COVER STORY: POLITICS

The Palin Problem

Yes, she won the debate by not imploding. But governing requires knowledge, and mindless populism is just that—mindless.

Photos: (from left) J. Scott Applewhite / AP; Khue Bui for Newsweek
 
Sponsored by
 
 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

 

The question, the McCain campaign later acknowledged, was a fair one. In one of her sit-downs with Katie Couric of CBS News, Sarah Palin was asked to discuss a Supreme Court decision with which she disagreed. "Well, let's see," Palin replied, pausing. "There's, of course in the great history of America there have been rulings, that's never going to be absolute consensus by every American. And there are those issues, again, like Roe v. Wade, where I believe are best held on a state level and addressed there. So you know, going through the history of America, there would be others but …" Couric followed up: "Can you think of any?" Palin, still pondering, said: "Well, I could think of … any again, that could be best dealt with on a more local level. Maybe I would take issue with. But, you know, as mayor, and then as governor and even as a vice president, if I'm so privileged to serve, wouldn't be in a position of changing those things but in supporting the law of the land as it reads today." Asked about the exchange afterward, a McCain adviser who didn't want to be named talking about a sensitive matter said the question was fair, but added: "I wonder how many Americans would be able to name decisions they disagree with. The court is very important, but Palin is on the ticket because she connects with everyday Americans."

Palin is on the ticket because she connects with everyday Americans. It is not shocking to learn that politics played a big role in the making of a presidential team (ticket-balancing to attract different constituencies has been with us at least since Andrew Jackson ran with John C. Calhoun, a man he later said he would like to kill). But that honest explanation of the rationale for her candidacy—not her preparedness for office, but her personality and nascent maverickism in Alaska—raises an important question, not only about this election but about democratic leadership. Do we want leaders who are everyday folks, or do we want leaders who understand everyday folks? Therein lies an enormous difference, one that could decide the presidential election and, if McCain and Palin were to win, shape the governance of the nation.

In an interview before her debate with Sen. Joseph R. Biden, Palin offered a revealing answer to radio host Hugh Hewitt. "Governor, your candidacy has ignited extreme hostility, even some hatred on the left and in some parts of the media," Hewitt said. "Are you surprised? And what do you attribute this reaction to?"

On the phone from McCain's retreat in Sedona, Palin replied: "I think they're just not used to someone coming in from the outside saying, 'You know what? It's time that normal Joe Six-Pack American is finally represented in the position of vice presidency.' I think that that's kind of taken some people off guard, and they're out of sorts, and they're ticked off about it, but it's motivation for John McCain and I to work that much harder to make sure that our ticket is victorious, and we put government back on the side of the people of Joe Six-Pack like me, and we start doing those things that are expected of our government, and we get rid of corruption, and we commit to the reform that is not only desired, but is deserved by Americans." This is, presumably, good politics: it makes a strength out of a weakness, always a shrewd tactic.

A key argument for Palin, in essence, is this: Washington and Wall Street are serving their own interests rather than those of the broad whole of the country, and the moment requires a vice president who will, Cincinnatus-like, help a new president come to the rescue. The problem with the argument is that Cincinnatus knew things. Palin sometimes seems an odd combination of Chauncey Gardiner from "Being There" and Marge from "Fargo."

Is this an elitist point of view? Perhaps, though it seems only reasonable and patriotic to hold candidates for high office to high standards. Elitism in this sense is not about educational or class credentials, not about where you went to school or whether you use "summer" as a verb. It is, rather, about the pursuit of excellence no matter where you started out in life. Jackson, Lincoln, Truman, Eisenhower, Johnson, Nixon, Ford, Carter, Reagan and Clinton were born to ordinary families, but they spent their lives doing extraordinary things, demonstrating an interest in, and a curiosity about, the world around them. This is much less evident in Palin's case.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Omaar @ 07/04/2009 10:03:29 PM

    Character: Look at all the Negative Things said about President Obama Before, During and After his Election and he Never Addresses this Negative Media, he Moves Forward, Ever Onward.

    Its Called [Character]

    President Obama and his Familiy Lives have been Threatened on Many Occassions, though the Media Rarely Talks about it.

    Does the President Address it or Run from it, in Fear or Moan about it to the Public [NO]


    Does Pres.Obama Shrug Off the Nation's Problems or his Responsibilities to the Nation, because the Media Attacks him [NO]

    Its called [Character]

    President Obama Meet his Responsibilities opposed to Running Away from them, the Bad Things the Media has to Say, will not Deter him, from his Responsibilities.

    You'll Never See or Hear President Obama going ....

    Boo Hoo Hoo,

    Woe is Me and Woe is Mine, They won't Leave me and Mine [Alone]


    Obama has Character and I'm Very Glad he's this Nation's 44th President

    Palin would Resigning from the White House as Vice President by now.

    I believe Palin is so Obsessed with being President, No Other Position Matters anymore.

    Palin's Resume is Paper Thin and she can not Finish or Complete her 1st Term as Governor.

    Yet she wants to be President, without considering the Resume must be one of Commitment,Consistency & Success...


    Palin's 2 1/2 Years as Governor Lacks all the fore mentioned.

    Oh Yeah...

    Palin Lacks [Character]



    Its Glaring, that Palin is Not Fit to Lead a State of 650,000 People, more over 350 Million People.

    Palin Lacks [Character]

  • Posted By: Omaar @ 07/04/2009 9:56:00 PM

    Character: Look at all the Negative Things said about President Obama Before, During and After his Election and he Never Addresses this Negative Media, he Moves Forward, Ever Onward.

    Its Called [Character]

    Look at how he's President Obama and his Familiy Lives have been Threatened, though the Media Rarely talks about this.

    Does the President Address it or Run from it in Fear or Moan about it to the Public [NO]


    Does Pres.Obama Shrug Off the Nation's Problems or his Responsibilities to the Nation, because the Media Attacks him [NO]

    Its called [Character]

    Meeting his Responsibilities opposed to Running Away, because of the Bad Things the Media has to Say about me...

    Boo Hoo Hoo,

    Woe is Me and Woe is Mine, They won't Leave me and Mine [Alone]


    Obama has Character and I'm Very Glad he's this Nation's 44th President

    Palin would Resigning from the White House as Vice President Huh.

    I believe Palin is so Obsessed with being President, No Other Position Matters anymore.

    Palin's Resume is Paper Thin and she can not Finish or Complete her 1st Term as Governor.

    Yet she wants to be President, without considering the Resume must be one of Commitment,Consistency & Success...


    Palin's 2 1/2 Years as Governor Lacks all the fore mentioned.

    Oh Yeah...

    Palin Lacks [Character]



    Its Glaring, that Palin is Not Fit to Lead a State of 650,000 People, more over 350 Million People.

    Palin Lacks [Character]

  • Posted By: Omaar @ 07/04/2009 9:35:08 PM

    Republican Governors...

    Tim Pawlenty:Announced he will [Not Run] for Re-Election in [2010]but will Serve out his Governorship.

    Responsible & Orderly Indeed, He'll still Lose in [2012]
    ---------------------


    Arnold Swarzenegger: Has every Right to [Quit] his State is Insolvent [Bankrupt] yet he Continues Onward.

    I Respect & Admire Swarzenegger in not taking the [Easy Way Out] via

    [Resigning-Quitting]

    ---------------------------

    Mark Sanford: He of all Governors should [Resign] he's Embarassed his Wife,Children & People in his State, that he Represents.

    Yet for Now, he Clings to his Governorship, though he was Ir-Responsible as Hell Itself.

    He Refuses to Relinquish the Governorship.
    ---------------------

    Sarah Palin: 2 1/2 Year Governorship. No National or International Experience, i.e. Congress Woman or US Senator. No Alaskan Pipeline, though the Media Allowed her to get Away with [Blatantly Lying]at the ..

    2008 RNC Convention, when she Asserted that the Pipeline was being Built, when not One Pipe has been Laid and Gas Companies she Snubbed and Prevented from Bidding in the Contract Process, to make the Pipeline...

    When in Fact, the Gas Leases are Owned by Big Oil-Gas.

    Trans Canada was given [500 Million $$] of the Alaskan State Money an they'd Only Build the Pipeline, Not Supplying the Gas, in any event.

    In any case, the Gas Pipeline's Cost More than [27 Billion $$] !!

    Guess who will be Financing the [28 Billion $$] Pipeline ..Hmm

    [The Dreaded US Government] Tada !!

    Can You People not See how Unstable,Unhinged, Un-Predictable & Sparatic this Woman is ?

    She's No [Maverick]

    John McCain Looks [Normal] Compared to Sarah Palin's Movement.

    The Worst McCain did was Pretend to [Suspend] his Campaign Last Year.

    McCain Never [Quit-Resigned]

    Even during the [Keating 5 Scandal]
    --------------------------

    Sarah Palin is a Hollow,Floating Bubble, Just Air Up There.

    Blames the Media, yet Runs to the Media at Any Given Chance. Matt Lauer, Wolf Blitzer to Sean Hannity.

    Mass Media, is Mass Media.

    Is Not Fox News the most Watched of the Cable News Programs..Hmm

    The Dum Dum is [Done]

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse