Spiders, Maggots, Politics

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: issm @ 09/19/2008 12:32:55 PM

    Perhaps the picture vs. real life is important. Would "liberals" react differently from "conservatives" when presented with a real spider on a face? But such a study won't be done for good reason.

  • Posted By: summer1216 @ 09/19/2008 12:32:16 PM

    I know that my reactions between a PICTURE of a spider on someone`s face and an actual spider on someone`s face would be different. A picture is a picture no matter what it is a picture of. It`s like the coroners who work on dead bodies: the body is dead, no matter how it looks or what has happened to it. I don`t think this kind of discernment means a corresponding lack of reaction (in the world) to real threats.

  • Posted By: starone @ 09/19/2008 12:26:54 PM

    THough I have to say that redheaded blue girl makes a very good point!

  • Posted By: starone @ 09/19/2008 12:25:48 PM

    In instances of strong emotional response, the level of activity and communication with the pre-frontal cortex is dimished. So, as the emotional response increases, rational thought is threatened. This makes sense in the context from which we originated, in other words, from a purely evolutaionary standpoint.. however, when it comes to leading, I'd rather someone who maintains objectivity rather than falls into some primitive cause-effect analysis..

  • Posted By: starone @ 09/19/2008 12:25:30 PM

    In instances of strong emotional response, the level of activity and communication with the pre-frontal cortex is dimished. So, as the emotional response increases, rational thought is threatened. This makes sense in the context from which we originated, in other words, from a purely evolutaionary standpoint.. however, when it comes to leading, I'd rather someone who maintains objectivity rather than falls into some primitive cause-effect analysis..

  • Posted By: redheaded blue girl @ 09/19/2008 12:22:50 PM

    I was born in 1960. I was in college (at a pretty conservative school) during the "Reagan revolution" and bought everything Uncle Ronnie said and believed. And then I really grew up and realized it was all rubbish. I am a staunch liberal now. And I guarantee if you showed me creepy spiders or maggots at any time in my life whether I was conservative or liberal, I'd react with "YUCK!". I strongly suspect this study is total crap.

  • Posted By: jblackwell88 @ 09/19/2008 7:42:30 AM

    I accept the article's conclusion. I recall a different study that showed liberals and conservatives brains light up differently when presented with threatening imagery as well.

    • Posted By: Bird Brain @ 09/19/2008 12:16:32 PM

      That's exactly what I mean. How can one not give it any further thought? You've seen something similar before, so it must be true. Ok, I'll post my original comment twice, so then you can accept it. ;)

  • Posted By: vstillwell @ 09/19/2008 12:04:35 PM

    So are Republicans scaredy pants? BOO!!!!!!

  • Posted By: grahamsdad @ 09/19/2008 11:59:41 AM

    Does not the reaction of ndrock to the picture of OBAMA'S face reinforce the premise of this article?

  • Posted By: vstillwell @ 09/19/2008 11:58:33 AM

    So before we invaded Iraq, did someone show Bush and Chenney a picture of a spider? It all makes sense now.

  • Posted By: Bird Brain @ 09/19/2008 11:53:07 AM

    I'm disappointed in Newsweek. It's like a conservative set out to prove their hypothesis, and no matter what results were found, they were going to mold into the proof they sought. Such a tiny sample was taken from a very limited demographic! What if conservatives are just wired to blindly react ("ack! spider! kill it quick!") and liberals are wired to think it through before reacting ("is it a dangerous spider? let's find out and then proceed....")?

    Just because someone sweats more, it doesn't make them more evolved or intelligent or passionate or competent. Shame on Newsweek, Tony Dokoupil and John Alford.

  • Posted By: Bird Brain @ 09/19/2008 11:52:31 AM

    I'm disappointed in Newsweek. It's like a conservative set out to prove their hypothesis, and no matter what results were found, they were going to mold into the proof they sought. Such a tiny sample was taken from a very limited demographic! What if conservatives are just wired to blindly react ("ack! spider! kill it quick!") and liberals are wired to think it through before reacting ("is it a dangerous spider? let's find out and then proceed....")?

    Just because someone sweats more, it doesn't make them more evolved or intelligent or passionate or competent. Shame on Newsweek, Tony Dokoupil and John Alford.

  • Posted By: lac1044 @ 09/19/2008 11:47:13 AM

    Exuse me? They were photo's! How is a photo of a spider more threatening than a photo of a bunny? When was the last time you were attacted by an angry photo? Besides, I like spiders. My sister had one for 15 years. Do only liberals have pet spiders or snakes?

  • Posted By: rcfoulk @ 09/19/2008 11:38:05 AM

    While the article suggests that ???liberals??? might be in a problematic state for not differentiating their response between a picture of a spider and a bunny I propose an alternative hypothesis. It would seem equally likely that someone not reacting to a picture of a spider viscerally understood that it was just a picture. In short, they did not have a fear response to a truly non-threatening stimulus.

  • Posted By: wshofner @ 09/19/2008 11:31:25 AM

    It seems as though this is much more closely tied to environment than nature. The old South Pacific song comes to mine,"you have to be carefully taught." There is something to be said for it being a more intelligent response and one tied to less propaganda to not be scared by a picture of a spider on a face. Watching Fox News all the time or listening to Rush Limbaugh, I am convinced, rots the brain.

  • Posted By: kedricsimmons @ 09/19/2008 11:21:38 AM

    Wow, this has got to be the stupidest thing I've ever read from Newsweek. Here's a little piece of information for your writers Newsweek - Conservatives are taught to fear anything that doesn't fit into there paradigm of how thier world should be, hence they take a more drastic and dramatic approach to dealing with unfamiliarities. On the other hand liberals are taught to use there minds (free thinkers) when dealing with unfamiliarities thus there less dramatic and drastic usually. Because most situation don't require such a response. Geez it's not Rocket Science ... as a matter of fact it's simple common sense! ... How about writing something with more thoughtfulness please

  • Posted By: midoftheleft @ 09/19/2008 11:02:32 AM

    Rather than attribute the conservatives response to genetics, don't you think that is more attributable to environment? Conservatives are raised to be afraid of EVERYTHING. Liberals are free thinkers who are more tolerable of things outside their own enivonment, communiuties or cultures.

    • Posted By: rogerhall @ 09/19/2008 11:18:46 AM

      My understanding is that our actions are determined by our chemistry, which is determined by our biological development, which is heavily enfluenced by our environment. But even your daily thoughts are influenced by genes; perhaps not directly, but then "indirect influences" are still "influences".

      Add to that our growing understanding of epigenetics (which is considered the software to DNA's hardware), and it is easier to see how "raised that way" becomes a multi-generational biological bias towards particular "threats".

      (If the "genetic" link these authors previously reported was "epigenetic" then humanity *might* be finding it easier to move from a 200 million to ten billion in just 2000 years than otherwise.)

  • Posted By: tbourlon @ 09/19/2008 10:07:15 AM

    Man, some of the liberal posts really make me SICK!!! You guys really do think you are smarter and superior to us, don't you? What a bunch of smug brats! Of COURSE I know it's a picture, you IDIOT!!! What makes you think I don't know the difference between a picture and the real thing, that wasn't even part of the study. It was measuring INVOLUNTARY REACTION TO A STIMULUS, not whether people can tell the difference between pictures and objects. Typical liberals, they will twist anything to suit their purpose, and ridicule something they don't understand. So tell me, libs, if you woke up at 3am to the sound of shattering glass, would you lay in bed making a reasonable decision, or would you jump up and grab a telephone/baseball bat and approach the noise with caution? And if it turned out to be your cat knocking a glass off a counter, would you feel stupid or relieved? Maybe we're not so different after all. And if you want to take the comparison with a conservative as an insult, GOOD!!!

    • Posted By: newdoc17 @ 09/19/2008 10:50:02 AM

      Actually, I'm a liberal. And if someone broke into my house at 3 am, my Rottweiler would be the first thing they saw, and my gun the last. But I'm a Liberal. How does that fit into your nice little rant?

      • Posted By: tbourlon @ 09/19/2008 11:18:17 AM

        That means you and I think EXACTLY THE SAME, do you think that's insulting?

  • Posted By: kedricsimmons @ 09/19/2008 11:16:34 AM

    This is pretty much the most ignorant reading I've ever read! .... My opinion is that Conservatives are, like your first commenter said, taught to fear the unknown hence they tend to make drastic and more dramatic decisions toward uncomfortable situations. On the other hand Liberals are taught to use thier minds when encountering unusual situations, thus they make more informed decisions. This isn't an attack on either groups just a fact! Actually pretty much common sense ...geez get a life and write a piece that actually makes sense!!!

  • Posted By: white trash @ 09/19/2008 11:06:32 AM

    I totally disagree on this view regarding sensitivity. The gifted intellect is infinitely more sensitive to all stimulli than the average IQ, The gifted are more conscious and more sensitive to the plight of others, animals, all issues, even more sensitive to noise and their environment. The gifted are also most likely to base all issues and cosiderations upon superior logic and reasoning abilities. The hypersensitivity of the gifted also causes them to react to images and emotions with greater pain and emotions.

    I am liberal in almost all issues, except a liberal immigratin policy because I always vote for Earth first -- the greater good for Earth, and human hordes are consuming the body of Earth. I follow the policy of thinking globally but acting locally, an old environmental war cry.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse