The Caucasian Card

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: DiBaskin @ 08/11/2008 12:20:32 PM

    If Obama was White he would be leading by double digits. He has been called the Anti-Christ, Un-American and many other names. McCain plans on winning not by telling Americans what he will do, but by bringing Obama down with lies and half truths. I think people are dreaming if they think White America will allow a Black man to be president of this country. Even with Affirmative action Blacks weren't allowed to go but so high up. Hillary was right some of her supporters are just racist and will never vote for a Black man. McCain can't win by saying what he will do for this country. His only hope is to bring Obama down and try to make him seem scary. The scary thing to me is that the same people that voted for Bush will be voting for McCain. Then they will blame Congress for the state of the country.

    • Posted By: denmill @ 08/12/2008 8:05:19 AM

      You are dead wrong! If Obama was white he would be long gone. CNN, ABC MSBC & NBC would not allow a white man who sat in a church for 20 months where a former KKK pastor talk trash about blacks. Obama sat and listened to Jeremiah White's garbages with his entire family for 20 YEARS. THINK ABOUT THAT!!!!!

  • Posted By: SgtLucifer @ 08/12/2008 5:34:23 AM

    Ms. Quindlen..., a great and wonderful piece, as always. It's remarkable how a white person is able to articulate the experiences and trauma a black person has to endure on a regular (or jarringly intermittent) basis, silently most of the time for fear of being branded an angry bitter soul. I have to commend Barrack Obama. You couldn't pay me enough to be in his shoes. With all the blows I experience in the country as a black man, I could never be persuaded to stick my neck out for this country.

  • Posted By: SgtLucifer @ 08/12/2008 5:25:56 AM

    Ms. Quindlen, great piece... as always. I find it quite remarkable how a white person could so well articulate the experience and the trauma a black person have to endure, many times silently for fear of being branded angry and bitter.

  • Posted By: josemarti @ 08/12/2008 12:15:36 AM

    Dear Ms. Quindlen. Just got to my motel after trying to spread the Obama Gospel in the suburbs of Cincinnatta, Ohio. I knocked at a door and told the rustic fellow who opened it: "You must repent you clinging clinger. Stop clinging to your guns and Bible. I teach you the Overman." What do you know, but the old critter did not take too kindly to my words and you never heard such cussing, and swearing, and I barely had time to get into my Subaru to escape having a skull broken by a bottle of whiskey. Must be a Reds fan. I am gonna try Dayton tomorraw.

  • Posted By: Original Obama Mama @ 08/11/2008 11:34:58 PM

    Oh finally someone other than an African American or person of color that understands AND bold enough to write about it. I am so tired of hearing we're playing the race card as if racism and prejudice is some sort of game that we use when convenient. However, when it comes to housing, jobs, education, police brutality, the justice system, health, etc. we are low on every totem pole. Thank you for your honest and courage.
    Obama is intelligent, insightful, and has vision. Yes, he is confident, as he should be. Still he's compared to dingy air heads. When he's not compared to them he's elitist, or he's too cocky, and arrogant. Words used to define intelligent black men that don't know their place.

  • Posted By: morbie5 @ 08/11/2008 4:29:15 PM

    This woman is mistaken if she doesn't think minorities get advancement because of Affirmative Action and white guilt. The only reason freshmen Senator Obama was considered a serious candidate for president was because he is black.

    • Posted By: ppc10 @ 08/11/2008 11:23:42 PM

      Just like the only reason he got into Harvard Law was because he is black. oh wait.

  • Posted By: jason13323 @ 08/11/2008 10:14:12 AM

    The laughable thing is that Obama was a white guy until he decided to become a black guy. I mean he was raised by a white mother and white grandparents. They sent him to toney white schools. It's hard to pinpoint the time when he made the decision to be black. Certainly he had become a black guy by the time he arrived in Chicago after Harvard Law.

    • Posted By: ppc10 @ 08/11/2008 11:21:56 PM

      Republican playing the caucasian card..cute.

  • Posted By: Pete Kent @ 08/11/2008 2:42:30 PM

    I find it funny that Obama and his minions are now pushing the meme that he did not include his race on his Harvard application. I am sure there were many ways his race was well known to them.

    • Posted By: ppc10 @ 08/11/2008 11:19:05 PM

      And why would that matter?
      I think this is the whole point of the article.

  • Posted By: josemarti @ 08/11/2008 4:16:44 PM

    Dear Ms. Quindlen after reading your excellent article I was surprised to see that you graduated from Barnard. I would have expected you to have graduated from the more prestigious Williams or Amherst . You must have been a late bloomer.

  • Posted By: josemarti @ 08/11/2008 5:10:44 PM

    Ms. Quindlen, your article has nearly driven me mad with guilt, shame, and regret. I cannot wait for election day when my vote for Obama will lessen the feelings that now oppress me. May your article be read by thousands of others like myself and may it burden them as it has burden me and may they too seek relief through their vote.

    • Posted By: Dr. S @ 08/11/2008 5:24:42 PM

      Jose,
      Please seek therapy for all of your guilt and affective morbidity, and please abstain from taking it out on the rest of US. Good luck!

      • Posted By: josemarti @ 08/11/2008 5:41:08 PM

        What kind of therapy? Cognitive behavioral. Interpersonal. Social rhythms. Dialectical behavioral. Supportive. Psychoanalytic. Group. Expressive. Art therapy. Light therapy. Medication therapy. EMDR. ECT. rTMS. Please be more specific.

        • Posted By: Dr. S @ 08/11/2008 5:48:14 PM

          YES......all of the above.

          • Posted By: josemarti @ 08/11/2008 5:53:12 PM

            They are all very expensive. I will have to wait until Comrade Obama socializes medicine.

            • Posted By: ppc10 @ 08/11/2008 11:14:18 PM

              I'm glad you're voting for him.

  • Posted By: CLASSIC DREAMS @ 08/11/2008 10:52:49 PM

    WAKE-UP MCCAIN! NO GO BACK TO BED.

  • Posted By: Power @ 08/11/2008 10:42:39 PM

    John Mc Cain played the Race Card when he allowed buttons to be circulated at one of his meetings that questioned whether the White House would keep its name.

  • Posted By: Spalding @ 08/11/2008 8:37:31 PM

    McCain has a darn good chance of winning in November. If the last eight years have shown us anything, it's that the overwhelming majority of voters in the U.S. are stupid and ignorant, unable to read a book and therefore unable to learn from history, gullible and therefore easy victims for scare tactics, greedy and selfish. They are largely without common sense and absolute strangers to logic. I would be very depressed about this, except for the fact that they are even now beginning to reap the disastrous results of their stupidity and it's going to get worse rapidly (yes I'm talking to the people who can't sell their big ole SUVs). Say hello to ever rising gas prices and a crumbling economy! You deserve it!

    • Posted By: kew498 @ 08/11/2008 10:24:49 PM

      We deserve it? Very nice Spalding. I love it when socialists display their hatred for a free-market capital society. It's a clear demonstration that the weak, lazy masses of the world are jealous of the great American dream. Obviously, no dream is without difficulties but America will survive these hard times as we always do. You socialists can just keep your mediocrity & continue hating us.

  • Posted By: jroyer24 @ 08/11/2008 9:53:01 PM

    It is sad the Newsweek has become so biased. This aritcle is so absurd that it is sad. To let every one know there is no conspiracy among white folks to keep the black man down. Maybe people do not want Obama as President because he is a 2yr Senator that keeps flip flopping. Maybe they want a more experienced person as President. I will not read the news if Obama loses because it will all say that it is because of racism. I am a 33yr old white maie that was not alive during slavery of segration. I am sick and tired of white guilt like the author of this article.

  • Posted By: the mermaid @ 08/11/2008 8:57:52 PM

    It"s not just "tough" being black in America; under the circumstances, it's amazing that people of color in this country - suffering from centuries of unspeakably brutal racism, discrimination and political fear-mongering -haven't completely and collectively lost their minds. I wonder what condition white America would be in today if the situation had been reversed?

  • Posted By: private312 @ 08/11/2008 7:43:03 PM

    "the big lie... that black men and women commonly use race as ..an excuse, and that they will always blame failures ...on racism." Ms Quindlen, I don't want this to surprise you since you think it is a big lie, but if Obama loses the election US blacks in the MILLIONS will blame his failure to achieve the presidency on racism. Thinking it is a big lie means you live in a tiny bubble. Of course it is that same bubble that allows you as a white woman to open your article explaining to me that it can be tough being black in America. By the way, it all has to do with the color of his skin. There are those that won't vote for him due only to the color of his skin, and there are those that WILL vote for him due only to the skin, both black people and white people.

  • Posted By: newsie0 @ 08/11/2008 1:52:28 PM

    I think your argument concerning race and meritocracy is excellent because I was caught in that racist trap of considering affirmative-action and quotas to mean the ascendancy of the second-rate. I knew that was wrong and unjust but wasn't able to articulate an adequate counter-argument, until I read your article so thanks for helping me to break through that conundrum. While I agree with practically all your points, particularly about non-whites experiencing discrimination (I'm east Indian so I know first hand), I will say in the case of Obama it doesn't apply. He most definitely was using race-card as a bludgeon against John McCain to try to shut down any attacks against him as racist. He stated it bluntly in June with him comment "oh by the way, did you know he's black" (where he repeated the same attack against McCain).

    I personally have no issues with a black president, but Obama's values are downright dangerous for this country, particularly his passivity towards the enemies of America, not to mention his lack of any leadership experience, his far left radical connections, his endless flip-flopping for political expedience, partisanship, his arrogance and presumption of entitlement and so forth, I'm just scratching the surface. If Obama and McCain's background/character were reversed, Obama would be getting my vote, but since that's not the case obviously McCain deserves it. Let's not elect a president out of white-guilt, that'd be a disservice to the country and also a setback for race-relations when people realize Obama is incompetent and unfit to lead.

    • Posted By: benitacanova @ 08/11/2008 4:16:33 PM

      beautifully written - i agree 100%. as B.O. would say "this issue of racism is nothing but a distraction from the real issues. the american people deserve better." and we do. unfortunately i believe it's a sad fact that considering his empty CV, if he weren't black, he would in no possible way be in the position he is in today as presumptive nominee.

      • Posted By: newsie0 @ 08/11/2008 7:36:12 PM

        Many thanks and very well said-absoluteiy, if Obama was white he would've been eliminated early for his inexperience. Its his novelty factor as a black presidential candidate, his good looks, great oratory and the fact that the country is disgruntled with Republicans over Iraq that buoyed Obama. Hopefully come election time people will make a cool headed sober decision and vote for the candidate with substance (McCain), not the preening prima donna. :)

  • Posted By: Richard1327 @ 08/11/2008 9:27:24 AM

    Obama got this far because the DNC prevented fair elections in 2 states that were Clinton wins. Obama got this far because 95% of blacks blindly voted for him and the caucuses skewed the primary results unfairly in his favor. Don't make this out to be some grand study of character in the face of adversity when it's just another shrewd politician who had unlimited funds and a scheme to be president since Obama graduated from law school. Obama farts and Newsweek hears Beethoven.

    • Posted By: jabadramo @ 08/11/2008 11:02:25 AM

      Why is it the white people continue to assume that black people know nothing about politics and policy? The offensive nature of your comments astounds me. I was for Hillary on the experience thing but Obamas ability to manage his campaign in such a keen manner made me look at him. Then when it became apparent that he was better organized then Clinton and that she made the assumption the people were going to vote for her just because she was Hillary, I changed my mind. My vote has to be worked for I owe it to no one. Funny because in your world you would think blacks would have vote for Jessie Jackson just because he was black but Bill Clinton got most of their vote go figure.

      • Posted By: Richard1327 @ 08/11/2008 7:27:04 PM

        No candidate ever got 95% support from a homogenized group. Those of us who live in the real world understand what happened and we know that unless 95% of whites also voted for Obama, the blacks made it a vote based mostly on race. By the way, campaigning for president doesn't give a candidate experience to be president; is just makes a candidate a good politician.

  • Posted By: cheerios @ 08/11/2008 5:39:17 PM

    BUSH BUSH CHENEY CHENEY OIL OIL NEOCONS...MCCAIN MCCAIN MCCAIN!. The preceding argument can be applied to any debate. Repeat loudly & endlessly.

  • Posted By: josemarti @ 08/11/2008 5:28:17 PM

    Ms. Quindle. Two months is too long to wait. How may I find relief today from this searing sense of shame, guilt, and regret. Should I make a donation? Yet me thinks that even a million dollars would barely quiet those Furies. Should I volunteer? Yes. I will volunteer. I will go into rural Ohio, rural Pennsylvannia, rural Michigan. I will knock on the doors of those clinging clingers clinging on their guns, and Bibles and tell them stop you clingers clinging on to your guns and Bibles. You will not begin to find relief until you have resolved to vote for Obama. They will greet with open arms. I am on my way.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse