Why I Am Leaving Guyland

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: The.Paladin @ 09/04/2008 2:34:50 PM

    I USED TO BE BEEFY and guyhood was demoralizing. Ok, let me preface this by saying that 1 - I'm still smart, good looking, relatively wealthy, educated, employed, and in my early 30's. But now I'm completely disenfranchised with marriage. I was all of these things in my late 20's, except that I was a beefy upbeat fitness freak during the week, and gentleman playboy on the weekend. Guyland totally sucked. Why you ask? It sucked because I WAS looking for a nice girl and a lot of partygoer men are lonely and lost. Find the nice girl, especially after an Odyssey, is nearly impossible. Clytemnestra's outnumber Penelope e^100 x 1. The catch-22 is that most of the "nice" girls are already married, so us early 3o's or late 2o's ready to settle down men, look about and what do you think we see? NOTHING! The remaining Bachelorettes today have sooo much baggage (daddy complex, sub-100 IQ, or played more times than Community Golf Course). It's scary. The few that I find who are normal, literally throw themselves at decent men. But get this. Here's the scary part. The part that makes a lot of guys cringe. Most of the women I meet who are quality, who will pursue (even engage in "fun times", EVEN IF THEY ARE ALREADY MARRIED. A majority of men are not afraid of commitment. They are afraid of a BAD commitment. Today's 'empowered' woman is 1,000% more likely to cheat than our fathers wives. And there are PLENTY of men who do the same. Women have this greater need to marry than men. So they grab the first thing they can lasso. Then when they realize he's a POS, or him her, it's sayonara. I think this is a cycle, that if men and women, were both on the same schedule, things would be much smoother. If the nice girls would wait around for nice guys to be ready, we'd all be better off (and less crowded). MARRAGE is not BAD. But a BAD MARRAIGE is LIFE THREATENING. ~Not Worth The Risk~

  • Posted By: The.Paladin @ 09/04/2008 2:34:22 PM

    I USED TO BE BEEFY and guyhood was demoralizing. Ok, let me preface this by saying that 1 - I'm still smart, good looking, relatively wealthy, educated, employed, and in my early 30's. But now I'm completely disenfranchised with marriage. I was all of these things in my late 20's, except that I was a beefy upbeat fitness freak during the week, and gentleman playboy on the weekend. Guyland totally sucked. Why you ask? It sucked because I WAS looking for a nice girl and a lot of partygoer men are lonely and lost. Find the nice girl, especially after an Odyssey, is nearly impossible. Clytemnestra's outnumber Penelope e^100 x 1. The catch-22 is that most of the "nice" girls are already married, so us early 3o's or late 2o's ready to settle down men, look about and what do you think we see? NOTHING! The remaining Bachelorettes today have sooo much baggage (daddy complex, sub-100 IQ, or played more times than Community Golf Course). It's scary. The few that I find who are normal, literally throw themselves at decent men. But get this. Here's the scary part. The part that makes a lot of guys cringe. Most of the women I meet who are quality, who will pursue (even engage in "fun times", EVEN IF THEY ARE ALREADY MARRIED. A majority of men are not afraid of commitment. They are afraid of a BAD commitment. Today's 'empowered' woman is 1,000% more likely to cheat than our fathers wives. And there are PLENTY of men who do the same. Women have this greater need to marry than men. So they grab the first thing they can lasso. Then when they realize he's a POS, or him her, it's sayonara. I think this is a cycle, that if men and women, were both on the same schedule, things would be much smoother. If the nice girls would wait around for nice guys to be ready, we'd all be better off (and less crowded). MARRAGE is not BAD. But a BAD MARRAIGE is LIFE THREATENING. ~Not Worth The Risk~

  • Posted By: lucky_irish @ 09/04/2008 11:05:41 AM

    This article sounds like it was written by Tony's fiance or was at least orchestrated by the puppet master as he will soon find out when he ventures into an entangling contract that he can never get out of with his manhood entact. I am married, and marriage is no walk in the park. Can most guys really be tied to one woman for a duration of 50 or 60 years anyway? (Increasingly more as our life expectancy grows). Either society or religious beliefs tell us that this is a realistic and desireable goal, but I would be inclined to say it is neither.

  • Posted By: spocksdisciple @ 09/04/2008 10:30:12 AM

    "Judge ye not, lest ye be judged" or something like that. I'm a 45 year old life long bachelor, I don't and never have fit the stereotype of the single guy(financially and socially responsible, never excessive in my behavior, don???t even drink! womanize etc).
    We have to admit to what this article is really painting; a stereotype. I've seen too many examples of younger men who get married in their 20s and display the same kind of smug arrogance the author does. They think they have the game and all the angles figured out, they think they've completed the quest and are on top of the world and need to justify it to the rest of his cohort. They're wrong and I think they know that as well but can???t admit it.

    Looking at the current divorce statistics and all the anecdotal evidence from family courts and other sources, the author has a slimmer chance then he thinks in finding lasting happiness.
    We should pull this article back up and finds out what has happened to his life in 5-7 years and see if he's so smug then, 90% of my male and female friends have at least one marriage under their belts and most are now working on their second or even third one.
    He may laugh at the "loser" single party guys, like someone who thinks this is a competition in life and he's just won the grand prize. Unfortunately, what he???s just won is not the gold ring or even the brass one, he???s won a pair a prison handcuffs and a possible 20 year sentence at hard labor.

    To all the single guys reading this article, take it from an old ???salt??? don???t cave into societal pressures to get married, do so because you think it???s the right thing to do for you and not because it???s acceptable or that you???ll feel accepted (or even because your girlfriend has issued an ultimatum), those are exactly the wrong reasons to marry. There is no right or wrong time for such a large step in your life, this author thinks he knows what???s best and even pulls out so called studies to support his arguments. But look at the current marriage and divorce stats, look at current family law and listen to the experiences of already married men. Then decide for yourself what you wish to do, don???t succumb to the shaming tactics of women and men who want to see a storybook happy ending(misery loves company), 70% of divorces are initiated by women.

    My guess is that this fellow won???t be quite so smug in a few years, once he???s been inside for a while. While you???re at it Google the terms ???Marriage Strike??? and ???MGTOW??? and learn about the true reasons why there are more single men then ever before. Not the so called reasons given out here.

  • Posted By: bobpetty @ 09/04/2008 8:36:36 AM

    Typical married guy who wants to justify his decision to the world......who the hell cares about your life?! You make a comment about how guys are happier and wealthier when married....complete BS! Where's your stupid statistic about over 65% of married couples get divorced!!?? The other 30% are cheating on eachother and the 4% are miserable because they can't get out of the hell they created. So that leaves you with the last 1% to walk off into the sunset.....good odds jerk! Have fun getting divorced and giving up half of what you worked for your entire life!! Happy and wealthy still? Don't get me wrong....if I met the right girl i'd marry her in a second.....but i'm not going to settle for anything just so society stops pressuring me into their misery. Congrats on your marriage and I hope it works out......just remember one thing NO ONE CARES!! Beat it NERD!!

  • Posted By: bobpetty @ 09/04/2008 8:36:22 AM

    Typical married guy who wants to justify his decision to the world......who the hell cares about your life?! You make a comment about how guys are happier and wealthier when married....complete BS! Where's your stupid statistic about over 65% of married couples get divorced!!?? The other 30% are cheating on eachother and the 4% are miserable because they can't get out of the hell they created. So that leaves you with the last 1% to walk off into the sunset.....good odds jerk! Have fun getting divorced and giving up half of what you worked for your entire life!! Happy and wealthy still? Don't get me wrong....if I met the right girl i'd marry her in a second.....but i'm not going to settle for anything just so society stops pressuring me into their misery. Congrats on your marriage and I hope it works out......just remember one thing NO ONE CARES!! Beat it NERD!!

  • Posted By: bobpetty @ 09/04/2008 8:31:39 AM

    Typical married guy who wants to justify his decision to the world......who the hell cares about your life?! You make a comment about how guys are happier and wealthier when married....complete BS! Where's your stupid statistic about over 65% of married couples get divorced!!?? The other 30% are cheating on eachother and the 4% are miserable because they can't get out of the hell they created. So that leaves you with the last 1% to walk off into the sunset.....good odds jerk! Have fun getting divorced and giving up half of what you worked for your entire life!! Happy and wealthy still? Don't get me wrong....if I met the right girl i'd marry her in a second.....but i'm not going to settle for anything just so society stops pressuring me into their misery. Congrats on your marriage and I hope it works out......just remember one thing NO ONE CARES!! Beat it NERD!!

  • Posted By: geektron2000 @ 09/04/2008 12:31:12 AM

    Actually I can sympathize with these guys. While they should definitely get a job and move out of their parents' basement, dating and work are often an unhappy ordeal. Many women regard men who earn less than $50k a year--a common fate for us mathematically challenged word people--as navel lint. Work is one long sodomyfest. John Mellencamp was right: life goes on long after the thrill of living is gone. The world may not end at 21, but joy and pleasure largely do.

  • Posted By: cambac4 @ 09/03/2008 10:59:57 PM

    To quote Camille Paglia (I believe it is from "Sexual Personae"): "Teenage boys, goaded by their surging hormones run in packs like the primal horde. They have only a brief season of exhilarating liberty between control by their mothers and control by their wives. " In other words, you probably should be too smug about stepping early into your prison, however cozy it appears from the outside.

  • Posted By: shmemily @ 09/03/2008 11:37:28 AM

    The conclusion of this article is that men do better when they get married. As a single thirty-something woman, I have to say, duh. The rub here is that women are wising up to the fact that they are mostly better off alone. Men get married and they get a partner, but also often a caregiver and primary parent. Women? They often lose their agency, their direction, and maybe they don't feel the point in taking care of someone else when they can take care of themselves just fine. The answer? Guys, learn to take care of yourselves and your fortunes will advance. And moms? Teach your boys to do things for themselves already! Mamas boys are so 70s.

    • Posted By: bobcatgrad @ 09/03/2008 10:57:34 PM

      I couldn't have said it better myself! I am only 23, my live-in boyfriend of a year, 30. He says he couldn't be happier, even after I drug him out of his "Peter Pan" lifestyle that he lived for the majority of his life. However, it's been quite the battle to get any other growing up out of him. I already have the retirement plans, pay all the bills and a start to a wonderful career. Luckily he is keeping hold of some of his carefree ways to share with me so iI can loosen up a little!

    • Posted By: mayrasilva @ 09/03/2008 11:53:38 AM

      Good point, however never going to happen. Like I said before I have 2 sons (16 & 18) they have been doing thier own laundry and cleaning their own room/bathroom since they were 12. I still have to remind them (constantly), they dont "just do it". My daughter on the other hand never has to be reminded. It has to be how we are hard wired. I know thats not what women want to hear but it is the truth. If you can't accept that in your guy then you should take the advise of just staying alone and taking care of yourself. The problem is that most women don't like being alone. So what do you? You love them just as they are.

      • Posted By: dtkeyc @ 09/03/2008 3:50:46 PM

        just because you have been teaching your sons to be self-sufficient doesn't mean they aren't affected by society expects of them...which is to be waited on and pampered because they are males...

        • Posted By: PresidentSupporter @ 09/03/2008 6:09:58 PM

          That's a load of nonsense! Whatever guys have been burning you aren't the norm. I wait on my wife and pamper her and our 5 kids a heckuva lot more than any of them do for me. Find a hard working man instead of waiting on bums. If you don't find a different kind of guy, you're just going to be alone and hate-filled.

    • Posted By: Cavallino_Rapante @ 09/03/2008 11:50:32 AM

      How's life as a Lesbian-by-Choice working out for you?

  • Posted By: obviously @ 09/03/2008 9:13:01 PM

    What about the 20-something women that perpetuate this pitiful lifestyle by gawking over these cocky, binge drinking losers? Guys are part of the problem, but i believe this is a larger cultural problem that involves the erosion of values and the extension of teenage immaturity in both men and women.

  • Posted By: daplane @ 09/03/2008 11:05:49 AM

    The main reason why so many 20 something guys are not growing up is because they don't have a dad that will kick their ass for not growing up. and efrain's comment is pure evidence of this attitude. Getting married isn't a "hindrance" to financial wealth and well-being. Being married is a BLESSING. And going to church isn't proof that you're mature. There's lots of people, men and women alike, that go to church all the time that are in no ways "mature". Maturity doesn't have a damn thing to do with chronological age, and neither does true wisdom. Most guys nowadays do not want to grow up because of all the mess they see around them, and instead of rising to the occasion and taking authority over the mess around them, they give in to it, and proclaim that smoking pot is so wonderful, and that getting drunk is what they need to do. Talk about a childish generation.

    • Posted By: atticus8 @ 09/03/2008 9:06:16 PM

      "Most guys nowadays do not want to grow up because of all the mess they see around them". Yes, you semi-accurately gauge the problem. So ask yourself, how did that "mess" get to be there? From the former-hippies now-parents that sold out all their values they espoused while gobbling up the drug-coated 60s and 70s all to turn into the Prozac-needing, selfish, rat-racing, record-deficit-making, record-divorce-making middle-age-children of the 80s and 90s.
      What exactly is that "dad that will kick their ass for not growing up" saying to the young 'uns? "Go out there and 'rise to occasion and take authority over the mess around' you, go out there and fix all the ways in which we screwed you. Oh yeah, and find out how to pay for our Social Security, since we couldn't even manage that." Sorry, fix your own problems. Talk about a hypocritical generation.

  • Posted By: cajademierda @ 09/02/2008 2:50:19 PM

    So there's straight guys on Fire Island?

    • Posted By: matilda613 @ 09/03/2008 10:33:06 AM

      LOL -- exactly what I thought!

      • Posted By: gomets @ 09/03/2008 7:18:57 PM

        I'm glad I wasn't the only one....LOL!!!!

      • Posted By: gomets @ 09/03/2008 7:18:17 PM

        I'm glad I wasn't the only one to think that

  • Posted By: Head42 @ 09/03/2008 6:46:02 PM

    I think that the men who are asked wither they are happier married are not telling the truth. Minus 1 or 2 of them, my married friends are constantly complaining about not being able to make their own decisions, being tied down by social events that they don't enjoy, and the never ending barrage of complaining that some women do. I'm 29 and not married, however I'm not some drunken bachelor, or are any of my single friends, I have a house, no furniture with duct tape as the author asserts all us bachelors have, and just want determine my life. My biggest issue with being married is that as a man in our society, you lose total control of your life to someone who doesn't necessarily have your best interests in mind. I have been in many relationships and in almost every case they have impeded on my goal of self improvement because if I get better, that makes me more desirable, and more likely to leave said relationship. And with all the power women have in relationships, many women do everything to prevent this. Add 50% divorce, the sexism of family court, and the possibility of never seeing your kids or money make me leery of marriage.

  • Posted By: aldoogie @ 09/03/2008 4:51:49 PM

    Love this article - it completely defines a pressing phenomenon among singles today. I think it's important to also look at other factors that have recently stepped into the equation. Take pets for example. I love dogs just as much as the next person, but have they replaced men and children to some degree. A girl asked me the other day if I have a dog. I responded with "nope, I'm acutally holding out for a kid".

    • Posted By: aldoogie @ 09/03/2008 6:30:20 PM

      ....another thing to consider is that we humans are living a lot long than we have in the past. Something to keep in mind. It just seems like there are many factors contibuting to this social behavior.

  • Posted By: cmaurer @ 09/03/2008 6:18:25 PM

    I think this is sort of bullshit... Most people are strong enough to resist peer pressure to drink, party, spend money etc. etc. Especially the older a person gets. I think this story was written by a very jealous male. At least that is what it sounds like. Why sit here and condemn everyone else for living the life they want? What makes this author god, or even better than the people he wrote about, that he can sit here and judge and critique their lifestyle? This is why I try to stay away from nearly all of the major news publications. They are horrible and usually cater to the conformists in the American society...

  • Posted By: nwswkusr @ 09/02/2008 4:49:44 PM

    When will articles like this represent the true facts of what they are about- HETEROSEXUAL males. This article is NOT about what it states- "...this testosterone-filled landscape is the new normal for American males". It is about HETEROSEXUAL American males. Every day I read about articles purporting to talk about "males", "men", or likewise "females" or "women". Articles that purportedly are "scientific" yet describe behaviors that are uniquely heterosexual. I don't disagree with the findings. In fact, I think they are important, but their labeling is misleading. While I am sure that homosexual men or lesbian women demonstrate similar behaviors, in many regards, in these articles, we also demonstrate significantly different behaviors such as- while gay men are "testosterone filled", we are much less prone to violence, an observation that holds not just for "American" gay men. We do not get into bar fights over each other. We do not kill our partners (now husbands or wives, as well), and then kill our children, because we are insanely jealous. Please exercise some degree of rationality when making overgeneralizations in these types of articles.

    • Posted By: PresidentSupporter @ 09/03/2008 6:01:40 PM

      Take the gay talk somewhere else. It's ridiculous that people think we have to include gay relationships in discussions.

  • Posted By: spacemonkeymojo @ 09/03/2008 5:32:41 PM

    Not all of us men who are single and unmarried are unhappy and binge drinking. What many see as "avoiding responsibility" is really the aversion to live a "traditional life" one that is expected of men: meet someone, get married, get a mortgage, raise children, work until retirement. Is this supposed to make us happy? How is this different from the gender expectations of a man in the 1950's? It isn't.

    And yet the

    Is

    Is

  • Posted By: Curtisag @ 09/03/2008 1:26:03 PM

    Women have asserted their independence, so men have reacted by liberating themselves from the same social conventions that held women back. I'm not saying women being independent is a bad thing, it's fine that they don't need a man now. But by contrast, men don't need women for more than sex either. They can provide a 2nd household income, but without a family to take care of, most men provide for themselves just fine. And we already do all our own housework for ourselves, and when we don't have a date we have porn and masturbation.

    That's the price to be paid for destroying traditional gender roles. Deep down a man wants to take care of a woman in my opinion, it gives him a sense of self-respect and pride. It's genetic. Our species would not have survived without it. But having lost this in the modern era though, it is not surprising that men have devolved into adolescence. Men grow up when there's a perceived "need" for them to do so. But that need has disappeared because of feminism.

    • Posted By: sregis @ 09/03/2008 4:14:07 PM

      who exactly are these women who the men in question are having sex with? i'm guessing it's mostly ones of a similar nature who are "postponing" their more adult futures in much the same way

    • Posted By: mayrasilva @ 09/03/2008 3:36:15 PM

      Beautifully put, Curtis you are brilliant!!!

  • Posted By: dtkeyc @ 09/03/2008 3:45:20 PM

    I think for the most part this article hits the nail right on the head. Unfortunately, it seems that a somewhat more accepting culture has caused something of a backlash in masculinity. Many of my friends are overly concerned about looking like a "***" or about what I think of their masculinity. Its like rather than accepting and being grateful for the fact that our society is more accepting of different kinds of masculinity, they want to lash out and be as militantly "masculine" and chauvinist as they can.

    My only problem with this article was this comment: "As a result, many men feel redundant." when referring to men being out-earned by women. This is ridiculous. On one hand you are saying that men should grow up and live meaningful lives but on the other hand you are saying that we should be offended that women are getting paid more than us sometimes? That just seems contradictory to me...maybe I don't fully understand the point the author is trying to make. I think its a great state of affairs that women are moving forward in the workplace, and maybe these little growing pains that we men are going through are just part of that process. But come on, let's do what the author suggests and stop being big babies about everything.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse