As a NYC resident I do not really support taking our local labeling system national for a couple of reasons:
1. Most people for whom the information would be beneficial COMPLETELY ignore the menu breakdowns
2. The people who are paying attention wither were already health conscious and fairly skilled at choosing healthy options and therefore most likely do not REALLY need to have the EXACT numbers staring them down, logical estimates are generally sufficient (and online queries can reveal those mystery offenders when necessary)
3. For some, the numbers can breed obsession with caloric intake and obsession with ANYTHING is an unhealthy thing for anyone
Having struggled mightily with a severe eating disorder since high school I have had to adopt a 'blinders' policy when it comes to menu breakdowns (though I generally just avoid chain restaurants because they are not usually the healthiest anyways...) and I wish they would just go away. The pain of obsession with every morsel that crosses your lips is not a fun experience. The joy of maintaining health through proper exercise and eating is a very one. I am a HUGE proponent of a holistic nutrition education for every, single person that includes an appreciation of moderation and enjoyment in one's approach to food. My opposition to the policy stems, not from a wish to watch Americans continue to ignore how bad their diets are for them but from a want to see more of a solution than another nutrition facts panel that can be so easily ignored. I want to see people LEARN about what makes them feel good in their bodies without obsessing over it. Good nutrition is simple once you get the hang of it, whole foods beat fake foods, everything in moderation, stay active, eat from the earth not the laboratory. Menu labels will not solve our health crisis, nutrition education on the other hand can.









Discuss