The Next Bailout: Detroit

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Rontron @ 09/18/2008 4:37:19 PM

    Years back when Congress tried to get the Big Three to continue improving fuel efficency after 1985, they cried to Congress that it would impose economic hardship on the Auto industry. Being greedy they made their own bed so let them lie in it.

    • Posted By: ThinkPleaseThink @ 09/18/2008 10:12:06 PM

      Why don't you try to build a car with those standards imposed on them and still keep it safe? How can we make a fuel efficient car? Lighter car -less around you. The body of the car has to be lighter however it still must be safe or all the car companies are going to be held liable (is that spelled right?). Maybe the Big 3 should just pack it up and say see ya' - it's not worth it to be exposed to all the lawuits. What about driving with a battery full of energy - would it be explosive? YOU BET! How about liability there too? Stop typing and start designing! Put YOUR butt on the line!!

  • Posted By: bigharry @ 09/18/2008 4:04:17 PM

    All this money will do is allow the Big 3 to keep union labor laid off until the end of the union contact in 3 years. My brother is on permanent layoff from the Big 3 and collecting 95% of 40 hours pay for 42 weeks then 85% of his pay for the remainder of the 3 year contract. When the 85% kicks in, he can also get another job and still collect!

    • Posted By: ThinkPleaseThink @ 09/18/2008 10:04:45 PM

      And i suppose your brother is going to school to get an education so he can compete in this "new" global market we have, right? That money is not a handout but yet it is being treated like one. Your brother, I hope, is investing in himself because only he is to blame when the checks run out and he has no skills to compete in this world!

  • Posted By: pinkpanther87413 @ 09/18/2008 10:02:47 PM

    It all depends how much stock in Detroit Congress has, if they get bailed out. As i see it bailing out Aig and others was a conflict of intrest. as i assume [pretty close to reality] most if not all those in DC have stock porf. with all there money, losing money. so a bail out was to protect there personel profits, ergo conflict of intrest, of being intrested in padding there stocks,with our borrowed money.

  • Posted By: Marvinlee @ 09/18/2008 9:53:50 PM

    Detroit has had at least fifty years of warnings that its focus on large vehicles was a trip in the wrong direction. Hundreds of studies and dozens of books have been written telling of the coming energy shortage. Statistics on our falling domestic oil production have been readily available. A bail out now will not solve Detroit's problems, but will create a new problem of never-ending car company subsidies.

  • Posted By: shackleman @ 09/18/2008 9:51:28 PM

    The big three failed themselves..Once we opened the US car market to the world..Any smart CEO and Union bosses should have anticpated decreased market share in the US..Most logical companies would have invested heavily in over seas market to make up for that loss..Instead the CEO's invested heavily in Large SUV of which we could not sell to the World..Realize most countries have been paying high gas prices for decades!
    Our CEO's instead lobbyied congress(Michigan politicians) not to raise mileage standards because it would hurt their industry..What a joke..that is what killed the Big Three..again we could not sell these gas guzzler to the world.. The unions are also to blame...Instead of pushing for being paid overtime for working over 8 hours in a day or double time for working a weekend shift..They should have been using their money and power to hold senior management accountable to increasing market share around the world.. What a bunch of dumm idiots..They ran themselves right into the ground. Unions were good for America..they helped us all out..their biggest down fall is...they didn't change with time..Once they got a good job with benefits...they just kept pushing for more..Unions should now be making management accountable and getting bad CEO's fired...I currently believe the only US car maker who possibly can survive is GM. Chrysler is a joke and Ford's current management is failing miserbly..So to repeat myself..Michigan has itself to blame..The Unions, its politicians and senior management all dismissed the warning signs..Hell, this week asking for more money and pushing congress not to fine for meeting mileage standards.. Hell mileage standards is what brought them to non existence..they are so freaking stupid..

  • Posted By: shackleman @ 09/18/2008 9:49:19 PM

    The big three failed themselves..Once we opened the US car market to the world..Any smart CEO and Union bosses should have anticpated decreased market share in the US..Most logical companies would have invested heavily in over seas market to make up for that loss..Instead the CEO's invested heavily in Large SUV of which we could not sell to the World..Realize most countries have been paying high gas prices for decades!
    Our CEO's instead lobbyied congress(Michigan politicians) not to raise mileage standards because it would hurt their industry..What a joke..that is what killed the Big Three..again we could not sell these gas guzzler to the world.. The unions are also to blame...Instead of pushing for being paid overtime for working over 8 hours in a day or double time for working a weekend shift..They should have been using their money and power to hold senior management accountable to increasing market share around the world.. What a bunch of dumm idiots..They ran themselves right into the ground. Unions were good for America..they helped us all out..their biggest down fall is...they didn't change with time..Once they got a good job with benefits...they just kept pushing for more..Unions should now be making management accountable and getting bad CEO's fired...I currently believe the only US car maker who possibly can survive is GM. Chrysler is a joke and Ford's current management is failing miserbly..So to repeat myself..Michigan has itself to blame..The Unions, its politicians and senior management all dismissed the warning signs..Hell, this week asking for more money and pushing congress not to fine for meeting mileage standards.. Hell mileage standards is what brought them to non existence..they are so freaking stupid..

  • Posted By: timrogers @ 09/18/2008 9:49:19 PM

    We can afford to bail out a bunch of greedy scammers who have brought the financial system to its knees with their gambling losses, but we can not afford to bail out the last bastion of manufacturing that exists in America because their executives were stupid? Detroit was chasing the money from big trucks, bigger SUVs, and the biggest financing profits. They were good at it, but nothing like the Wall Street boys who made ice cream out of *** and sold it all over the world as solid gold. Detroit pays for its stupid and short-sighted mistakes because they put their money where their mouth is. Wall Street puts their mouth where the money is. They love you, they like you, and then they leave you all on the first date. Detroit deserves help from the Government because they are real, they make stuff, and they live with their mistakes. Wall Streeet makes stuff up, calls it investing and then denies reality at every downturn. If I have a choice, my tax money goes to Detroit. Send the tax collectors to Wall Street; where they only tell the truth by accident. Trust Wall Street; the check is in the mail, and they won't bend you over unless you turn your back. Don't trust Detroit with money, they just represent a bunch of middle class sheep waiting to be sheared.

  • Posted By: Punchy0 @ 09/18/2008 9:36:54 PM

    The Automakers cannot be allowed to fail... they are part of an ever dwindling industrial base which is in the national interest to maintain. That is one reason Chrysler was saved so many years ago. Even though people would rather stick their heads in the sand and pretend it doesn't matter, in time of conflict it isn't practical, or perhaps even possible, to buy your defense needs from someone overseas. Would victory in WWII been possible if we'd been forced to buy our equipment instead of produce it ourselves? I think not.

  • Posted By: Rserp1 @ 09/18/2008 9:36:25 PM

    This Government is a disaster. Full of inept people void of any critical thinking. They bend to dieing Businesses cry for help while people live in tenet cities!
    Someone needs to tell these clowns that when a Business has run it's corse or demise to let it die. When it dies 10 more pop up to take it's place with fresh new ideas and direction.
    We shouldn't be bailing out any business that had the lack of vision and fortitude to survive their own mistakes.
    Rewarding stupidness is dumb. And the one thing you can't fix is dumb!
    Why should we as tax payers bail out any bank or auto or insurance company??
    You think if your in trouble you would get bailed out for your stupidness?
    Say you lost a lot on the stock market, is the government going to step in and say, "Tough Luck, Here is some money to get you back on your feet."? So you can invest it dumb again! I think not. So why should we bail out AIG? Bail out the Banks? They stuck money in oil stocks and watched it drop and lost their ars. They stuck their money in bad loans for housing. They were dumb and now they should be dead. Let someone else come in that can do it right and stop saving companies that don't deserve one plum nickle. Fact of Life people Businesses Die! And others are reborn from the ashes. The Government needs to keep our money out of it and stay out of the free market.

  • Posted By: wetwilly @ 09/18/2008 9:33:34 PM

    After 9/11 America leaned on GM, who offered a variety of financing to keep the economy going and spirits high. Pay it forward?

  • Posted By: emptywallet @ 09/18/2008 9:25:35 PM

    In the 70;s Toyota, Nissan and Honda were making fuel efficient vehicles; in the 80's Detroit
    alctually was producing vehicles that were more efficient. Did Toyota Honda and Nissan stop with their R&D and say "we don't need to move forward with no technology our cars get good gas mileage......No....they did not, the developed hybrids, etc. meanwhile Detroit puts out a few SUB's and Wow everybody runs out and buys them; fine but why did Detroit stop
    further R&D Now they lag behind and we are supposed to bail them out---If they had intelligent leadership they would have moved ahead and they wouldn't need a bailout and furthermore, their employees would still have jobs. Any good business person knows youi must reinvest and develop better products; what kind of idiots were running Detroit; unless they knew our tax dollars would bail them out, time after time. In fact per Newsweek, above,
    the 10 ten vehicles that are most gas efficient are all made by foreign auto makers. Why is
    that???? Surely we do have people wih the engineering skills to develop products to compete with those markets or did Detroit outsource those as well

  • Posted By: norm w @ 09/18/2008 9:18:05 PM

    I cannot think of a single reason to provide welfare to Detroit's big 3. They warnings have been clear since 1970 that Japan was intent on moving into the void left by Europe's failure to provide Americans cars they want. This coupled with the outsourcing of plants (MI FORDECITO HECHO EN MEJICO) and whatever the Canadian equivalent is..

  • Posted By: woodja @ 09/18/2008 8:29:10 PM

    Hey Widgetmaker, you are so right you ain't never been wrong. I too was born and raised in MI. My entrie family built the vehicles of independance these pukes want to flush away.
    It is far wiser to maintain and grow the the domestic market to avoid a dependance on "cheap foreign oil burners" After all when they are the only store in town, the cars won't be cheap and the jobs will not be even moderatley close to living wage jobs. These idiots think that ripple effect will not hit them because they are in some other state or some other industry? Big picture thinking is not for everyone and common sense is not that common!

    • Posted By: St. Germain @ 09/18/2008 9:15:06 PM

      Wrong we will all feel the effects. A few effects will be cheaper fuel prices as the petro giants will be loosing a lot of money on gasoline sales so the price per gal will go down to get us to buy more. The imports of small autos will increase as more of them can be stuffed in a ship then suvs, so our ports will be more busy. There will be an increase in the national unemployment rate. Over time there will be fewer suvs on our roads. As far as our jobs go I never heard an outcry like this when we were loosing our steel mills in the USA. It didn't destroy our country only those of us that worked for them as steel is produced in Mexico and over seas much cheaper. I understand your outrage, however; this will not destroy the USA . Only the lives of the people that work for these auto manufactures. Mexico, China, and Canada will hurt a lot more then we will over this. Then to I would almost bet that the big 3 moves to Mexico if we don't bail them out. One has to concider if that hasn't been their plan all along. After all, the big 3 are all about a profit.

  • Posted By: goosemon @ 09/18/2008 9:00:03 PM

    The bottom line is, in a global economy, everone is expendable. The world doesn't need American manufactured goods...ask China. In 1977 we imported 77% of our vital resources, today it is around 90%. Manufacturing is the engine that drives an economy...without exports we are only trading dollars here at home. A serviced based economy will fail, you have to have foreign money coming into our economy.

  • Posted By: theoatwa @ 09/18/2008 8:58:56 PM

    americans are pathetic. won't support their own industries, won't build new infrastructure in midst of crumbling nation, and don't have any vision or whereathal to do anything that matters anymore. sure keep the right-wing mentality and just tear down everything to keep things as it is. just like frogs staying in point when being boiled to death. enough already.

  • Posted By: goosemon @ 09/18/2008 8:44:36 PM

    What is the new ad this year, employee priciing, you pay the same price for that vehicle as they (employees) or the CEO would. I believe it was about a $6,000.00 discount, the manufacturer never blinked an eye. The mark up must be tremendous, right? Just think what it would be like to order your vehicle on line, no middle man to make rich. We don't need show rooms, just a monitor and a mouse.

    • Posted By: drb29 @ 09/18/2008 8:53:09 PM

      Now that is a good way to make the automakers more competitive and encourage car sales! The same thing could also be done with real estate to get us out of this housing mess (no realtors who are generally pointless anyway).

  • Posted By: Dam Tired Of This @ 09/18/2008 8:36:35 PM

    Congress needs to go back to working FULL TIME for their pay!! They need to WORK to get this country back on track!!!

  • Posted By: madpuppy @ 09/18/2008 7:02:14 PM

    Hell No ! When is it going to stop ? I`m the CEO of a small corp. and I`m filing for dissolution of business because my company cant make any money ! Can I have a tax payer bail out ? If a company cant make it get out and let someone that can do it ! Quit crying for the government to help ! If the " Big Three " made cars that would last and get good gas mileage they would not be in the place their in ! They are in bed with Big oil, that's why they wont make a car that will do 50-60 mpg. Toyota made a car called the " Echo" for 3 yrs. it was made so well and got excellent (42-45mpg) gas mileage they took it out of production! It can be done TODAY ! SO DO IT! NO TO BAIL OUTS !

    • Posted By: goosemon @ 09/18/2008 8:32:47 PM

      remove dealerships that are grandfathered in due to greed and corruption, allow the manufacturer to sell cars on line and we can best all the rest. I believe Toyota has one dealership to our 10, thus eliminating markup that makes these dealers filthy rich!

  • Posted By: woodja @ 09/18/2008 8:21:09 PM

    They don't need a bailout. Just impart tarriffs on the import or sale of foreign automobiles commensurate with the costs already borne by the domestics. The companies that built the auto industry are being priced out of it with our own politicians holding the door open. Just send these jobs to Mexico and or Canada and watch the US economy irretreviably fall behind.
    And if you are the type of person who does'nt mind seeing that happen, well you are not an American, you are Can - meximerican. And we don't like your kind much. So, make sure you are the right side of the fence McCain will build and you and the rest of us will all be fine.

    • Posted By: St. Germain @ 09/18/2008 8:32:13 PM

      We are already falling behind as our jobs have been going to Mexico and over-seas for quite a few years now. That fence is needed to keep the Mexicans from sneaking over here to work illegally, as it takes more jobs from us. I bet you must live in Mexico so we all know what side of the fence you will be on.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse