I was also very disappointed the first time I saw the movie. I did, however, go back for a second go around and this time I found myself enjoying the movie. There are, of course, things that they could have done much better, but over all the second time around was a much better experience. I agree - the tension- between Edward and Bella is not at all really depicted in the movie and the viewers are left trying to figure it out. If you had not read the book many of those moments are lost. Case in point- the scene where Edward first encounters Bella's scent in the chemistry lab..... the book goes into great detail of Edwards feelings and his reactions to that single second of time- you get the full impact of what that moment means to him, the many thoughts going thru his mind.....how he moved as far away from her as possible and how he clenched the table-clenched it so hard that he had sawdust in his hand........ Only showing him covering his mouth....and a funny look on his face- the viewer was lost at what that moment actually meant for Edward. There were many such moments in the book that are lost to the viewer who only saw the movie- the humor of the book is also lost to the viewer. I feel that the director missed a great chance to show more depth to the characters and missed it by a long shot. I hope that "New Moon" will be a much better show.









Discuss