SOCIETY

A Recipe For a Family Fight

At Thanksgiving, vegetarians and vegans object to the menu (and the heckling), while other relatives feel family traditions are being scorned.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: spuds @ 12/19/2008 12:29:25 PM

    Factory farming....you find one or two cases of abuse and point your fingers and say there that is how it is everywhere, Its all like that. In as much as we could find a serial rapist who is vegetarian and point and say look what there diet has done. All vegetarians must be rapists. Most animals are farm raised, at least around here. raised in pastures, coops and large pens. You can go there and talk to them and see how there feeling today. Since you feel they can talk or you can tell by looking at them how the "feel"

    Pay into, you mean farm payments from the government? I dont belive in tobbacco, I still have to pay for them through government farm programs. We all do, you cant exempt yourself because of "feelings" I feel strongly against welfare, I feel that those getting it sould have to pass tobbaco and drug test before getting it. Then do randoms while getting it, guess what Rarnold, I still have to pay for it.

    Please dont insult those who have a differant view point other than yours. As I stated before, all animals think about is what am i going to eat and who will i fornicate with today.

  • Posted By: Rarnold773 @ 12/18/2008 12:06:09 PM

    Spuds, an animal doesn't need to talk to exhibit clear signs of extreme stress. Please don't insult vegetarians until you have read about factory farming conditions. Here are a few abuses I can pull from memory, but the list is much much longer than this. Most animals are not given enough space to turn around, lie down, run, graze, spread their wings, or do any of the things that come naturally to them. They often live their lives indoors and in terrible conditions, being poked by needles and being force fed by machines. Pigs feet get deformed from standing on metal bars, and they are in constant pain. A byproduct of smooshing them all together is that they bite each others tails, causing them to bleed and become infected. Pigs, by the way, are at least as intelligent as dogs. Chickens are crammed into tiny cages so that they cannot turn around or open their wings. A large pecentage of chickens die purely from the stress of their torment (in Europe they have ethical laws requiring the cage be large enough to allow them to open their wings). In this day and age, I shouldn't have to mention why veal is unethical; if you don't know why, you've been living in a cave for the last 20 years. Just in case, veal used to be the meat of newborn calves. It turns out that if you allow the calf to age, the meat toughens and is not as good. So, factory farmers figured out that if you starve the calf in a certain way, giving it only a liquid that contains certain nutrients to allow it to survive, the animal can live long enough to grow more meat, and thus be more profitable. The calf gets anemic from malnutrition. It tries to eat the bars of its cage due to vitamin deficiency. The calf is not allowed to move, because using it's muscles would toughen the meat. It is chained to the ground in a tiny pen. It cannot stand, turn around, or lie comfortably. Is it really that unreasonable that people like me and TomOfMaine don't want to pay into this system?

  • Posted By: TomOfMaine @ 12/01/2008 10:59:52 AM

    That's the point bryan2369, animals can not talk to us to express how they feel about things, so instead of us assuming anything, they should be respected and left alone to live out their natural lifespans on their terms in their own environments.

    • Posted By: spuds @ 12/02/2008 1:24:54 AM

      you watch too many cartoons, all animals think about is what Iam i going to eat and who can I fornacate with. Not that much differant than a lot of posters here.

  • Posted By: martialguy @ 11/21/2008 10:32:37 PM

    The last time the same treatment on farm animals afforded to humans, it was called genocide or ethnic cleansing. It has been worse for animals because they can't talk.

    • Posted By: spuds @ 11/23/2008 2:00:19 PM

      Genocide is the deliberate and systematic destruction, in whole or in part, of an ethnic, racial, religious, or national group

      Why on earth would you wipe out your food supply? Makes about as much sence as plowing under a crop of organic lettuce. Farm animals like lettuce are a crop to be eatten period it has noting to do with Genocide.

      • Posted By: TomOfMaine @ 11/26/2008 7:43:33 AM

        Have you asked the "farm" animals how they feel about that ? When their families, and species in general, are being exploited, brutalized and killed against their will by another species (ours), that can definitely be considered genocide. We are not God and we are not Mother nature, everything is not existing just for our pleasure and use. We are just another species. Meat is not a necessity at all unless you live in the arctic.

        • Posted By: spuds @ 11/28/2008 2:05:26 PM

          Now you lthink farm animals can talk? you need help.

      • Posted By: lupe1111 @ 11/23/2008 7:19:59 PM

        you could die tomorrow too in the hands of a sociopathic killer with equally no sight for you at all.
        you might be a little smarter than a farm animal, but you would not be more afraid, and it would not hurt more for you.
        point being it is possible for you too to be a "crop" of sorts for somebody with a "need" to get you, your inner life and body be damned.

  • Posted By: Westergirl @ 11/27/2008 1:52:15 PM

    The thing that bothers me the most about being a vegetarian, is not giving up meat, it is all the meat eaters having their say and talking bad it. I don't care what you put in your body, I don't say a word to you. So please keep your opinions to yourself about how us vegetarians choose to eat. It's none of your business. I think the only reason you meat eaters talk down to vegetarians is they feel bad for eating meat themselves. How sad, you should feel comfortable in your decision to kill animals to eat and not lash out. So if you really are a proud meat eater keep your trap shut.

  • Posted By: bryan2369 @ 11/27/2008 10:54:20 AM

    Yes, let's ask the "farm" animals how they feel about it, because we all know they can talk! What a stupid comment. Eat turkey, not tofu! What about how plants feel? Somebody call a Waaahmbulance! Socialist vegans should be shot.

  • Posted By: Jan in AZ @ 11/24/2008 2:46:08 PM

    Sorry, that last post made little sense because it was supposed to be a reply to Spuds' remarks in another post about why vegetarians introduce themselves by immediately announcing their vegetarianism. Someone gave an in-your-face answer, and Spuds decided that all vegetarians behave that way. "Is that what vegetarians do call names and point fingers. . ." I mean, really. Just because some do, that means we all do?? Several meat-eaters have been very rude to me, but I wouldn't ask "Is that what meat-eaters do?"

    • Posted By: spuds @ 11/26/2008 1:32:58 AM

      I quote; Comment: you could die tomorrow too in the hands of a sociopathic killer with equally no sight for you at all.
      you might be a little smarter than a farm animal, but you would not be more afraid, and it would not hurt more for you.
      point being it is possible for you too to be a "crop" of sorts for somebody with a "need" to get you, your inner life and body be damned.

      This is civil? To respond, no this has happen more than once, that is why i asked the question. What is with the label...meat eater.... have I at any time called you a cud chewer? Granola cruncher? Tree hugger? No I have kept things on the high road, that is the road I take now.

  • Posted By: Nannynano @ 11/25/2008 10:44:16 PM

    I'm serving a vegan celebration roast to my vegan family and a pork tenderloin to the rest. At least the vegans won't have to view arms and legs. I'm just the simple vegetarian, but I welcome the thrill of trying to please everyone. Typical Montana mother!

  • Posted By: compassionateliving @ 11/24/2008 8:30:35 PM

    In my opinion, spending Thanksgiving, or any other similar celebration, with non-vegetarians (or non-vegans in my case) is not the big challenge it sounds. I find that, with advance notice, people are always willing to cook vegetables on their own without adding any animal products, so there is always a lot I can eat. In addition, I bring my own alternative to the turkey (either Tofurkey that I cook before hand or another alternative I make myself - see for example
    www.vegcooking.com for ideas), so my meal ends up looking very similar to the one of everyone else. Often, non-vegetarian
    friends and family members even decide to try my cruelty-free alternative and realize that it tastes actually very good!

    For good reasons to eat cruelty-free alternatives at Thanksgiving and any other time, and many positive and practical ideas to help end animal suffering, I recommand the book 'Building an Ark: 101 Solutions to Animal Suffering' by Ethan Smith with Guy Dauncey, forward by Jane Goodall, PhD, DBE. Check it out at: www.earthfuture.com/ark

  • Posted By: vegan @ 11/24/2008 8:28:14 PM

    Easily solved! Just bring your own delicious vegan dishes and share with all. Thanksgiving can be a golden opportunity to share the vege cause via tempting meat-eaters' tastebuds!

  • Posted By: Cuban Pete @ 11/20/2008 5:05:51 PM

    I think some people who are Vegetarians think too much of themselves. Noboby really cares if you eat the turkey or not...just don't give me the speech about how the birds are raised and slaughtered.

    • Posted By: Panorama @ 11/20/2008 5:14:23 PM

      The turkeys are raised and slaughtered

      • Posted By: JulieFrog @ 11/20/2008 5:27:43 PM

        poor turkeys

        • Posted By: Independent! @ 11/20/2008 5:43:20 PM

          No one is forcing you to eat the turkey. I leave you alone and you leave me alone. Got IT.

          • Posted By: arcsc @ 11/24/2008 2:50:06 PM

            Mmmm pass the gizard gravy. Just thinking about Thanksgiving is making me hungry.

  • Posted By: Pit Chic @ 11/21/2008 12:30:17 AM

    I usually keep my mouth shut while reading these comment boards, but I can't tonight. I was raised near farms and helped butcher chickens at my friend's family farm. Usually I couldn't eat chicken for about two weeks after. But these are domestic animals were put on earth to feed and clothe us. I have a problem with abusing them, but I also have a problem with the way most of the people here that jump on a band wagon about issues they know very little about. My 15 year old daughter is a vegetarian and I would have to say she has been one for most of if not all of her life. She is one not because of the animals, she is one just for the plain simple truth that she doesn't like meat. My future daughter in law is a vegan for the same reason, she just don't like the taste. At our family dinners we each bring something so everyone has something they enjoy. I sware most of you people have no lives other than to sit here and argue about something so stupid. Thanksgiving is for what you are thankful for not what is on your plate. And thank you sexieveggie for stating the obvious, it's a lifesytle not a cause.

    • Posted By: Charisma73 @ 11/21/2008 1:10:24 AM

      If you were raised near a farm then you should know that the meat people eat DO NOT come from family farms. They come from large agribusiness corporations that have put family farmers out of business. These agribusinesses hire undocumented workers that steal OUR identities. Also, they are a breading ground for animal abusers. It is a proven scientific fact that animal abusers move on to more serious crimes involving humans. So, to the people out there that think the animal industry doesn't affect them? Think again, It affects everyone! Please, meat eaters, go out there and educate yourself. If you must eat meat, then make wiser choices about where it comes from. At least the meat you eat won't have the taste of a bitter life!

      • Posted By: arcsc @ 11/24/2008 2:45:14 PM

        My family owns a farm. We usually have between 75 and 100 head of cattle. Every year or so we have one butchered and divide the meat. So yes, the red meat that we serve in my house comes not only from a family farm, but from my farm.

        I am in the midst of planning the Thanksgiving feast. If one of my guests informed me that they were vegetarian (or their significant other were vegetarian) I would make efforts to have a vegetarian main course (though to me, the main course at Thanksgiving is the side items). However, if I invited folks to my home for the major culinary holiday of the year and received no advanced warning, I would be a bit miffed if I worked for two days and someone turned their nose up at every dish because it contained meat/dairy etc. At the end of the day it comes down to being gracious hosts and guests.

    • Posted By: nln548 @ 11/21/2008 12:54:01 AM

      Pit Chic, it is a cause, and there are dozens of non profit organizations created for this cause.

      • Posted By: lupe1111 @ 11/21/2008 8:25:53 PM

        yes, and increasingly law and graduate programs as well.
        i don't think Pit Chic read any of the reasons posted on this succinct board about how it is a cause.

  • Posted By: spuds @ 11/22/2008 1:28:39 AM

    All I asked last night was a simple question I did not attack anyone. It was a simple question, why is it that vegetarians feel the need upon first meeting someone they must tell them they are a vegetarian? Hi so and so meet so and so. Hello nice to meet you I am a vegetarian. You might as well tell me how your bowel movement was yesterday as well. I dont really care, and I really dont need to know either thing. If and when you or I are invited to either ones house for a meal then yes say something then. but for a casual first time meeting? That is too much information please keep it to yourself.

    shigahdeebah , I never attacked you I never called you names, is that what vegetarians do call names and point fingers to make themselfs feel better? I quote (In the future, people will look back in horror & disgust at these dark days where humans actually ate the cut up insides of dead animals & drank their body fluids.
    There are just some things civilized people don't put in their mouths.) Ya that is just how my last meal was, we took a goat and hung it from the rafters and slit its throat and filled or goblets with ist blood. Then we disemboweled it and ate heartally from it. Then we tossed the carcass on the dinning room table and ate the flesh!.................................. come on! I at no time and ever will put anyone down for the eating habits is this how you all make yourself feel better, or is that reserved for talk among yourselfs?

    We are entering the time of Thanksgiving, cant we all just be thankful for the bounty of food we have to share with friends and family without the finger pointing and name calling? I can eat my turkey right next to you as you eat your tofu, I will not shame you or call you names for doing so.

    But can anyone answer my above question in a civil manner?

    • Posted By: Jan in AZ @ 11/24/2008 2:29:11 PM

      You did not ask your question in a civil manner. You asked why vegetarians introduce themselves this way. Not all of us do. Lumping us all together into one obnoxious personality type is rather insulting. SOME vegetarians are pushy, but most of us are not.

    • Posted By: chandresakhar14 @ 11/22/2008 12:33:55 PM

      To be honest, I don't think i've ever experienced this, that is, while engaging in a conversation with someone they tell me they are a vegetarian without it being mentioned prior. But I would assume that the reason someone might tell you this is because to alot of people vegetarianism/veganism isn't just a dietary conviction, but a part of who they are. I guess it is bias for me to say this, but I think that if someone mentioned to me that they are a vegetarian, I would respect them more, and assume that they have some sort of strong moral and or ethical beliefs. Now, someone else obviously might not view vegetarianism the same way, but once again, typically to a vegetarian, it is not just a diet but it is a lifestyle and a cause. I hope helped to answer your question

  • Posted By: Pit Chic @ 11/21/2008 12:56:36 AM

    I usually keep my mouth shut while reading these comment boards, but I can't tonight. I was raised near farms and helped butcher chickens at my friend's family farm. Usually I couldn't eat chicken for about two weeks after. But these are domestic animals were put on earth to feed and clothe us. I have a problem with abusing them, but I also have a problem with the way most of the people here that jump on a band wagon about issues they know very little about. My 15 year old daughter is a vegetarian and I would have to say she has been one for most of if not all of her life. She is onemot because of animals, she is one just for the plain simple truth that she doesn't like meat. My future daughter in law is a vegan for the same reason, she just don't like the taste. I sware most of you people have no lives other than to sit here and argue about something so stupid. Thanksgiving is for what you are thankful for not what is on your plate.

    • Posted By: Lome @ 11/24/2008 1:26:29 PM

      Adam and Eve were vegetarians in the Garden of Eden (Genesis 1:29-30: "29 Then God said, "I give you every seed-bearing plant on the face of the whole earth and every tree that has fruit with seed in it. They will be yours for food. 30 And to all the beasts of the earth and all the birds of the air and all the creatures that move on the ground???everything that has the breath of life in it???I give every green plant for food." And it was so"). It wasn't until after the flood that humans were allowed to eat meat (Genesis 9:2-4: "2 The fear and dread of you will fall upon all the beasts of the earth and all the birds of the air, upon every creature that moves along the ground, and upon all the fish of the sea; they are given into your hands. 3 Everything that lives and moves will be food for you. Just as I gave you the green plants, I now give you everything.
      4 "But you must not eat meat that has its lifeblood still in it. 5 And for your lifeblood I will surely demand an accounting. I will demand an accounting from every animal"). So upon what basis do you say that animals were put on earth to feed and clothe us? If that's just your opinion, fine. But if you're Biblically basing your opinion, killing animals or humans was not God's original intent. I choose not to eat meat because that wasn't God's original plan for humanity as laid out in the Garden of Eden. If it was good enough for Adam and Eve, it's good enough for me.

  • Posted By: hungry vegan @ 11/23/2008 11:53:33 PM

    Also check out this overview of a turkey's life.
    Good to know before you eat!
    http://www.all-creatures.org/anex/turkey.html

  • Posted By: hungry vegan @ 11/23/2008 11:51:37 PM

    Thank you for this coverage. There are many good reasons to be a vegetarian: health, protecting the environment and protecting life. I am happy to see a healthy debate and happy to know that the number of vegetarians has doubled in the last 10 years. May this beautiful trend continue!

    http://www.animalliberationfront.com/Practical/Health/nutshell.pdf
    http://www.animalliberationfront.com/Practical/Health/nutshell.pdf

  • Posted By: acorne @ 11/20/2008 6:44:36 PM

    I have step-daughter who's decided to be a vegan, which eliminates butter, milk, eggs and cheese, on top of the meat. It makes organizing the holidays tough, especially when you add *step-family sensitivity around holidays* into the mix. I admit to initially feeling secretly challenged -- and annoyed , almost offended -- by her choice. I didn't feel she should disrupt our family traditions -- and I still think vegans might work to mitigate any disruption.

    But soon, I settled down, thought it through, and settled on the policy that follows. It's all about striking a balance. Just as one would never serve an invited guest a dish that we *knew* she/he couldn't/wouldn't eat for religious reasons, I make sure we serve a selection of side dishes that we're sure she'll eat. I help this along by serving butter on the side or by substituting olive oil here and there -- small modifications. I ask for general family contributions, so that either she or her (Indonesian) father can help me with the cooking by whipping up something with tempeh or tofu -- enough to share.

    On my side, I don't think I should be expected to throw out my excellent holiday foods because somebody hauls off and becomes a vegatarian -- I think that would be rude to me -- but I don't want to be rude to any guest by starving them at my table, either.

    Vegans can help matters by being a good sport about small amounts of ribbing, and hosting carnivores can back up their guest's right to eat what they want. Light-heartedly defend your guest, when called for. Vegans, however, should refrain from proselytizing, sanctimony, or lectures.

    Who knows what may evolve? On Christmas two years ago, instead of lunchtime chicken soup, or even the previously popular corn and cheese chowder, we tried making *chestnut soup* -- high in protein, red wine ... and brandy -- very festive ... It's become part of our holiday routine, by popular acclaim. Happy-happy!
    *Liz, from NJ

    Vegetarians and vegans can help out by bringing a (protein) dish to share -- just call the host/ess first, to inquire about the menu and discuss complimentary possibilities. To me, this very helpful to hosts, who should remain open to considerate vegetarian overtures, so they can get on with the business of having a nice visit and a happy meal together.

    • Posted By: AgathaSilver @ 11/20/2008 8:28:07 PM

      Good post! I have a vegan son (for the past nine years) and Thanksgiving is no big deal. I roast a turkey and that's almost the only thing on the table he can't eat. The dressing is vegan, the veggies are prepared without butter (but plenty of flavor) and the pumpkin pie which everyone loves is made with tofu! My nephews have discovered they like Tofurky and my stuffed pumpkin has become a family tradition. There is a way to work it all out if we just use our imaginations. . . .and heart.

      • Posted By: colowildcat @ 11/23/2008 11:15:04 AM

        I am a vegan, my daughters and mother are vegetarians, husband, son and father are meat eaters. I host most of the family meals. No one ever complains about the lack of meat or other animal foods offered and they keep coming back to my home for meals. Even on the job, my co-workers respect my vegan lifestyle. I rarely receive rude comments.

    • Posted By: mistygab @ 11/20/2008 7:01:05 PM

      i just don't see why vegetarians should have to be a good sport about the ribbing at the table. It gets very tiresome to endure the childish comments. I can see why the woman in the article wants to go to Austrailia. I usually just refill my wine glass and wait until the uncomfortable converstaion is over. I have been vegetarian for 20 years and dread the lame comments about dead flesh, how I don't know what I am missing, don't I crave a big steak, etc, etc, etc. Remembering what Thanksgiving was originally about should help intolerant meat eaters to let up on the table bullying. Our ancestors had to learn new ways to eat to survive in this new world. Be thankful, tolerant and kind to those at your table.

  • Posted By: colowildcat @ 11/23/2008 11:14:06 AM

    I am vegan, my daughters and mother are vegetarian, husband, son and father and most of my friends are meat eaters. I usually host the parties. So far, I haven't heard any complaints about the non-meat, animal free food I serve. :-)

  • Posted By: hannaht93 @ 11/22/2008 11:51:59 AM

    i'm a vegetarian,
    but not because of animal rights, or because of the environment or anything.
    i'm a vegatarian because of the health benefits- its been proven that vegetarians have less risk of heart disease/ colon cancer/ brain tumors/ stomach cancer/ etc.
    so- thats why I'm a vegetarian. :)

    • Posted By: lupe1111 @ 11/22/2008 2:09:27 PM

      and i don't sell little girls into the sex trade because i might get caught, and i would not be able to handle jail.
      (i know a more compelling reason for not eating animals, but yours is a really good, sound one, too.)

  • Posted By: jim_corbett25 @ 11/22/2008 5:39:20 AM

    I am a vegetarian, but I do draw the line at amino acids and take my share of milk and eggs, call me a food facist or whatever. However, all decisions we take have consequences. Brazil is the worlds largest producer of soya, yes even bigger than China, driven by the vegan demand for soya products, everyday thousands of acres of rainforest land is reclaimed to soya farming. I think vegans should consider, the more abnormal you keep your diets the less you adapt in your natural surroundings, there is always a balance. So pull that stick out of your ass, eat healthy and stop destroying the rainforest.

    • Posted By: lupe1111 @ 11/22/2008 1:54:01 PM

      "pull the stick out of your ass." that's some ugly vulgarity, especially considering that the throwbacks on factory farms take their fun with the animals that way (in PETA'S recent taped investigation, a two-foot stick was shoved down a live turkey's throat, for the thrill of it).
      so in this context speak of the rainforests while maintaining tact and consideration.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse