The Next Bailout: Detroit

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: rottenman641 @ 09/18/2008 8:04:09 PM

    I was thinking the exact samething that it said in the article before I even read it.The companies themselves are at fault for building all those damn big-ass gas guzzlers in the first place.All those years when I could not even afford to buy one of those suvs to begin with,then I had to put up with all the same years trying to drive in a regular ECONOMY car and try to see the god damn road but always had problems because 3 out of every 4 vehicles were some type of large ass suv that I couldn't see over or around.Well guess what I don't feel one god damn bit of sympathy for the companies or any one of the owners who now have to put a $100.00 bill down to fill up the tank every week.Tell them all when thier at the pumps to think of me driving my nice little convertable Sunbird around when thier all paying almost a second car payment for thier gas.JOHNNY ROTTEN.STERLING HEIGHTS,MICHIGAN.

  • Posted By: Mattiegirl @ 09/18/2008 7:25:21 PM

    Let's not forget the unions - they too have had their hand in the automotive pot for a long long time which also drives up the price of cars. This is not a simple problem nor will there be a simple answer. However, as long as those in control continue to look only after themselves and their respective pet interests NOTHING will ever get resolved - until it's too late. The auto industry is its own worst enemy, slow to react, arrogant and bureaucratic - but it has had a lot of outside "help" to get it where it is today. I live in a suburb of Detroit - it still facinates me that EVERY local ad that comes on television for car sales caters to automotive workers and their discounts...It has never occurred to the automative powers-that-be that not EVERYONE who lives in Detroit works for the auto industry...it's yet another example of their short-sightedness.

    It's really a vicious circle that seems so painfully obvious to everyone on the outside looking in (but it's a classic case of not being able to see the forest for the trees)...You take the greed of the union, the safety and environmental regulations imposed by the government, the slow moving behemoth automotive companies, the outsourcing of parts to other countries - put all those ingredients together and it becomes a recipe for disaster.

    Let's all hope for a better 2009 where greed and complacency takes a backseat to the spirit of cooperation and honor...

    Wishing you all a new found peace and hope for prosperity

    • Posted By: St. Germain @ 09/18/2008 7:36:42 PM

      Excellent you get an A+ from me. Good writing skills is a must for a person to be truely taken seriously. Also thanks for the insight of the car adds tailored for their employees.

  • Posted By: scobman @ 09/18/2008 5:49:42 PM

    Hey RangerDan

    The gov is already talking about selling the water rights to foregn countries that will then control the water.

    havent you heard about that yet?

    They even say they own the rights to RAINWATER, and its reported on FOX NEWS too.

    www.infowars.com if you want the truth

    • Posted By: RangerDan @ 09/18/2008 7:35:36 PM

      There are tens of thousands in Michigan alone that will pick up arms and fight to stop any transfer of water out of the region. Moving that water could start a civil war.

  • Posted By: scobman @ 09/18/2008 6:56:00 PM

    How much does the owner of the detroit lions (ford) pay their best player?

    How much could FORD get for the DETROIT LIONS if they sold them to get the "BAILOUT" money?

    How much did FORD save with the BUSH tax cut?

    How much a year does FORD save by paying sweat shop employees to make the cars in china?

    One way or another, they aint using my tax dollars for the big 3 who should be renamed to the 3 that went bankrupt in detroit.

    Detroit mayor in jail for lying and corruption, they are all criminals in gov and until you realize it, the will loot us until "ONE DAY WE WILL FIND OUR CHILDREN HOMELESS SLEEPING ON THE STREETS IN THE COUNTRY THEIR ANCESTORS CONQURORED" as the gov live like KINGS with all their friends there to join them.

    Next they will bailout the airline industry, then again each and every year give ISRAEL another 50 billion and give PAKISTAN another 10 billion so a few months later they can fire upon our troops just like what is happening now on the afghanistan/pakistan border.

    if the gov bails them out, you will have to realize its all true and they are looting you into such a debt foregnors will eventually collect it from each of us, door to door with their troops.

    You all must rise up and let GOD put his hand of protection on you and the coutry in a battle to take back what is ours and NOT theirs.

    • Posted By: RangerDan @ 09/18/2008 7:31:21 PM

      Ford Motor Company does not own the Detroit Lions. Who told you that?

  • Posted By: drb29 @ 09/18/2008 7:28:50 PM

    Any loan should be like that given to AIG. The government takes 80% of the company and charges a high interest rate (say 11%) for a two year loans. It should also be required that the executives give back three years bonuses, have reasonable pay and the unions have to bring their deal in line with what is received by most of America (no free healthcare, long vacations, pensions, etc). If they don't do that then the auto companies/unions are just loking for a giveaway at taxpayers expense to pad their inevitable failure.

  • Posted By: Nins @ 09/18/2008 6:21:19 PM

    Fannie Mae, Freddy Mac, Bear Sterns, Lehman Brothers, AIG and the rest of the failed institutions have failed primarily because of former Senator Phil Gramm. The Gramm-Leach-Biley Act stripped away the regulations separating banking from investment companies, insurance companies and mortgage guaranty companies. Those regulations were added after the Great Depression when it became obvious that allowing banks to be in bed with the stock market was a sure way to rig the system to collapse, as it did in 1929.

    Lo an behold, a few years after the regulations were removed, the sh!t has hit the fan, and the inter-related investment, insurance, mortgage and banking industries are now starting to collapse, and guess what, you, the taxpayer will have to pay to clean it up.

    Phil Gramm is the Senator who brought you the "Enron Loophole" that de-regulated futures trading, causing the prices of oil, gas and food to spiral out of control.

    Senator Phil Gramm was McCain's top economic advisor until recently, when he was forced to step down after he said that there is no problem with our economy other than a "mental recession" on the part of a "nation of whiners." Phil Gramm is the man who McCain said he wants to name Secretary of the Treasury if he becomes President. You have to believe John McCain when he says that he knows little about the economy -- so little that he doesn't even know who to choose as an advisor.

    Barack Obama addressed the Enron Loophole, futures trading, short-selling and Wall Street de-regulation months ago in his economic position papers, which are available on his website. Obama has been saying all along that he is going to put in strict regulations and clean up Wall Street.

    McCain just started saying that he favors regulation in the past couple of weeks. How is it that McCain is going to put in new regulations, when he plans to appoint Phil Gramm, the man who caused the de-regulation, as Secretary of the Treasury? McCain says he would fire Christopher Cox, the SEC Chairman, to solve the problem. However, the problem is caused by lack of regulations on the legislative level, regulations that were removed before Cox was appointed. The SEC can only enforce regulations that actually exist, so making a scapegoat of Cox solves nothing. I would suggest that McCain is guilty of saying what's politically expedient, that he does not actually intend to regulate the banking industry. McCain knows that most Americans are unaware of the details.

    I am a middle-aged white conservative Republican who loves America. I am voting for Barack Obama.

    http://www.thecarpetbaggerreport.com/archives/15050.html
    http://www.newsweek.com/id/145011/page/1
    http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/editorial/outlook/6007788.html
    http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9A01E0D81038F934A25752C0A9649C8B63
    http://my.barackobama.com/page/community/post/stateupdates/gG5Rzb

    • Posted By: St. Germain @ 09/18/2008 7:05:33 PM

      Nins... You seem like a well educated person. So, come on you have to know that these canidates will promise us the shirts off their backs to get elected. They already know most of their promises will never be fulfilled as they will be voted down. The polititions are deep in the big corps. pockets

  • Posted By: bt4u @ 09/18/2008 7:04:47 PM

    This wasn't a mistake for a year or two. They had THIRTY+ years to right this ship w/electric cars on their drawing tables for just as long. They chose the route of quick profit through gas guzzling SUV's & trucks & resisted all attempts for a soft landing. They chose, let hem fail. If my tax dollar is going to bail them out, then I'd better see concrete monetary divdend checks in my mailbox soon after & we know that's not happening!

  • Posted By: MrCoffeeTV @ 09/18/2008 4:13:45 PM

    I absolutely, positively agree that auto industry NEEDS these loans. Too much has been spent on bailing out speculators, hedge funds, and investment banks. The tax payers will never see that money again. However, an investment in our DOMESTIC manufacturing and engineering is a good investment that will benefit ALL of us. It will help us become more independant on foreign energy and manufactured goods. Our congress would be very stupid to pass up this opportunity. Do we really want to bend over for the Asian battery cartels, like we are already doing with OPEC?

    • Posted By: olderwiser @ 09/18/2008 4:26:34 PM

      I must agree with you about congress being very stupid. Mark Twain was of the opinion that no one is safe while the legislature is in session. As far as any American business needing a loan from the government to survive, though, I must refer you to the thousands of speeches by Republicans in times past who argued that subsidizing indolence and failure was the path to the failure of the whole country. These are the arguments that got them into office. To say now that a lazy, shiftless, and unsuccessful business is entitled to government aid has to be the funniest joke in any crowds of hard working Americans. The quality of Republicans has fallen mightily in recent years and one might say that about their candidates for the office of president and vice president as well. They are literally held together with chewing gum and lipstick.

      • Posted By: MrCoffeeTV @ 09/18/2008 6:58:54 PM

        I'm not so entirely sure if our auto industry saw what was coming. Big SUVs were more profitable, more so than cars to be sure. However, the huge spike in energy prices suddenly changed things. And now, we are in a position where we need to think different. Part of this is in the interest of protecting our national security. GM, in fact, plans to make the new Chevy Volt in Detroit. I would like to see a clause put in some place that requires the creation of more American jobs, especially in the Midwest. Michigan can use all the help it can get. Having read some of Obama's ideas, a lot of them make sense. McCain on the other hand, looks the other way along with Bush in regards to our current economic crisis.

        We need to start designing, and MAKING stuff again. OR, we will end up increasingly dependant on foreign nations. The value of our currancey will once again collapse, and the world will go on without us. I don't want to live in a country that has nothing to offer but its military.

        MrCoffeeTV

  • Posted By: Car buff @ 09/18/2008 6:26:29 PM

    If the government sits still and lets the big 3 fail, it is obvious that no one in the thread below will really care except maybe one or two of you. But, consider how unemployment will skyrocket when cars are no longer built by the big 3. What about all the industries related to the automobile business? Steel, rubber, plastics, leather, aluminum manufacturers. All the business related to maintenance of automobiles from audio to car washes. Will the refineries lower the price of gas when we stop buying it? I think the price of home heating oil may just skyrocket. Perhaps we should take a hard look at what Detroit has done over the years. Do you think the government has anything to do with why cars cost as much as they do? The restrictions and regulations that have been and are being placed on the industry have definitely added to the cost of a car. Emission controls being foremost and then the mpg restrictions on top of that. The safety factors built into cars today are not cheap either. Think about all those belts and air bags. Computers and sensors built into the engine and drive train. Most cars today require little more than routine oil changes for the first 100,000 miles. A far cry from the points, plugs and grease jobs every few thousand miles 50 years ago. Detroit builds fine cars that the Japanese have copied and in some cases improved upon but the gap has closed between the two and the American car is now global too. The next time you see a truck load of GM, Ford or Chrysler cars, remember that the rail cars and trucks that carry them are all part of business. Windshield repair and automobile insurance and the list goes on. Take a close look around you before you try to solve this problem by cutting it off.

    • Posted By: St. Germain @ 09/18/2008 6:44:36 PM

      Sorry car buff...The steel is made in Mexico, and China,and may I add at a big savings compared to USA steel. Yea I do know that as I and 300 others like me lost our jobs at Oregon Steel Mills located in Portland OR. becouse they could buy it cheaper overseas, and from mexico then we could produce it in the USA. The auto co's may put the cars togeather here, however; 90% of the parts are made in Mexico, Canada, and china. So really how can it hurt the USA if they fail... Heck we don't even have a say in how the tax money is spent. So let them help themselves if they succeed great if not at least our atmosphere will get cleaned up a bit (now if that's not a bonus to the world I don't know what could be) I support Americans that support Americans not Americans that support Mexico, China, and Canada.

  • Posted By: royh @ 09/18/2008 6:42:42 PM

    The Big 3 have known for years that these changes had to be made in order to survive but they had so much money in thebank and the fat cats kept cashing their outrageous paychecks because that is really all that mattered to them. All of these so called leaders didn't leadm at all. They have had many many years to plan for the future and they just didn;t do it. I do not pity them. Let them fail like any other ill runned coporation in the U.S. Toyota and Honda have been ahead of them for the last 15-20 years and now they are the leaders in automobile design and manufacturing.

  • Posted By: scobman @ 09/18/2008 6:28:48 PM

    Hey Car buff

    After FORD sells the DETROIT LIONS and attempts to help themselves maybe we might be more willing.

    they are rich bastards wanting a handout when they have assets they can sell if they really need a bailout.

  • Posted By: scobman @ 09/18/2008 6:23:11 PM

    mccain helpped get that "enron loophole" passed into law too.

    now mccain says he is gunna stop the wall street corruption? Just another lie from mccain and the neocons

  • Posted By: scobman @ 09/18/2008 6:21:42 PM

    the gov stole your 4th amendment right to privacy.

    now they want your money to bailout their criminal friends on wall street.

    and the gov is preparing to lock you down under MARTIAL LAW with usa troops policing our streets,

    so HELL NO, no more of our money is to be stolen from us to make their friend richer.

    Why are they not letting all the candidates debate on tv?

    its all criminal and YOU HAVE TO SAY NO THIS TIME or be their connon fodder for the new world order like slaves they want you to be.
    www.infowars.com

  • Posted By: underdog @ 09/18/2008 6:15:02 PM

    Years ago the government bailed out Chrysler under Lee Iococca. After the bailout Chrysler stated doing pretty good. But, all it took was some bad decisions by managment to put them in the sinker again. Poorly designed cars, lack luster performance and appearance., poor milage. Pretty much fit most of the US auto industry. They may have had some cars which sold well but overall they have continued to loose ground to Japan and now Korea. They produced high margin gas guzzlers while Honda targeted mileage. Of course it didn't help that the union benifts added a thousand dollars to every car sold, something the Japanese automakers are not hamstrunged by. The union and the management are going to kill the US auto industry.

  • Posted By: takeitwithyou @ 09/18/2008 6:06:38 PM

    It is appalling to watch, as a taxpayer, payment by our government to large businesses for lack of stewardship. My college economics prof would say let them drown (like us taxpayers when we become poor stewards)-the market will adjust, new companies or mergers or acquisitions will arise and the beat rolls on. There should be an outcry from the taxpayers and the congress. Who has has tricked us? For me, this is the key presidental issue.

  • Posted By: xihe @ 09/18/2008 6:00:37 PM

    Why bail them out. For years they fought tooth and nail again raishing the miles per gallon on cars saying it wasnt feasible but apparently they can do it if someone else foots the bill. What a joke

  • Posted By: jhforce @ 09/18/2008 6:00:19 PM

    My recommendation is for all those CEO's and other high salary and bonus drawing exectives in the auto companies management loan their companies back the monies they have previously received when their companies were making huge profits. After all, if the companies are that improtant to them it shouldn't hurt them at all and I am sure they have more than enough tucked away to fund their own bailout.

  • Posted By: steeler @ 09/18/2008 5:58:56 PM

    Sooner or later the outsourcing of American jobs some day would come back and bite you in the ASS. Also what are all the CEO'S of the big three going to do with the big fat bonuses that wil be no more should the goverment bail them out.

  • Posted By: scobman @ 09/18/2008 5:55:01 PM

    St. Germain

    I agree, take away their tax cuts and bring the jobs back and we can discuss a plan to help them with our tax dollars.

  • Posted By: Life-is-Good @ 09/18/2008 5:54:10 PM

    If every single person in the auto industry took a 25% pay cut and the unions stopped all those ridiculous perks like pay when they are laid off, then I'd think they were serious and support their loans. .Until then they???re just putting off the inevitable.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse