HEALTH

America’s Top Killer: Us

A new study argues our personal choices cause more than 1 million premature deaths a year. What, if anything, should the government do to protect us from ourselves?

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: jingrmai @ 01/13/2009 4:45:14 PM

    I didn't know people would die from making bad deicisons. "That means more than half the population will make a decision leading to an early grave, he reports, including a full 55 percent of people who die between the ages of 15 and 64." 15-64? that's 49 years of bad choices. OF COURSE YOU'RE MOSTLY TO DIE IF YOU MADE 49YRS OF BAD CHOICES

    waste of time and research money

  • Posted By: Qidisrupt @ 01/10/2009 1:50:47 AM

    I wonder... the fuel emissions; are they more dangerous healthwise for us than junk food, booze, cigarettes, etc. I know I am guilty of spewing fuel emissions on a daily basis. What about all of the modern pharmaceuticals in today's market that are more dangerous than not taking them? We can dodge some of these "bullets" by our personal decisions. But one thing all of us cannot avoid...someday we will all pass away.

  • Posted By: dain555 @ 01/08/2009 12:49:38 PM

    This is one of the things that makes America great, personnal freedoms. We do not need additional governmental control on our choices. Let us make mistakes. It makes us stronger. If it kills us than the stronger/smarter survive! It's a clear example of Darwinism.

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/08/2009 2:19:46 PM

      What personal freedoms do Amerikans have? Hell, you can???t even own property in Amerika.

  • Posted By: YashBudini @ 01/07/2009 4:14:55 PM

    Keeney is an idiot, via his own words:

    "America's top killer isn't cancer or heart disease, or even smoking and overeating???it's our inability to make smart choices that leads us to engage in those and other self-destructive behaviors."

    Smoking and overeating ARE "not smart choices" or "self destructive behavior."

    And suicide is not that that simple. He's obviously never had a rational conversation with someone in the late stages of bone cancer, else he couldn't make such an ignorant statement. Has Keeney actually had any rational thoughts?

    And he prints a book to make himself look like an expert? That's like the ultimate irony.

    Actually the problem with overeating is the damage doesn't happen quickly enough. At least if they ate themselves into a grave before breeding then natural selection would be able to accomplish its natural goal.

    I wouldn't mind a federal AND a state tax on corn syrup. Same reason we have taxes on beer and cigarettes, it's a stupidity tax.

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/07/2009 7:49:34 PM

      I see you don't mind stealing wealth from others or delegating it others to do it in your stead.

      • Posted By: YashBudini @ 01/08/2009 10:41:28 AM

        Those idiots raise my health insurance costs.

        • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/08/2009 2:18:56 PM

          Only a theft based system increases insurance costs. Why do you support theft?

  • Posted By: dain555 @ 01/08/2009 12:52:02 PM

    This a clear example of Darwinism. The strong/intelligent suvive. Let us make our mistakes. We do not need more governmental control over our lives. Freedom of choice is what makes America great, be it right or wrong choices.

  • Posted By: Qidisrupt @ 01/05/2009 5:01:05 PM

    distantsmoke...you are misinformed that it is the DNC's agenda to control you or me. As I stated earlier, I made a personal decision to make healthier lifestyle choices...I also stated that if people are truly happy suffering through bad health issues because of their own lifestyle decisions, then let them live with it; choices like these should never be mandated...people either want to or they don't. I am a democrat and proudly helped in the cause to vote for President-elect Barack Hussein Obama. You and many others can put your paranoid fears to rest...the DNC will not tell you what you can or cannot do...but, with so many USA workers sitting on the sidelines because of the failed economic policies of the GOP, healthcare is no longer an option or a personal choice...we need to change our healthcare system...look at the shambles it is in right now. People working for subsistent wages, cannot afford health insurance, cannot afford to feed and clothe their families...not because of personal choice, but because of livable wage jobs being outsourced. Where are you coming up with the notion that our govt. will pay for everything...if you would lose your job, and could not find another job for quite a while...wouldn't you need some kind of healthcare coverage? Just think, all of this economic mess created by the blundering GOP...and yet you insist on blaming Obama and he isn't even in office yet??? You have a truly pitiful argument.

    • Posted By: YashBudini @ 01/08/2009 10:56:36 AM

      "distantsmoke...you are misinformed that it is the DNC's agenda to control you or me."

      It's more than that, he willingly accepts being misinformed. He likes it because it's an easy excuse.

    • Posted By: rousch15@hotmail.com @ 01/06/2009 9:58:44 AM

      Only a racist blames Obama for the nation's ills before he takes Office.

      • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/06/2009 11:53:07 AM

        Only a fool blames anything other that government for the nation's ills.

  • Posted By: tired and old @ 01/04/2009 12:12:45 PM

    FREEDOM OF CHOICE TO MAKE BAD DECISIONS?

    OUR YOUTH ELECT TO SERVE THEIR COUNTRY AND JOIN OUR MILITARY.

    TAKING A CHANCE IT WILL LEAD TO THEIR PREMATURE DEATH.

    AFTER ENTERING THE MILITARY AND HAVING BEEN ASKED WHAT SCHOOL THEY PREFER; THEY ARE TOLD " WE DON'T GIVE A F**K WHAT YOU REQUESTED , YOU WILL DO WHAT WE WANT YOU TO DO ! "

    YOU LOSE YOUR CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AS A SERVICEMAN.

    WHY ? STATE CONTROLLED DISCIPLINE IN A DICTATOR STYLE ENVIRONMENT.

    MANY DECISIONS ARE MADE WITHOUT THINKING.

    • Posted By: YashBudini @ 01/08/2009 10:44:58 AM

      "OUR YOUTH ELECT TO SERVE THEIR COUNTRY AND JOIN OUR MILITARY."

      Wrong, a decision made under duress is not a decision. If you can't find a job and enlist you had no choice. Notice how Bush's kids, Cheney's kids, Hilton's kids, they never enlist.

    • Posted By: rousch15@hotmail.com @ 01/06/2009 11:16:52 AM

      Watch your language.

  • Posted By: rousch15@hotmail.com @ 01/06/2009 9:50:45 AM

    The Democrats have NO intention to control the People....and that's sad, because the People demonstrate NO ability to control their own lives.

    They spend too much, eat too much and watch too much television.
    They don't read, don't talk to one another and are lacking in imagination,due to the amount of hours they spend in front of the idiot box...watching Fox News.

    I see a correlation here. I hope I'm wrong. However, since I'm just your average articulate liberal who reads, writes and pays attention, I'm probably more correct than I realize.

    • Posted By: YashBudini @ 01/08/2009 10:42:09 AM

      Actually it's Faux News. Along with Newsweak.

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/06/2009 11:54:08 AM

      And the typical modern liberal is "educated" in a government school.

  • Posted By: hindusensei @ 01/08/2009 4:01:52 AM

    People have more choices than they did in the past. Its not that our grandfathers were any better than us. The environment conditioned them in many ways just as the environment conditions us.
    Poorer people in poorer countries are probably harder working with less fat on their bodies.
    Does that mean they are better?
    No, its just that they don't get the same number of choices in life.
    So I guess in a competitive world they have advantages, but not match point!

  • Posted By: distantsmoke @ 01/05/2009 12:24:07 AM

    Welcome to the Democratic National Committee's true agenda: Your welfare is our concern. We will tell you what level of education you deserve (and we are willing to pay for), we will tell you what job you must do (and we are willing to pay for), we will tell you what kind of house you can live in (and we are willing to pay for), and we will tell you what medical care you can and cannot have (that we are willing to pay for).

    Once the government is paying for everything, YOU will no longer have a choice. Thank you to the mainstream media for making d*mn sure the country elected Sen Obama for President. Now we can all sit back and let the DNC tell us what we do and do not deserve.

    • Posted By: YashBudini @ 01/07/2009 3:56:57 PM

      It's the RNCs agenda to make Halliburton rich and start WWIII in the name of the Lord.

  • Posted By: hottopicstalk @ 01/02/2009 5:53:35 PM

    We can not expect legalism to be the answer our problems. God's Word has indicated we are not able to live right on our own power. If we sin a little sin it's still sin, the consequences in this life may not be as great but it still seperates us from God. If the sin is great it will cause more harm in this life to oneself or to others and it seperates us from God. If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, then why call it a pigeon.

    • Posted By: SilentObserver_intheCorner @ 01/06/2009 4:23:55 PM

      'Cause it makes more sense than an old father figure who sits in a white robe that observes what we do, that if we do or not pray to him he will either bless us, give us all of our needs and love for all eternity, or damn to a burn lake of fire. where we'll burn for all eternity with the devil and all his demons. Yeah that is completely how "your" god is like, what about the rest of the nations that don't subscribe to your religion what'll they have to do?

  • Posted By: soulja4christ @ 01/02/2009 5:43:18 PM

    I agree with you 100% hottopicstalk. Only Christ will change this mess.

    • Posted By: SilentObserver_intheCorner @ 01/06/2009 3:55:07 PM

      Why Chris?t What about the Flying Spaghetti Monster and his noodly appendage of fate ? If FSM was in our lives we would all prosper and advance as one body into his spaghetti and meatball bosom.

    • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/05/2009 8:00:19 AM

      How is a mythological creature going to help us?

  • Posted By: hottopicstalk @ 01/02/2009 5:39:50 PM

    It should be obvious to all that we are hurting and killing ourselves, however, what will it take to change directions? Only if we are willing to face and accept the truth that Jesus died to save us from sin. And how is the government going to save anyone when the government is a body made up of human individuals who are just as prone to making bad decisions as anyone else. The evidence is all around. Was this question to get to the heart of what troubles the human life in existence or some other motive?

    • Posted By: SilentObserver_intheCorner @ 01/06/2009 3:50:38 PM

      So do you suggest that if the government is human and prone to error, and if they let Jesus in then many of the bad decisions would be few and far between? If so would we no longer be a democracy, but a theocracy? With that said who would we have to listen to then to make decisions? And, what would stop the governmental body from pursuing the end times in earnest?

    • Posted By: skinnyminny2 @ 01/02/2009 6:11:37 PM

      The fact that people believe someone died for their sins makes it even easier for them to be bad. I say let people wallow in their poor decision making--that's the only way people learn.

      And I agree with the comment about airlines--if you're really fat, you ought to pay for 2 seats. And don't give excuses, I don't care why you're fat. Every passenger ought to pay bsed on weight, just like the post office. After all, we are merely human cargo. You don't argue or negotiate with the post office about the cost of your heavy package, do you?

  • Posted By: tired and old @ 01/04/2009 12:29:21 PM

    WHEN ADOLPH HITLER TOOK POWER CITIZEN RIGHTS WERE LOST.

    WHEN THE U.S.CONSTITUTION AND OUR BASIC FREEDOMS ARE IGNORED BY THOSE CORRUPTED BY SELF INTERESTS------ THEN WE ARE LOST TOO.

    CONGRESS CHOOSING TO IGNORE ILLINOIS SENATE SELECTEE IS A MESSAGE :

    YOU ARE GUILTY UNTIL YOU ARE PROVEN INNOCENT.

    CONGRESS THROWING US IN DEBT WITH BAILOUT MONEY TO BIG BUSINESS :

    WE DON'T GIVE A **** WHAT AMERICANS WANT, WE ARE GREEDY BASTARDS WHO ONLY CARE ABOUT OURSELVES AND OUR RICH FRIENDS.

    • Posted By: rousch15@hotmail.com @ 01/06/2009 10:02:47 AM

      The only thing that is throwing us into debt is our military.

      • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/06/2009 11:51:52 AM

        What about all the welfare checks that are given to other countries and corporation (a creation of the government)?

    • Posted By: rousch15@hotmail.com @ 01/06/2009 11:15:44 AM

      Yawn.

      What about the Bush family and their thefts of the 2000 and 2004 elections? Funny that you didn't mention that.

      You are looking for ANYTHING that will stick against President Obama because you demonstrate an inability to accept the fact that your president is BLACK.

      Either deal with it or get out of my country.

      • Posted By: Bill Smith @ 01/06/2009 11:50:39 AM

        Interesting. The whole "love it, or leave it" usually comes from the right side of the demopublican party.

        Many politicians steal elections all the time. That is what government is all about. Funny how you don't mention the wealth that is stolen from the productive EVERY SINGLE DAY.

  • Posted By: pspay01 @ 01/05/2009 4:01:20 PM

    this is the stupidest article I ever read. Like people do not know that certain things are bad for them. We do not want the government to tell us what to think. If we want to eat food that tastes great but shortens our lives 1 year, then that is our decision.

    We should not be told what is "bad" or "good". Just state the facts and the rest we can judge on our own.

    • Posted By: rousch15@hotmail.com @ 01/06/2009 10:01:17 AM

      It's obvious that MOST people NEED to be told what's good and bad.
      Why are they sitting like brainwashed drones in pews every Sunday, instead of reading like intellectuals in libraries?

  • Posted By: freespeak @ 01/02/2009 9:04:41 PM

    the Declaration Of Independence says that all men are created equal and endowed by their Creator with inalienable rights of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. If we give the government the power over us .....the government in power may decide whether we even have the right to life, liberty etc.

    • Posted By: rousch15@hotmail.com @ 01/06/2009 9:56:19 AM

      The right-wing government in Washington, D.C. had that power for eight years.

  • Posted By: bkmac53 @ 01/02/2009 5:22:29 PM

    The government has our best interests at heart??? What world are you living in??? Get real, if it wasn't for the media, we would know even less than we already do about what our so-called "public servants are actually up to. Don't get me wrong, the media manipulates us, but what do you think our government has been doing for decades??? It's people like you who will hand their guns over when the cops come knocking and then be totally surprised when you're left defenseless against unreasonable and unjustified persecution. And the persecution will be coming from none other than the ones who holld the weapons. If people choose to kill themselves, slowly or rapidly, they should be allowed. Since when did I ask my government to become "my brothers keeper?" Stay out of my business and I'll stay out of yours...

    • Posted By: rousch15@hotmail.com @ 01/06/2009 9:54:56 AM

      New Deal vs. Reaganomics, my friend.

      A government which is controlled by liberals has your best interests at heart, while a government which is controlled by conservatives just wants your heart to stop so it can be donated to someone who can afford quatlity health care.

  • Posted By: christopherkidwell1 @ 01/05/2009 4:12:17 PM

    Yeah, right. Let me tell you, that the number of fat people in my family is high, yet 90% of us live until the age of 80 or beyond, well past a 'premature death' that I think of as 40-50 years old.
    We need to realize that the REAL thing that is killing us is not what we eat, but the stress that is put on some people to 'get thin, execise, etc.!"

  • Posted By: Qidisrupt @ 01/05/2009 12:42:54 AM

    I'm glad that there is forgiveness for all the wrong things I have done.

  • Posted By: JEZZY @ 01/05/2009 12:17:30 AM

    I AM 54 YEARS OLD AND I HAVE MAJOR DEPRESSION,SEIZURES,MACULAR DEGENERATION. I HAVE LEARNED THAT THERE ARE ACCEPTABLE BRAIN DISORDERS AND THOSE THAT ARE NOT.BRAIN CANCER,BRAIN TUMORS,DEMENTIA,ALZHEIMERS, AND PARKINSON'S ARE A FEW OF THE ACCEPTABLE ONES.DEPRESSION,BIPOLAR,SCHIZOPHRINA ARE NOT.TAKING ANTIDEPRESSANTS INVARIABLY MAKE YOU GAIN WEIGHT.I WOULD LOVE TO BE SKINNY AND TAKE A 'HAPPY PILL' THAT DOESN'T HAVE SIDE EFFECTS.MY FAMILY TREE IS LITTERED WITH MOTHERS,NIECES,NEPHEWS,AND COUSINS WHO DID NOT WIN THE GENETIC LOTTERY. BUT WE DON'T TALK ABOUT IT AND WATER THE FAMILY TREE WITH WATER FROM THE DENIAL RIVER.I KNOW FROM PERSONAL EXPERIENCE THAT IF I DON'T TAKE MY MEDICATIONS THAT THE SUICIDE SWITCH WILL GO OFF AND THE MISERY IS UNBEARABLE. SO MY PRAYER IS THAT A 'HAPPY PILL' THAT DOESN'T MAKE YOU GAINS WIEGHT AND THE MENTALLY ILL WILL LIVE HAPPY EVER AFTER.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse