LIVING POLITICS

Howard Fineman

Making the Most of Mom

Obama needs to use her story to connect with voters.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: pumapurr @ 08/25/2008 3:59:22 PM

    Obama is no family man. Obama is an Obama man. Never mind his treatment of his mother, grandmother, and brother, Obama has mistreated his own kids by dragging them to the hateful Reverend Wright every week, all so he could gain "cred" with some fringe moonbats who claim to represent the black community (they don't). Involving his kids is disgusting. What a nasty piece of work this guy is. No wonder he and Wright were such pals. Birds of the same feather, and boy did they flock together.

  • Posted By: sjpersonal @ 08/25/2008 3:17:33 PM

    Comment: The Next Smear Against Obama: "Infanticide"


    "Unlike Obama in Illinois, Sen. Hillary Clinton voted to support the [2002 federal] bill," Hudson wrote earlier this year. "In fact, the bill passed the Senate 98 to 0 with pro-abortion senators like Boxer (D-CA) and Reid (D-NV) supporting it. In 2003, the bill was introduced in the Illinois legislature for the third time and directed to a committee chaired by Obama, Health and Human Services. They refused to bring the bill to a vote. Only when Obama left for Washington in 2005 did the Born Alive Infant Protection Act pass the Illinois legislature. It's for good reason Barack Obama has been called 'the most pro-abortion presidential candidate ever.'"

    One significant problem with Hudson's logic is that it requires comparing apples to oranges. The Illinois and federal bills differed not only in language, but regulatory impact. Critically, the Illinois version of the bill that Obama opposed was also bundled with other proposals that would have put doctors at risk of prosecution, which led the Illinois State Medical Society to oppose the measure along with Obama. The state bill also carried greater influence in terms of enforcement, since states had been granted greater leeway in regulating abortion practices ever since the U.S. Supreme Court's 1992 ruling in the case of Planned Parenthood v. Casey.

    Illinois State Representative Rosemary Mulligan sighed when the Huffington Post told her about the "infanticide" claim currently being leveled at Obama. As a pro-choice Republican who is supporting John McCain for president but also worked with Obama back in 2001, she described the first Illinois version of the Born Alive legislation as "a very onerous bill," adding that "I think that the hardcore, hard right conservative Catholics overreach on this one."

    Something else Deal Hudson fails to note in his critique of Obama is the fact that the 2005 version of the state bill, which passed, was a compromise bill free of any other measures Obama had previously opposed. Had he been there to vote for it, he may well have done so. Specifically addressing his onetime concern over the impact of a re-definition of what "born alive" could be interpreted to mean, the 2005 measure that passed after Obama left Springfield included three new clauses that read:

    (c) Nothing in this Section shall be construed to affirm, deny, expand, or contract any legal status or legal right applicable to any member of the species homo sapiens at any point prior to being born alive, as defined in this Section.

    (d) Nothing in this Section shall be construed to affect existing federal or State law regarding abortion.

    (e) Nothing in this Section shall be construed to alter generally accepted medical standards.

    link to entire article: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/08/04/the-next-smear-against-ob_n_116891.html

  • Posted By: gmgl @ 08/25/2008 3:17:18 PM

    I respectfully disagree with the article. People have heard an enormous amount about Obama as a personality and precious little else. More just feeds into empty sugar rush calories followed by the subsequent crash of disappointment. Obama has a second opportunity to put this campaign in the dem court and its not more bloviating about his wonderfulness in the form of biography, as interesting as that might be to the hard core Obama supporters like Fineman. Obama needed 1) to unite the party which he blew by not picking Clinton and thus stop the leakage of Clinton supporters to McCain. Failing that, which he did by picking Biden, he has one more more chance, maybe two to win. The second chance is to focus us all on a "cause" beyond him Obama -- pick energy independence and the return of economic greatness and power (again the Obama camp is blowing an opportunity by not having Bill Clinton both stoke his own ego and introduce the Obama era as ussering in economic prosperity once again. Obama could make it about racing China in economic greatness (you know insert patriotic inspiring message here, try not to make it too offensive to the Chinese, rather a friendly competition). In short the more Obama takes the focus off himself the better off he is. He already has the votes of the Obamabots like Fineman who would like to stare endlessly at him. Obama needs to give something to the rest of us to cheer about, he's already taken away cheering for a woman on the ticket, give us something hopeful to take our minds off it. More fluff about Obama himself isn't it.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

 

Up and Coming Newsweek Stories on Digg

Discover more Newsweek content on Digg
 
 
COVER STORY

Cerebral and cool, Obama is also steely, and his strength comes from the absence of a father. The making of a self-reliant man.