MONEY CULTURE | Daniel Gross

Subprime Suspects

The right blames the credit crisis on poor minority homeowners. This is not merely offensive, but entirely wrong.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: ComplainceAuditor @ 10/23/2008 1:35:50 PM

    The sub prime and conventional markets dies nearly 2 years before the collapse. According to Maher Soliman, a housing analyst from Los Angeles, CA ???There was excess capital being sourced and allocated from world investment money managers and Wall Street could not resist???. Pure and simple the capital investment from domestic and off shore money mangers was artificial stimulation for non existent demand for housing. So the market remained strong. Now, come the problem - how do you manipulate a market when the demand for housing subsides and rates make refinancing unattractive? DROP THE FLOOR ON THE QUALIFYING RATE & CREDIT, TREND VALUES BASED ON THE PRIO BULL RUN UPWARDS, LOWER ALL STANDARDS USING EXCEPTIOON TO GUIDELINES LENDEING , PAY PEOPLE TO QUALIFY (USE THEIR SCORE) AND JACK UP THE LOAN ADVANCE AMOUNT (LTV). Minorities, con-men called straws, Donald Trump seminar fools, brokers turned investor flipping properties, and I saw it all. Is it a minority thing when you show someone who earns a minimum wage, under the table, how to submit a Stated Income file showing they make $12,000 a month? How did the lenders of America get caught up in the crimes and why did Wall Street give them a playing field. I can't take even writing about it , I get so upset. www.borrwerhotline.com ???Keep your Home & fight back! The Blog is www.foreclosureinfoshare@blogspot.com

  • Posted By: mb-bythesea @ 10/23/2008 2:51:26 AM

    Excellent reporting. I have worked 10 years in the mortgage industry. I saw lenders pushing adjustable rate mortgages onto people--in order to justify selling them a refi in a few years--who knew values would decline and make them ineligible? Adjustable rate mortgages (ARMs) are not practical for any consumer--esp. when the Fed was upping interest rates 16 consecutive times. ARMs should be recalled or extremely limited. No income documentation loans should be recalled. Having these kind of mortgage products in huge volume on the market is an example of regulatory oversight. And NO it is not POOR People's fault. That is a disgusting lie perpetrated by self-serving oppressors.

  • Posted By: tech4u2hire @ 10/22/2008 10:59:21 PM

    Now, now, lets be fair......
    "Lending money to poor people doesn't make you poor. Lending money poorly to rich people does." Lets revise that to "Poorly lending money to ANY people makes you poor." I have little pity on the majority of people who are getting foreclosed on in this mess. Do you think it is reasonable for someone who works for minimum wage to expect that they can afford a $500,000 dollar home? Lets do some simple math here, $500,000/360 payments = $1389 per payment, and that is without even including interest...... then lets take that $1388 and divide it by, lets say, $9/hour that is 154 hours a month JUST FOR THE COST OF HOUSING, and that assumes a 0% interest rate. I mean seriously do the consumers have any responsibility in this fiasco ABSOLUTELY, regardless of race or any other socio-economic factors, these people have to accept some level of responsibility.

  • Posted By: mooseNY @ 10/08/2008 9:35:19 AM

    To West Coast Messenger. At least your name is appropriate. Claerly a "Leftist" thinker. When is the left going to acknowdlege that the last and only 2 democrats for the past 40 years in the White House are right in the middle of this? Republicans have come and gone many times, but you dont see thier names tied to actual laws related to CRA and Fannie and Freddie. Both significant actions were done be Democrats. Those are facts. THat is why Fannie pumps millions into electing democrats.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 9:10:00 PM

      I do see their names tied to Savings and Loan debacle, Persian Gulf War, Halliburton, Iraq, Carlyle Group, speculative developer business plans, Wall Street and de-regulation. Don't live in denial, sweetheart.

  • Posted By: crx1 @ 10/08/2008 9:37:15 AM

    Let's not forget the Clinton admin. threatening to sic Janet "Waco" Reno and the justice dept onto lenders for racial discrimination if they didn't make these risky loans to minorities who couldn't afford it.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 9:06:33 PM

      Yes because only those lazy, good for nothing Black, I mean minority people bail on their mortgages.Us, good upstanding, hardworking white people are always paying on time. We know what the rules are--heck, we wrote them. Oh, wait., that means we wrote these rules, too....

  • Posted By: paulte @ 10/08/2008 10:41:35 AM

    Clearly poor minorities are to blame for the financial crisis. They were given mortgages they could not afford by banks and financial institutions under pressure by the government. Now the rooster has come home to roost! And that same government now expects the taxpayers to pay for the bailout!

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:58:15 PM

      That's funny. If "poor minorities" could muster up a $700 billion crisis, they would not be "poor minorities". I also think that it's really cute that you believe taxpayers are rich and white. Why else would you separate the two thoughts. I am a taxpayer, a minority, a homeowner and I am not poor. Your stereotyping of the situation has made you a stereotype--KKK.

  • Posted By: NotLivinLarge @ 10/08/2008 11:11:32 AM

    The average "Joe Sixpack" (as Ms. Palin would have herself be characterized) is NOT to blame for this mess we're in. I am an average Joe (Josephine) Sixpack-when I bought my house I could afford it. What I can't afford is the fact that my heating oil obscenely doubled in price this year ($158 to $311/mo), my food prices have skyrocketed along with the gas that I need to drive to a job for which I haven't had a raise in 2 years.....I am not a deadbeat, I make my mortgage payments, I pay my property taxes and my income taxes, but it's harder and harder to get by when my income stays the same and the prices keep going up-I've cut as much as I can (internet, TV, food, clothes) cancelled life insurance (no one to leave anything to so why bother), switched car insurance, dropped coverages-I have analyzed everything down to the last dime and I'm still looking for a 2nd job just so I can bring in more than goes out the door. WE ARE NOT THE PROBLEM.....

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:53:37 PM

      Say it, sister, I'm in the same boat. This is so FUNNY--no where in these comments has anyone talked about the fact that those of us who bought homes we could afford then did not see income increases matching the cost of living for the last ten years. What happened to my annual "cost of living" raise--you know the one I had been receiving one for ten years prior--what's that all about? How did food cost increase by 45% while my salary increased by 5%? How did my employer paid medical insurance increase by 35%? And guess what, I'm lucky-I actually still have a good paying job. On top of everything that you did to cut costs, I also got a roommate. I then saw a movie about the Depression--apparently those folks did the same thing to keep their homes. Does that mean something?

  • Posted By: cflare @ 10/08/2008 11:20:30 AM

    The only reason why you can label this as racism is because the view of the poor in America centers around the minority.

    I wish people would grow up and get over the race card. I watch Fox news and not one time did they blame minority groups. They did, however, blame people that can't afford their mortgage.

    Now, if in your mind that immediately translates into minority groups instead of people up and down the social hierarchy, then the racism is in your own heart.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:38:29 PM

      AMEN!! and HALLELUJAH!!!

  • Posted By: Boulder Sue @ 10/08/2008 11:32:55 AM

    Thank Heaven for this column! I cannot tell you how many otherwise normal people are willing to put all the blame for almost anything that has gone wrong on the poor and minorities. Simple common sense should tel you they simply don't have the leverage to create a world-wide meltdown, or even a national meltdown. As for scolding people for "living beyond theIr means", it's a national disease with plenty of fraudulently presented deals presented to people who should have read the fine print, but maybe couldn't afford the glasses necessary ro do so. Additionally half of all bankruptcies are due to medical costs. I am on disability, and therefore on Medicare. Thank God for that! If it weren't for that we might well be on the street or living with relatives. The insurance premiums alone (we are both 61 YOA) or the medical bills without insurance would not allowed us to pay our mortgage payments. My husband has run his own business profitably since 1979, until the last few years, which have been a desperate struggle to keep going, jus waiting for things to get better, meanwhile trying to think up creative new services the busines can offer (and that people can afford) and marketing them without bankrupting the company on ads, etc. We don' worry about the stock market much, since all we have left ther is the IRAs. The rest has been "loaned" to the business. No, I don't feel the slightes bit responsible for the present economic crisis as we slip from middle-middle income to lower middle income.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:36:13 PM

      Thank you. SOund reasoning and the TRUTH!!

  • Posted By: Ohboy1 @ 10/08/2008 12:27:27 PM

    ryoushi - "they just signed that EIGHT INCH THICK stackof docs and hoped for the best)". It's known as asking the lender what the monthly payment will be on any given amount of money, then sitting down and figuring out if you can afford that monthly mortgage payment along with all of your other bills. It's not rocket science.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:33:23 PM

      And again you are wrong. It's more than that.

  • Posted By: think4yourself @ 10/09/2008 11:57:42 AM

    It is up to the American Citizens to demand from the media to find out if Obama Ever sent a letter about the Bailout he claimed he sent during the second debate. There is evidence according to C-Span that he DID NOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    And for all of you sympathizers of the poor. Why dont you go live in Section 8 housing for one week and see if they deserved to buy a home with NO MONEY DOWN, NO CREDIT HISTORY AND NOT ENOUGH INCOME TO QUALIFY. Now they are going to get yet another check off of the back of middle class who are already paying the taxes that they are not?????? 40% of Americans dont even PAY TAXES AT ALLL! WE NEED THE FAIR TAX!!!



    Finally Good news! YOU CANT STOP THE TRUTH!!!!!

    After much protesting - Hulu.com brought back the Saturday Night Live Congress Bailout skit back. CHECK IT OUT!!!!!!!!!!!!

    http://www.hulu.com/watch/38041/saturday-night-live-washington-approves-the-bailout#s-p1-st-i1

    NOW WITNESS THE REST OF THE STORY B-4 THE MEDIA TAKES IT OFF THE SITE AGAIN!

    • Posted By: THOMASAY637 @ 10/09/2008 4:21:29 PM

      I'd rather save a poor person, working for a living and trying to make ends meet than some a-hole millionaire. The greed at the top in this country is astounding. Don't you know that if you don't help your neighbor keep his house, yours will lose a great deal of value and you may wind up ion the same situation as them. When will the right wing middle class learn that trickle down economics is bullsh-t. Economies need to built from the bottom up. If you and I have money to spend rich people will get it honestly by providing goods and services that we all need and want. What do we get when the rich spend money (if they ever do, most rich folks don't pay for squat)?

      • Posted By: Bernice's Mom @ 10/10/2008 2:36:08 PM

        Spoken like a person who is not a millionaire, I bet everyone on this blog calling people money had some of their own they would think differently. There is nothing wrong with protecting what your work hard for wether it be twenty thousand a year or a million a year. Those that say people who make money dont pay their fair share of taxes are wrong. The more you earn the more of a percetage of income taxes that you pay. Every year that my salary goes up the more taxes that I pay.

        • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:30:08 PM

          Then you need to do what your friends are doing and find those shelters.

  • Posted By: habitforming @ 10/08/2008 11:54:34 AM

    I am going to ask all of you to join me and reject credit completely. If you cannot buy it outright, don't buy it. They keep trying to punish us, telling us how hard it will be to get credit. How hard will it be if we don't want it? After all, they only reason they offer credit is so they can make additional money (interest) on top of the full price you are paying. We have to get back to our roots, expecially us minorities, where we took care of ourselves and rejected their notions of how we are supposed to live. They want to sell their goods and services, they want to sell them for whatever the market can bear. I say, it is time for us to deprive them of money. Who cares about buying a house -- I live in the city and if I did buy a house, nine times out of ten I still wouldn't own the land the house stands on. Screw those rich muckety-mucks. I say we collectively drive them into the poor house by not purchasing anything but the bare necessities. I am hoping us minorities will stop trying to buy favor with people who hate us and make them beg us to be a part. Be honest, their system(s) has(ve) never worked for us. A few individual accomplishments does not make us a part of things anyway. Deprive those wealthy dirtbags, deny them your money. If they continue to try to put people out of work (manufacturers, retailers, etc.) to make money, we need to deprive them even more and make them close their doors. Please people, review your history -- particularly our history of philanthropy by us for us. When they denied us, we went on without them. They looked up, saw we didn't need or want them and suddenly, it was important to reach out to us and make us confirm to their standards. While most of us are by no means wealthy, many of us are willing to help and we can help each other now. We can use our dollars to keep us going outside this stupid system. But even if you don't join me, I'm going on anyway and I will just have to be satisfied with not participating in this corrupt system. It is corrupt, it has always been corrupt, and there are no rules or regulations that will put their system on the side of right. It is their nature, their inherent belief that some people are better than others. Read some of the response to the article, especially the ones decrying racism. Until we minorities take charge of our future, our destiny outside the powers that be and stop participating in this wide-spread criminality perpetuated by our so-called betters, these so-called experts, we will continue to suffer and allow them to lead us straight to hell.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:27:17 PM

      That's beautiful. I'm with you.

    • Posted By: veer5 @ 10/08/2008 12:43:23 PM

      That is a great philosophy to follow....never buy anything you can't afford to pay cash for on the spot. Credit cards should only be used as a convenience and paid off at the end of each month; otherwise you are paying an inflated price for goods and services once the interest is factored in. Obviously the average individual cannot pay cash for a large purchase such as a home, but the monthly outlay on that purchase should not exceed 30% of your income. When I retired I sold my primary residence in 2005 and "downsized". I was encouraged by friends to reinvest my proceeds in other real estate investments that would in turn make me more money....Ha! I ignored the well intended advice, took my profits, and paid off all of my debt. I walked away from one investment prior to closing, forfeiting my deposit, because I could see the handwriting on the wall. Friends thought I had lost it! Today they are saying "why didn't you insist that we do the same!" I'm not bragging, I'm just suggesting that it's better not to take risks unless you are prepared to suffer the consequences....I'm not. I made the CHOICE to live comfortably with less. I'm losing money right now like everyone else, but the difference is I won't lose my home or automobile because it's all paid for.

  • Posted By: A New York fan @ 10/08/2008 11:55:01 AM

    celticdreaming you have hit at a very big part of the problem. The tilt was on home ownership for the lower income families of America and yes the Democrats are to blame for forcing the issue and blocking oversite. See this web site http://www.state.nj.us/dca/hmfa/consu/buyers/ownprg/smart.html not only can you still get a loan without a real ability to afford you can also get a $10,000.00 grant to help you buy it. Tell me realistically if they need a grant to buy a house what are the chances they waill be able to afford it down the road but these loans are still out there.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:24:27 PM

      The same chances other people have when they borrow $10,000 from mommy and daddy for the down payment.

  • Posted By: Ohboy1 @ 10/08/2008 12:01:17 PM

    Additionally, the poor and blacks and other minorities most certainly are to blame for this mess. You had people barely making enough money to keep the electricity on in their efficiency apartment who were told by lenders that they could buy lavish, sprawling homes in the suburbs and elsewhere for a payment of a few hundred dollars a month and they (the poor and blacks and minorities) fell for it. How could anybody be that stupid? They weren't stupid. If you make an offer like that to somebody who has never had anything then they are going to take you up on it. And they did. They knew they would never be able to keep these houses and the plan was that they would stay in them as long as they could and when the payment got to be too high they would walk away. And that is what they did. Just like when they buy cars. They'll buy a Cadillac or a Lincoln or some other expensive car that they obviously cannot afford. They drive them for a few months, make a few payments, then they can't afford the payments anymore so they tear the car up, trash it, and abandon it or the company comes and picks it up in the night. They don't care. They just go get another car the following day under they Aunt name or they Uncle name or they baby name or they brother name or they sister name. Come on people. Don't hand me this line. We all know what is going on and everybody is too afraid to say it except me. So there. I said it and you all know it's the truth.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:22:14 PM

      Wow, let me finish that thought for you--"I hate these n*gg*rs coming in here taking everything like we owe it to them. Why don't they go on back to Africa."

  • Posted By: eagle575 @ 10/08/2008 12:14:17 PM

    one more point: the 1993 legislation required that fannie and freddie, when considering mortgage applications from minority and low income applicants, that welfare payments and food stamps were to be considered income.

    that makes a whole lot of sense doesn't it?

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:15:06 PM

      Yeah, because do you actually know anyone on welfare that owns a house? Hmmm, one of the criteria for being on welfare is that you have no assets. Houses are assets! Not likely that welfare recipients own houses. For more on that try www.hud.gov and stop the inflammatory lies.

  • Posted By: sillyme @ 10/08/2008 12:15:10 PM

    If you have someone making minimum wage buying 3 or 4 bedroom house, how can they afford it when I can't even do it on $22/hour. Something is very wrong here.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:12:55 PM

      That's the point--the truth is, you don't have someone making minimum wage buying a 3-4 bedroom house. The fallacy of these comments is the use of the word "poor". I don't think that people know what "poor" is anymore. "Poor" is minimum wage and we don't qualify for anybody's mortgage!!!

  • Posted By: Ohboy1 @ 10/08/2008 12:15:35 PM

    Let's see. When I bought my house in 2001 I was "pre-approved" for $300,000. But did I buy a house for $300,000? No. I bought a house for $119,000. And why did I do that? Because I knew that a $300,000 mortgage was too much for me to handle comfortably. I did not want to spend nearly everything I made each month on the mortgage payment and not have money left over to buy groceries and pay other bills. So I searched and searched until I found the house that I have now in a nice area and I'm still making my payments. What ... was I the only one out there who wasn't blinded with greed and gimme, gimme, gimme. Was I the only one who was willing to settle for a less grandiose house - something that I could afford and that I could keep for years to come.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:09:32 PM

      Wow, man, that's ANTI-AMERICAN! Didn't you hear Bush say "Shop, shop, shop"? "Buy, buy, buy"? I thought you were a patriot.

    • Posted By: RIPADGETT @ 10/08/2008 12:39:24 PM

      Nope, you're not the only one. My wife and I did that. We planned for the amount of house we bought. We al.so saved to be able to pay significant down payment (1/3 the cost of the house.) We started off with equity and low payments and that is where we are today. BAIL ME OUT! NOT! I don't need and don't want stinkin government assistance. That how this crisis began in the first place. Fire all of them and lets start over.

  • Posted By: ryoushi @ 10/08/2008 12:20:43 PM

    Racism is running thick and true here. It's all the fault of those poor, i mean non-white folks, taking all that money being thrown at them instead of being 'moral enough not to take it. Well, i see a lot of WHITE people in the same boat for doing the same thing, and lets not even talk about the studies showing minorities even with good credit histories and good jobs were routinely steered to subprime loans because mortgagers made MORE money that way. The subprime mortgage fiasco is squarely the fault of the lenders who had all the power and all the knowledge (I'd like one of the covert racists here to explain THEIR mortgage and home purchase, because I bet they can't - they just signed that EIGHT INCH THICK stackof docs and hoped for the best) And, the bigger problem was the massive Ponzi pyramid schemes played by the investment banks in unregulated insurance and finance schemes which, as all Ponzi schemes do, deflated like a leaky balloon once the money flow from the bottom dried up.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:06:15 PM

      AMEN!! Thank you. I think I can sleep now without the fear of a cross burning in front of my home, which clearly, many commenters here believe I don't deserve to have. Minority doesn't always equal poor. White doesn't always equal deserving, financially literate, responsible and moral.

  • Posted By: Tgo01 @ 10/08/2008 12:23:06 PM

    Angry American Mama once again who ever said those paying their bills were to blame? If everyone was paying their bills we'd be in great shape right now. The problem is those who were living above their means (yes this goes for those making 200k a year as well) got in over their heads and stopped paying their bills.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 8:01:46 PM

      93% of American homeowners are paying their bills--ON TIME! Get angry about something REAL!

  • Posted By: ricemanstm @ 10/08/2008 12:27:19 PM

    I find this article somewhat offensive. Nobody is blaming the poor, at least I'm not. I do however blame stupid people for getting themselves into mortgages they couldn't afford. I blame banks for pushing mortgages on people they knew couldn't afford it. I blame Freddie and Fannie for pushing bad loans, from people they knew couldn't afford, onto banks who normally wouldn't have taken or given those loans to those people. I blame Congress, specifically the Democrats, for blocking any attempts to regulate Fannie and Freddie to keep this form happening. I blame Barney Frank, Chris Dodd, and Maxine Waters for telling everyone "everything is fine people, nothing to see here. Move along." However, I do HOLD PEOPLE RESPONSIBLE for their actions. If you make 1500 a month, sorry, you can't afford that 500000 dollar house. Especially if you don't put anything down. Nope, this economy exploded and imploded all in the name of political correctness. This article is partisan at it's best and worst.

    • Posted By: wethepeopleco @ 10/15/2008 7:58:07 PM

      Really? Because do you know someone making $1,500 per year getting that mortgage? Do you?

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse