Why She Cuts

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: LoveIsTheMovement @ 01/03/2009 2:45:53 PM

    Youre not alone.
    Thats why were here.
    twloha.com please go here, you dont have to make accounts or pay,you dont have o be christian or catholic, its there for YOU. just learn how there are so many people that can help you on the road to recovery =]
    bless all.

  • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 12/30/2008 8:02:27 AM

    As long as people are not hurting other people, more power too them. Kill yourself if you want. It is nothing more than attention getting, since most, if not all, "cutters" are "educated" in a government school.

    • Posted By: nimodahooligan @ 12/30/2008 10:08:33 AM

      and you know some cutters personally? you wouldnt know if your own kids were cutters because you would be oblivious to the signs. it happens everyday in all types of families, whether they were "educated" at a "government" school or not. dont act as if you understand what they go through, because you dont in the least. so keep your mouth shut and use your brain before you make ridiculous assumptions and ASSume your right. same goes for "thesaneone".

      thesanone: your part of the problem, sitting there calling them freaks and saying cutters are "contaminating" the gene pool. how positive and helpful is that to someone thats going through some internal turmoil? you have your outlet for stress (stupidity, intolerance, naivete), and cutters have they'res, and neither is necassarily healthy. you probably have friends that are cutters and you dont even know it.

      • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 12/30/2008 10:35:22 AM

        Since you are so sure I'm wrong, show me the evidence. As I have said before, I really don't care if they kill themselves. More power too them.

        • Posted By: nimodahooligan @ 12/30/2008 11:51:30 AM

          i dont have any facts beyond the fact that almost every cutter always wears long sleeves to cover up, they never talk about it even to the people they love. my girlfriend was a cutter for awhile when she was around 15-16. i see the scars everyday. she hasnt cut herself in years and the scars slowly but surely fade as she improves her ability to handle life without the need to take out stress on herself.

          how are you so sure that YOUR right there billy?

          and what a wonderful peice of humanity you are...screw it right? who cares if people in need cut themselves for release, let them die and wither away like the freaks they are right? just let them bleed out from a cut too deep? alone, feeling helpless and out of control, and feels like they cannot confide in anyone because they might be labeled as "freaks"& "crazies"....but who cares, they are just meatbags with brains right? more power to them for wanting to die right?

          have you ever wanted to die? do you know what it feels like to never want to wake up again? do you know what its like to be in a world that you feel doesnt and never will understand or accept you?

          what if your straight child turns out to be a homosexual cutter because the father was intolerant and inconsiderate and the child felt there was no one to confide in for help? then you come home to find your only child dead on the floor of your kitchen and a razor in hand and a note, "im gay, and you and the world couldnt accept me and didnt care what happened, so now im gone. its for the best". you would change your tone pretty quickly.

          • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 12/30/2008 12:21:05 PM

            I don't have any problems like this with my children. I'm actually am involved with their lives. I'm a real parent with my kids. I don't dump them off into some government run concentration camp like so many sheep in America do every day.

            So yes, let them cut themselves up all they want. Maybe someone will be willing to "help" them with their "problem". Just don"t steal money from me in order to pay for their "help".

            • Posted By: JU1978 @ 12/30/2008 1:29:37 PM

              Dear Bill Smith and thesaneone:

              This is coming from someone who has no experience with cutting, but as a parent critical of those who level judgement against other parents:

              Please keep your hate-mongering and instigatory ways to yourselves. No one here is interested in your opinions, as clearly they are based on ignorance, arrogance and bigotry.

              With that being said, Bill Smith, I am sure that your kids are out somewhere smoking dope in a trailer and having all kinds of pre-marital sex right now (or, if they're under the age of 15 they will be soon). But don't worry, because ilk from the likes of you will certainly follow in your footsteps to become asuch an ignorant, abusive cretin as yourself.

              And to thesaneone: Please, before you level such nastiness thinly veiled as an attempt at educated opinion- please learn to spell properly. Or, perhaps place more stringent focus on proper grammar. People will respect your disgusting and backward attitude so much more that way.

              Thanks!

              • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 12/30/2008 2:14:10 PM

                I know exactly where my children are. They are either with me, my wife, or with one of the other trusted parents who also take care of our children. We don't dump ours off at government run propaganda camps like most sheep in Amerika do. You obviously know very little about me. I???m far from "bigoted" or a "cretin". I actually show compassion and understanding to my children. They don't have a "need" to be disfiguring themselves.

                It seems you are the one who needs to take a look into to the mirror and question your own morality.

                • Posted By: XxXcrippled_hopeXxX @ 01/03/2009 2:19:39 PM

                  ya, my mom thinks that too. but i do things she has no idea about

                • Posted By: xdrozzyx @ 12/30/2008 2:40:19 PM

                  We get it, Bill. You know where the quotation mark key is.

                  • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 12/30/2008 2:49:26 PM

                    Obviously you do NOT get it.

            • Posted By: JU1978 @ 12/30/2008 1:18:56 PM

              Dear thesaneone:

              Please keep your hate mongering and instigatory ways to yourself. To the saneone- I bet your kids are out getting high on dope in a trailer and having all kinds of premarital sex right now behind your back. It's nice that they're able to keep it from you, though. Don't worry, eventuallythey'll have their own family of degenerate ignoramuses like yourself to "contaminate" a gene pool already littered with cretins.

              Please- before you level nastiness at those you don't know- at least learn to spell properly. And perhaps focus on good grammar usage.

              Thanks!

        • Posted By: Caring2 @ 12/30/2008 3:57:19 PM

          Your ignorance shows in thinking that self-injurers want to die. Obviously you didn't read the article and you are not a psychologist or psychologist. So great, you can have an opinion, but those of us who know better will take your opinions with a grain of salt.

          • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 12/30/2008 5:34:21 PM

            I never said they want to die. I said I don't care if they kill themselves. You might want to read my post again.

    • Posted By: JulieCT @ 01/01/2009 9:28:43 AM

      Wow, so where's the statistics to prove that?

      Bill, I think madam does protest too much. What are you so agitated about? Why has this issue hit so much of a nerve that you feel the need to denigrate other human beings?

      • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/01/2009 1:56:07 PM

        Obviously the issue is upsetting to everyone else because of the nasty ad hominem attacks.

        • Posted By: caligirl818 @ 01/03/2009 2:11:39 PM

          Bill, you keep using that phrase, "ad hominem", most likely to sound more intelligent than you actually are. You honestly just sound like an elitist ass. People who cut typically hide their scars. They wear long sleeves or bandages, and are careful to make sure people don't see what they've done to themselves. That doesn't sound attention seeking to me.

  • Posted By: XxXcrippled_hopeXxX @ 01/03/2009 2:13:02 PM

    Why does everyone make a big deal with cutting???
    ive been cutting since this summer,it started with me accsedently cutting my foot witha razor shaving my legs it helped ease my mind from other things going on in my life. so i use a razor but i cut my feet mostly, somtimes my wrists. but if i cut my feet, no one knotices as much. but i enjoy scratching myself better. i will did my nails into my arms,neck,face and just scratch as hard as i can drawing lots of blood. i have alot of scares.and when i scratched my face, my school knoticed. i told them i accsedently scrached myself in myself, i told my mother this also.
    I take anti-depressents, but they dont help at all so ive been skipping out on them.
    but if i ever told my mother what i enjoy, she would not belive me. she thinks i am wanting attention. so i swore to myself i'm not going to tell her. and i'm fine.

  • Posted By: momworries @ 12/30/2008 11:36:26 AM

    My son is a "cutter" and has been for the last 10 years. At 26 he is still cutting and unable to work. Social Security has denied him several times and he is unable to secure any type of medicaid to pay for therapy and medication. Is there anyone who has any advise for me?

    • Posted By: caligirl818 @ 01/03/2009 2:04:08 PM

      As stated above, I suggest that he see a counselor once or twice at least, to figure out what causes him to cut and if there is a possibility that he has some other kind of mental disease.

  • Posted By: mel8986 @ 12/30/2008 4:35:12 PM

    I am not saying this is the case with ALL cutters, but in my experience (I have 2 teenage daughters), many of the kids that are cutting are, in fact, doing it for attention. And they are not LACKING attention to begin with. Medically speaking, they are not cutting so that any endorphins are being released...they are cutting just enough to get noticed. Most do not understand what they are doing but they have heard of it and seen it on TV so they do it. They say that it makes them feel better....it might make them think they feel better but it is not doing anything more physically to them than drawing on themselves would do. I believe It is an emotional cry for help in many cases. These days it is difficult to distinguish which acts are teens being a pain in the butt or teens truly needing help. Once I carved a boys initials into my leg with a piece of glass...it did not feel great but I did accomplish just what I was hoping to...he noticed me. I was not a "cutter", I did not need "help", I needed to grow up. The cut healed and I do not have his initials scarred on my body forever, thankfully. It is a shame that a teen can turn on the TV, see someone cutting, decide to do it and truly believe that it has made a difference. If they knew the medical facts of it (not the emotional ones..they are not one in the same) they would know that they are not doing what they think they are.

    • Posted By: caligirl818 @ 01/03/2009 2:02:10 PM

      No, they're not. More often than not, people cut because they have so much emotional pain that they can't deal with it, so they take it out on themselves physically. I know dozens of people who have cut, one who even tried to kill himself, and none of them did it for the attention. People cut to feel something, to get out of a state of numbness. Just because YOU cut yourself for attention at one point doesn't mean that most people do, and you have no right to make a statement like that. I cut myself for over a year, and I certainly didn't do it for attention. I mean, I'm an only child with one parent and plenty of friends; I didn't need attention. I was seriously depressed and cut myself because I was more emotional pain than my body could handle.

  • Posted By: gardenarine @ 12/31/2008 10:33:14 PM

    I think it's bad to try to stop people from self-multilation with drugs. The only way a person will be able to get better from a bad habit is by themselves. They can't rely on a drug to cure all their worries, or bring their loved ones back from the grave, or stop them from being abused or lonely. What people that cut need is someone that believes they have the power to STOP.

    • Posted By: caligirl818 @ 01/03/2009 1:49:36 PM

      I agree with you on the whole, but I find your last statement to be untrue just based on personal experience. I had a lot of people who believed I could stop, but I continued cutting for over a year. You need more than just people believing you can stop. You need to WANT to stop, and you need to want it for yourself. That's what really helps, when you do it for yourself and not because it makes other people happy but not you.

  • Posted By: v00d00-d0LL @ 01/03/2009 11:51:03 AM

    I am fourteen years of age, and just starting high school. But along with high school I've also started cutting. Over the summer it became a habit, and I tried to hide it, but hiding your cuts under long sleeves can be difficult when it's over one hundred degrees outside. That's why my family started guessing at what I was doing, and even after my mother warned me that I would have to go to therapy if I continued, I kept going. So in the end, my mother found a therapist for me. Sometimes it does help to talk about the things that I experience, and the feelings that I have that I can't really talk about with my own mother. Other times therapy just forces me to think about what's going on around me, and those thoughts make me feel even worse after my session. A few times I've arrived home from therapy, and immediately went for the knives I keep hidden in my room. I know that it won't help me get out of therapy, but when I'm acting on impulse... I'm not really thinking. There are a lot of people that would call me pathetic for what I'm doing, and I can sometimes agree with them. But... when I feel alone I don't know what else to do. I'm trying to get through it. I know that I want to stop, and this article has helped me to realize once more how important quitting is to me.

  • Posted By: Harred @ 01/03/2009 9:05:05 AM

    If that is the only way she can feel happy, her life must be pathetic. I have a traumatic childhood, my mum was beaten by my father, cousins (even my brother) in and out of jail. But if you cannot find one thing that you can hold on to, that you can single out and focus on while everything around you is falling to shreds, your life is horrible and pathetic in my opinion

    • Posted By: lovelylullaby @ 01/03/2009 11:16:30 AM

      That's horrible to say. Some people aren't as tough as others, you know. You were stronger then most children are today. I'm thinking that since some many parents are getting divorces these days and having to live with the mother, they are softer then they would've been with their dad or if the parents were still together. Maybe that's why so many teens resort to self injury. Well, that's my opinion. But still, calling people pathetic for their lives is like telling them to go die, since they aren't worth it. Cutting can actually become an addiction. It did for me.. a long time ago. But life gets better in the end! It all just depends on what you do with it.

    • Posted By: lovelylullaby @ 01/03/2009 11:15:23 AM

      That's horrible to say. Some people aren't as tough as others, you know. You were stronger then most children are today. I'm thinking that since some many parents are getting divorces these days and having to live with the mother, they are softer then they would've been with their dad or if the parents were still together. Maybe that's why so many teens resort to self injury. Well, that's my opinion. But still, calling people pathetic for their lives is like telling them to go die, since they aren't worth it. Cutting can actually become an addiction. It did for me.. a long time ago. But life gets better in the end! It all just depends on what you do with it.

  • Posted By: concerned2009 @ 01/03/2009 9:33:55 AM

    Okay, so like, I've cut myself [on accident] shaving my legs once..and it felt good..so good that I wanted to do it again, but I didn't..because I had made a promise not to purposely cut myself. Well, the point is, that cuts and scrapes, while they may hurt, they feel good at the same time. It does help with the emotional pain one goes through. I'd rather not have emotional pain. Physical pain, to me, is better and doesn't hurt as much. People look at cutters and are all like 'well, that's just dumb' but they don't dare to ask what's wrong, they just think that person is stupid and mental. It's not a mental illness..in some cases, it's a cry for help..in others, it's an attempt to feel something, to relieve emotional pain. Most people don't have very many friends or a good home life and they need some way to get out of that. Some people have a great life with great friends and choose to cut because they just want to feel something. And I've noticed I'm being extremely repetitive so I'm going to hush now. But lemme just say this: If you see someone cutting or someone who looks like their not having the greatest of days, GO UP TO THEM AND BE NICE! It will make their day. Don't be a selfish idiot and say 'oh, well that person needs some help', be nice and friendly, ask them what's wrong. I know I'd like it, when I was in school, I'd sit alone and no one'd care..everyone always picked on me. But yea, I'm out. =]

  • Posted By: saber wulluf @ 01/03/2009 5:11:37 AM

    and i havent felt ral physical pain in a long time iether it doesnt hurt when i cut i barly feel the metal or what ever i am doing to hurt myself it realieves emotional pain for a short time then it briungs me even lower than b4 it numbs the emotional pain for a while until it wears off thats y i do it just like y i use drugs and just like y i used to steal constantly its just like a drug the cutting numbs the emotional pain the stealing covered it with addrenaline and the drugs cover it and numb it with the chemicals that r active inb them.and sorry for the double post it didnt say it registered the first time the text went away and i rewrite it and it didnt come up when i went to all the comments iether so i though it never went in.

  • Posted By: saber wulluf @ 01/03/2009 4:58:10 AM

    im someone that self injures in many ways cutting,friction burning,sticking needls in here and thier and then takeing them out,self piercings and many others i dont talk about it to anyone i am ashamed of it its not something i do for attention i do it for the brief brush with reality and feeling i get from it and when i cut or stick needls into myself thier usually not steral at all i usually just use my knifes that i also use for cutting string/rope/and many other things i dont like attention at all really i usually dont even talk that much and stay away from people i always cover up my marks with a sweater or sweat bands even if its the middle of summer ill wear a sweater to covver it up and not take it off till im alone and bymyself i have cut many times at once with serated or straight edge knifes or a razer even if it was rusty i dont no how i havent got infections yet and when i self pierce or stick a needls in myself its usually off my clothing like a safty pin but i dont leave anything thier and take it out.and i cant stop i can only stop for a small portion of time and then wind up doing it again and cant stop doing it for a long time after i redo it and no it isnt hot or anything its bad and its something that does need to b treated some how and i dont think its one thing that couses it i think its many different mental disabilitys that can couse someone to do it.and i also used to b suicidal but stopped and i also use drugs freaquintly but started cutting b4 i started drugs and i also was a clepto and that was b4 i started cutting so basically i have been switching addictions to addictions and have gaind more if anything and all its done is hurt me more than help me in anyway and i wish i had never started any of it couse now i cant stop the main thing is the self mutilation i still to this day regret the first cut i did and every cut i do now i only feel good for a short time then i feel even worse than b4 oi did it.if anyone is thinking of self mutilating or anything i have done from experience try ur hardest not to do it it doesnt help its a horrable addiction and habit and ull always come down and b in a worse place than b4 u did it i dont want anyone else that has read these words to go the same rout i have or at least try thier hardest to not do it and seek and find help somewhier or some how.and i am also male and dont really no the statistics but one reason i can think of for thier being more documented cases in women doing it is couse self injuries a guy could do then go get into a fight and blame it on that as well.

  • Posted By: Debrad1207 @ 01/02/2009 4:06:52 AM

    I wish more people would be open about the problem that is affecting a growing portion of our population. The people who self-injure need to be shown compassion and support. I used to have a problem and an addiction to self-injury, as well. Luckily, my best friend helped me through the toughest years of my life, and it's not an addiction anymore. And to the people who think it's for attention, think again. Another friend of mine doesn't talk to me because of the injuries she saw on my arms, and the issue is rarely brought up between my best friend and I. Doesn't sound like attention-seeking to me!

    P.S. It's frightening knowing people like Bill Smith are even allowed to reproduce, let alone find someone to reproduce with!

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/02/2009 10:22:44 AM

      Hitler had the same mind set as you. He was a firm believer in forced sterilization too.Now your true colors come shinning through.

  • Posted By: JulieCT @ 01/01/2009 9:22:27 AM

    Thank you for an informative article (after recently reading a piece where the old "attention-seeking" line was used, it's good to see that some journalists do their research).

    Drugs aren't really going to help combat self-injurious behaviour or the disorders that might cause it (e.g. borderline personality disorder). People need to learn positive coping strategies to replace the old negative ones. People also need to learn how to self-soothe. For many victims of childhood abuse this can be a difficult ask indeed. I wear long sleeves all the time to hide the burn marks and the razor blade scars. It's shameful to me to see them, so I sure as hell don't want anyone else to.

  • Posted By: nevermindtheend @ 12/30/2008 10:15:15 PM

    So much for responsible journalism. In its attempt to shock people into reading this story - with a photo of a razor-slashed arm on its front page - Newsweek has undoubtedly triggered self injury in many of the "between two and eight million Americans, most of them women, have engaged in self-injury at some point in their lives."

    • Posted By: gardenarine @ 12/31/2008 10:34:40 PM

      when the general public sees devastating pictures like that, they are actually entertained at times.

    • Posted By: gardenarine @ 12/31/2008 10:34:09 PM

      very true

  • Posted By: weathered @ 12/31/2008 9:38:30 PM

    We all have ways of punishing ourselves...physically and emotionally. Those who don't care if others kill themselves: I'd say you've got some major issues of your own.

  • Posted By: lightshimmer @ 12/30/2008 5:29:28 PM

    I am 23 years old. I work two jobs, am saving up to finish college, and I am a very healthy and normal person. I love my parents, I'm getting married to a wonderful man, and my life in no way sucks. I never cut, I scratched until I bled. I have eight scars on my arm, my fiance thinks they are old chicken pox scars. My parents never knew. I hated having to hide my arms all the time, so I stopped scratching. Now I bite my fingernails until they bleed. I take toenail clippers and clip the bottoms of my feet until the skin is so thin its hard to walk sometimes. I pinch myself until there is a blood blister, but only where its not noticible, and never very large. I've never been to therapy, and I probably won't go. No one knows what I do, and it really doesnt impact my daily life all that much. I'm not accidently slicing any veins, I no longer give myself horrible scars, but it hasnt gone away. Its my little secret. If you think I'm strange, check the feet and hands of someone you know and love. The backs of the knees and the side of the heels are a good spot to check for pinch spots. You might be surprised.

    • Posted By: tnwhitley @ 12/31/2008 6:15:53 PM

      lightshimmer...in my opinion (because I do not know you though your story bothers me as a father of a young daughter who has done some of the same things, and a deceased son who hung himself) I think you need to deal with why you want to punish yourself, why you dislike some part of yourself and why you feel the need to hurt your body as a result.

      I myself have had to deal with issues inside my own life with feeling like a loser, with daily thoughts of suicide though I've never cut myself or attempted to end my life. I do understand how you feel inside and can only ask that you talk to your doctor and ask him/her for help in coping with life.
      I would also like to tell you that even though you might not think so at times your life is important to those who love you and who if they knew what you're going through would/should want to help you in any way they can. Please don't give up on life.

      Fight this like it was a real thing attacking you and try your best to overcome it. I know, it's difficult but I also know that it IS possible to beat it.
      May God Bless You and Keep You My Dear Sweet Child.

    • Posted By: tnwhitley @ 12/31/2008 6:15:09 PM

      lightshimmer...in my opinion (because I do not know you though your story bothers me as a father of a young daughter who has done some of the same things, and a deceased son who hung himself) I think you need to deal with why you want to punish yourself, why you dislike some part of yourself and why you feel the need to hurt your body as a result.

      I myself have had to deal with issues inside my own life with feeling like a loser, with daily thoughts of suicide though I've never cut myself or attempted to end my life. I do understand how you feel inside and can only ask that you talk to your doctor and ask him/her for help in coping with life.
      I would also like to tell you that even though you might not think so at times your life is important to those who love you and who if they knew what you're going through would/should want to help you in any way they can. Please don't give up on life.

      Fight this like it was a real thing attacking you and try your best to overcome it. I know, it's difficult but I also know that it IS possible to beat it.
      May God Bless You and Keep You My Dear Sweet Child.

  • Posted By: C. MacLean @ 12/31/2008 11:19:50 AM

    The role of journalism is to inform, but responsible journalism should attempt to balance risk. Rather than just publish an article about the problem, a few websites or hotline numbers of agencies that could offer help, or at least, more information, would have been appropriate here.

    Publishing such information would have been more in keeping with the public's 'right to know.'

  • Posted By: Aidra @ 12/30/2008 8:22:12 PM

    I want to say that I disagree that cutting/self-injury is all about the pain. I used to cut myself, for at least 2 years, and I don't remember it hurting, I didn't do it to feel pain. I did it because I was angry at myself, I felt hopeless. I cut myself because I knew what I was doing was wrong and I was damaging my body. It was punishment. I hated myself and where my life was going, I felt like a failure. I never felt the razor go over my skin, I never felt a sting or pain, it just felt like a strand of hair gliding over my skin. It was seeing the blood run down my arm that calmed me, I felt I deserved it.

  • Posted By: TishtheDish @ 12/30/2008 5:53:55 PM

    There are places that people can go (that self-injure) for help in New Jersey....since this story is based on a girl from NJ, why not give a link or place people can go??? Well, I can't remember the name, but it is in Morris County, a self injury support center and they have support groups and a recovery program going on. I will come back with the name if I find it!

  • Posted By: rka9990 @ 12/30/2008 3:59:14 PM

    self inflicting is not just a physical relief. self inflicted emotional harm can be just as devastating. it can be a method to cry out for help for those who do not know any appropriate way of expressing their own pain or their own low self esteem. as a child, i not only caused physical injuries to myself, but i also acted out by role playing - solely to avoid being who i was - a person i did not know or like. as i grew up, i engaged in other methods of self destruction - drug addiction, criminally bordered activities, refusal to face reality. finally, at age 48, i finally had enough and sought much desired and much needed therapy. it finally worked, however, i always have to be attuned to the fact that i can easily regress if i complicate my life too much. as such, i try to keep life as simple as possible, even in trying times. so, for those who struggle as adolescents, those who struggle as young adults and those who struggle as adults, there is hope if you can reach inside yourself to find the desire to seek changes to your own inadequacies. i would be glad to assist anyone who has struggled with life and themselves as i have.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse