THE MONEY CULTURE

Desperate Housewares

Saks is taking a cue from automakers and offering zero percent financing. Even Tony Bergdorf Goodman is cold-calling shoppers.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: ThePrairiePrankster @ 12/11/2008 2:09:06 PM

    Lots of finger point, no solutions.

  • Posted By: cflare @ 12/08/2008 12:48:38 PM

    This is not a recession. This is the burst of an economy bubble. This bubble was created by people slowing gaining 10k debt a year because they outspent their means.

    Now the middle and lower classes learned from seeing the banks collapse that they can't live outside their means.

    People are spending 2/3 and as low as 1/2 of what they used to spend because they are spending within their means.

    When a nation that's more service and retail oriented is hit by lower spending this is what happens. If we had not outsourced all our manufacturing jobs then the recession wouldn't be as bad.

    Now, Congress wants to borrow our way out of a 'borrowing' problem. Like that makes sense.

    We need to bring back our outsourced jobs. All the jobs you're watching kick the bucket was jobs created because businessnesses were living outside their means as well. They created a bunch of jobs they didn't need. Look at GM. They kicked the bucket because their laborers were earning 4 times the national average, because of a union. People fired from there won't find another job because they are now overqualified (by being overpaid). So if anyone thinks a union is a good thing....

    This is simply a credit market bust. People are refusing to borrow to spend, and banks won't let them borrow to spend.... that's why spending went down.

    In short..... THIS IS A GOOD THING in the long run. Once people start living within their means and the markets stabilize (after a lot of damage to the middle class), then we can all work on created wealth instead of borrowing it. America HAS TO CHANGE. You cannot borrow wealth and pretend you own it. THIS BUBBLE HAS TO BURST.

    • Posted By: kold @ 12/11/2008 4:50:57 AM

      yes, a very good comment, only if more people make as much sense as you do, but, unluckily, the world seems to hit its wall of stupitdity head on each time.

    • Posted By: sebs112 @ 12/08/2008 1:38:12 PM

      Yes, you are correct. The deregulation did take place during the Clinton Administration...when the Republicans were in control of the Congress.

  • Posted By: McLovinB @ 12/08/2008 3:46:29 AM

    "Well, the top 20 percent of households account for about 40 percent of discretionary spending, and the top 40 percent account for 74 percent of all discretionary spending, according to BCG. As go the rich and wannabe rich, so goes the nation."

    So goes the nation.
    Bye bye.
    I guess New Yorkers will feel Schadenfreude from seeing the peers and pals of Leona Helmsley get their comeuppance, and I guess the holiday shopping season is leading many to recall THAT SCENE in Pretty Woman... you know the one I am talking about.

    But this situation is much more messed up than that. It skates over the larger general problem of American style ultra capitalism. The article does show that less affluent people do not have so much discretionary spending. Well, yeah.. no duh. What the article does not say is that these people buying things from these stores are not spending cash that they earned from work. They are borrowing against the deposits of hardworking people to finance a wasteful lifestyle based on a Ponzi scheme. A society that relies on credit for basic business and personal needs is a society of people living a lie. It is a national illness.

    It has always amazed me that people can whine about taxes for schools and health care, and then go out and buy a thousand dollar jacket. I would feel shame at doing such a thing. Doing it on credit would not make it easier for me to consume something so petty. Ugh. Even in the best of times, Fifth Avenue is like watching an eating contest being staged in Ethiopia.

    What the article does not say is that the retailers are paying their employees and suppliers peanuts. Possibly, the employees work on commission and the suppliers are supplying the credit to these stores to hock their widgets to the "well-to-do". So the stores are losing very little. Although it seems like the stores are getting what they deserve, the truth is that Leona Helmsley's little people are getting hurt the most.
    Those salespeople politely asking you to look at the discounted items? Just imagine that they are begging you for money to pay the rent and heat their apartments for the winter. If they have no savings, and they don't, then that is really what they are doing, you know.
    But hey. Happy Holidays everyone.

    • Posted By: Brian33 @ 12/08/2008 12:43:13 PM

      I can tell you, you are right on what you said about the retailer sales people. I know many of them personally. My friend who works at sears is around 32 years old. He still lives at home, and makes 6.00 dollars a hour plus commission and no benefits. 6.00 dollars a hour? I have seen food and energy go up about 80 percent since year 2000. After Bush, and his economic policies, the only people I can say who have faired very well, is the wealthy and rich. The people in the middle class were hood winkied at thinking they were achieving the American dream, but didn't realize that they were achieving their lifestyles on credit and bogus wealth created out of thin air by the Wall Street crowd many of whom are the corporate Bush cronies. We were told that Tax cuts are good for the economy and trickle down. Well people, how is that working out for you?

      Then the people who defend these tax policies say we did have a economic expansion that took place between 2001-2007. What they don't tell you are the real facts. The fact that most of this so called expansion they speak of was not true productivity and wealth creation by traditional means. But instead was wealth creation by huge govemernmet spending (massive debt) and when that wasn't enough, and no more legitament debt could be created, Bush and Paulson had to run to the Federal Reserve to get them to print up more money for them last estimate over 6.8 Trillion so far. Oh wait, they weren't printing up the money , they were giving them loans. And guess what the FED used as collateral for these loans?
      The very assets that were deemed worthless with no estimated value which originally caused the Banks to fail in the first place. And guess who allowed these banks to sell mortgage debt and other debt as a supposed ivestment bond of some sort? Federal agencies, Bush, and the Federal Reserve Chairman which at the time was Alan Greenspan. Guess who was one of the biggest supporters of Bush's tax cuts? Alan Greenspan. There, I connected the dots for you, these are the people responsible for this ess, have a good day.

      • Posted By: cflare @ 12/08/2008 1:05:40 PM

        Yes, the Wall Street crowd corporate Bush cronies that donated 100s of thousands of dollars to Obama's campaign.

        Yes, the Bush policies that tried to regulate Fannie and Freddie, because he and McCain saw this coming 7 years ago (compared to the almighty 'savior's' foresight of 2 convient years, at which time he started campaining and stopped voting 'present')

        This has NOTHING to do with Tax cuts to the wealthy. This has everything to do with the politically correct shoving bad loans down the poor's throat dangling a 'carrot' of American dream saying not to worry, "The middle class taxes will pay for it later."

        Yeah, look who's paying for it now. Everyone.

        So go ahead and try to rewrite history. Obama did when he took the stage and claimed Bush tried to deregulate. But I sorely remember those two longshots taken by Bush and McCain to stop deregulation of Fannie and Freddie. Only if the politicians (who were porked with FanFred campaign money) didn't try so hard to hide the truth.

        And you're wrong about who allowed banks to sell mortgage debt. Fannie and Freddie bought up marginal loans and resold them in packages labeled as AAA credit statuses to banks and the global market. So you LIED there.

        Also, you're wrong about the deficit. The deficit has increased by an equivalent percentage over all the presidential history with few outlying points. One of those outlying points was the Clinton era. Guess when all these laws were passed that deregulated Fannie and Freddie, Clinton era. Guess how the Clinton economy did well, Tech Boom. Guess when the Tech bust occured, end of Clinton era. Guess what pork made the Clinton era look good but just busted right now, deregulation of Fannie and Freddie.

        Guess who wants huge government spending to give tax cuts to the middle class and create 2 million jobs. Obama. Guess what kind of jobs he'll create, service and transportation. Guess what kind of jobs kept America from having a recession buffer, service. Guess what kind of jobs would create a buffer, industry and manufacturing.

        So yeah, I have a few things against Bush: Outsourcing, Illegal Immigration, Economic Stimulus ($600 bonus). But he did not create this recession. Deregulation from Clinton Era created the recession.

  • Posted By: chaup @ 12/08/2008 9:57:40 AM

    I don't believe the economy is as bad as everyone says. I live in S. Calif. The resturants (average ones) are as crowded as ever. You cannot get into any upscale ones without a reservation. Supermarkets and malls are alos crowded. You haver to stand in long lines to pay. Airlines (international/domestic) are fully booked. The downturn in economy is simply not true.

    • Posted By: 1winner1 @ 12/08/2008 11:53:11 AM

      "The downturn in the economy is simply not true"?, you've got to be freaking kidding. If you can make a statement like that, give me some of your money.

  • Posted By: 1winner1 @ 12/08/2008 11:48:20 AM

    Happy to see these high end stores taking it in the backside. Haute Couture is the same as saying I've got you by the you know what's, but only as long as you want to play the game. Shoppers, no matter their income level are now calling the shots.

  • Posted By: LucyElinor @ 12/08/2008 11:46:45 AM

    I don't know where you are, but here in Ohio, the stores are still as crowded and the mall lots are still full.

  • Posted By: csweb1 @ 12/08/2008 11:36:16 AM

    What is the largest group of people in this country? The poor and lower middle classes. Walmart caters to them and does well.

  • Posted By: csweb1 @ 12/08/2008 11:33:43 AM

    What is the largest group of people in this country? The poor. Walmart caters to them and thus it does well.

  • Posted By: Lady Marion @ 12/08/2008 11:20:36 AM

    You can not tell their is a recession by NYC, the hub bub is still there. Long Isand hasn't seen much from a loss of shopping. Although the island is suffering from foreclosures. The housing market has all but had it. As write this new houses are still being built. Seems ironic. Since so many mini mansions have not been sold since 2005.

    In the 60's, 70's and 80's many businesses left the city and the island to go to Jersey and the midwest as the cost of property and rising taxes..

    The economy is not fueled by industry in NYC or LI. But sooner than later we will take the hit as people loose their jobs loose their jobs around here.

    Unless you working in public schools, or local governents or filthy rich you are in a safe haven.

    Believe it or not Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New York State just increased my bill by $1,000.00 a year!!!
    Please this is ludicrous.

    So shop as you want, it may be your last "HOLIDAY" on Long Island!

    • Posted By: Lady Marion @ 12/08/2008 11:25:43 AM

      I apologize for the typos ....

  • Posted By: thermalboy2 @ 12/08/2008 11:12:03 AM

    Sometimes, less is better! George Bush will still get His GOLDEN parachute!

  • Posted By: sebs112 @ 12/08/2008 11:11:00 AM

    Well Chaup, that's SoCal for you...come into the real world and see how the other half is living. Then you can decifer if the "economy is as bad as everyone says".

    I live in the Metro NY, NJ area and you can drive into a mall on a Saturday afternoon and find a parking spot right in front of Nordstrom without breaking a sweat. Best Buy was empty--EMPTY!--on Sunday around 4PM with about half a dozen cars in the lot. 3 weeks before christmas and no one is shopping. I'd say the economy is as bad as they say it is. The buying public isn't lossening their purse strings for crappy Christmas (Holiday) presents this year.

  • Posted By: jag24659 @ 12/08/2008 11:03:17 AM

    I haven't seen big sales in the area I'm in, which is a fairly wealthy area. Politically we fall into the middle class, but it sure doesn't feel like it. The price of groceries has risen to such heights that we aren't buying steaks, roasts, or pork chops even. With 2 teens and one pre-teen, things have gotten expensive. Being a registered nurse comes with the perks of overtime, but even that is limited and the taxes take nearly 50% of what I earn on it.
    When the gas prices go back up (thanks OPEC, you greedy jerks!) we'll be back to hand to mouth. The utility bills are killing us also, despite cutting the heat way back. I certainly don't FEEL middle class!! Five and a half years ago we were still OK. Spent a lot at Christmas, and year round. Things were good. This year I feel like the poorest middle class person I know.
    C'mon Obama... just get into that big White House and give us something to hang onto...

  • Posted By: gozo @ 12/08/2008 10:50:26 AM

    Champ......Southern California is fueld by the entertainment industry...an industry that has not felt the depression like others. You need to see past your immediate community to understand what is happeing to 70% of people in this country affected by bush's banckruptcy.

  • Posted By: ecinaj55 @ 12/08/2008 9:44:57 AM

    The "recession" seems to be a here and there event--we live in an area that was depressed before, and will be after, this period of economic uncertainty is over. However, many of the people I have noticed still shopping like crazy are the ones who can least afford it. As for us, if we don't need it, we don't buy it--and if we do need it, we plan for it.

  • Posted By: NiceGuyMike @ 12/08/2008 9:44:02 AM

    I can't speak for anyone else, but I know I don't have the extra to spend this year. My company, while doing better than almost any other company in its field, isn't doing bonuses, the price of food has gone up astronomically, and we're pretty much not buying unless we have to. I've increased my savings so they take up almost everything taxes don't. So far, my Christmas spending limit per person is down 2/3. And, yeah, I expect that to hold true for everyone on my list. And I'm even trying to find reasons not to buy for people on my list, or wait until after Christmas to give or send something. It's true that people having a hard time can be found in any economy, but I have yet to see a crowd anywhere. There weren't even that many people shopping for Thanksgiving dinner in the week before, that I saw. The people who think the recession is "media-imposed" have their heads in the sand such that they can't even hear King George admit that we're in one.

  • Posted By: newday50 @ 12/08/2008 9:28:17 AM

    And so this is Christmas............ Take a look at the papers, at the internet, and television; What is Christmas? Seems we've gotten lost at the mall, Christmas does not happen at the mall, Christmas is not economics, maybe take another look, I can't find Christmas either, maybe when we look a little harder for Christmas we will find it, and it won't be in a store, and may not even be gloomy......... Merry Christmas

  • Posted By: pupsdad78 @ 12/08/2008 8:31:24 AM

    I have heard enough doom and gloom also, when I don't see any of it, except on the news, I am sure some people are having money problems, but you can find them in any economy.

  • Posted By: rga1863 @ 12/08/2008 7:34:13 AM

    Enough with the doom and gloom! I think this "recession" is media-imposed. We're not seeing anything different in Houston Texas. Restaurants are still packed. Malls are packed and yes, everyone is carrying tons of packages just like last year. Get out there and spend money (money you have)!!!!

  • Posted By: earth3650yahoo @ 12/08/2008 6:24:22 AM

    Hey, check out the jewelry counter at most mainstream department stores. When the holidays arrive in poor economic times, nothing says "I am needy" quite like buying diamonds.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse