JUDGMENT CALLS

'Wealth Effect' in Reverse

The downside of too much belt-tightening

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: ZappoDaClown @ 11/26/2008 3:37:47 AM

    okay..and let's point the finger and the true fear mongers...our lovely media...our lovely Newsweek, CNN and all the others calling out 'gloom, doom'! Yes, we've over spent. Yes our entire country is now a debt based country, up for sale, by the way...but who got us here? Government? Yes, with the help of public opinion--very much 'guided' by the media. Go into debt, you'll be happy. Buy this stuff, you'll be happy. Oh no, we're in trouble, oh no, panic panic panic..the election was won by the media, our our downfall has it's ugly, green, greedy finger pointed in the said same direction. I wonder who will buy us...Japan looks like it's in pretty good shape. Maybe we could all ban together and buy the country back? Nawww...who'd want to do that.

    • Posted By: er123 @ 11/26/2008 11:41:38 AM

      ???Maybe we could all ban together and buy the country back? Nawww...who'd want to do that.???

      They said be careful of what you wish for, for you may get it. Check www. yespeoplepower.com and someone is starting it.

      Remember what Pres. Kennedy said, ???Ask not what your country can do for you, but ask what you can do for your country.??? But everybody is waiting for bailouts and dole outs. No workouts.

      Only the people of a nation can save their country if they ???ban together.??? For examples, in USA:

      AFL-CIO, a labor union confederation, has 10.5 million members. I pay $500 + every year in union dues as a member. That is about $5.25 billion in union dues every year. And the unions just spend it every year. Because they are non- profit, they cannot engage in business. If they convert their unions into business corporations, they can build business empires and create jobs for themselves, with $5.25 billion capital every year.

      Directv has more than 16 million subscribers. If each pay $50 a month, in 1 year, that is about $9.6 billion. If these 16 million subscribers band themselves as stockholders, they can fund business empires and create jobs with $9.6 billion capitalization every year.

      Last year, there were more than 16 million college students nationwide. If they band together and save $10 each month from their allowance and pool the money together, they could raise $1.92 billion capital for a business empire and create jobs.

      Now, who would do these? Us, we the American people. Come on, people.

    • Posted By: er123 @ 11/26/2008 11:38:57 AM

      ???Maybe we could all ban together and buy the country back? Nawww...who'd want to do that.???

      They said be careful of what you wish for, for you may get it. Check www. yespeoplepower.com and someone is starting it.

      Remember what Pres. Kennedy said, ???Ask not what your country can do for you, but ask what you can do for your country.??? But everybody is waiting for bailouts and dole outs. No workouts.

      Only the people of a nation can save their country if they ???ban together.??? For examples, in USA:

      AFL-CIO, a labor union confederation, has 10.5 million members. I pay $500 + every year in union dues as a member. That is about $5.25 billion in union dues every year. And the unions just spend it every year. Because they are non- profit, they cannot engage in business. If they convert their unions into business corporations, they can build business empires and create jobs for themselves, with $5.25 billion capital every year.

      Directv has more than 16 million subscribers. If each pay $50 a month, in 1 year, that is about $9.6 billion. If these 16 million subscribers band themselves as stockholders, they can fund business empires and create jobs with $9.6 billion capitalization every year.

      Last year, there were more than 16 million college students nationwide. If they band together and save $10 each month from their allowance and pool the money together, they could raise $1.92 billion capital for a business empire and create jobs.

      Now, who would do these? Us, we the American people. Come on, people.

  • Posted By: willem1234 @ 11/25/2008 4:31:26 PM

    Welcome to the great depression of 2008.........

    • Posted By: YashBudini @ 11/25/2008 4:47:42 PM

      Name one positive thing that has come out of a W presidency?

      OK, now compare this record to his record when he ws running 2 oil companies. Note the similarities. Now for the scariest thought of all, God allowed him to breed, and now his kids will breed.

      • Posted By: Johndeere @ 11/25/2008 5:27:17 PM

        I don't know if I can think of a lot of positive things, but I sure can think of an ignorant thing -- YOU!!

        • Posted By: YashBudini @ 11/26/2008 9:18:58 AM

          All you need do is look at history. You do know how to to read books and newspapers, don't you? But then if you had any facts you would not need to attack me. Duh.

  • Posted By: RO in Reno @ 11/26/2008 9:12:25 AM

    The Great Depression had a profound effect on America's spending habits and the current crisis will as well.
    Obama will create jobs and we may see some increase in the spending, but it will fall short of keeping the huge number of retail establishments open and as they close or downsize as many have it will only add to the unemployment rolls and the ripple effect to the manufacturers who in turn will downsize or close their doors.
    The term "supply side economics" used by the Bush administration actually would work but the fact is the supplier is the manufacturer not the retailer, and as we all know the manufacturer is China and India. True to form the ripple effect has reached those manufacturers.
    The American consumer who has been under wage pressure since Nixon has had a false economy to rely on, principally the equity in their homes to sustain their life style and buying habits. That equity is gone and with it the economy.
    Bush and Paulson seem not to realize this fact and keep pumping money into the banks in hope are at least the stated desire, banks will loan money and the next economic reports will look more favorable,
    When you have an administration whose vision for America is limited to the next economic report and who think cheap junk is the future of America, I suppose we should not be at all surprised the money has essentially run out, and things will get worse before they get better.

  • Posted By: pete the simplifier @ 11/26/2008 12:03:32 AM

    already entered, hope you got it! pete welch. it's regarding the gov selling fixed annuities with an inflation kicker in $50000 increments. it wou ld help the deficit, and help retired who have lost faith in traditional
    annuity sellers.why trust prudential when you can deal with uncle sam!!!!

  • Posted By: marley07 @ 11/25/2008 10:35:27 PM

    Klebrun..
    With the new administration, just take that story and change a few words around:
    The latest rumor is that a local government is willing to buy America back for who knows how many trillions of dollars and nationalized healthcare system. The plan to securitize the deal, insure it with treasury bills, pay out millions in bonuses to new government programs where people will have no choice but to work there and they won't have to apply for a bailout because they will just get it from the government who took it from someone else is to successful.

    Geihner, (Paulson's buddy who has made almost every decision with Geihtner) is said to have been named treasury secretary and is on board to continue to interupt free markets by puting an artificial floor under our economy.

  • Posted By: marley07 @ 11/25/2008 10:35:15 PM

    Klebrun..
    With the new administration, just take that story and change a few words around:
    The latest rumor is that a local government is willing to buy America back for who knows how many trillions of dollars and nationalized healthcare system. The plan to securitize the deal, insure it with treasury bills, pay out millions in bonuses to new government programs where people will have no choice but to work there and they won't have to apply for a bailout because they will just get it from the government who took it from someone else is to successful.

    Geihner, (Paulson's buddy who has made almost every decision with Geihtner) is said to have been named treasury secretary and is on board to continue to interupt free markets by puting an artificial floor under our economy.

  • Posted By: Loree4444 @ 11/25/2008 6:48:44 PM

    Look at the Dow chart from 1935 to present. You'll see when Reagan began his "consumerism" campaign to supposedly "solve" the ills of that recession. We are at the end of that 28-year bubble. Reagan asked us to spend, and spend we did...including what we did not have. After 9/11/2001...W asks us to spend. The rich pocketed their $, and the only trickle down economics was the $ into the bank accounts of the ultrarich.

    • Posted By: marley07 @ 11/25/2008 10:21:09 PM

      Where do you get your information from? That is big theory with very little substance to prove your statement. I know many examples of people starting with absolutley nothing and now created succes to live a life they dreamed of, including myself, through the years you just talked about. There has never been more new found wealth than in the last decade or 2. Not just the rich becoming richer. Opportunity is available to anyone with movitivation and work ethic. Free markets allow this and as soon as you interuppt the process they don't function correctly. Failure for companies and idividuals is a part of free markets/capitalism and it is healthy. Sure we could you use some correction in regulation but you can't swing to the extreme and over regulate. To blindly say look at a chart and that only the rich became richer is simply ignorant.

  • Posted By: klebrun @ 11/25/2008 9:23:43 PM

    The latest rumor is that a local Indian tribe is willing to buy Manhattan back for $24 and a hand full of beads. They plan to securitize the deal, insure it with worthless credit default swaps, pay out hundred million dollar bonuses to the chieftans and then apply for a bailout to fund the bonuses.

    Paulson is said to be on board for the bailout but wants to expedite to avoid a crisis.

  • Posted By: Kat12 @ 11/25/2008 3:28:23 PM

    Thank you for this article. I keep saying this and wondering why the media is not picking up on this more. The media needs to stop scaring Americans and start telling us what we can do to make things better (start spending!). Many of us are still in a comfortable position right now, but we all have work together to make a difference!

    • Posted By: 1c0n0clast @ 11/25/2008 8:24:07 PM

      I'm not spending anything until I see W and Dick blow over half their wealth on cars, suvs, eating out, fancy clothes, and other worthless things. I want to see our "leaders" care with more than words, politcs and paper.

  • Posted By: Jaray24 @ 11/25/2008 5:40:16 PM

    Useless article. The average American has $18,000 in consumer debt. How will spending help them? Pay off the debt, save money for hard times in the future, then go out and spend. The economy will have to adjust to everyone learning how to save, and manage their fincances. All spending does is put money from your pocket to someone else's.

    • Posted By: Generic Person @ 11/25/2008 7:51:34 PM

      Really? Oh man, you have totally proved basic macroeconomics, the business cycle, and the depression wrong. IT WAS ALL A LIE!

  • Posted By: klebrun @ 11/25/2008 7:44:24 PM

    We borrowed and spent at an economically unjustifiable level which created millions of new jobs. The continued borrowing to fund the bailout will only cushion the fall. We are unlikely to return to recent employment levels anytime soon.

    It is unfortunate that the ship of state did not have a skipper at the helm as it navigated into troubled waters.

  • Posted By: expatincebu @ 11/25/2008 7:38:34 PM

    "Every major episode of this crisis???from Bear Stearns's failure to General Motors' possible bankruptcy???has come as a surprise. " - Only to Walls St shills like you Samuelsom! Check out
    http://www.financialsense.com/
    http://www.dailyreckoning.com/
    Read and learn from guys who PREDICTED the bust, Bear Stearns, AIG, Fanny and Freddy, Citi, and GM.

    Or listen to con men like Samuelsom. His "cure" is to borrow and spend! More debt and more consumerism. Well wake up, those are the two things responsible for the current crises leading us to the Greater Depression. Not only that, he wants thrifty Asians to destroy their economies by doing the same! And why not, it serves to enrich Samuelsom and his masters, the wealthy financiers.

    The real cure is simple. Stop spending what you do not have. Form lynch mobs for all the bankers and CEO's and politicians that created this mess to steal from working people. I include Samuelsom on that list.

  • Posted By: Johndeere @ 11/25/2008 7:34:25 PM

    As if the collapse of the "Big Bubble" isn't bad enough, now both the current and incoming administrations are proposing to spend upwards of $1.5 TRILLION (yes Trillion! -- again, that's Trillion [$1,500,000,000,000]) in bailouts and additional stimulus efforts. Are they crazy? That will just prolong and intensify the agony the middle class is about to suffer. WHY? Will somebody please tell me? WHY?

  • Posted By: Johndeere @ 11/25/2008 7:33:54 PM

    As if the collapse of the "Big Bubble" isn't bad enough, now both the current and incoming administrations are proposing to spend upwards of $1.5 TRILLION (yes Trillion! -- again, that's Trillion [$1,500,000,000,000]) in bailouts and additional stimulus efforts. Are they crazy? That will just prolong and intensify the agony the middle class is about to suffer. WHY? Will somebody please tell me? WHY?

  • Posted By: REALITY CHECK @ 11/25/2008 7:11:56 PM

    Don't expect a fast recovery. People have lost $Trillions in "perceived" income thru the stock market and house equity declines, so they'll be in a savings mood for some time to come. Even a huge stimulus package will probably go primarily into savings to make up for these "perceived" losses. It should be interesting to see how this plays out.

  • Posted By: feb1931 @ 11/25/2008 7:10:57 PM

    Ameican poilitics is but a house of cards, and sofisticated shell game.Time it seems to me has run out for all concerned. Obama and his troops may put a bandade on our problems, but is NEVER going to cure the universal GREED than now runs ALL AMERICANS crazy. The results down the road will prove beyond anyones doubt, that this country has lost its way. The funeral is not yet, but the hearse awaits, with its motor running. Weep, cry, bash your head against the wall, but get your marrying and burying suit ready.

  • Posted By: bitterblogger @ 11/25/2008 6:20:55 PM

    For years, an occasional news story would report on the abysmal savings habits of Americans in comparison to the rest of the developed world, often opining that an increase in the rate could forestall household budget collapse in the wake of a layoff or unexpected large expense. Naturally, this had little effect on behavior, what with the bombardment of advertising and the practically explicit admonishment that spending was the patriotic duty of real Americans. One is reminded of the classic quotation by a Wisconsin senator who, upon learning that cheese consumption had flattened in his state without a concomitant reduction in production and an increase in inventory, said "the problem is not too much cheese produced, but too little cheese consumed."

    Now, at the very time that the chickens have come home to roost, it is urged that we spend anyway--with the housing market still falling, jobs being lost, etc. Seems Samuelson would suffer if readers had to stop their Newsweek subscriptions.

  • Posted By: YashBudini @ 11/25/2008 4:56:57 PM

    Still waiting to put some of these bozos in jail. Oh, maybe we should wait because W will pardon them before he leaves office.

  • Posted By: BostonTeaParty13 @ 11/25/2008 4:16:01 PM

    Where is Obama? I am lost without Big Government. What will we all do until Janurary 20? I don't know what to do, I am so helpless without Obama and the Democratic Congress.

    Some of you are really scary. Look both parties got us into this mess and some of you think the Obama is going to save the day.

    Wake up before it is too late. If you think you are belt tightening now, just you wait and see.

    And now back to the Obama lovefest. The Media has been in the Liberals back pocket for years.

    • Posted By: YashBudini @ 11/25/2008 4:51:48 PM

      "The Media has been in the Liberals back pocket for years."

      Really? Why not examine Ruppert Murdoch, this biggest republican propaganda machine that was ever let loose through massive FCC regulation. Your one sided remarks are the standard neocon remarks whenever the facts don't suit you. Next you'll tell us W was a conservative, and Ann Coulter is the poster child of objectivity.

  • Posted By: Johndeere @ 11/25/2008 4:31:55 PM

    Excess spending is what got us into this mess. The avg. consumer has spent way more than they should have for the last 10-15 years, and we are starting to see the results now. People have taken money out of their houses by taking 2nd mortgages, and then they've spent all of it on crap like big SUV's and totally worthless stuff -- totally blown it all. Now look at what it has brought us. We need to recognize that an economy built on consumer spending and constant real estate growth is just a pipe dream. It is not reality. We will end up paying the price for excess spending either now or later. Later will be worse than now, but it looks like that's the way we are heading.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse