Sorry, Pal, You're Rich

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: monti7301 @ 08/28/2008 2:43:36 PM

    Rich folks, I cannot fathom your world. I did a quick calculation on living in a neghborhood where the mortgage would be let's say $3k a month. Taking that plus the following expenses into consideration, mortgage, heating, electric, food, Life insurance, auto gas, Water, Auto Ins, internet, TV, Cell phone, Voip. I still come up with an annual expendable income of $107000.00. That's an extra $8,900 a month to blow on whatever. Please enlighten me on what other survival needs your family has that eats up $8,900 a month besides those I've listed above.

    • Posted By: MKII @ 08/28/2008 2:50:40 PM

      HAve you ever heard of taxes!!!

      • Posted By: newimperium @ 08/28/2008 3:47:35 PM

        The problem is that people live beyond their means, no matter how much they make. That's why most millionaires are still in debt and unhappy. The toys just get more expensive.

      • Posted By: monti7301 @ 08/28/2008 3:41:54 PM

        Actually, I have. I incorporated them into my calcuation of Net income after taxes. Even if I didn't take them into consideration we are talking about taxable income. Have you ever heard of deducatables (City, State, Real Estate taxes as well as Flexible spending accounts, insurance deductions and payments made on Federally funded student loans-which I'm sure all of these highly educated self made upper class folks used because certainly, mummy, daddy or Grandma/grandpa didn't put any money aside for their college.

  • Posted By: jcjohns91107 @ 08/28/2008 3:17:05 PM

    Hogwash, $250K is not rich! I'm in that category. I have to put my kids in private schools because in the city in S. California where I live, the schools are dangerous. There's a lockdown once a week. I don't drive fancy cars, we have a Ford and an Accura, and neither is one of their high end models. I worry about how to pay for college and if I will ever be able to retire. I am definately hoping Social Security stays around for awhile. I live in a 2400 sq. ft. house thats 50+ years old. I'm sorry I don't choose to live in a box and save all my money. The answer is a flat tax. No deductions which those who I feel really are rich use to pay less taxes than I do.

    • Posted By: homeschooler @ 08/28/2008 3:47:20 PM

      No you don't have to put your kids in private school, you could always homeschool them. I bet they would turn out better that way anyhow. Oh and you don't need a 2400 sq. ft house to live comfortably.

  • Posted By: billyquid @ 08/28/2008 3:46:43 PM

    "The Congress shall have power To lay and collect taxes, duties, imposts, and excises???"(and these shall) "???be uniform throughout the United States...."

    This is simply a divide and conquer technique by the politicians, both democrat and republican. No person is truly free when you are financially tithed to a national governmetn to the tune of 30-50 percent of your household income. Economic freedom first. One person one dollar.

  • Posted By: Kristiecsu @ 08/28/2008 2:45:30 PM

    This is great. I especially liked the guy who claimed to be a disabled trucker saying "I'm sure I could do your job with a little training." Suuuuure. That training is called "college," and if you were so able to complete that training, then how come you chose trucking? The bottom line is that not everyone can be rich because to be rich you have to either a)be incredibly intelligent, b)be incredibly attractive, or c)be incredibly talented. Oh, and I forgot d)be incredibly industrious. It's unfortunate that these choices have to be made as teenagers, but that's just financial natural selection. People who choose to be teachers know damned well that teachers don???t make much money. Most of them don???t complain about it, because they are intelligent enough to recognize that choice. I didn't want to be poor or have to stretch financially, so I chose a major in college that maximized potential income. Failing that plan, I wanted to have a backup, so I passed on the pizzas, beer, and sloth so I could remain a thin, attractive young woman (like it or not, like attracts like. This means that if you are wealthy and attractive you will attract other wealthy and attractive people. If you are fat and poor, you will likely end up in a household of two fat, poor people. I didn???t invent this rule, I just don???t ignore it). As it turns out, I now am marrying a hot, intelligent doctor and don???t really have to work at all???but I certainly could if I chose. The beauty of this? He CHOSE to be studious and dorky when everyone else was CHOOSING to do keg stands and contracting Chlamydia. The best part is, the hot studious guys always have the best personalities because they were too busy studying to realize they???re hot. The moral of this story is that us ???wealthy folk??? don???t expect poor people to live without handouts, we just don???t want to hear you bitching about being poor when you picked your life story. Also, stop making babies if you???re poor. That just makes you poorer and sets your kids up to be another generation of poor.

    • Posted By: newimperium @ 08/28/2008 3:46:42 PM

      Those are very cruel things to say. Sounds like you have a big problem with pride.
      It is never right to look down on other people like that. Those are not the qualities that made our country great.

    • Posted By: likeamistery @ 08/28/2008 3:33:36 PM

      lol. Your story cracks me up! So while he was studying, were you the one out contracting Chlamydia? You didn't happen to mention your own particular study habits. =)

    • Posted By: tngal @ 08/28/2008 2:58:17 PM

      Sounds to me like you are a money grubber and WAN'T to mooch off someone else. I pitty the man you are marrying.

  • Posted By: billyquid @ 08/28/2008 3:44:50 PM

    "The Congress shall have power To lay and collect taxes, duties, imposts, and excises???"(and these shall) "???be uniform throughout the United States...."

    This is simply a divide and conquer by the politicians, both democrat adn repubican. The hear of the matter is that no person is truly free when they are financially tithes to a national governemtn to the tune of 30-40 even 50 per cent of income, regardless of the level of that income. True freedom can only start when we take back our economic freedom from the federal government.

  • Posted By: cindyn @ 08/28/2008 3:44:12 PM

    It must be nice to have that kind of income.I live in Las Vegas and it takes myself and my husband to make ends meet and raise 3 teenagers. And sometimes it's a struggle so it must be great to be rich if you make $250,000 a year..We don't come close to that..Give the lower class income people a break..

  • Posted By: rdelawder @ 08/28/2008 3:01:36 PM

    Let's create a tax Chart at 14% paid by US Citizens on yearly based earnings
    Restaurant Employee $13,000 pays $1820
    Receptionist $18,000 pays $2520
    General Labor $25,000 pays $3500
    Manager $35,000 pays $4900
    Supervisor $45,000 pays $6300
    LPN $55,000 pays $7700
    RN $65,000 pays $9100
    Commissioned Emp. $75,000 pays $10,500
    Upper Mgmt $85,000 pays $11,900
    Senior Mgmt $100,000 pays $14000
    Attorney $150,000 pays $21000
    Doctor $250,000 pays $35,000
    Specialist $350,000 pays $49,000
    Executive's $500,000 pays $70,000
    Million Dollar earners $1,000,000 pays $140,000 per year in taxes

    If everyone paid a flat tax and we looked at the dollar amount instead of the percentage paid, then everyone pays their fair share! A flat tax would most likely create more jobs and allow eveyone to put more money back into their future instead of worrying about why the rich are getting richer. With out the rich we wouldn't have people to invest and take risks to start new businesses and charities. I'm sick of giving money all year long to Taxes and then getting back about 10% of what I put in when I get a tax return, if I even get a tax return.

    • Posted By: Cabot @ 08/28/2008 3:44:00 PM

      I agree with your Flat tax proposal, but the $1,000,000 earner would pay much more than 140K Trust me how about 35% at $275K - check the rate sheet. I know. You also did not mentioned the lower tax payers get all of their federal income tax returned to them, some even make money. Thats not fair and adds to your Flat tax argument.

  • Posted By: njsparks @ 08/28/2008 3:43:56 PM

    I'm sorry, but if you have two homes like kwynne, and all of the other material possessions... you're far more well off then most Americans. I work TWO jobs, have my Bachelor's degree and can barely make ends meet... I make $37,000.00 a year. I pay $300.00 per month on student loans... I pay a $950.00 mortgage payment plus utilities... I don't have the money for a second home.. a nicer car than my old, beat up pick up truck. I garden for vegetables... I raise a couple of steers a year and a pig or two for food. I can't afford groceries. I can't afford a more fuel efficient vehicle. I commute 20 miles each way to work. So, to us 'middle class' folks... you're rich!!!

  • Posted By: Roger47 @ 08/28/2008 3:42:21 PM

    I have two children, 4 and 14. They each owe tens of thousands of dollars. My 4 year old has never spent a penny of his own money, and my 14 year old is frugal. The problem is the national debt. We either need to radically cut spending or we must raise taxes, or both. We got this way by reckless spending by the republicans. They claim to be fiscal conservatives, but look to their actions, not their words. They put us up to our eyeballs in debt, then run for re-election on a "cut taxes" platform. The result is my kids are massively in debt.
    Right now the middle and upper middle classes are struggling, so there is no way their taxes can be increased without causeng a depression. Besides, the republicans have made such a policy political suicide. The only choice left is to increase taxes on the rich, or to disband our military. $250,000 seems like a good place to draw the line. Anyone who can't make ends meet on that income should be reincarnated as a disabled person.

  • Posted By: daryllanderson @ 08/28/2008 3:41:04 PM

    I don't make $250K a year and may never make that much. However, fair is fair...everyone should pay the same tax rate. This ensures people who make the least pay the least and people who make the most pay the most.

  • Posted By: MKII @ 08/28/2008 3:40:36 PM

    The government just wants more of your money so that they can efficiently hand it out and feel like Robin Hood. Let???s help them feed their ego???s??? please

  • Posted By: toolkien @ 08/28/2008 3:29:47 PM

    I just went to wikipedia and looked up Wealth. They break beween rich and middle class by POWER. The rich have power, the middle class doesn't. If people think making $250,000 a year versus $50,000 nets you an OUNCE more power, you're deluded. I guess that's what it comes down to. While the wife and I make very good money, if the affluvia ever hits the fan blades, there's no question which direction we go fairly quickly.

    Per Wikipedia-

    The upper class
    Inheritance establishes different starting lines. The majority of those in the upper class have inherited their wealth and place a greater emphasis on wealth than on income

    The middle class
    There is a distinct difference in views about wealth among the middle class compared to those of the upper class. Where the upper class beliefs focus on wealth, the middle class places a greater emphasis on income

    The working class
    The working class has fewer options for advancement and wealth accumulation than the upper and middle classes. This can be characterized as having limited income, unstable employment and an insignificant retirement pension account

    The welfare class
    Those with the least amount of wealth are the welfare poor. Wealth accumulation for this class is to some extent prohibited. People that receive AFDC transfers cannot own more than a trivial amount of assets, in order to be eligible and remain qualified for income transfers. Most of the institutions that the welfare poor encounter discourage any accumulation of assets

    So I assert again, somebody whose kids are grown and gone who are making $250,000 a year and have plenty of their own accumulation as well as a likely inheritance from their own parents likely spend more time thinking wealth and its preservation. They are rich. Those who make $250,000 a year, with young kids (daycare and college to save for), decent savings but not huge, and no inherited capital are still operating within INCOME and not WEALTH. They are, and act, middle class.

    I guess journalists and sociologists aren't paid to make such striations.

    • Posted By: spjon @ 08/28/2008 3:40:31 PM

      Yeah, Wikipedia. If i wanted to I could say that Salmon is a type of Spider and that would make it on that website as truth. Keep looking. Also, definining being rich as having power is kind of lame and even then is not within the context of the article or what 99.9% of the people responding to it think it is. You yourself had to look it up just to make an argument against the article.

    • Posted By: GoBoilers @ 08/28/2008 3:36:22 PM

      You are talking about the difference between wealth and income... You rightly state that "rich" should be measured by wealth and that wealth and income are not directly correlated, but often that is the result of consumption preferences (e.g. choosing to consume all of your income rather than save). People that have saved, some possibly that make much less than 100k, and amassed wealth should not be considered any more rich than someone who makes $300k per year and spends it all on trips, cars, and expensive dinners...

      http://www.beyondthemargin.net/2008/06/life-as-slave.html

  • Posted By: dorfy @ 08/28/2008 3:19:06 PM

    According to McCain - $250k is middle income....all his friends make much more. I'd like to see his wife and him live on that amount. I know they have much more....Sell a few houses and cars, I wonder how well they'd do?

    • Posted By: Cabot @ 08/28/2008 3:39:47 PM

      I dont know about you but I do not want my President a poor unsuccessful person. I want a successful person to be President. By the way Barrack has not even ran the corner store yet. how can he run our country.

    • Posted By: GoBoilers @ 08/28/2008 3:21:21 PM

      Don't let envy bias your opinion. Don't be jealous of his (or her) success. Live within yourself.

      http://www.beyondthemargin.net/2008/08/escaping-burdens-of-consumer-debt.html

  • Posted By: blackcourt @ 08/28/2008 3:24:26 PM

    If you are among the top 20% of the wealthiest people in this country... you are rich. You might not feel rich because like Gross says, you are too busy looking at your wealthier neighbors. Try driving through northern Maine sometime.

    If you are driving a european luxury car... you might be rich.

    If you are taking vacations to exotic locales... you might be rich.

    If you are debating over buying a $200 pair of shoes or a $300 pair... you might be rich.

    If you are buying $200 ties... you might be rich.

    You get where I'm going with this?

    • Posted By: adamwells @ 08/28/2008 3:38:59 PM

      So, what? That entitles you to someone elses money? That was the most empty headed posting I've seen yet.

    • Posted By: GoBoilers @ 08/28/2008 3:32:46 PM

      Or deciding between a $600 or $1200 pursue... or $300 vs $600 shoes... etc. Consumption society will lead you to life as a slave! You get what you ask for.

      http://www.beyondthemargin.net/2008/06/life-as-slave.html

  • Posted By: dellie @ 08/28/2008 2:49:34 PM

    Hey Bill Clinton where's the health care that you promised 16 years ago? Just think in 16 years we'll be able to ask Obama, why am I still poor? you promised to help me out...

    • Posted By: yorkielover2 @ 08/28/2008 3:36:40 PM

      That health care program was blown out of the water by the health insurance companies that have lobbiests sticking money in every Republican pocket they can get close to.

    • Posted By: adamwells @ 08/28/2008 3:04:36 PM

      Welcome to America! You are a perfect example of the kind of person many of us are tired of carrying on our backs. Help yourself like the rest of us. If you want the government to do it for you, move to China.

    • Posted By: spjon @ 08/28/2008 2:59:44 PM

      Hey Dellie, why don't you ask your Republican counterparts in Congress where that healthcare you mentioned is.

  • Posted By: curtkf @ 08/28/2008 3:35:18 AM

    250K per year? Hell, $100,000 per year; I worked three jobs, sometimes in excess of 90 hours in a week, but never less than 75 hours per week to earn $42,800 last year. I???m not a drooling idiot savant that is smoking crack in my spare time and sucking the welfare system dry. I am a working man, not the one who makes $30, or more per hour, but the guy who makes $10 an hour. I get up everyday, and go do what needs to be done to get the bills paid.

    I paid a week???s wages last year because I was 10 days late on my car payment and my car was repossessed. I know two people who are living in their vehicles because they can???t find a place to live that hey can afford. Wake up and smell the roses, I know a lot of people that would kill, yes kill, for $250,000, because they are that desperate to feed their kids, and to keep a roof over their heads.

    There is such an incredible ???disconnect??? between the people that are making six figure salaries and the rest of ???us??? that it is almost inconceivable to the majority of the American people that ???they??? could be whining about their lifestyle.

    When was the last time you had to decide between a few gallons of gas and a meal for your family? When was the last time you had to pay 129% APR to a paycheck lender to keep the lights on at your house? When was the last time you had to say NO to your child because they wanted a, crappy, six-dollar toy in Wal-Mart, and you only had five dollars until payday?

    Welcome to a taste, an infinitesimal taste, of the real world.

    • Posted By: WhenWillTheyLearn @ 08/28/2008 11:56:47 AM

      curtfk- why do you and your friends have children if you can't afford to keep the lights on or have to decide between gas and a meal for your family? you are right, there is an incredible disconnect between people making six figures and 'the rest of you', but not for the reasons YOU think.

      • Posted By: grubish @ 08/28/2008 3:36:21 PM

        It was a sin that all the people of Mississippi bred to..
        Whenwilltheylearn, who taught you to judge like that and did you ever learn compassion?

      • Posted By: grubish @ 08/28/2008 3:34:03 PM

        Must be terrible to pull that kinda cash. I bet those immigrants who clean your house make less than this guy. The most clueless people I have ever met are those that make more than the $250,000. Clueless to what the rest of the world sees and goes through. Clueless to why people shop at dirty walmarts and cant afford a new car. It must be nice to be able to judge the rest of the world like that. The average income in Bejing is 4,400 per year. How dare they have children and strugle.

      • Posted By: loli717 @ 08/28/2008 12:52:17 PM

        How dare you comment on why he has kids. You must think you're so high and mighty. Did you take the time to ask him his financial situation when he had his kids? No, you just assumed he has been in the same state from the beginning, you arrogant jerk. Maybe he was financial stable when he had his kids and then this crumbling economy took that away from him. And how dare you criticize this man, who works 75 hours a week just to make sure his kids eat. It's not like he's abondoning them., He makes sure they are fed.

  • Posted By: chadcoker @ 08/28/2008 2:10:49 PM

    Just wondering why we have demonized rich people in this country. Isn't the ability to increase our wealth one of the great things about a free society? For some reason, we like to punish those that achieve more. So, who cares if $250K is rich or not.

    • Posted By: yowfunk @ 08/28/2008 2:16:19 PM

      We are not demonizing the rich. If someone does well for themselves then good for them. The problem is that opportunities for working and middle class people to improve their standing are not as available as they used to be. We just want a fair playing field.

      • Posted By: ckologinczak @ 08/28/2008 2:31:12 PM

        Newsflash: Life is never fair. Fair is subjective and rarely defined the same way from person to person. What may be fair to you, won't be fair to me. There is no fair. There is only work and reward. Taking rewards from hardworking individuals smacks of socialism and creates an economic vacuum.

  • Posted By: rdelawder @ 08/28/2008 3:31:58 PM

    If we flat taxed and did away with all the different tax loops, we would really know people's net worth. They would quit hiding it over seas, shipping business out of the country. Moving to smaller and less communities to afford to live. Families would have more time to be a family instead of working 2 jobs to pay for private school, athletics, books and college tuition. That's just like the report that the economy increased to the positive side for the last quarter. Sure it did we all got stimulus checks to buy groceries and pay bills. I am middle class and the wife just lost her job for the 3rd time in 18 months, In the past 2 years I've gone from a household income of $140,000 down to a house hold income of $90,000. I could live with that on a flat tax, but not paying 34% of my wages to taxes and $400 a month for insurance. A lot of people are going to become a statistic this year, foreclosure's, bankruptcies and uninsured or on public assistance. We are only half way through this mortgage mess, first it was subprime and now it's prime customers. Fannie and Freddie needed help this year, and the last time I checked they do good beneficial loans and for good credit people that can afford what they bought. What are we going to blame next? Quit dropping rates, drop taxes so people can afford to pay what they currently have!

  • Posted By: NYXKP @ 08/28/2008 3:30:26 PM

    This article should be required reading (with exam to follow) for every two-bit 'talking head' on TV, and that CERTAINLY applies to all Congress members. I am sick and tired of hearing the belly-aching by people complaining about not being able to make-it on their (purported) 'middle class' salaries of a MERE $250K. These are the same people who traipse into the hinterlands with fistfulls of cash and buy up properties out here in the West where $50K is a typical family income. Call it a 'middle class salary' based on quintiles, namely what the average salary is amongst people in the 40th to 60th percentile. If $250K doesn't allow you to keep up with the Joneses (er...the Rockefellers) get your butt the hell outta there. Enough with the crocodile tears, already!!

  • Posted By: 66percent @ 08/28/2008 2:15:19 PM

    My family income is more than $250,000 and we are far from being ???rich???? My nest-egg is not tucked away and just awaiting my retirement. My daughter???s wedding has not been paid for. College tuition has not been paid for my kids. My mortgage is not paid off. I have no assurance that my ???wealth??? will provide a quality of life that will last until I'm 100. Instead, I'm investing in 401K, 529, IRA, Mutual funds, stocks, real estate, etc??? and praying that my hard earned (and wisely invested) money is available to me in 15-20 years. Under Obama???s tax plan, however, the government will get a greater share of all that money, and it will be redistributed to families of lower income.

    I don???t know about you, but I feel like the $75,000+ that the government takes from my family right now is already too much. I will never see a penny of that returned to me in any form other than a national military. (I know, it???s also used to build bridges, repair levees, etc???, but we???ve seen those systems fail miserably over the last 5 years.) By the government???s own admission, the social security system that I???ve been paying into my entire career will be bankrupt before I can ever get a penny of it back. If that doesn???t bother you, then take $5,000 and throw it into your fireplace this Winter. Now, just imagine doing that with $75,000 every year. And, in addition to that $75,000, my family gives thousands to our church (in support of missions, feeding the homeless, and other faith based initiatives), and we donate time/money to breast cancer awareness, muscular dystrophy, muscular sclerosis, community food banks, Blue Santa, United Way, Red Cross, etc??? How dare the government, the Democrats, and/or lower income families tell me that I???m rich and I???m not doing enough to level the playing field!

    My Dad was a truck-driver, and my mom worked at Wal-Mart. Neither of them ever made $100,000 combined, and at the age of 60 my Mom has gone back to work making about ~$15 an hour. (My father has passed away, and under Obama???s plan I will need to pay taxes on my father???s assets, which he also paid taxes on, but I digress.) Point being that I was/am far from a trust fund baby. However, after a lifetime of making more good decisions than bad, and taking responsibility for my actions, I???ve graduated from college and built a good life for my family. And according to Michelle and Barak Obama, and according to the Democratic party, I need to give the government more money in order to help out families that are just like the one I grew up in??? BULL!!!

    Stay off drugs???study in school???don???t join gangs???don???t commit crimes???don???t get pregnant???go to college...get a job???save your money???improve your community???don???t become dependent on the government....and, DO NOT TELL ME THAT I'M RICH, AND THAT I SHOULD GIVE YOU MORE MONEY.

    • Posted By: spjon @ 08/28/2008 2:23:04 PM

      Obama is really gonna tax you that much more. People are making a mountain out of an anthill. All Obama is going to do is let the Bush tax cuts expire. And then, even if he wanted to raise taxes there would still be enough republicans left in Congress for that not to happen. Now, if you're still paying off your kids college education...maybe you should have made them get student loans. That's what my parents did.

      • Posted By: TheTruthHurts2008 @ 08/28/2008 3:30:15 PM

        What most people do not realize is that Bush's tax cuts also benefited those that are not rich as well. I know many people that received rebate checks that earn less than $36,000/yr. Also, the program create a new 10% tax bracket for those that earn less than the poverty level versus the %15 tax braket. When the tax cut expires, we will all be paying higher taxes, not just the rich.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse