The Mayhem in Mumbai

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Rebelryt2 @ 11/28/2008 1:02:28 PM

    Mr. Zakaria, as always seems to subtly justify the involvement of muslims in any terrorist activity, by using terms such as UNTOLD STORIES, etc. I am from India and has known the country far better than Mr. Zakaria, and have seen the madness upclose. The ruling congress is soft on terrorism, and ofcourse there are always elements in Muslim community, even if its just 1%, which will account to millions of fundamentalists that are bent on destroying anything else thats not MUSLIM in nature. They are bent on destroying Jews, Christians, Hindus, Sikhs...and here we are, closing our eyes to the fact that the root of terrorism is the same country that plays terror games with the money the Americans send!

  • Posted By: dudale @ 11/28/2008 11:56:40 AM

    Why there is no word "Jew[ish]" in the whole piece? Doesn't Mr Zakaria see the direct link between the Daniel Pearl murder and this targeting of Habad House? No parallels with the antisemitic militant Islam in both cases, by chance? Maybe for Newsweek, that woul be too strong a case to solve...

    • Posted By: emmarcee @ 11/28/2008 12:58:05 PM

      You are very right. Still these people pretend not see the elephant in the room.

  • Posted By: socprof @ 11/28/2008 12:45:21 PM

    This interview was a waste of time.

  • Posted By: mbronner @ 11/28/2008 12:12:35 PM

    Since when do you need to make sense of a senseless act? What a completely stupid headline.

    • Posted By: divinely speaking @ 11/28/2008 12:40:19 PM

      mbronner, why didn't I think about it? How stupid the headline can be?

  • Posted By: mbronner @ 11/28/2008 12:19:34 PM

    Newsweek, like the New York Times, like the BBC are now determined to present the world with the worst excuses for journalism. Newsweek doesn't even see fit to have the author's name associated with this horribly written article. With Kristol and Sorkin at the NYT's making up their own world of "facts", the BBC's relentless attacks on israel, and Newsweek's continued decline into tabloid hell, they have become irrelevant, and this hopefully will save the world a few trees.

  • Posted By: dudale @ 11/28/2008 11:56:58 AM

    Why there is no word "Jew[ish]" in the whole piece? Doesn't Mr Zakaria see the direct link between the Daniel Pearl murder and this targeting of Habad House? No parallels with the antisemitic militant Islam in both cases, by chance? Maybe for Newsweek, that woul be too strong a case to solve...

  • Posted By: divinely speaking @ 11/28/2008 12:48:16 AM

    Within last few weeks Osama had released a statement that something more spectacular than 911 is will occur. May be it was the Mumbai mayhem. If it is, then we are still paying the penalty of the legacy of Reagan's and Charlie Wilson's myopia. The CIA wanted the mujaheedin and the soviets to slowly bleed each other to death. Instead, because of Charlie Wilson's flamboyance and pushy ways, we provided the military and financial support to the mujaheedin that trained them in terror techniques, which now they are
    using against us and India as re-incarnated group Al Qaida. Did you read Charlie Wilson's War? That cowboy with the blessings of Reagan started this mess. The CIA new the extent to which the muslims, mullahs, mujaheedin and pakis hated America as much as they hated the Soviets. Therefore, the pros in CIA had long term plant to let the Soviets and Mujaheedin along with Pakis fight until they bled each other to death. Enter Charlie Wilson. He circumvented the CIA's plan, got carried away after being seduced by a Texas christian blonde socialite hurraaye jannat and pampered by Zia, got funding, and financed the recruitment of the muslims from around the world who now form al qaida. Procured arms from Israel, Eqypt and USA. They were to be channeled through ISI only, who re labeled them and made them look like they are a gift from allah. For transportation, the mules were used. To alleviate the shortage of mules, USA provided with Tennessee mules. When the mujaheedin discovered the mules were American, they literaly sodomized them to express and to vent their hatred towards America. And USA continued to help them. Many of those mujaheedins were send to fight in Kashmir. Now ISI is trying to destabilize India and reduce it to the level where they have held Pakistan for last 50 years.

    • Posted By: reinadelaz @ 11/28/2008 11:50:15 AM

      To even attempt to imply that the Mumbai incident in any way rrumps the atrocities committed in the US on September 11, 2001, shows a level of ignorance not often seen in a person capable of operating a keyboard. Thousands of people from around the world died in the WTC. Can you even count?

  • Posted By: satsangi.arun@gmail.com @ 11/28/2008 11:40:13 AM

    Apparently the perception expressed here in by various experts could be absolutely correct, because without methodical planning and thorough training this kind of methodical execution of the mercenary plan could not have been carried out.

    Certainly behind this is highly experienced and trained Brains are there who could take care of the minutest details therefore, they could keep the world at tenterhooks for over 36 hours.

    The most important factor, which has always been ignored in most such incidents, is WHY and unless we try and find out the root cause we may never be able to root out terrorism from the society. The Gap between the HAVE' s and HAVE NOT' s has been widening at the alarming rate with huge margin not only in India but every where in the World.

    Everything is ELITIST in India at least be it Politics & politicians, Bureaucracy & Bureaucrats, Industry & Industrialists, Traders & Businessmen and MNC's/Corporates Top managements & Managers leaving no scope for the common people and people at large. In absence of nothing better to do the youth or for that matter any one who is desperately trying to meet the ends in day to day life can be brainwashed, swayed and or lured for a few Dollars towards the so called lucrative life on the dangerous path and the result is increasing terrorism around the globe.

    Particularly in INDIA if you have the Elitist Label you have a license to do anything and get Scot free therefore keeping in view of this Elitist Trade Mark the misguided and deprived people turned terrorist could have come to the conclusion that targeting common people is meaningless and have now targeted the Elitist places frequented by the so called Elite of the Elite of the so called high Society people in India resulting in a severe jolt to the society and the Politicians of the country.

  • Posted By: keibocklee @ 11/27/2008 5:01:06 PM

    You F'ing NRI's are a plague to India. I'm an American living/working full-time in India for 6 years and married to an Indian National. Ask any Indian citizen and they will tell you that NRI's are the worst people to deal with in India. Arrogant, ignorant, biased, classist, racist, sexist, etc. etc.

    Back up your words; use the money you stole from good Indian citizens and move back to India full-time and effect change in this country instead of raping it on your regular holiday???s here. You are responsible to make a difference in India to make all this nonsense disappear. Either shut up and go away or try and make a real difference to your homeland.

    • Posted By: daplane @ 11/28/2008 11:32:30 AM

      Right....let us know when you return the job you're plundering from an Indian, leave your Indian national wife and carry your stupid k*unt back to the States. Talk then, efftard...!

  • Posted By: OneJest @ 11/28/2008 9:06:49 AM

    I am very happy that someone could explain at least a little bit about what is happening in Mumbai and the background. I find the mainstream media is good at shooting video and saying the same thing over and over again, but not at giving us the backstory. Thanks Mr. Zakaria.

  • Posted By: nimodahooligan @ 11/28/2008 7:43:17 AM

    thats very scary, i was just stayin in the taj not long ago...i know the owner and some of the workers there well...very very sad to see such crimes against humanity..

  • Posted By: leena_khanna @ 11/28/2008 6:12:59 AM

    Not sure about who has done it but seriously it should not affect the muslims residing in INDIA.
    The people from outside india just want to create a threat between local civilians so that they start feeling insecure from the ppl living next door.we should surely fight against terror but not by blaming innocence which the terrorist wants us to do!!!!!!!!!

  • Posted By: rightinsanfrancisco @ 11/28/2008 2:12:21 AM

    The government of Pakistan requires global support. If there is to be security in Afghanistan and India, it is essential that the Pakistani government be able to exercise a modicum of control over its western provinces, its security forces, and those internally who would attack its cities and those of its neighbors. Hopefully, people will not respond with efforts to weaken the Pakistani government. Its not as if they aren't trying, sometimes at the cost of their own lives.

  • Posted By: mominaj @ 11/28/2008 1:43:06 AM

    It was highly expectant of Indians to play the blame game. In the time of crisis, one needs to show responsibility in every step and action. Blaming it all on Pakistan is like the only logic India has, maybe, even influenza is Pakistan's fault. Seriously, grow up! Just because international chains and investments and self-proclaimed future superpower (Read ???White Tiger???) cannot give you the right to bad mouth other countries. All those who believe that Pakistan is responsible should know that my country has lost & losing much more lives in suicidal blasts and the bull *** war on terror then India.
    Yet, it is standing and finding its ground rather than playing the blame game like ???Neighboring Country???. It is not Hindus, Muslims or Christians dying in Pakistan, it is PAKISTANI that is dying in here and we realize that fact before anything else. I have Muslim relatives in India who have to paint their walls on every August of 14-15 with Indian flags to avoid the graffiti that says "Go Back to Pakistan".
    So, our "Neighboring Country" should come out of their fantasy land "Bollywood" and realize the independence movements going in their own country.
    For historical reference: http://adaniel.tripod.com/separate.htm

  • Posted By: Tenzin Gyatso @ 11/27/2008 9:42:27 PM

    India should review its policy againgst Muslim.

    • Posted By: divinely speaking @ 11/28/2008 12:39:26 AM

      India does not have a policy "against" muslims. What is there to review? It is individual groups who may have issues, but not India as a nation. So, what you say makes no sense.

  • Posted By: Arunvenky @ 11/27/2008 11:33:40 PM

    The Western Analysts always say that the root cause of all the militancy is because the muslims of India have been left behind in the economic succcess story. Indian system has its own faults but it is more a class issue. And a lot of these militants turn out to be college professors and computer engineers who had a modern education and a upper middle class life. Muslims in India have a vote, has even the right to practise their very archaic muslim law for civil matters. I am not sure if any other country in the world offers these choices to their so called minorities. If anyone said that African Americans had a reason to carry out such attacks against the civil society in the US since they are after all very marginalized and are often persecuted and were disenfranchised for a long long time, most Americans would foam in their mouths. Muslims in India or elsewhere always have a reason, real or imaginary to attack people who are infidels. After all the central tenat of their religion is that if you are not a faithful muslim then you deserve to die. Instead of being apologists and trying to find a rational reason for such irrational behavior, the whole world would be better served if every country which faces this issue, co-operate with each other and take care of these bastards.

    • Posted By: ferozkhan @ 11/28/2008 12:05:43 AM

      Arunvenky, you and your big mouth. Do you know anything about any religion. You know shitheads like love drawing conclusions. What do you want to take care? Giving a religious name behind any stupid selfish motive does not make it a religious movement.

  • Posted By: ferozkhan @ 11/27/2008 11:52:35 PM

    The recent killing in Mumbai is the extreme brutality to mankind. Why? Obviously no answer. What they have to gain from such killing? Again no answer.
    Every time something happens anywhere around the globe ok, point your finger towards the Muslims. Does anyone know the meaning of being a Muslim. Having a Muslim name does not make any person or organization Muslim. Quran says, ???If you kill a single innocent as if you have killed all mankind???. Now can someone tell me where do you find Muslim among the terrorists. Muslim is not a trade name. Like Mr. Zakaria said, I do agree with him. It is a beast unleashed. Who created the beast that is a question? Mujahedeen, made by Americans to fight Soviets now paying the price. Tamil Tigers made by Indians paid and still paying the price. So stop pointing your fingers.

  • Posted By: ferozkhan @ 11/27/2008 11:50:59 PM

    The recent killing in Mumbai is the extreme brutality to mankind. Why? Obviously no answer. What they have to gain from such killing? Again no answer.
    Every time something happens anywhere around the globe ok, point your finger towards the Muslims. Does anyone know the meaning of being a Muslim. Having a Muslim name does not make any person or organization Muslim. Quran says, ???If you kill a single innocent as if you have killed all mankind???. Now can someone tell me where do you find Muslim among the terrorists. Muslim is not a trade name. Like Mr. Zakaria said, I do agree with him. It is a beast unleashed. Who created the beast that is a question? Mujahedeen, made by Americans to fight Soviets now paying the price. Tamil Tigers made by Indians paid and still paying the price. So stop pointing your fingers.

  • Posted By: HOMIRUSTOM @ 11/27/2008 8:00:58 AM

    Islam means peace bull sh*t .All muslims are not terrorists but all terrorists are muslims.

    • Posted By: ferozkhan @ 11/27/2008 11:32:05 PM

      Stop pointing fingers. That is all you guys can do. You had had other incidence where you were involved. Come on guys if you can kill Mahatma Gandhi, Indira Gandhi you guys can do anything.

  • Posted By: Alexeduardo @ 11/27/2008 12:02:17 PM

    Manishyt, why do you insist on blaming the boogeyman?
    Sure, pakistan is feisty, But that doesn't mean Ahmadijenagadad (or something) is Dr. No. Seriously, ISI is responsible for Al Qaeda? let me remind you of how much the USA used to defend and even fund anti-commie "Freedom Fighters" during the nineties and eighties. Those young, idealistic rebels grew to what we now know as "The Taliban". So if you're so self-centered you believe that a sole entity is responsible for Al Qaeda, that entity is The U.S. of A.

    And, robert, What The Hell?
    No one would steal if everyone had bread! sure, fareed's a muslim, but that doesn't mean he's wrong! Goddmamit! what's wrong with you people? get your noggin out of your buttocks and look at the world for what it is! You're not chuck norris in The Delta Force, you're a supergiant in the brink of disaster. You need to get smart and get EVERYONE on your side if you don't want to dissappear.

    • Posted By: manishyt @ 11/27/2008 10:18:01 PM

      Alexeduardo - just one thing: Ahmedinajad is Iranian not Pakistani. Thats the next country over. Honestly. You can check it on a map.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse