A 3 a.m. Moment

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Spacer @ 08/17/2008 9:47:11 AM

    After 9/11, the Iraq debacle, and the Israeli/Hezbollah conflict, only an idiot would claim that the Georgia situation is the first major crisis of the 21st Century, ANd that's exactly what McCain did. But now the corporate media are praising McCain for being "prescient" about Russia's intentions despite the fact that he's repeatedly shown himself to be a clueless warmonger.

    • Posted By: Shash Nahalin @ 08/17/2008 10:43:30 AM

      McCain has already done his homework on Georgia and has already formulated a response. He visited Georgia a couple of times and know it???s President. McCain is also a graduate of the Naval Academy, Retired Navy Captain and attendee of the National War College John McCain has a command of the facts. Obama hasn???t even got his boot???s on.
      McCain understands that the dissolution of the USSR resulted in Russia being surrounded and isolated both politically and militarily. Instead of calling the tune, the newly liberated captive nations have Russia in a bit of bind. The US efforts to get the former captive nations into NATO may have been more tit-for-tat than ???arrogance,??? because Russia has targeted the former captive nations with cyber attacks, cut off natural gas and oil supplies, supplied Russian speaking rebels and still has army troop occupying some areas.
      McCain also understands that the only ice free ports for Russia's Baltic Fleet is the Kaliningrad Oblast which has has no land connection to the rest of Russia It is surrounded by Lithuania and Poland which both became members of the European Union and NATO, and entered the Schengen Zone, which means that the oblast is surrounded by the territories of these organizations as well.

      Russia's Black Sea Fleet now leases its main base in Sevastopol, Ukraine. Ukraine told Russia the lease will not be extended and that the fleet will have to leave Sevastopol by 2017. After the invasion of Georgia, Ukraine has limited the Russian navy's movement in its waters.

      Russia's North Fleet operates out of bases in the Arctic circle and Pacific Fleet is at the end of a long logistical line. Reminiscent of humiliated, but resurgent Germany in the 1930s, Russia is beginning a Naval rearmament program to replace 45% of it's fleet by 2015.

  • Posted By: mrspeel @ 08/16/2008 7:44:41 PM

    John McCain, whose chief campaign adviser was, until April, a lobbyist for Georgia, just had to jump all over the situation even before our own President did. Now granted, Bush should have reacted immediately instead of languishing at the Olympics, but John McCain is NOT the President and had no right to begin his inevitable and ever-ready saber-rattling, before he even had all the details. Yes, he was talking to President Saakashvili on a daily basis, but obviously the President of Georgia fed him a line and he fell for it hook, line and sinker! The puffed-up rhetoric, coupled with his bluster of the "you'll be sorry" meme was aimed at Russia, but as fate would have it, new details are slowly coming to light that it was Georgia, NOT Russia who was the instigator in creating the crisis. That really makes me wonder about his so-called Foreign Policy!

    On the other hand, Barack Obama - who IS NOT a MUSLIM - took a measured approach and waited until he had all the details before making any of his statements. When both candidates had finished their prepared statements, they were basically on the same page as to how to handle the matter. That said however, because McCain chose to continue his rhetoric in proclaiming "Nations don't invade other sovereign nations in the 21st Century" which, I might add is exactly what we did with Iraq and he heartily voted for at the time.

    The Bear has awakened from her sleep, and will need to be dealt with, but John McCain is of the "Do as I say, not as I do" mold, and what he showed me was that a McCain Presidency would be an "Act now; ask questions later" Foreign Policy. That is a VERY SCARY propositition in my opinion!

    • Posted By: Shash Nahalin @ 08/17/2008 10:31:53 AM

      Virginia Governor Tim Kaine said that Russia's President Medvedev "complied" with Senator Obama's request for a cease fire was of a piece with the MrsPeel and the Dem's meme about Obama being a natural (no experience needed) Bear Whisperer.

      A Bear whisperer (not unlike a horse whisperer) is a politician who adopts a sympathetic view of the motives, needs, and desires of the Bear, based on natural diplomacy and modern ursidae psychology.
      Obama supporters devoutly believe that he will be able to say things to the Bear in a way the Bear will understand and accept so that the Bear will be quickly gentled by his mysterious techniques.

  • Posted By: arbite @ 08/17/2008 9:46:35 AM

    What happens at 3 am is often caused by what we did the day before.

    McCain has been aggressive, even belligerent, in criticizing the Russian invasion. But Putin has ignored him, because all Putin needed from McCain was 150,000 American troops bogged down in Iraq. That invasion gave Russia all the permission it needed.

    McCain has also been naive. Asserting that "in the 21st century, nations don't invade nations." It was a Nancy Reagan "just so no to [international crises]" moment.

    Neither McCain's aggressiveness nor his naivite have accomplished what Georgia's neighbors have, when the Presidents of five former Soviet satellites travelled to the Georgian capital to show Putin that his former slave states were not going to be cowed easily, even without the U.S. to protect them. Biden, to his credit, has done the same, as has Condoleeza Rice. Both deserve for this to be noted in history.

    Finally, we need to stop congratulating ourselves on "winning" the Cold War and realize that Russia is still there, and still a rival at best, but more often an enemy, and that China remains a rival and terrorists still have free reign in Pakistan. Our enemies have learned that the path to victory is patience and giving Republicans a chance to gloat about a battle before they lose a war.


  • Posted By: vakosh @ 08/16/2008 11:05:19 AM

    O is giving me much pause for concern he is on vaca a LOT and seems completely uninterested in what is going on in the U.S., much more comfortable to sit it out until he has to respond. I hope he has something really, really big planned for the convention, because it seems to me he is trying to lose.

    • Posted By: MG of IL @ 08/16/2008 9:51:49 PM

      I think you are mistaken - Obama's vacation is the first in some 16-18 months. He visited his grandmother and friends in his native Hawaii - what's the problem with that? He has not taken LOTS of vacations or LOTS of days off. John McCain takes weekends off - two days here and there adds up to quite a few days off.

  • Posted By: just-another-sweetie @ 08/15/2008 8:19:08 PM

    valadezaj, Obama reminds me of those Verizon commercials???he requires that crowd of helpers following him wherever he goes!

    • Posted By: cult followers @ 08/16/2008 8:55:07 PM

      ...can you hear me now?

    • Posted By: Omaar @ 08/15/2008 8:27:38 PM

      OH YEAH....

      LIKE THE LARGER CROWDS THAT READ, WRITE , FOLLOW AND INSTRUCT BOTH GEORGE W. BUSH JR. AND JOHN "SEMI-SENILE" MCCAIN !!!


      LIKE EITHER ONE OF THOSE (2 CLOWNS) WRITE THEIR OWN SPEECHES ?

      MOREOVER MCCAIN CAN'T REMEMBER WHAT HE READ, THE DAY BEFORE.

      NAME A MILITARY STRATEGY THAT JOHN MCCAIN CONCIEVED CREATED AND MILITARY JOINT CHEIFS OF STAFFS, HAVE IMPLEMENTED IN ANY SUCCESSFUL WAR(S)

      AND DON'T BRING UP THE SURGE, THAT WAS GENERAL MCFARLAND'S BABY...SORRY


      MCCAIN VOTED YES TO IT, AS DID OTHER SENATORS.

      JOHN "I KNOW HOW TO WIN WARS" MCCAIN


      HAHAHAHAHA !!!

  • Posted By: AmericanPatriot92 @ 08/16/2008 3:20:23 PM

    One question that needs to be asked, is how did we even get to this point, and who is best to lead our country, so that our future policies change America's place in the world for positive outcomes.

    From what happened with the Georgian Crisis, I would say it was NOT McCain. His irresponsible comments, and presumptiousness to speak on what the policy should be, before even Bush has had a chance to comment, has made America look stupid on the world stage. His rhetoric, and eagerness to appear like a "commander-in-chief" made a hawkish bluff, which the world, and Russia knew we weren't ready to commit to. George Bush's continued policies to push Russia on Poland and putting missile's in Russia's backyard will not go unanswered by the Russians. What do you think our natural response would be if they tried the same? Oh wait - that already happened with the Cuban Missile Crisis.

    Georgia made a fatal error to push on disputed territory and they were punished by Russia, too much by decent standards, but in major way that Russia wanted to get the message across - don't think you can get away with it. Bush failed his big promises to Georgia, and they are left with disallusionments and bitterness toward "democracy". McCain's idiotic statement of "we are all Georgians" is just big talk - and of little value to the Georgians who are suffering because of Bush and his administration's failure to have a real policy for Russia.

    Obama is our chance to break from the old guard and shed our negative baggage of the failed Bush Administration's policies to reach out to the World, and reconnect and ensure our American image can once again shine and be held up as an example of true democracy.

    McCain is running on negativity and what's pathetic, is that he feels he can't get elected on his own merits, and the only way he can do this is to put fear and negative smears against Obama. Some maverick he turned out to be. The man is essentially the emperor with no clothes on!

  • Posted By: timrogers @ 08/16/2008 2:48:18 PM

    Johnny 'shoot first and ask questions later' McCain would have no problem going to war anywhere at any time. Like many Republicans of his generation he equates picking fights with courage. He would never resort to diplomacy to settle a dispute if the military option was available. He knows that war Presidents have more power than peace Presidents. Something the Democrats have yet to understand.He sees war as the natural role of a leader; much like the past and present leaders mentioned in your article. If and when he gets his shot , McCain will prove that he is a tough guy at every opportunity. Republicans have always been willing to sacrifice American lives to prove their manhood. As you point out , once a war is started every politician knows it is suicide to try to stop it . At least until the polls begin to show high levels of opposition. Even then, no politican can survive being called a weakling who would dishonor the troops by giving up. The war drums already pound out the message that Obama is that weakling. I think it is working for McCain, and he will beat Obama because of it. That and the fact that Obama is unwhite mean our next President will be ready to 'rumble' from day one.

  • Posted By: loriw @ 08/16/2008 1:44:53 PM

    Forum with McCain and Obama moderated by Rick Warren will focus on ethics and values and will air on CNN at 8pm tonight.

  • Posted By: Omaar @ 08/16/2008 1:01:49 PM

    The Los Angeles Times said Bush Shares Blame for South Ossetia Bloodshed

    Published August 14, 2008

    "Oh, it's got to be somewhere on this paper!" A Russian caricature by Sergei Elkin.

    One of America's leading newspapers said that President George W. Bush is one of those who must answer for the disastrous consequences of Georgia's invasion of South Ossetia. The Los Angeles Times says the Georgian leadership was so stupid that they believed that the USA would give them aid if they got involved in a war with Russia in South Ossetia.


    First of all, America is busy handling crises in Afghanistan and Iraq, and, secondly, the US cannot engage in conflict with Russia, as it is the world's second-largest nuclear power.



    The newspaper puts part of the blame also on Republican presidential candidate John McCain, as he has been actively lobbying for Georgian interests in Washington. However, the main blame is on President Bush, whose anti-Russian record includes support for the so-called "colour revolutions" in the Russian backyard, condemnation of so-called anti-democratic crackdowns in Russia, whilst ignoring crimes committed by America's authoritarian friends, and also Washington's support for Georgia's bid to join NATO and its planned deployment of missile defence elements in Poland and the Czech Republic, right on the doorstep of Russia.

  • Posted By: Omaar @ 08/16/2008 12:59:23 PM


    BBC & REUTERS: GEORGIA MADE A GRAVE ERROR IN ATTACKING S. OSETTIA..



    Source: www.reuters.com & www.bbc.co.uk



    In the meantime, Russia has made similar allegations against Georgia, some of which may be backed up by witness reports.

    Despite Western governments' public statements of support for Saakashvili, some Western diplomats now privately say that the Georgian leadership or military made a serious and possibly criminal mistake last week by launching a massive barrage against the South Ossetian capital of Tskhinvali, which inevitably led to major civilian deaths and casualties.


    Russian officials have said 2,000 people were killed in the Georgian offensive, a figure that has not been confirmed independently. But it is indisputable that large numbers of civilians were killed in and around Tskhinvali.(Reuters)
    We're Americans.

    We like to divide up opponents in any conflict into Good Guys and Bad Guys. Since reality tends to be more complicated than that, we can easily be misled by politicians and media pundits whose personal agendas are served by telling us which are the Good Guys and which the Bad Guys.

    Russia has agreed to "stand down" (NYT); and Georgia has apparently filed a lawsuit against Russia in in the International Court of Justice for ethnic cleansing. (Newsmeat; Examiner.com) But Russia made similar claims against Georgia when it went into South Ossetia. Is either side telling the truth? Are both?

    Both sides have traded accusations of genocide and ethnic cleansing.

    Russia has accused Georgia of killing more than 2,000 people, mostly civilians??? The claim couldn't be independently confirmed, but witnesses who fled the area over the weekend said hundreds had died. (Examiner.com)
    During the course of trying to fit together the pieces of the media jig-saw (speaking of trust, lack of), a number of quotes snagged my attention.

    Yesterday, Vladimir Putin said:

    "The Ferocity in which the actions of the Georgian side were carried out cannot be called anything else but genocide, because they acquired a mass character and were directed against individuals, the civilian population, peacekeepers who carried out their functions of maintaining peace." (BBC News Key Statements)

  • Posted By: david-fahey @ 08/16/2008 12:45:35 PM

    let's see. george bush was in china trying to duck the spit aimed at his eyes by putin. bush must have seen it coming in putins eyes because there are no reports of the prez taking a hit. so we know where he is/was.
    and as usual when a crisis arises bush did not rush back to d.c. but where i our v.p.? we have hardly seen his re-assuring puss in weeks in the media(maybe on fox but i do not watch)? maybe, as post-911, cowering in an un-disclosed location no doubt. where is the co-prez? why is he not assuring the base we will bomb the russian forces back to their borders(because we are lone superpower remember). because i believe the russians are in possession of W M D's, this time for rea, and that means war ! we went to war over iraqi aggression/oil, why not this time? putin is a repressor of his people, like sadam, but no rush to war? if anyone has seen the veep please let us know what he is up to - thanks. bush just said he is not an appeaser like chamberlin and obama, so why are we not at def con 1? may be it is a D's girly response like in cuba and berlin crisis' bush does not want to look week? bush is a manly man, he must have something more up his sleeve than his tepid call for peace and sanctions ? no? because the cons always say they do not work and are a cowards way out! so lead us mr prez. after 1/20/09 you will be free to lead the first combat mission, you are about the same age as some reserves you sent to iraq afterall.

  • Posted By: otm861 @ 08/16/2008 12:43:25 PM

    this article said nothing

  • Posted By: Omaar @ 08/16/2008 12:24:00 PM

    www.bbc.co.uk & www.reuters.com

    Saashaskavilli started this Mess and he got his Ass kicked for his Manaical Ambitions.

    In the meantime, Russia has made similar allegations against Georgia, some of which may be backed up by witness reports.

    Despite Western governments' public statements of support for Saakashvili, some Western diplomats now privately say that the Georgian leadership or military made a serious and possibly criminal mistake last week by launching a massive barrage against the South Ossetian capital of Tskhinvali, which inevitably led to major civilian deaths and casualties.


    Russian officials have said 2,000 people were killed in the Georgian offensive, a figure that has not been confirmed independently. But it is indisputable that large numbers of civilians were killed in and around Tskhinvali.(Reuters)
    We're Americans.

    We like to divide up opponents in any conflict into Good Guys and Bad Guys. Since reality tends to be more complicated than that, we can easily be misled by politicians and media pundits whose personal agendas are served by telling us which are the Good Guys and which the Bad Guys.

    Russia has agreed to "stand down" (NYT); and Georgia has apparently filed a lawsuit against Russia in in the International Court of Justice for ethnic cleansing. (Newsmeat; Examiner.com) But Russia made similar claims against Georgia when it went into South Ossetia. Is either side telling the truth? Are both?

    Both sides have traded accusations of genocide and ethnic cleansing.

    Russia has accused Georgia of killing more than 2,000 people, mostly civilians??? The claim couldn't be independently confirmed, but witnesses who fled the area over the weekend said hundreds had died. (Examiner.com)
    During the course of trying to fit together the pieces of the media jig-saw (speaking of trust, lack of), a number of quotes snagged my attention.

    Yesterday, Vladimir Putin said:

    "The Ferocity in which the actions of the Georgian side were carried out cannot be called anything else but genocide, because they acquired a mass character and were directed against individuals, the civilian population, peacekeepers who carried out their functions of maintaining peace." (BBC News Key Statements)

  • Posted By: lil'_dymphna @ 08/16/2008 11:18:21 AM

    If we are all Georgians, does that mean that Randy Scheunemann works for all of us, too? Oh, great, that's all we need is to start dancing to the drumbeat for another war of nonnecessity complements of the boyz from PNAC (the folks who brought you Operation Iraqi Freedom) . And shame on you, Evan Thomas, for your "3AM crap"! How 'bout committing some journalism and research, or even just going to http://www.eurasianet.org/departments/insight/articles/eav042308f.shtml, and reading a freaking article to give the voters the information resources they need to understand this insane situation. Ultimately, we are the ones who are going to be asked to throw money and lives at this in the worst possible scenario. Give us the tools--Give us the information! Quit feeding this beast of our vapidness!

  • Posted By: Mwalimu @ 08/16/2008 11:16:24 AM

    Evan Thomas doesn't quite get it. Russia's invasion of Georgia is merely a copy of our own policies. If you were to read a recent article by Martin Cruz Smith on Moscow appearing in the National Geographic, you'd know that Moscow has more billionaires than any other place in the world, including Dubai. It is a-wash with petro-dollars. The government is of the rich, for the rich, and by the rich. It's the very neo-con paradise that McCain wants to establish in the United States.
    We decided to invade Iraq as a reponse to 9.11. Russia decided to invate George simply to avenge the terrorists attacks in Chechen. They want to show the world that they mean business. Bush and McCain both trumpet pre-emptive war. McCain off and on has been advocating bombing Iran, invading Syria, and liberating Cuba. The Russias believe in pre-emptive warfare too. That's the reason for their behavior n both George and Poland.
    Bush decries spheres of influence, but what is he setting up in the Middle East? McCain advocates remaining in Iraq for 100 years and using that to extend American influence over Iran, Syria, and other Middle East Countries. The Monroe Doctrine, a unilateral declaration, puts the entire Western Hemisphere in our sphere of influence. Yet we are denying Russia the same privilege.
    To the Russians, Bush and McCain represent en epitome of American hypocrisy. These words do not justify Russia's behavior, but we can't criticize Russia when we behave the same way.

  • Posted By: Mwalimu @ 08/16/2008 11:07:20 AM

    Evan Thomas, like all journalists, does not get all the facts. If he checked out Obama's statements, he'd notice that months ago, Obama warned about trouble spots like George. He stressed the need for internatinal mediation. And, what is Bush trying to do? Excatly what Obama advocated - except of course that Bush and McCain have worked so hard to ensure that we can't have enough enemies and have spent so much time sneering at international cooperation that their credibility is non-existent.

    As a recently retired teacher from an innercity high school in Los Angeles, in the middle of gang territory, I can give you some straight-talking, common sense wisdom that McCain and Bush cannot. As a teacher, the last thing you want is the 3 AM moment. In the case of my school, that 3 AM moment would would be a fight.
    To prevent the fight, which could easily escalate into a school wide melee (It did once while I was there), you evolve a whole system of crisis detection radar that defuses potentially dangerous situations before they explode. This an important part of Obama's defense and foreign policy - a pro-active policy that de-fuses the crisis before it starts. It's not a perfect system - but furn superior that the reactionary system that we have now. (If you read Michael Hirsh's excellent article, you'd know that Bush and McCain should have predicted this crisis and prevented it.)

    I am sick and tired of war presidents and presidents that flaunt their wartime credentials. As a patriotic American, I want our country to represent the best - not the worst. I want our country to get a reputation of preventing wars rather than starting them. If your read Jonathan Alder's article, you'll notice that Obama is already assembling a core of intelligent foreign policy advisors. In contract McCain relies on the same K-Street lobbyists that got us into Iraq. His chief campaign advisor, Charlie Black was once a lobbyist for Ahmed Chalabi, whose lies started the Iraq war, and who later turned out to be an Iranian agent. If we want a regime change in super-capitalist Russia, we need a regime change here. That's the reason for voting for Obama.

  • Posted By: Davole @ 08/15/2008 10:16:05 PM

    After Russia's invasion of Georgia, what now for the West?
    At least for now, the smoke seems to be clearing from the Georgian battlefield. But the extent of the wreckage reaches far beyond that small country.
    Telegraph.co.uk by John R Bolton 15 Aug 2008

    Saying this may cause angst in Europe???s capitals, but now is the time to find out if Nato can withstand a potential renewed confrontation with Moscow, or whether Europe will cause Nato to wilt. Far better to discover this sooner rather than later, when the stakes may be considerably higher. If there were ever a moment since the fall of the Berlin Wall when Europe should be worried, this is it. If Europeans are not willing to engage through Nato, that tells us everything we need to know about the true state of health of what is, after all, supposedly a ???North Atlantic??? alliance.

    Finally, the most important step will take place right here in the United States. With a Presidential election on November 4, Americans have an opportunity to take our own national pulse, given the widely differing reactions to Russia???s blitzkrieg from Senator McCain and (at least initially) Senator Obama. First reactions, before the campaigns??? pollsters and consultants get involved, are always the best indicators of a candidate???s real views. McCain at once grasped the larger, geostrategic significance of Russia???s attack, and the need for a strong response, whereas Obama at first sounded as timorous and tentative as the Bush Administration. Ironically, Obama later moved closer to McCain???s more robust approach, followed only belatedly by Bush.

    In any event, let us have a full general election debate over the implications of Russia???s march through Georgia. Even before this incident, McCain had suggested expelling Russia from the G8; others have proposed blocking Russia???s application to join the World Trade Organisation or imposing economic sanctions as long as Russian troops remain in Georgia. Obama has assiduously avoided specifics in foreign policy ??? other than withdrawing speedily from Iraq ??? but that luxury should no longer be available to him. We need to know if Obama???s reprise of George McGovern???s 1972 campaign theme, ???Come home, America???, is really what our voters want, or if we remain willing to persevere in difficult circumstances, as McCain has consistently advocated. Querulous Europe should hope, for its own sake, that America makes the latter choice.

    • Posted By: SPIRITED AWAY @ 08/16/2008 11:02:03 AM

      Excellent post-I agree.

  • Posted By: Phil08 @ 08/16/2008 10:47:43 AM

    Bambi has shown he would first listen to John McCain's response and then go into double secret conference with his political advisers. After this conference he would find a microphone with a teleprompter and repeat, "I think both sides should work this out towards peace."

    There, now don't we all feel better :O)

  • Posted By: ALLEAS @ 08/16/2008 8:24:37 AM

    ONCE AGAIN, JOHN McCAIN HAS SHOWN HIS TRUE FEAR MONGERING, WAR MONGERING COLORS. DOES THIS MAN EVEN REALIZE THAT THERE IS SUCH A THING AS TOUGH DIPLOMACY?

  • Posted By: bluegrass101 @ 08/15/2008 9:07:45 PM

    There could not possibly be a more Grotesque sight then Cyndi and John McCain, Lindsey Graham, JoeLiebermann all on stage together.

    • Posted By: loriw @ 08/16/2008 1:36:04 AM

      Could there be a more superficial person than bluegrass101?

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse