What Michelle Means to Us

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: blackhippychick @ 11/30/2008 4:01:28 AM

    This is a great opinion piece. However I saw the CNN piece first and I had to use some very serious critical thinking skill as I read the article. I really don't understand how this article got translated on CNN to society views black women as street walkers and drug addicts. I have written about the CNN coverage at :
    http://blackhippychick.wordpress.com/2008/11/28/highlights-of-the-michelle-obama-role-model-ac-360-coverage/

    As a result of seeing how CNN put someones words from news week on TV. I think my comment to you as a black women is you ought to speak for yourself. Some of the words you have written are very old cliches. "black women use skin whitening creams" , a cliche left over from the fifties. The opinions about skin color etc. These are interesting things and provocative things to write but when writing to a public audience we should always ask ourselves if the words we write can be scientifically proven. If CNN continues to portray black women in the manner that they did several days ago. They probably will be looking at a class action law suit. while opinion pieces are nice when they are defamatory the victims of this discourse have a right to seek damages in court. I have been damaged by the CNN coverage of me as a black women. Maybe if people would leave black people alone they could go on with their lives. However this needless sensation of black women is really horrifying.

  • Posted By: Rachel1201 @ 11/29/2008 8:14:41 PM

    There are absolutely no similarities between Michelle Obama and Jackie Kennedy. Michelle O. seems angry and appears to have a chip on her shoulder. Jackie K. was the epitome of style and had an extremely pleasant demeanor about her. Everyone I have spoken to about Mrs Obama agrees with me. She's just an angry woman and she would actually scare me if I had to deal with her.

    • Posted By: 40YearR @ 11/29/2008 9:53:48 PM



      Rachel, Yer hangin' wid da wrong croud der Rachel. You know like a set of bitchy adolescent girls...

      There is more anger in your few lines of sputum than I have ever seen from Michelle, through the entire campaign, as a very skepticle observer.

      Spit yours up onto a plate and eat it.

      A 40 year republican

  • Posted By: NewsWkDickG @ 11/29/2008 11:46:58 AM

    ???Sarah Palin haters???, I think people who use that phrase are missing the point. It really isn???t hatred; it is disgust, disgust with her many faults and her brazenness and surprise and disgust first with John McCain for bringing her out of obscurity and now with those who are trying to make her their next puppet to pick up where GWBush left off. There is where the real fault lies. One individual stated they didn???t think she was a sociopathic personality because she had meaningful relationships but, as McCain discovered, it is apparent she just uses relationships for her advantage. They also felt she deserved credit for having her DS baby instead of aborting yet there is the question, does she deserve credit when she constantly uses the baby as a prop, soliciting sympathy and recognition, and then just handing it off? No, those along with all of her other self-focused characteristics, especially the lack of any conscience, strongly suggest she really fits the sociopathic category and would be a real disaster in any national office (as the sociopathic GWBush has been). Personally, I think she is a sick and sad case and simply wish that she would fade away. George W Bush has proven to be the worse President this country has ever had and we need to remember all of it in order to recognize and reject anyone else who is similar ??? Sarah Palin is a cut from the same mold!

  • Posted By: pbertram @ 11/29/2008 5:52:45 AM

    Thanks for t his article. The Uncrowned Queens Institute for Research and Education on Women, Inc., is publishing a book of letters from ordinary African American women. They are letters of encouragement and support. We were quite struck at the response for letters. Women from around the world. The book will be published by SUNY Press and will be ready on Inauguration Day. Peggy Brooks-Bertram

    • Posted By: Pia1981 @ 11/29/2008 11:11:50 AM

      Thank you for the information. Looking forward to reading.

  • Posted By: A normal fella @ 11/28/2008 10:10:41 PM

    Wow, So many haters out there. Lincoln just rolled over in his grave and became a democrat. PS.....The civil war ended over 140 years ago and smarter minds prevailed.

  • Posted By: obgyn @ 11/27/2008 4:01:47 PM

    Michelle will be ok, as long as she keep a winning, supportive attitude and someone should tell her, do not make Oprah an enemy..
    Oprah was a wonderful supportive person and friend to Barack's campaign
    and it should be appreciated and embraced as if they were sisters not rivals.

  • Posted By: MyTurnNow @ 11/27/2008 9:01:36 AM

    First off, I didn't vote for Barack Obama. Second, I realize and acknowledge that his wife Michelle Obama is an attractive, intelligent, articulate, and poised woman who will be an historic and dynamic first lady. Yet, reading "What Michelle Means to Us" by Allison Samuels my first thought was, "Here we go again" .

    What if Michelle Obama were lighter-skinned, Asian, or even Caucasian (as her husband's mother was)? Would the author and her friends be less smitten by Michelle? Do Obama's accomplishments matter more and justify so much conversation and printspace extolling her praises because she's "brown, real brown"? What if the opposite were true, would she be less of a "girlfriend" or "regular sister"? So, following that logic, then Mrs. Obama's skin tone makes her black enough and better at understanding & relating to other black people. Really?

    This topic has been studied, reported, and debated ad nauseum & ad infinitum. The color of our skin--the hues of lightness or darkness--and the texture of our hair--"good" or "bad"--and the feature of our faces--African or European--are out of anyone's control. That issue's settled at conception and we play the hand we're dealt after birth. Why it keeps coming up in articles like these is because we black folks--or African-Americans if you prefer--keep the stereotypes alive.

  • Posted By: MyTurnNow @ 11/27/2008 9:00:31 AM

    First off, I didn't vote for Barack Obama. Second, I realize and acknowledge that his wife Michelle Obama is an attractive, intelligent, articulate, and poised woman who will be an historic and dynamic first lady. Yet, reading "What Michelle Means to Us" by Allison Samuels my first thought was, "Here we go again" .

    What if Michelle Obama were lighter-skinned, Asian, or even Caucasian (as her husband's mother was)? Would the author and her friends be less smitten by Michelle? Do Obama's accomplishments matter more, and justify so much conversation and printspace extolling her praises because she's "brown, real brown"? What if the opposite were true, would she be less of a "girlfriend" or "regular sister"? So, following that logic, then Mrs. Obama's skin tone makes her black enough and better at understanding & relating to other black people. Really?

    This topic has been studied, reported, and debated ad nauseum & ad infinitum. The color of our skin--the hues of lightness or darkness--and the texture of our hair--"good" or "bad"--and the feature of our faces--African or European--are out of anyone's control. That issue's settled at conception and we play the hand we're dealt after birth. Why it keeps coming up in articles like these is because we black folks--or African-Americans if you prefer--keep the stereotypes alive.

  • Posted By: ccemt461 @ 11/27/2008 5:30:04 AM

    Sarah is a dumbass!! it is well past time that Americans see past the rovian playbook, open their eyes,and really look around!! The 50's or anything that remotely represent that era are long gone and cannot be replaced. Grow up.. the 60's, 70's 80's and 90's are gone they happened too, but they have past. Time to stop being scared of the future and world as they exist today.

  • Posted By: ccemt461 @ 11/27/2008 5:19:51 AM

    I truely hope Mrs. Obama will just be herself. I think that "Black America" may be just a little too taken with itself. A strong woman is a strong woman, I don't really care if she's purple, orange, or any other shade ( except plaid, I hate plaid!!) What a lot of black (is that CORRECT?) people don't grasp is that we as American's (as a whole) don't care what you look like IF you can lead and inspire us. The Obama's have made no excuses, no sad sob story about their past , and nothing of what they think they or their race may be owed. Instead, they were Americans with a vision and a dream that they would let no one take from them. THAT is what makes them special, above all else. The Obamas are Americans, living the American Dream, first and foremost. What black America needs to take away from this whole experience is that if you work, get your education, and make excellence your goal.... you won't be any different then any other American success story in America. But, take heed, you are no more owed here than any other race or culture that thrives here. It is who YOU are as a person, are, not race that gets you ahead and nothing else. The Obamas happen to be black... but, their impact, together is what will leave their mark on history.

  • Posted By: neeka @ 11/27/2008 2:13:19 AM

    This was a nice article. I just found parts of it a little to hopeful.Those parts would be where Michelle will supposedly transform people's ideals of beauty. I am skeptical. Admirable women that look like Janet Reno are not going to be on the cover of Sports Illustrated. People might have wanted to wear Barbara Bush's pearls but not her face. Hillary may be smarter, Michelle may be cooler, but Sarah will always be prettier

  • Posted By: bronzee @ 11/26/2008 11:32:44 PM

    I really believe that the world will be better now that we have calm, cool, educated and calibrated in the white house. Hot heads like a previous commentor have lost their champions and hopefully, in time, will grow up and get on with what it means to be responsible adults who contribute positively to our society instead spewing hate, ignorance and intolerance with anything that even looks different than them.

  • Posted By: jupiter25 @ 11/26/2008 10:44:46 PM

    Excellent article. My cousin who lives in Chicago and goes to the same hair dresser as Michelle. She told me how Michelle came in one day after Barack had been nominated and she was now being accompanied by the secret service. MIchelle waited her turn just as any other client would do. That spoke volumes to me. They are such real people and I truly believe they will stay that way.

  • Posted By: VoiceOne @ 11/26/2008 7:21:35 PM

    .....................................Geeze......Those Nobama finaticos are still here 3 weeks after the election!!!

    • Posted By: Pia1981 @ 11/26/2008 8:13:20 PM

      Ridiculous isn't it?

      • Posted By: HolyRoller @ 11/26/2008 8:25:06 PM

        Ridiculous???....what's crazy is this....YOU voted for an image...an illusion...a hoodwink...a CROOK and a FRAUD. Now you got what you got....

        See what is happening in India??? When is the Messiah gonna wave his hands...raise his voice...and make the world safe and prosperous???

        Looks like his mohammed bros. are mocking him...TO HIS FACE...

        NOBAMA...NEVER!!!

        CHANGE ONLY AN IDIOT WOULD BELIEVE IN....

        • Posted By: Pia1981 @ 11/26/2008 8:31:12 PM

          HR- You need to give up on this because you will lose every time. Please, stop this...it's Thanksgiving. Happy Thanksgiving!

          • Posted By: HolyRoller @ 11/26/2008 8:43:28 PM

            Hey Pia...You are right...it is Thanksgiving. Does the Hussein family recognize it? The don't have Santa for their children...Mohammed obviously doesn't approve....but I digress...

            I'm so Thankful...for so many blessings. Not the least is this...

            I didn't fall for The Un-American Idol. The media creation. The totally clueless man-child...YOU DID(shows a deep-rooted, denial of the truth)....Allah Akbar Comrade...

            NOBAMA!!!...cause he is a FRAUD.....

  • Posted By: HolyRoller @ 11/26/2008 9:31:32 PM

    BREAKING NEWS...ESSENCE Mag. prints interview with Alan Keyes over birth-certificate issue....

    http://www.essence.com/news_entertainment/news/articles/alankeyesobama

    Is he...or...isn't He??? Enquiring Minds want to know....

    Allah Akbar Comrades....

    NOBAMA!!!

  • Posted By: HolyRoller @ 11/26/2008 9:14:39 PM

    BREAKING NEWS.....NBC is reporting "ELIGIBILITY ISSUE and Supreme Court...Don't believe me???

    http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/archive/2008/11/26/1689515.aspx

    We are gonna soon know. WND is in process of getting a MILLION signatures to petition court. Growing by over 1000 per hr and getting faster.....

    Granny Hussein in Kenya says..."I was in the delivery room in Mombassa."

    Hussein is a CROOK and a FRAUD...

    NOBAMA!!!

  • Posted By: HolyRoller @ 11/26/2008 8:51:22 PM

    Hey all ya'll obamamohammeds in the KNOW......

    What up with Typical White Woman Granny??? Did Barry put her on ice??? Maybe had her transported on Elijah Mohammeds ship, straight to Paradise??? Having her stuffed for a lawn ornament??? What up???

    NO service...NO memorial...NO sad, crying Grand-son....

    Guess she was just a stepping-stone...MicHELLe better be careful...

    NOBAMA!!!

  • Posted By: Vypurr @ 11/26/2008 8:43:14 PM

    Obama and his Mother in Law. You gotta love it.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D1CELqykhks

  • Posted By: whatisreal? @ 11/26/2008 4:12:28 PM

    CC and HR and all,

    To be honest I didn't even read this article. I saw the title and was not interested. I did think it would bring the freaks back out, and I wanted to watch a freak show. And of course, Constipated CONadien and Holey Roller came out and started quoting reliable sources and blessing us with thier prophecies.

    For some reason they think that we forgot their prophetic prowess from the pre-election times, which were pretty much around that last corner. And here they come, just back from reading "prophecy for Dummies" and armed with so much knowledge and insight.

    The funny thing is I and so many of us remember their prophecies very well, because we were here as witnesses to their greatness, and they were just spot on; McCain did trounce Obama correct?

    CC and HR, we did not forget you and when you were gone we had some chuckles, especially at 8:00 pm pacific time on election day...

    • Posted By: Pia1981 @ 11/26/2008 5:22:51 PM

      You got. it Excellent!

      • Posted By: whatisreal? @ 11/26/2008 5:32:05 PM

        Hi sweetheart!

        • Posted By: Pia1981 @ 11/26/2008 5:39:40 PM

          Me? Hello, whatisreal?! How are you? Ready for tomorrow? Got the cranberries cooked?

          • Posted By: whatisreal? @ 11/26/2008 6:01:07 PM

            I am going to be on my own tomorrow. Kids are leaving and I just want to get some low key rest. Might order out, some chinese or something. How about you??

            • Posted By: Pia1981 @ 11/26/2008 8:11:19 PM

              Alone on Thanksgiving is not good. Chinese is not for Thanksgiving! I'm going to my parents.

      • Posted By: Pia1981 @ 11/26/2008 5:33:17 PM

        Correction- You got it. Excellent.

  • Posted By: HolyRoller @ 11/26/2008 6:42:33 PM

    ALERT!!! ALERT!!! ALERT!!! ALERT!!! ALL OBAMAMOHAMMEDS CALLED TO STATION!!!

    It appears that Prez. elect-B. Hussein Obama JR., may have a problem on his hands. He desperately needs his minions to shut down The World Net Daily...www.wnd.com (the #1 read Internet daily in existence). That hounddawg Jerome Corsi, is involved. They MUST BE STOPPED...or...THE MOST BENEVOLENT...HIS EXCELLENCE...DIVINELY ANNOINTED (false) ONE, has trouble brewing.....

    Check out the sight...www.wnd.com...It speaks for itself.....


    BTW...has any of ya'll seen Prez elect Hussein's Birth Certificate layin around anywhere???? Judge Clarence Thomas need a copy...REALLY BAD!!!! Somthin about a Constitutional Crisis....Come on ya'll....help a brother out!!! PROVE ya'lls Salvation was born in the USA. Seems lots of folks have some serious DOUBT....www.wnd.com...check it out...www.wnd.com

    NOBAMA...NEVER!!!

    p.s. www.wnd.com....

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse