High-Powered Treatment

Despite the stigma, electroshock therapy is making a quiet comeback.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Janet Stein @ 09/13/2008 12:45:06 PM

    Anyone considering electroshock for himself or a loved one should check out the electroshock survivors groups. I don't know of any other "therapy" that has inspired thousands of former patients to join together to educate the public about the horrors of this treatment. Electroshock is STILL being forced on people - and to me, that says it all. Doctors and technicians that deliver electroshock have lost all trace of humanity.

  • Posted By: Janet Stein @ 09/13/2008 12:41:49 PM

    Anyone contemplating electroshock for himself or a loved one should check out the electroshock survivors groups. I can't think of any other treatment which has inspired thousands of recipients to join together to educate the public on the horrors of what they experienced. Electroshoock is also forced on people - and that, to me, says it all. Doctors and technicians that deliver electroshock have lost all trace of humanity.

  • Posted By: jane.simpson.wilson @ 08/15/2008 3:14:12 PM

    ECT....are we regressing because we are not willing to work on other therapies that can be effective. This just seems so Draconian to me. Cukoo's Nest. Kesey worked at the Palo Alto VA when he was at Stanford and saw this brutality practiced, hence his book. Please stop this madness. My husband is 100 per cent disabled from his service to our country and his Depression is staggering in it's depth and the pain that it causes him on a daily basis, but I would rather euthanizehim than put him through this bbarbaric "treatment". Shame on the AMA.

  • Posted By: A. Nonymus @ 08/07/2008 2:19:40 PM

    There's a good deal of ill-informed reactionary hysteria aimed at ECT, much of it promoted by the Church of Scientology. John Breeding, for instance, is a notorious flack for the "Citizens Commission on Human Rights," a CoS front organization that promotes L. Ron Hubbard's dictum that psychiatrists are "the sole cause of decline in this universe." The real reason for Hubbard's hostility to psychiatry and its therapeutic tools is obvious: vulnerable people make better victims for predatory con men, and real scientific healing makes them harder to victimize.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse