The Smear Gap

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Omaar @ 08/19/2008 1:18:46 AM

    Cindy McCain's Half Sister 'Angry' She's Hidden
    by Ted Robbins

    NPR.Org

    Kathleen Hensley Portalski displays newspaper clippings of her father in World War II, as well as snapshots of herself as a child with her father.

    Courtesy Nicholas Portalski

    Portalski is shown with her late father, Jim Hensley, who also was Cindy McCain's father.

    Read the original profile on Cindy McCain.

    Nicholas Portalski, whose mother is McCain's half sister, says it's "very, very hurtful" that he and his mother haven't been recognized.

    All Things Considered, August 18, 2008 · Last Tuesday, NPR broadcast a story about Cindy McCain's business and charity work. In it, Ted Robbins described McCain as the only child of Jim Hensley, a wealthy Arizona businessman. The next morning, NPR received an e-mail from Nicholas Portalski of Phoenix, who heard the story with his mother.

    "We were listening to the piece about Cindy McCain on NPR, All Things Considered, and it just struck us very hard," Portalski said.

    His mother, Kathleen Hensley Portalski, is also Hensley's daughter.

    The Portalski family is accustomed to hearing Cindy McCain described as Hensley's only child.

    She's been described that way by news organizations from The New Yorker and The New York Times to Newsweek and ABC.

    McCain herself routinely uses the phrase "only child," as she did on CNN last month. "I grew up with my dad," she said then. "I'm an only child. My father was a cowboy, and he really loved me very much, but I think he wanted a son occasionally."

    McCain's father was also a businessman ??? and twice a father.

    "I'm upset," Kathleen Portalski says. "I'm angry. It makes me feel like a nonperson, kind of."

    Who Is Kathleen Hensley Portalski?

    Documents show Kathleen Anne Hensley was born to Jim and Mary Jeanne Hensley on Feb. 23, 1943. They had been married for six years when Kathleen was born.

    Jim Hensley was a bombardier on a B-17, flying over Europe during World War II.

    He was injured and sent to a facility in West Virginia to recuperate. During that time, while still married to Mary Jeanne, Hensley met another woman ??? Marguerite Smith. Jim divorced Mary Jeanne and married Marguerite in 1945.

    Cindy Lou Hensley was born nine years later, in 1954.

    She may have grown up as an only child, but so did her half sister, Kathleen, who was raised by a single parent.

  • Posted By: Occam @ 08/19/2008 1:17:49 AM

    Obama's padded resume Part III

    For all his glowing job titles, Obama has never gotten much done. Is it any wonder that his spokesmen respond with sweeping generalities when asked what Obama has actually accomplished relevant to the presidency?
    Obama has held several serious positions from which a serious man could have made a serious impact. But Obama made none. He remains a man of proven charisma, but unproven skill???and not for lack of opportunity. He???s treated his offices as if they were high school student council positions-fun to run for, fun to win, affirmations of popularity, heady recognition from superiors, good resume-builders for stepping up to the next position of power, and???well, that???s about it-actual accomplishments are not expected; heavy lifting is never on the agenda.
    Obama???s record of accomplishment is thin not because of lack of opportunity, but in spite of it. For twenty years, Obama has walked the floors of the most prestigious institutions in the nation, but has left no footprints other than those from his runs for whatever office came next.
    It???s been said that some people want to be President so they can do something; and some want to be President so they can be something. Obama has accomplished nothing noteworthy despite the golden opportunities and positions he???s had; why should we believe he???d be a different man in the White House?
    No company would hire anyone with Obama???s empty track record, pattern of underachievement and padded résumé to be CEO. Is America really ready to hire him as President?
    Most of this is familiar material to us here. But it can???t be repeated enough.
    Allah knows, our watchdog media will never tell us about Mr. Obama???s lack of credentials.
    ...........................................................
    Obama, All Lies All the Time

    Obama, CHANGE you can believe in if you want a President who is narcissistic, specious, vacuous, and effete.

  • Posted By: Occam @ 08/19/2008 1:17:29 AM

    Obama's padded resume Part II

    Obama???s other activities since 1985 have included Harvard Law School, writing two autobiographies (including several months writing in Bali), prestigious summer law firm jobs, three years as an associate at a Chicago law firm, and twelve years part-time on the University of Chicago Law School faculty. As Medved notes, it takes quite the ego to consider any of those stints ???public service.??? Which of them is Obama including?
    Obama made yet another inflated boast last month during his visit to Israel. At his press conference in Hamas rocket-bombarded Sderot, Obama talked up ???his??? efforts to protect Israel from Iran:
    ???Just this past week, we passed out of the US Senate Banking Committee - which is my committee - a bill to call for divestment from Iran as way of ratcheting up the pressure to ensure that they don???t obtain a nuclear weapon.??? (Emphasis added.)
    Nice try. But as even CNN noted, Obama is not even on that committee. That is one peculiar ???mistake??? to simply have made by accident. Again, his claiming credit for the work of others just looks like clumsy, transparent résumé embellishment.
    Would someone with Obama???s stellar list of job titles resort to making stuff up? He seems to think he has to. In spite of the many impressive positions he???s held, he???s done almost nothing with them. If he wants to claim specific, relevant accomplishments, his only resort is to stretching the truth.
    Look at his record: he???s now completed over half of a Senate term; yet, is there even one signature issue he has taken hold of, other than his own presidential run? Similarly, as the New York Times recently pointed out, Obama spent twelve years on the University of Chicago Law School faculty???singularly famous for its intellectual ferment and incubator of scholarship???and produced not even a single scholarly paper. He was President of Harvard Law Review, but wrote nothing himself. Even as a state legislator for seven years-or community organizer for three years, there is little that shows his imprint. OK, to be fair, he did write two books. About himself.

  • Posted By: Omaar @ 08/19/2008 1:16:36 AM

    Cindy McCain's Half Sister 'Angry' She's Hidden (Pt 2)

    NPR.Org

    She may have grown up as an only child, but so did her half sister, Kathleen, who was raised by a single parent.

    Portalski says she did see her father and her half sister from time to time.

    "I saw him a few times a year," she says. "I saw him at Christmas and birthdays, and he provided money for school clothes, and he called occasionally."

    Jim Hensley also provided credit cards and college tuition for his grandchildren, as well as $10,000 gifts to Kathleen and her husband, Stanley Portalski. That lasted a decade, they say. By then, Jim Hensley had built Hensley and Co. into one of the largest beer distributorships in the country. He was worth tens, if not hundreds, of millions of dollars.

    Sole Inheritor To Hensley's Estate

    When Hensley died in 2000, his will named not only Portalski but also a daughter of his wife Marguerite from her earlier marriage. So, Cindy McCain may be the only product of Jim and Marguerite's marriage, but she is not the only child of either.

    She was, however, the sole inheritor of his considerable estate.

    Kathleen Portalski was left $10,000, and her children were left nothing. It's a fact Nicholas Portalski says his sister discovered the hard way.

    "What she found in town ??? on the day of or the day before or the day after his funeral ??? was that the credit card didn't work anymore," Nick says.

    The Portalskis live in a modest home in central Phoenix. Kathleen is retired, as is her husband. Nicholas Portalski is a firefighter and emergency medical technician looking for work.

    They say it would have been nice if they were left some of the Hensley fortune.

    They also say they are Democrats, but Nicholas Portalski says he had another reason for coming forward.

    "The fact that we don't exist," he says. "The fact that we've never been recognized, and then Cindy has to put such a fine point on it by saying something that's not true. Recently, again and again. It's just very, very hurtful."

    Kathleen Portalski says she'd like an acknowledgment and an apology.

    NPR asked the McCain campaign ??? specifically, Cindy McCain ??? to comment or respond. Neither replied.

  • Posted By: Occam @ 08/19/2008 1:16:22 AM

    The audacity of resume-padding (or, why Obama makes things up)
    By ABRAHAM KATSMAN AND KORY BARDASH
    Aug 17, 2008
    One of the knocks on Barack Obama is that his résumé is, so to speak, paper-thin. But that is not entirely accurate. Obama, in fact, has held some major job titles which are noteworthy all by themselves: United States Senator, Lecturer at the University of Chicago Law School, Harvard Law Review President-each of these titles puts him in rarefied company. Tack on a few Illinois State Senate terms, and his resume actually appears solid. Yet, in spite of these prestigious positions, Obama has increasingly resorted to making claims of accomplishment that are so patently inflated that even his cheerleaders at CNN and the New York Times are taking notice. Why?
    It seems that Obama recognizes that while his résumé titles are impressive, his actual accomplishments are weak. It???s as if he were jockeying to be the next company CEO with little to show for his prior high-profile management positions. So, he does what anyone else does who has spent years coasting on charisma without doing any heavy work: he pads his résumé???stretching the truth here, stealing credit there, and creating the illusion of achievement during his lackadaisical, undistinguished tenure in previous jobs.
    A few examples? Take Obama???s first general election ad. We are told that Obama ???passed laws??? that ???extended healthcare for wounded troops who???d been neglected,??? with a citation at the bottom to only one Senate bill: The 2008 Defense Authorization Bill, which passed the Senate by a 91-3 vote. Six Senators did not vote-including Obama. Nor is there evidence that he contributed to its passage in any material way. So, his claim to have ???passed laws??? amounts to citing a bill that was largely unopposed, that he didn???t vote for, and whose passage he didn???t impact. Even his hometown Chicago Tribune caught this false claim. It???s classic résumé-padding???falsely taking credit for the work of others.
    Or take one of Obama???s standard lines: his claim of ???twenty years of public service.??? As pundit Michael Medved has pointed out, the numbers don???t add up. Shall we count? Three years in the US Senate (two of which he???s spent running for President), plus seven years in the Illinois State Senate (a part-time gig, during which time he also served as a law professor) equals, at most, ten. Even if we generously throw in his three years as a ???community organizer??? (whatever that means, let???s count it as public service), that still adds up to just thirteen.

  • Posted By: Omaar @ 08/19/2008 1:14:57 AM

    Cindy McCain's Half Sister 'Angry' She's Hidden
    by Ted Robbins

    NPR.Org

    Kathleen Hensley Portalski displays newspaper clippings of her father in World War II, as well as snapshots of herself as a child with her father.




    Enlarge

    Courtesy Nicholas Portalski
    Portalski is shown with her late father, Jim Hensley, who also was Cindy McCain's father.




    Read the original profile on Cindy McCain.





    Enlarge

    Ted Robbins/NPR
    Nicholas Portalski, whose mother is McCain's half sister, says it's "very, very hurtful" that he and his mother haven't been recognized.


    All Things Considered, August 18, 2008 · Last Tuesday, NPR broadcast a story about Cindy McCain's business and charity work. In it, Ted Robbins described McCain as the only child of Jim Hensley, a wealthy Arizona businessman. The next morning, NPR received an e-mail from Nicholas Portalski of Phoenix, who heard the story with his mother.

    "We were listening to the piece about Cindy McCain on NPR, All Things Considered, and it just struck us very hard," Portalski said.

    His mother, Kathleen Hensley Portalski, is also Hensley's daughter.

    The Portalski family is accustomed to hearing Cindy McCain described as Hensley's only child.

    She's been described that way by news organizations from The New Yorker and The New York Times to Newsweek and ABC.

    McCain herself routinely uses the phrase "only child," as she did on CNN last month. "I grew up with my dad," she said then. "I'm an only child. My father was a cowboy, and he really loved me very much, but I think he wanted a son occasionally."

    McCain's father was also a businessman ??? and twice a father.

    "I'm upset," Kathleen Portalski says. "I'm angry. It makes me feel like a nonperson, kind of."

    Who Is Kathleen Hensley Portalski?

    Documents show Kathleen Anne Hensley was born to Jim and Mary Jeanne Hensley on Feb. 23, 1943. They had been married for six years when Kathleen was born.

    Jim Hensley was a bombardier on a B-17, flying over Europe during World War II.

    He was injured and sent to a facility in West Virginia to recuperate. During that time, while still married to Mary Jeanne, Hensley met another woman ??? Marguerite Smith. Jim divorced Mary Jeanne and married Marguerite in 1945.

    Cindy Lou Hensley was born nine years later, in 1954.

    She may have grown up as an only child, but so did her half sister, Kathleen, who was raised by a single parent.

  • Posted By: mnjam @ 08/19/2008 1:12:29 AM

    fMcCain is a Republican and, thus, a compulsive liar. Really, he can't help it.

  • Posted By: HankSF @ 08/19/2008 1:09:08 AM

    I can't believe that I still read Alter's dribble. I need another good laugh so I will now read Fineman.

  • Posted By: Mimi13 @ 08/18/2008 10:38:26 PM

    "who has never been on a private payroll beyond that of his beer distributor father-in-law"

    What an interesting line. Is he on his father-in-law's payroll? In what capacity?

    • Posted By: HolyRoller @ 08/18/2008 11:14:58 PM

      I don't know if he is or not...but regardless...it would be better than being on Tony Rezko's. Don't you agree???

      NOBAMA!!!

      • Posted By: Mimi13 @ 08/19/2008 1:01:09 AM

        I don't know. I haven't seen any news reports that Obama is on anyone's payroll. I still wonder what McCain is on his father-in-law's payroll FOR? Keeping Cindy happy? Facilitating corporate sales to foreign nations? Exporting jobs to Europe? Rolling back pollution laws? Curious minds . . . .

      • Posted By: DavidCA @ 08/18/2008 11:49:01 PM

        As always, one should consider the source. We always do with your posts, HolyRoller. But please enlighten us. Who are these "real journalists" of whom you speak? They wouldn't, by any chance, be the crowd from Fox News that you recently told us are the only credible news source? Names, we want names!

      • Posted By: love is universal @ 08/18/2008 11:35:28 PM

        NOBAMA YOU ARE AN ***!!!! I HOPE THEY'RE PAYING YOU MORE THAN $200.000 CAUSE THATS THE ONLY WAY YOU CAN GET THE TAX BREAK YOU'RE LOOKING FOR. AND AS FAR AS OBAMA YOU CAN ONLY LIE ABOUT HIM, BUT WE KNOW FOR SURE THAT MCWAR GOT PAID FROM GEORGIA'S PRESIDENT THATS WHY HE CALLED HIM OUT BY NAME.
        JOHN MCWAR AMERICA'S MILITARY IS NOT FOR RENT OR FOR SALE!!!!

  • Posted By: judithod @ 08/19/2008 12:59:01 AM

    I have no problem with the critical ads on Obama. In fact, Obama himself compared his popularity to that of Paris Hilton. What the McCain team needs to do is run an ad pointing out that Obama has had lots of opportunities but no achievements to show for those opportunities. Obama offers empty "hope and change," which is equivalent to a TV reality show.

  • Posted By: bereal @ 08/19/2008 12:54:51 AM

    This is just another one of Jonathan Alter's love letters to Obama. Alter does not have the ability to write a fair or truthful column. I have yet to read a column of his that is not slanted completely toward Obama. Alter should be writing for The National Enquirer.

  • Posted By: sharenews @ 08/18/2008 7:40:08 PM



    FOX NEWS ALERT!!!

    FoxNews has a special on TV tonight. . . 8:00pm - 9:00pm EST and repeat at 11:00pm - 12am EST

    PRESIDENTIAL CHARACTER: Obama

    A profile of presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama that focuses on his CHARACTER and CONDUCT, and what the DECISIONS he has made in his life could indicate about WHAT KIND OF LEADER he would make.


    • Posted By: Pia1981 @ 08/18/2008 7:49:59 PM

      Share, do me a favor will you? When you visit Fox ask Sean Hannity for me how his Neo-Nazi buddy is doing these days. Thanks.

      • Posted By: sharenews @ 08/18/2008 8:11:16 PM


        Hey, what is fair is fair. They are doing the same type of show tomorrow nite about McCain's Character, Conduct, Decisions. That should be interesting to see if they talk about McCain crashing his plane 5 times I keep on seeing in the blogs at times. ; - D

        • Posted By: raddave @ 08/19/2008 12:48:02 AM

          I have not found anything about him crashing five planes, unless they are counting the one destroyed in the fire on the Forrestal and the one that was shot down and another one. It is in his bio on wikipedia that he did have two planes crash.

        • Posted By: Pia1981 @ 08/18/2008 8:35:24 PM

          Hey share! Of course it's fair, I wasn't saying it wasn't. I just refuse to go to Fox anymore if Sean Hannity is on. IMO, he is a hypocrite. I once liked and respected him. He gloated for months over the Wright video, meanwhile, he was buddy buddy with a Neo-Nazi.

  • Posted By: nwkerr2005 @ 08/19/2008 12:13:07 AM

    I think McCain is a strong candidate and is showing the world that Obama is not wuite ready for primetime. I am an independent and defintiely leaning towards McCain.

    • Posted By: chindognyc @ 08/19/2008 12:15:36 AM

      Well then I hope you don't have a job that can go overseas nwkerr2005. Carly Fiorina is going to make sure that the rich get richer.

  • Posted By: nwkerr2005 @ 08/19/2008 12:13:54 AM

    I think McCain is on a roll.

  • Posted By: valwayne @ 08/19/2008 12:09:26 AM

    Having "The Obama" campaign come out and denounce how unfair John McCain is being to poor Obama is hardly news. What not "The Obama" campaign? It's Johnathon Alter, worshiper and chief of The ONE, at the Newsweek bureau of "The Obama's" campaign. You're right...."The Obama's" campaign would be more non-biased! So "The Obama" comes out and says that "They" meaning McCain is going to try and scare you because he has a funny name and doesn't look like George Washinton"? The race card again!!! McCain responds with an ad comparing "The Obama's" celebrity to Brittany?????Who's gone to far? Who's more negative???? Why of course Obama's worshipers think its McCain. If I were Johnathon Alter I'd be a little panicked after watching "The ONE" give Nuance a bad name at Saddleback why McCain showed why he should be our next President. Johnathon......its till not too late.........You and Newsweek can still plead with the super delegates to Nominate Hillary at the convention and save the election. I know it will be hard to change your new religion....but its a cult Johnathon....you can do it!!!!

  • Posted By: DavidCA @ 08/18/2008 11:17:21 PM

    Finally, someone has the courage to say "the emperor has no clothes," rather than the noncomittal "the latest court fashions are decidedly skimpy!"

    McCain's campaign clearly has the mindset that if they keep throwing stuff our fast enough, nobody will be able to catch them. And it's not just lies about Obama, they even lie about their own policies.

  • Posted By: News and Notes @ 08/18/2008 10:49:04 PM

    Alter maligned Hillary throughout the primary season. If you're not an Obama supporter, it is open season! He and Olberman are all aboard the Obama train

  • Posted By: HolyRoller @ 08/18/2008 10:25:58 PM

    Well Hussein finally told the truth about something. In the Saddleback massacre, he admitted making decisions was above his "pay grade". Then later today, his camp admits he has been lying about the infanticide bill he oppossed in Illinois. Wonder when he is gonna fess up about his birth certificate???

    NOBAMA!!!

  • Posted By: notroubleatall1963 @ 08/18/2008 10:06:10 PM

    John McCrass, leader of the class of bourgeois bigots who will stop at nothing to smear a brilliant candidate's name and reputation - in the name of Mediocrity, Averageness and sheer and utter ignorance. The Bushes belong to this class too. It's our American upper class, so called mainly because of the money; the classiness (or lack thereof) has nothing to do with anything. And forget integrity, ingenuity, innovation or inddependence of thought - these folks all cling to their peers and profits like an old fart clings to his golf clubs on the green of his bourgeois country club. Monkeys think alike, act alike and exclude alike.

  • Posted By: just-another-sweetie @ 08/18/2008 6:29:28 PM

    I think most of us out here...given the choice of your guy and John McCain...have NO choice really.

    We wince every time we see your guy stutter and stammer when caught off guard...without benefit of his carefully-scripted "sermons" via teleprompter. We know he's a glitzy invention of David Axelrod, with limited experience and a dismal record of things he has undertaken. We are also highly suspicious of his money sources and those sending it. We still have horrifying memories of his pastor of 20 years on TV...railing against this nation, us (Americans) and we are still snitting over his snide remarks about our penchant for guns and religion. With all of these "givens" and perhaps 50 more that time precludes me from mentioning here...we are stoutly slamming your guy...anywhere and everywhere we can...knowing that if we can keep him OUT of the White House...our only choice left...is someone we KNOW, feel safer with and that is...of course...John McCain. Simple. Isn't it? :>) P.S. If Hillary were running...........I could sleep nights. I think she was railroaded...!!!

    • Posted By: belle12 @ 08/18/2008 7:02:47 PM

      Can't you guys think of anything else? No matter what the story is you say the same things over and over again. Although, it is laughable that you are supporting a candidate who makes gaffes on the stump every day. It is also funny that you would rather support a candidate who finished at the bottom 1% of his class and only had his position in the military because of his family connections. And if we want to talk about connections, John McCain is allied with Phil Gramm whose actions led to the financial crisis we are now facing and referred to Americans as "whiners", his relationship with Abramoff's buddy Ralph Reed, his role in the Keating 5 scandal, Pastors Hagee and Parsley, and the list goes on and on. If you're not "horrified" by those associations, then you're not paying attention, or you're just a Republican who puts party before country.

      • Posted By: Lee Holmes @ 08/18/2008 7:34:12 PM

        I suppose we had better note here that the architect of the subprime meltdown was not Gramm,but Clinton Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin,who as it happens,is Obamas economic adviser.[unofficial,or maybe not]. McCain may had had a relationship with Reed,but Obama had a relationship with Abramoffs firm[GREENBURG],itself,raking in over 125,000$ in campaign loot even after the scandal broke.[Center for Responsive Politics]. Something strange going on in Chicago,as investigative reporters have been blocked by the City of Chicago from looking into records tying Obama to terrorist Bill Ayers. It is expected that they will file FOIAs so we will see what else we do not know about Obama here soon enough.[as he is already getting pummeled for his abortion position due to his lies in this area].

        • Posted By: notroubleatall1963 @ 08/18/2008 10:01:49 PM

          You are really weird. They probably blocked the Ayers access coz every crackpot around the country was trying to dig up some non-existant "dirt" on Obama. When Ayers was active, Obama was 8 years old.

          You guys are SO AFRAID to have to look up to a Black guy in the White House. It's just so funny to see what chickens you are - like it's going to really matter or make that much difference?? What did BUSH do for abortion in this country? Did his two terms help reduce the number of fetuses being aborted? NO. Not one bit. So stop your crap and get a life. Like you really care about unborn fetuses - gimme a f'''g break!!! You're just trying to clutch at any kind of straw, even half-truths or lies, to smear Obama - just like your idol, John Wayne McCain - or McCrass, as I call him - the head of the crass class of Bourgeois Bigots.

        • Posted By: SPIRITED AWAY @ 08/18/2008 7:55:11 PM

          Your posts are brilliant! Please keep up the good work, thanks.

      • Posted By: SPIRITED AWAY @ 08/18/2008 7:22:05 PM

        RE: "If you're not "horrified" by those associations, then you're not paying attention, or you're just a Republican who puts party before country."

        As far as being HORRIFIED by associations-your guy is in the lead. (Rezko, Auchi, Wright, Flager, Ayers etc.) So does that mean your just a Dem who puts Obama before her country?

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse