Ending the 'Sick Care' System

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: C. MacLean @ 12/26/2008 2:59:22 PM

    As a nurse who worked for a manged care insurance company for five years, and hospitals for over 20, let me make a few suggestions.

    1) Right now the emphasis on reimbursement is stacked in favor of surgeons and diagnostic tests, and stacked against primary care providers, pediatricians, and ob/gyn's - and mental health providers frequently aren't reimbursed at all. Take all the diagnostic codes in the CPT book (the diagnostic bible) and cut the surgical and diagnotic test code reimbursement rates by 10%. Increase the Evaluation and Management codes for primary and preventative care by 10%.

    Let's put our money were our mouth is: if preventative care is preferrable to end-result care, let's pay for it that way.

    2) Start reimbursing for nurse visits in the doctor's offices that include things like pre-natal teaching, asthma management classes, diabetes management, cardiac management, etc. Include nutrition and diabetic teaching by registered nurses. We badly under-utilize the valuable insights and training that nurses have to offer - they are the ONLY group of health care professionals that are trained to look at the whole patient from the first day of nursing school , and the ONLY group of health care professionals that have patient teaching as a significant part of their training. MD training is not set up to provide holistic care, although primary/family care schools are doing a better job of training in this area than they used to, and medical schools seldom if ever include patient/family teaching in their curriculums.

    Again - if you want true preventative care, start reimbursing for it.

    3) Eliminate the Homebound Rule as the criteria for who gets a nursing visit at home after discharge from the hospital. Base the criteria on whether or not a home nurse visit will prevent a hospitalization, not whether the patient can't get to the doctor's office. This is an outdated rule, based strictly on keeping the reimbursement in the doctor's office, and has absolutely nothing to do with what is best for the patient. We need to change the emphasis on WHERE we provide care - into the cost effective settings of homes, schools and places of work, and out of the expensive settings such as doctor's offices, clinics and especially, the hospital emergency rooms.

    4) Every frail elderly patient needs a baseline evaluation by a podiatrist. Patient falls are one of the most expensive and preventable problems in health care for this population, and untreated feet/ill-fitted shoes are frequent culprits, yet so inexpensive to fix. Don't over-estimate the impact a good podiatrist can have for this group, ditto the chronic back pain folks, another population that uses millions of health care dollars in inefficient ways.

    • Posted By: C. MacLean @ 12/26/2008 3:00:29 PM

      Part II

      5) Make outpatient mental health services easier to access, and see comments on reimbursement (#1) for mental health providers. Depression causes more lost work days than any other single diagnosis - throw in alcohol and tobacco abuse, and you've got an invisible health crisis on your hands. We do an abysmal job in this country of helping people with depression, but we are more than happy to send them for expensive tests for complaints of chronic head aches, back aches, stomach problems, insomnia, and fatigue. We treat the symptoms with millions of dollars but never get at the root cause.

      6) Everyone should have access to a dental hygienist for an annual teeth cleaning - poor gum care is a big factor in heart disease, but periodic teeth cleaning is easy, affordable, and prevents so many costly problems down the road.

      Surprised that the suggestions listed here have less to do with doctors and more to do with nurses, dental hygienists, podiatrists, and mental health care providers? Don't be. These are the people who can provide good, efficient, cost-effective preventative care.

      Until we acknowledge that it is life style change, not medicine, that gets us and keeps us healthy, we won't be able to make a solid impact on our health care crisis: it is no longer enough to change how we pay for health care, we must change WHAT we pay FOR. and WHO we pay for it.

      Under the old fee-for-service system, we proved that doctors were lousy businessman.
      Under the managed care system, we've proven that businessmen are lousy doctors.

      If we truly want cost-effective preventative health care, we need to start accepting that it isn't the businessmen or the doctors that are the first line of defense: the patient is.

  • Posted By: Molly1011 @ 12/26/2008 2:46:04 PM

    I am nearly a senior and have no insurance, although the state in which I live requires it. I have no job and live off the help of a few friends. If recently did get sick and had to utilize a local ER at night (urgent care centers require cash or insurance). The physician administered an antibiotic to which I was allergic and, after two months, I still suffer the complications of his mistakes. I cannot afford coverage, nor any co-pays, and I surely can't pay for care to correct the mistakes of careless physicians.

  • Posted By: joejoemom10 @ 12/26/2008 2:09:11 PM

    I could not agree more with myopinionhere. I am self-employed & have a high deductible health plan that is basically useless unless something horrible happens. Well, something did- my 12 month old son was diagnosed with leukemia on Thanksgiving. Now I worry that they will drop our coverage at our anniversary or make it so expensive I cannot afford it. I can't tell you how much sleep I have lost over this. I have a great job & have been self-employed for 10 years but now I am wondering if I will have to work at Starbucks 20 hours a week so that my son can continue his cancer care. But then, who will take care of him? I'm a single mom & he cannot go to daycare because he has no immune system.

  • Posted By: KansasJayhawk @ 12/26/2008 1:46:10 PM

    Pie and cake and ice cream taste good. I have a piece and then another because I am indulging myself. Face reality here, a few skinny people are not going to be dictating to the rest of us what we eat. We are all free people under the Constitution and we will eat whatever we want. Chief.

  • Posted By: myopinionhere @ 12/26/2008 1:20:58 PM

    I don't understand the folks who believe that health insurance is anything but the biggest scam and extortion scheme in the history of business and that WHERE we WORK should dictate whether or not we're able to see a doctor and receive adequate care.

  • Posted By: myopinionhere @ 12/26/2008 1:18:53 PM

    we already have other socialized aspects of society that we rely on for live-saving (polce and fire dept), doesn't it make sense that we would have a social system set up for the most important life aspect, our bodies? It floors me why we can't just adopt a simple OPT-IN plan to medicare or medicaid and request to be put in a higher tax bracket for healthcare. It would be another block on the W-4 and on our yearly tax returns. We make it seem like it's a whole lot more difficult than it really could be.

  • Posted By: bellethiel @ 12/26/2008 1:16:24 PM

    Why would someone who today wouldn't go to see a doctor on the simplest complaints want to waste a day sitting in a bursting waiting room?

  • Posted By: dean0232 @ 12/26/2008 12:58:29 PM

    Aren't we still talking about Socialized medicine where it takes a month or two to get to see a Doctor on even the simplest med-problems and even people who wouldn't go to see a doctor on the simplest complaints, sre now filling the waiting rooms to bursting??

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse