BY THE NUMBERS

The Four Worst Kinds of Soup

Some types of soup contain half a day's recommended calories and sodium in one serving. Here's how to avoid those that are the least healthy.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: bobtich @ 11/29/2008 4:00:09 PM

    limiting calories is a worthy goal. Not eating good food because it is high in calories makes no sense.A bowll of clam chowder for lunch and french onion soup for dinner may be all one eats and how wonderful. The same number of calories in greens or carrots would be sickening. The idea is limit overall calories. If your one meal is a double beef whopper with cheese it willbe very satisfying and have some tomato and lettuce with it.

  • Posted By: Tea6 @ 11/17/2008 5:06:40 PM

    Leave soup alone.
    Its good stuff.

  • Posted By: netty1 @ 11/17/2008 12:33:14 AM

    Heck, I agree with the HillbillyReaper...

  • Posted By: WeGotPapi @ 11/17/2008 12:17:20 AM

    Oh, for God's sakes. Now they're going to start shredding SOUP? Just stop it. Anyone who has half a brain knows that canned ANYTHING or powdered anything can't be great for you! To those of you counting every half calorie and jumping on scales every 14 minutes, unless you have a health issue (such a diabetes), you need to relax. You're number is up when it's up, it is that simple. Enjoy food while you can. Any chef will tell you that. And we all know you probably won't be getting that steak and potatoes in heaven, so why are you depriving yourselfs so much?

  • Posted By: HillbillyReaper @ 11/16/2008 11:01:13 PM

    Just had a bowl. Heck, everything we eat is gonna kill us, might as well enjoy the taste on the way out.

  • Posted By: browniegirl @ 11/16/2008 10:45:48 PM

    While I agree that it's smart to stay away from many of the 'store bought' soups, in these rough economic times we would all be smart to add more soup to our diet. You wont find many meals that cost less per serving than a good bowl of bean soup, home-made bread and an apple for dessert. We choose to eat these simple meals 4 nights a week at a cost of less than $1. per person. If you work let your slow cooker and bread machine do the work and you will still take a bite out of your food budget and have something healthy to eat.

  • Posted By: Dr. Joe @ 11/16/2008 10:10:58 PM

    Yes- so?? I have no problems with MSG, the same as 99.9% of the population.
    It's a lot lower in sodium than salt.

  • Posted By: leecee @ 11/14/2008 3:15:47 AM

    The easiest way to avoid high calorie/sald soups is to read the labels before you buy.

    • Posted By: articmink @ 11/16/2008 10:03:37 PM

      Soup is very easy to make, a few spices and a few bags of frozen veggies and its done. I take one day a week and cook up my broth's with onion and some spices, then freeze them and I can make a batch of soup in half hour. Many excellent recipes at allrecipes.com, but all you really need is your basic stock to whip up a delicious and healthy soup in a half hour.

  • Posted By: zeff @ 11/16/2008 9:48:50 PM

    Yes, Hullo, ac'cent is MSG

  • Posted By: zeff @ 11/16/2008 9:45:56 PM

    ac'cent is MSG....No thanks

  • Posted By: aem_RN_momof4 @ 11/16/2008 9:30:21 PM

    Consider using some other herbs than Ac'cent which contains monosodium glutamate, or MSG. MSG also adds to the sodium content and can cause headaches, at least it does in me.

  • Posted By: Dr. Joe @ 11/16/2008 8:05:32 PM

    If you want to reduce the sodium in your soup and keep the flavor, adding sodium glutamate is the way to go!! 1/3 of the sodium of salt, and great flavor enhancement. You can buy it at the store - Ac'cent.

  • Posted By: chiblues @ 11/16/2008 7:17:43 PM

    Mash half (or more) of vegetable you have simmered in water or broth of your choosing as the thickener. Cauliflower is one example of where this works well, simmering with some onion/peppers or your choice of flavoring. No flour/cornstarch or cream required. Non-fat yogurt with fresh herb to dress at presentation.

  • Posted By: 2022 @ 11/16/2008 8:50:56 AM

    Why in the world would they discuss soups and not mention that you can actually make your own soup, which will be much more flavorful, healthy and economical? Soup is probably one of the best comfort foods I know of. We are having a soup cookoff at work tomorrow and I'm taking my homemade vegetable beef and also potato soup. I know they are both winners. The broth from the veggie beef is absolutely to die for. I started with beef stock that I made myself and then let some sauteed vegetables simmer in it a very long time before I strained it to use in the soup. I then began adding my vegetables (potatoes, onions, celery, carrots, garlic, corn, peas, canellini beans, black beans, Italian green beans, zucchini) as well as my fresh spices (cilantro, parsley, a bit of dill, fresh ground black pepper), and then also added some ground cayenne and a little bit of sea salt. I also added the beef roast I had used when making my stock. After a very low simmer for a few hours, I tossed in some baby spinach, just letting it wilt down. Awesome and chock full of vitamins and minerals.

    My potato soup probably isn't quite so healthy, but is it ever good! A nice creamy soup with potatoes left in chunky pieces, real butter, heavy cream, chicken stock, sauteed onions and celery and just a bit of grated carrot, dill weed and parsley, salt and fresh pepper. I'm going to top the bowls off with some crispy bacon, aged cheddar, and a few chopped scallions. Very satisfying. Sometimes you just need to feel good - you can watch your caloric intake the rest of the day and walk a few extra steps.

    Shame on the person who doesn't take the time to offer their family items from scratch - just a little time and effort and you'll never go back to that tin-tasting glob in a can.

    • Posted By: kmf7619 @ 11/16/2008 6:06:22 PM

      Yummmm, I wrote down your first soup and I'm going to try it. I make a lot of my own soups too, but I kind of get stuck in an ingredient rut. Your recipe has lots of different things in it. Thanks

  • Posted By: N_Cherny @ 11/16/2008 2:53:32 PM

    You CAN have your cream and eat it too. There ARE healthy creamy soups -- they use soy milk as their basis for the creaminess, and they are delicious. Imagine Portobello Mushroom soup is out of this world, low fat (3g), low calorie (80), and comparitively low sodium (390 mg/8 oz. serving). Imagine and Trader Joe's have a whole line of these great soups, all organic.

  • Posted By: MissyE @ 11/16/2008 1:59:31 PM

    I like to take leftover vegs in their broth, cut leftover meat, and add pasta or noodles to make soup. It's easy and uses up what's let in the fridge.

  • Posted By: pumple @ 11/16/2008 1:41:14 PM

    It really doesn't matter what soups you eat. The key to what you eat is; HOW MUCH AND HOW OFTEN YOU EAT. That is to say, an occasional bowl of the tasty soups listed in this article is fine. However, it's not a good idea to feed you or your children these kinds of soup everyday.

  • Posted By: spm8808 @ 11/16/2008 11:54:40 AM

    You definitely can make creamy soups without using cream or dairy. Look for vegan recipes for the soups you want to try, like these at http://www.eatingvegan.com/soupsandstews.html#a. Even though I'm not vegan myself, I've tried lots of different vegan recipes and would never have known that they didn't include any animal products of any sort had I not made them myself.

  • Posted By: ebakerts @ 11/16/2008 9:48:56 AM

    I can make cream of broccoli soup, potato leek soup, sweet potato soup, my own version of new england clam chowder all without any cream or dairy, and I don't use any boullions to add flavor, everything is natural, and stocks made from the real thing. We developed a soup group, where six of us would cook one type of soup, put them into lunch size containers and we can have a different soup for the next six days, saves time and cooking,

    • Posted By: sjl9905 @ 11/16/2008 11:06:24 AM

      I would love to know how you make your creamy soups without the cream or dairy - my husband cannot have cream - would love to make these creamy style soups for him...and me too!!!

  • Posted By: chefjonny1972 @ 11/16/2008 10:13:18 AM

    I have been making all types of cream soups for years with nonfat skim milk. Instead of making a traditional butter and flour roux to thicken try masa flour.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse