Mental Health

Why She Cuts

One woman's fight against the compulsion to injure herself, and why medical experts disagree about how to diagnose those who cut, or in extreme cases, embed objects under their skin.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: xXashleysmileXx @ 02/11/2009 8:34:01 PM

    i cut myself for years. in the beginning i did feel alive but the more i did it the more guilty i got. and it became an addiction. i had to cut daily. soon everyone knew i was doing it because it was hard to hide. i eventually didnt care who saw. and after i while, maybe because ppl knew, it died down. i havent done it in a month. now when i cut i just kinda scratch. i still feel the need of a cold razor in my flesh. but i found a new way to get the pain i crave. tattoos and piercings. i like them plus i get the blood and a high from the pain. and you know...tattoos have helped me. i dont wanna ruin my ink. so slowly im covering my arms in tattoos. i dunno. a girl with a bunch of tats may seem icky, but i enjoy it. and i cut less. so..yeah.

  • Posted By: cutter123 @ 02/06/2009 4:19:12 PM

    Thats very true i know that when I cut my self it makes me feel... alive.

  • Posted By: cutter123 @ 02/06/2009 4:18:00 PM

    I need to talk to Beki. Maybe she can help me with my self injury problem...

  • Posted By: pagan_baby @ 01/18/2009 4:01:19 PM

    no nasreen if the person doesn't want help they wont take it until then there is nothing that can be done

  • Posted By: dannimac @ 01/18/2009 9:20:17 AM

    THere are related conditions such as pulling out own's own hair, things that trigger pain to differing degrees, that are all in response to generalized anxiety.... the pain gives expression to the emotion for a moment. The relief at releasing the emotion is incredible and addictive

  • Posted By: nasreen @ 01/14/2009 2:39:57 PM

    what do figures matter, the fact lies in why these young people mutilate their bodies. Therapy and mental treatment is the only cure.

  • Posted By: pagan_baby @ 01/09/2009 7:37:45 PM

    i totally agree freegirl

  • Posted By: freegirl @ 01/09/2009 1:20:12 PM

    Actually, Bil Smitth, you are incorrect. Those figures are for sexual abuse specifically. For those who would like to learn more, I recommend visiting the nonprofit organization Darkness to Light online at http://www.d2l.org.

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/09/2009 5:53:08 PM

      And where do they get their figures from?

  • Posted By: freegirl @ 01/09/2009 11:55:32 AM

    When are we going to start dealing with the problem of childhood sexual abuse in this country? One in four girls and one in six boys are sexually abused by the time they reach age 18. That's an epidemic. Instead of focusing on the after-effects, such as self-injury, we should be focusing on prevention and getting kids into treatment as soon as possible if they have been abused.

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/09/2009 12:28:22 PM

      So, who decides what abuse is? The so called statistics you quote lump a normal spanking and yelling with sexual and physical abuse.

  • Posted By: pagan_baby @ 01/07/2009 4:21:44 PM

    i didn't say life isn't hard and i don't hate my life,but the point of the discussion( for the people who aren't being total dick heads about this) is we are sharing our stories and trying to help the people who do have the same problems or worse come forward and talk to each other not drag each other down!

    and FYI you ignorant narcissistic *** all of those soldiers have seen battle over there my sister has seen her friends get blown up and shot,then she has to go clean the weapons after there pried apart from the dead body! i can handle you bagging on people like me with problems and what not but don't you dare say anything bad about the soldiers,the vets or anything pertaining to them!

    AND NEWS FLASH FOR YOU MR. RED THIS IS A SUPPORT GROUP!

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/07/2009 7:52:54 PM

      Ahhhhh, I'm saying bad things about the people who do the biding of state. Don't worry, I did it too, but I woke up.

  • Posted By: mr. red @ 01/07/2009 3:29:44 PM

    i agree with bill smith life is hard get over it *** happens oh well if you're going to dwell on bad experiences then you might as well not even live, let alone bitch about it to strangers. join a f***ing support group bitch

  • Posted By: pagan_baby @ 01/06/2009 4:33:18 PM

    actually no,my sister is a marine in Iraq and she has really bad ptsd but the funny thing is she got it from our abusive dad when we were younger!going to war or not doesn't make a damn bit of difference yea it sucks but they chose to join,i respect them for it very much for it but still.just because you cant or don't go into the service don't mean you don't have an easy life,and the war zone doesn't mean guns and weapons either.sometimes its all inside someones head!

    and no i take that back about being nice,dude go *** your self,better yet why don't go to to where my sister is in Iraq and get your self shot?there are enough douche bags in this world,and i have a feeling you wont be missed.

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/07/2009 8:22:23 AM

      And your sister has what to do with you? The only "douche bags" in the world are those that cry because life is so hard. You don???t even know what hard is. I bet your sister has never even seen combat. Most who go to Iraq in the last few years don???t.

  • Posted By: christopherkidwell1 @ 01/05/2009 4:21:13 PM

    The main reason that people cut themselves is because they have too much pressure put on them by society and their families, and, absurdly, harming themselves and causing themselves pain makes them 'feel better'.

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/06/2009 7:15:51 AM

      Oh the horror!!! They don???t know what pressure is unless they have been in a war zone.

  • Posted By: pagan_baby @ 01/06/2009 1:31:53 AM

    As for Bill Smith,look I'm not going to get shitty you obviously don't respond to that so hear me out.could you please stop making the rude comments.some of us are actually trying to help other and we take this seriously.so could you please stop?


    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/06/2009 7:14:25 AM

      I???m not making rude comments at all, just telling it like it is. Welcome to the real world.

  • Posted By: pagan_baby @ 01/06/2009 1:30:26 AM

    towards the end of 9th grade i made the mistake of dating my best friend,he was the first person i ever loved and trusted with everything i had still to this day.he left after i turned 15 and walked out of my life.that one hit really hard,especially when every said he said that he left because i was crazy.that one really tore me apart, because he was the one telling me from day one i wasn't(found out later people lied thank god)to be continued a few months later it started out when the started messing around with my meds and i started doing it then it became a nervous habit,it never helped that i have a fascination with scars.I haven't done it in over a year but I've wanted to.so bad it burns.in 10th grade was the turn around i started taking my meds right and things got better well kinda,i started hanging out with a kid who claimed he loved me after talking to him for like and hour(i was lonely and *** retarded)he only came around because i stopped caring and i let him take over my body when ever he was around.he was a cutter as well.i lost track of how many anxiety attacks he managed to give me over the next few months but anyways.but once again everything got better,my best friend came back at last and things improved some what.he started to wake up emotions and feelings i thought were dead.I'm a control freak when it comes to my self so i put up all my walls and put in every amount of control i had so i wouldn't fall again then have him walk out of my life.i knew he was moving to Ohio with his dad because his mom and step dad were over bearing douche bags so i knew better then to get attached.I've never been one for relationships and i burn through them like crazy,but my 16th birthday rolled around and i got together with someone that is the only person i regret being with.but we are going to skip all those details for the moment.but needless to say i do have my happy moments,but they don't last forever.i have an overly harsh critic in my head that screams at me all the time,the anti depressants block some of it out,but not all.I'm on them mostly because the head is like an off tune radio and the screaming wont stop.it got to the point where i would walk through the halls at school and i can hear people screaming my name ans it got to the point where i wanted to rip my hair out and slam my head into a wall just to make it stop.i guess over time i traded one type of self abuse for another,i rip my self apart mentally all the time. have no regrets in my life i try to learn from everything:an error doesn't become a mistake unless you choose not to fix it,for there is no such thing as failure there are only ways to learn how not to do something.you will never learn if you do not pick your self up and put effort into it...I'm trying though i guess.

    and don't worry about it yea i hear the same words all the time,but at least you are trying to help :)

  • Posted By: pagan_baby @ 01/06/2009 12:51:04 AM

    deathdaname: yea I've was ten when they told me i had ADHD that was on the border of bipolar,i was put on meds after that,i was bullied a lot when i was younger,and when i got put on them i dropped like 50 lbs in 3 months,of course i loved it at first,but i despise that kind of attention,and everyone that bullied me before suddenly wanted to be my best friend.so i stopped taking them. i regret it because when i stopped taking them i *** up a lot of things,people hated me again,i thought i was kewl and went to 7th grade thinking i was a bad ass,i gained some friends but i scared more people off then anything,i got expelled of my 2 term of that year because someone called me a lesbian and i threatened to hunt down all the people who said it and kill them.i didn't go back to school that year of course,they kept me out because i was a goth,smart in both good and bad and the women i think honestly kept me out because she knew i wanted to get back to school really bad.well i sucked major ass started dressing like a prep and they let me come back in 8th grade.needless to say i came back in bondage pants and fishnets lol.the day i got off probation of that year i got kicked out again for two reasons.one i pissed off my friend and he said "bite me" i did and made him bleed.two these preppy *** say down at my table of losers and freaks,there were other tables they were just being cunts.they called me a satanist(i was a christian at the time)so i got up in there face and said yea I'm really a *** satanist I'm going to go sacrifice you right now,never mind you aren't worthy!yea that went over like a lead balloon and i was back to square one!they let me come back a few weeks later but the catch was:i was only allowed to wear light colored clothes,no make up,couldn't talk to my old friends,and if i even messed up once i was gone again.my mother being my mother sat back and let them do it to me.anyways i went back even though i was depressed and in misery.that spring and summer things got bad.i was in a relationship and i thought was the best that ever happened to me,everyone told me that he didn't love me and is cheating on me,i lived in denial the whole time we were going out,well the truth hit me really hard,he only talked to me cause he felt sorry for me,and didn't give a good rats ass.he tried to tell me other wise the whole time,after he left i shut down,and i started hearing and seeing ***.it hit me hard,on my 14th birthday i found out he was sleeping with two girls while i was sick with the flue.a few weeks later my grandma was found dead in her apartment by her mom.so things just kept building.then towards the end of summer everything just hit a wall and crashed.a kid i knew that i liked a lot was found dead from the choking game.it hit the two towns he hung out in really hard.anyways i started going to the high school and once again i did the same thing i did in 7th grade.towards the end of 9th grade i made a big mistake. to be

  • Posted By: victim @ 01/04/2009 12:10:11 AM

    Yes Death, I do hate people noticing I cut myself and for that reason I am currently not getting any help; only reason I posted on here was because I can remain anonymous. Even worse than attention is when people feel pity or actually worry about me. Making my friends or family worry about me is yet another reason to punish myself.

    Posted again to clear this up, I highly believe most people do not do this for attention. In fact, I actually take it as an insult when people say cutters do it for attention.

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/05/2009 10:00:26 AM

      Don't worry, most of us do not feel sorry or pity you. We just think you are an imbecile.

      I just love the name "victim". How are you a "victim"?

  • Posted By: JulieCT @ 01/01/2009 9:37:30 AM

    I've never been on a Newsweek discussion forum before. For some reason,I had an expectation that the quality of the comments would be better than a lot of the drivel online. Expectation not realised (thanks Bill and the other bullies for not even reading the article and then foaming at the mouth about the subject matter).

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/01/2009 1:52:42 PM

      Please explain how I am "foaming at the mouth", if you can.

      • Posted By: iheartwaffles69 @ 01/03/2009 5:32:26 PM

        bill smith shut the hell up and go kill yourself, after all no one would care (as you say)

        • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/04/2009 9:03:02 AM

          How nice. Maybe you can explain how I am "foaming at the mouth" instead more of the same emotional nonsense.

  • Posted By: Aidra @ 12/30/2008 8:30:41 PM

    I want to say that I disagree that cutting/self-injury is all about the pain. I used to cut myself, for at least 2 years, and I don't remember it hurting, I didn't do it to feel pain. I did it because I was angry at myself, I felt hopeless. I cut myself because I knew what I was doing was wrong and I was damaging my body. It was punishment. I hated myself and where my life was going, I felt like a failure. I never felt the razor go over my skin, I never felt a sting or pain, it just felt like a strand of hair gliding over my skin. It was seeing the blood run down my arm that calmed me, I felt I deserved it.

    I was not doing this for attention. My parents thought I was and never sought counseling for me or sending me to a doctor for treatment. They thought if they ignored it, it would go away. I was miserable. I needed help but they never offered it. Near the last year or so, I didn't both hiding my arms. I was crying out, but no one offered assistance because of their religion and beliefs. I eventually handled the stuff that was causing my depression and cutting and I haven't cut or hit myself in 6 years.

    • Posted By: deathdaname @ 01/04/2009 12:25:47 AM

      You are incredibly strong, =] and yes sadly people these days are incredibly selfish. But since you experienced things like these, you should be trying to help people as well! This way you can help the world, right? Meh =p

  • Posted By: jimbo3800 @ 12/31/2008 2:24:33 PM

    Further evidence that most American women are wacky. Suspicions confirmed.

    • Posted By: JulieCT @ 01/01/2009 9:32:07 AM

      Except that men do it too. Sorry to blow your deeply sexist theory out of the water.

      • Posted By: jimbo3800 @ 01/02/2009 3:07:22 PM

        Here's an exact quote from the article, "Though figures vary, researchers estimate between two and eight million Americans, most of them women, have engaged in self-injury at some point in their lives.rom the article ".

        I guess that makes me right, and you wrong. for calling me 'sexist', doesn't it?

        • Posted By: deathdaname @ 01/04/2009 12:22:40 AM

          Jimbo, women are more emotionally open than men. Men are full of pride, and me being a *** load of that knows that the best. There are probably more men in this world that do self injury then women, but people don't find out because like I said women are more emotionally open.

        • Posted By: caligirl818 @ 01/03/2009 1:57:02 PM

          Wow you're a total idiot. Just because MORE women cut than men doesn't mean you can make a blanket statement like "American women are wacky". You're obviously not an authority on the subject so write about it when you are a more informed and actually know what the hell you're talking about.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse