FACTCHECK.ORG

Same Old Claims in Another Language

Ads targeting Spanish-speaking voters make claims we've heard before.

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

Summary
The presidential campaigns and third-party groups have been bilingual throughout the election, targeting Spanish-speaking voters with some misleading and false ads. Among the recent TV spots:

A McCain-Palin ad tries to paint Obama as a "riesgo" (risk), falsely claiming that his health care plan would require small businesses to cover their employees. But Obama's plan explicitly exempts small businesses from this requirement, and an adviser has said the threshold "would almost certainly be higher than ten" employees for businesses to be excluded.

The ad also says small businesses would be hit with "more taxes," but only those business owners clearing more than $200,000 would see an increase under Obama's plan.

An Obama-Biden/DNC ad offers other misleading statements on taxes, saying McCain would tax workers' health care benefits but failing to mention he'd give a $2,500 tax credit ($5,000 for families) to cover the cost. It also says McCain's tax plan gives "nothing" to "100 million households," ignoring his health care tax credit.

A National Rifle Association ad features a retired police officer who claims Obama "didn't think we should be allowed to use a firearm for self-defense." That refers to a vote in the Illinois Legislature to uphold enforcement of local gun bans. It wouldn't have made it a crime to use guns for self-protection elsewhere.

A new group called Latinos 4 Reform has launched a misleading anti-Obama ad that tries to paint him as no friend to Latinos by falsely claiming he doesn't support trade with countries south of the border, among other charges.

Analysis
Lest our readers start thinking that misleading political ads only come in one language, we present a look at Spanish-language ads – which, not so surprisingly, put forth the same old false and exaggerated claims we've seen in English throughout this long, long, very long campaign. Uttering these words with a melodic Spanish accent doesn't make them any more true, though it does make the ads more fun to watch – especially when we learn that Obama himself can habla español. (He speaks of the "sueño americano" – "American dream" – in an ad released this week.)

Here's our look at what the McCain-Palin and Obama-Biden campaigns, as well as third parties, have served up recently to capture the Latino vote.

McCain-Palin 2008 Ad: "Riesgo" (Risk)
Announcer:
Los expertos predicen que los nuevos impuestos y mandato para un seguro de salud obligatorio de Obama y sus aliados liberales del Congreso eliminarán empleos.

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
Al Gore's Climate-Change Evolution
Al Gore's Climate-Change Evolution

Using emotion to convince people to change.

Heaven Can Wait
Heaven Can Wait

A new book promises proof of eternal life.

The World's Biggest Foods
The World's Biggest Foods

Monster edibles from around America.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: itburnsme @ 11/05/2008 12:33:25 AM

    I wonder if they have voting booths in the prisons along with all the other freedoms of the out side world. It seems everyone is being catored to except the ones who are paying the taxes. Lets all go to prison and get free run without paying or working. Lets pretend we do not speek any english and not pay taxes. Hello wake up america we shouldnt have to select which language we want something in..................

  • Posted By: itburnsme @ 11/05/2008 12:22:41 AM

    I agree with the others if you can not speak our language than you must not be a citizen of the US so what are they doing trying to vote any way. Either become a citizen and pay taxes like the rest of us or go back home and ruin your own country.

  • Posted By: eckolaw @ 11/04/2008 3:17:55 PM

    I have an idea! Instead of catering to people who do not speak the standard language of our nation, all ballots and voting apparatus should only be in english. Learn our langauge and understand our language and then you can vote!

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

My Take

Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage
to feature your favorite columnists.

Customize Now
 

A new ad goes too far when it says Medicare will be "bankrupt" in eight years.