By: thehappyamerican @ 08/06/2008 7:18:47 PM

    Portland, Oregon!
    At the Obama Show here , I went Portlands' nice zoo, passed that assembly and knew my zoo trip was going to be great! Obama was like a mothlight to all the wierdows, streeties,pamphleteers, gays, pan handlers, druggies, and everyone I'd rather not see at the zoo.
    I have heard reports that the Obama organizers put the portable rest rooms on a memorial to the fallen Police Officers who died protecting the peace... but can't confirm that. Though the memorial is real and immediatly in the area of the Obama Show.
    Please Obama! Bring you Rocking Rolling act here again only somewhere far from memorials to good men and women. Bring back the Pied Piper show of shows! Clean up Portland, Oregon, if even for a few hours!
    Thanks to you my zoo visit was awesome!

  • Posted By: jgundrey @ 08/06/2008 7:11:52 PM

    You can point fingers back and forth with all the mind-numbing ad hominem attacks you want (mostly by the conservative side). But face the reality - the American experiment is coming to an end. We're going to see states get redder and bluer until the disparity turns us into two different nations within a nation. Some states will outlaw abortion while others will always assure its availability. Some will permit gay marriage while others will never allow it. We'll have polar opposites in everything from gun laws to public assistance programs to drug laws to civil rights laws - you name it. Merely crossing a state border could instantly cost you rights or as quickly make you a criminal.

    Since there are no constitutional provisions for secession we're going to see the country devolve into two federal republics - separated by political philosophy rather than geography - with two different interpretations of the same constitution.

  • Posted By: bluegrass101 @ 08/06/2008 7:07:38 PM

    How come the poorest states like Ala, Ga, Missi,Louisiana, Tenn, , and also the most Obese, the most uneducated vote for the Repig Party. I'll tell you why, it's because they will always, for the most part be brainwashed by the Foaming Mouth's of the Far Right Talking heads and the Screwball Evangelicals.

  • Posted By: dale rutherford @ 08/06/2008 7:03:03 PM

    As I read the posts responding to this article, one of the funnier themes is how accurate stereotypes are reflected (in this case not race; but by political preference). The liberal posts are mostly far left, barely able to contain the self importance that conservatives place under a microscope nightly on propaganda fests such as Fox News, Bill O'Reilly, and the rest.

    Meanwhile the conservative posters fulfill their stereotypes including the inability to much of anything other than bash liberal point of view and repeat the republican media talking points. I have news for you conservatives; your party aint conservative. When conservatives stop pushing religion into state run institutions (public schools, etc), stop pushing freedom crushing laws such at the Patriot act, stop pretending that the republican party stays out of the business of US citizens, and most definetly stops hammering democrats as tax/spend enimies of the state while bankrupting the country with cut tax and spend policies.

    No one listens; everyone talks. I love this country for what it achieved; but it is slipping away from us. As a country you cant spend 20+ years in political gridlock or political activism and expect a balanced budget, money that is worth more than the paper it is printed on, security and opportunity for all.

    There is a tipping point and the United States is on the peak.

    You know, shut the hole! To quote: ???Ask not what your country can do for you .. and get off your butts, shut your mouths, and do something for your country.???

  • Posted By: Lee Holmes @ 08/06/2008 7:01:53 PM

    It points to the total failure of ''diversity'',something no-one really wants at the heart of the ''Big Sort''.Bishop is right. Homogenized ideologies tout ''diversity''so long as it fits within their partisan mores. I see gay bars openly operating in Oklahoma City. I see few to no rightist conservative evangelical churches in San Francisco. I see writers[including Dickey,whose relative was the author of ''Deliverance''],waxing eloquent on the ''New South''. I also see raging bigotry no differant than that which was practiced in the old White Citizens Councils being performed on one American campus after another. Several of these,in regions of the nation that espouse ''tolerance''and ''diversity''.[including the new tactic of ''tolerance'',firebombing,such as that which is being endured by scientists at UC Santa Cruz by leftwinged Luddites at the present time]. People point at the ''other''not realizing as they look around,that their peers are cookie-cutter wearers of fashion,listerners of music,readers of books,bearing the same political and social ideologies as their own. One side asks ''if you are against abortion,then why don't you want to take care of the baby after it is born''? The other asks,''If you are such a champion of minority rights,then why are you not living on the Southside beyond the railroad tracks rather than in safe suburbs and wealthy neighborhoods''? It goes on and on,contributing to the ideological segregation. ''I hate guns''[except when my bodyguards are packing heat]. ''I am against global warming''[except when I fly on LEAR jets,and drive SUVs].''Jesus Saves''[except when I am raking in enough loot to build twenty mansions]. ''I am against gay rights''[except when I engage in sordid park bathroom affairs]. The Age of the Internet was to be the great leavener. Instead,it performs its share to contribute to the Age of the Big Sort acting no differant than tradtional,increasingly partisan[''Big Sorts'' of their own],media,which is more problem creator,than problem solver,fitting neatly with the presentday form of government as practiced in Washington.

  • Posted By: Noam_Saying @ 08/06/2008 4:52:57 PM

    Steven: If you Democrats are so educated and forward thinking then why is the core constituency of your party made up of people who populate ghettos, trailer parks and labor unions?

    • Posted By: lvbartman @ 08/06/2008 6:38:02 PM

      Spoken like the true prejudiced bigot you are !

    • Posted By: stephenprestwood @ 08/06/2008 5:04:35 PM

      Get your facts straight. Statistically, Democrats are better educated than their Republican counterparts. (Again, the truth hurts.) But your incorrect assumptions help prove my point about conservative stereotyping and misinformation.

      • Posted By: Noam_Saying @ 08/06/2008 5:11:28 PM

        I live in Memphis, and believe me, the people who vote Demoratic here are far from educated. They're walking around with one hand palm up asking for a handout and the other pointing the finger of blame at everyone but themselves. By the way, I have two college degrees with a 3.5 GPA.

        • Posted By: stephenprestwood @ 08/06/2008 5:19:38 PM

          It's a big country, Noam_Saying. Get out of Memphis some time and check out the realities in other areas. The fact is that Blue states like California and New York subsidize Red states like Tennessee with their tax dollars. The US Treasury Dept can supply the facts. And if you look at the economic engines in California like the Silicon Valley and western LA County, they are dark Blue.

          • Posted By: donbl @ 08/06/2008 5:36:16 PM

            Stephen, that is a fanciful Blue state statement.

            Actually, NY and CA get more dollar per citizen than Tennessee.

            Saying poor Southern Tennessee is a bunch of redneck poor people is elitest and wrong.

  • Posted By: Noam_Saying @ 08/06/2008 5:51:15 PM

    donbl: Don't confuse the liberals with facts. They find them completely irrelevant anyway.

  • Posted By: Noam_Saying @ 08/06/2008 5:25:44 PM

    If anyone knows about subsidies, it's a Democrat!

  • Posted By: coctyle @ 08/06/2008 3:13:48 PM

    I think this does happen, but it is only one of many factors that determine where people live. Most can not afford to move wherever they want and may be limited by job prospects, particularly if the person works in a technical or specialized field.

    On the other hand, I used to live and work in an area where I was a political minority, and that was one of many reasons that I chose to move. It took a couple of years before I could find a better job in a new community, but eventually I did. So, I don't think this phenomenon is going to lead to massive relocation, but more of a slow trend. The way politics go, people's opinions probably change faster than their address.

  • Posted By: stephenprestwood @ 08/06/2008 2:09:49 PM

    Let's just tell it like is, okay.

    Half of this country is ready to move forward and sees the future as a challenge and a great opportunity for global cooperation and progress. They believe in education and a reasoned, scientific approach to technical problems. They believe in compassionate approaches to social ills. They believe that our resources can be better allocated and that the goal of social equity brings many benefits. Their spiritual lives are rich and diverse and embrace an evolving moral consciousness. These people mostly live in blue counties and cities and vote Democratic. Their views are challenged everyday because they respect reason and intelligent discussion, and as a result their feelings, opinions and ideas continue to evolve.

    The other half of the country is less well educated and doesn't even believe science is a legitimate approach to solve issues or learn about the world. They already "know" everything because they've spoken personally to God. They have a child-like view of religion and often attribute the same uneducated spiteful values of their own communities to God. They are suspicious of foreigners and unfamiliar customs. They do not believe the US has anything to learn from other countries or other customs. Their idea of community does not include people of other colors, ethnic backgrounds, or sexual orientations. They live in mostly "red" counties and cities where their views are rarely challenged. They believe it is more important to be unyielding than it is to be wise; more important to invoke the name of God than to act in godly ways. These people vote Republican.

    No surprise then that these two groups choose mostly to live in separate communities.

    Oh! Wait. I forgot. There is a third important group. They are just like the first ???blue??? group, except they are rich and selfish and cynical. They are well educated and sip Chardonnay too, but they vote Republican. In fact, they used to run the Republican Party but now it is a bit hard to maintain control over all those uppity religious types that they so successfully manipulated with wedge issues for decades. For them, it is all about hoarding their wealth and diminishing the competition. Fixing the game, so to speak. Interestingly, this group lives right along side the ???blue??? group and enjoys all their customs and ways--a strangely parasitic existence, really. They were killing the host for a while, but I think Americans are finally growing more immune to their virulent policies and actions. At least that is my hope.

    • Posted By: lvrplfc4l @ 08/06/2008 3:10:21 PM

      Steven telling it like it is? Please your response is representative of the problem.
      The blue half is all knowledge and light, the red half is all ignorance and darkness, and
      then you find a third part? Wait half plus half equals a whole and then you find more?
      So much for the education in your blue half. This is the problem in America the unwillingness to see the other side???s point of view; both sides take all the credit and place all the blame on the other. The polarization of communities into enclaves of liberal v conservative, rich v poor or even educated v uneducated produces alienation and simplification. This allows groups to disdain other???s ideas, to belittle their beliefs and view them as nescient. What both parties have forgotten is that a representative democracy is not about crushing your opponent but about governing, governing both the wining and losing side, understanding that opposing sides must find common ground to govern effectively and that compromising is not surrendering principles but adjusting principles for the common good.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse