Civilian Voices

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: forjustice @ 01/08/2009 5:15:39 PM

    Intolerant and ignorant folks contribute as much to human misery as the actual perpetrators.
    On the pro-Isareli action side, stop giving this stupid excuse of who started this cycle of violence first. Ther is little doubt that the latest Israeli reaction is motivated by forthcoming elections in Israel. So the sensible thing would be to vote Olmert and the gang out. Bring back Rabib like leaders.

    On the Palestinian side, blame Egypt and Abbas first before blaming Israel.These folks were instrumental in weakening Hamas politically and militarily. Also ask Hamas as to why they send rockets now to help re-elect the current Isareli regime.

    Is it possible that Hamas and Olmert are in fact colluding weirdly in their own self interests? Politicians are weird no matter in where they are.

  • Posted By: boscobear @ 01/08/2009 3:52:33 PM

    Let's keep one thing straight. This mess started when Hamas shot rockets into Isreal--israel wasn't shhoting rockets iat Hamas. Also Hamas places their rockets in civilian areas, so when they are hit, there will be civilan injuries and death. Also, if this were happening to my family, I would ask why it's happening? Why is Israel doing this? Is it because they eant to kill us? No, wait it is because Hamas is shooting at Isreal from the backyard next door. My next step would be to tell Hamas to stop and I would not support them.

    But this isn't happening and people need to ask why it isn't happening? Once this is answered, then perhaps there will be real and honest discussion on how to bring peace to this area.

    I also believe that peace will only come when the Arab women find strength, throw the yoke of hundreds of years of oppression/repression and open a can-of-whoop a_ _ on their husbands, brothers, sons ,fathers, and those idiots in the white turbans!

  • Posted By: yuuu2005 @ 01/08/2009 11:57:15 AM

    I'm upset that the poor suffering civilians of palestine are mere victims of the onging crisis in the middle east being masterminded by hammas,hazebollah and Iran.Nevertheless,I'm strongly in support of Isrealis defensive of her citizens.Only God almighty in heaven knew when and how mideast crisis will be resolved.The bible has the answer.the world can only manage it.Havent you heard the above terror group calling for the elimination of both the isrealis and jews from the surface of the eart? Their ignorance convinced them Isrealis were not created by God and therefore has no right of homeland and exixtence.Shame unto Hammas and Hazebollah.I wish they knew there'll be a judgement day.God said we should love and not send rocket to kill and destroy.God bless Isreal and the innocent people of Palestine.A lover of the word of God and peace.

  • Posted By: shahzeb1119 @ 01/08/2009 11:05:06 AM

    I fully support the Palistinians because it is my moral duty as a Muslim. Even though I live in Pakistan and am only 15, my heart breaks whenever I switch on the television and find that more and more innocent women and children are murdered. I also feel embarrassed of being an American Citizen because they are not taking any action against this act of genocide. I have always loved America and been proud of being American but this time it is different. Now i can only pray to Allah to bring peace and stability to the region.

  • Posted By: shahzeb1119 @ 01/08/2009 10:57:53 AM

    I fully support the Palistinians because it is my moral duty as a Muslim. Even though I live in Pakistan and am only 15, my heart breaks whenever I switch on the TV and find that 50,60, etc palistinians have been killed. Out of them most are women and children. I also fell embarrassed to be an American Citizen as America is not doing anything to stop this genocide. Now all I can do is pray to Allah to bring stability to the region

  • Posted By: Emmilly @ 01/08/2009 9:13:27 AM

    I think that despite this so called 'voices' article it is still extremely biased and there is no proof that you interviewed any Jewish Israelis.
    I believe that Israel is doing the right thing by protecting itself against the savage Arabs. Death and destruction can be seen on both sides - the difference is, is that the Israelis are trying to attack the coward militants who hide in the suburbs, while the Arabs by pass the soldiers and aim for citizens.

  • Posted By: LudwigVanBeet @ 01/08/2009 1:53:46 AM

    I wish Iran would go full speed ahead and manufacture one hundred Nuclear Bombs.

  • Posted By: cloudburst @ 01/07/2009 10:10:06 PM

    How can there be peace when one side (Hamas) is bent on exterminating the other side at the expense of its people? That's the only peace they believe in, meaning, when the other side is already gone..

  • Posted By: berenger1 @ 01/07/2009 9:29:08 PM

    Israel handed Arafat his Palestinian State on a gold platter at Camp David and he ran for the door. Israel pulled out of the West bank and Gaza and all they got for it was a terrorist training ground firing rockets at civilians in israel and hiding behind civilians in Gaza. The Grand Iranian Ayatolla the Islamic version of the Pope has made it clear they will not accept Israel right to exist and Western civilizations right to exist.There still stuck on Revenging the Crusades to which I say take it up with the Pope in Italy. The Brotherhood, Hamas, Hezbollah, Alkieda, and all the Other Wahabist groups and Ayatollas have made it clear also. 5000 thousand years before Muhammed was even born Israel was the land of the Jews. If you think I am a crazy extremist the charters of these Wahabist organizations are available to read.

  • Posted By: forjustice @ 01/07/2009 1:18:37 PM

    Chicken and egg game of blame and counterblame has to stop. Does it really matter who strikes first in a 50 year battle?
    If a military solution is wanted, then allow Hamas and other resitance fighters to import arms without restriction and then have a conventional war instead of Hams launching rockets on civilians because that is all they can do. Else, which is the civilized way, is to accept Hamas as elected representatives of the Palesitian people and then engage in talks. Remember at one time Samir and others were labelled as terrorists, PLO was viewed as a terrorist organization, and PLO and Egypt and others didn't recognize Israel either.

    • Posted By: gweg @ 01/07/2009 3:10:04 PM

      LOL in a WAR you do NOT give weapons to the other side or even allow them access to weapons that you can prevent them from having. Do you think Hitler would of stopped fighting long enough to move out the innocents in good ole Yellow France? LOL War may be hell but you don't allow the other side to do anything. War is never civilizied. The Gaza people elected hamas a terror group to be their politicians now they are paying the price.

      • Posted By: forjustice @ 01/07/2009 3:53:02 PM

        Unfortunately so did the Israelis, electing folks who will whatever nasty things it takes to get relected.

        • Posted By: gweg @ 01/07/2009 6:08:07 PM

          So now both sides are fighting and it should be as always winner take all...

  • Posted By: sjbrock80 @ 01/07/2009 5:32:35 PM

    My question is if Iran and Syria are such big Hamas backers, why aren't they doing anything right now? If Iran and Syria are so anti-Israeli, why aren't they helping the people they support?

    Iran, Syria, Hamas, and Hizbollah are a bunch of cowards. I couldn't care less about so-called war crimes or anything else. What I care about is that these big-mouthed nations and organizations fighting like they talk. If they're so dead set on Israel being wiped off the face of the earth, the do something!!!

    Iran and Syria, you are pathetic cowards.

  • Posted By: shakeyjake @ 01/07/2009 3:55:49 PM

    Let the turkeys gobble gobble all they want, this is exactly what we want, an all in out war! then we can get all the radical muslim is one centralized area and rid this world of them once and for all. this is their prophet Mohammed's, a child molester! he married a baby of 6 yrs old and consummated the marrigae when she was a little girl of 9 yrs old and that one we know of image the others?. Now what kind of GOD would annoint that marriage? only satan would (allah) the moon god look up the origins and muslims think this is ok, whats wrong with this picture??? people dont want a world war??? Islam is already at war with the world! ask spain, The U.S. china, india, africa, and so on, are people that blind? radical islam must be eliminated because thats what they are trying to do to us! any country that backs terrorist is our enemy, duh. and we should launch a military campaign against them. Russia will stay out of it and with the powers that be we can eradicate islam.

  • Posted By: ma.cormack @ 01/07/2009 2:25:26 PM

    Israel is a 'rogue state' which habitually violates International Law, possesses weapons of mass destruction and practises 'state terrorism'
    There has been NO CHANGE from the Tony Blair 'Cabal' which manoeuvred and manipulated for a criminal war against Iraq, colluded and was compliant in letting Israel continue the Lebanon War in 2006 and Gordon Brown and David Miliband have done similarly in their 'blocking' the two proposed UN resolutions so far to call for an immediate ceasefire! Gordon Brown and David Miliband's response to the crisis so far has been pathetic and wholly incompetent. Once again the British People's Christian Values have been Betrayed in this UNHOLY ALLIANCE with the other two parties in this AXIS OF EVIL the US and ISRAEL.
    Gordon Brown and David Miliband must be asked to resign!

    • Posted By: gweg @ 01/07/2009 3:42:03 PM

      What is internatinal law? lol There is only laws by force... or laws of the individual country... Israel may very well possess wmp's but their never show them nor do they use them against anyone. Who cares...

      The UN is a worthless organization and only there to make the sheep think they can be heard. Lands that were taken from the anchestors or Israel were taken back in the two Israel wars in the 40's n 60's. The Palastinian people have no actual claim to the land as it wasn't theirs in the first place. Then they lost it just as theyir anchestors took it earlier. Then the UN gets into the middle and claims they can make Inter- national laws to force people to believe in. What rubish is that... As to making UN laws when only the one side is held to them... then no one should believe that they are just even let alone in a legal position. When the Hamas idiots hide in mosques, puyt there weapons there than those places are targets. Don't cry foul when they get the *** blown out of them.

      Also the UN security council has NO power to uphold a resolution as when Isreal is fighting terrorists as the UN is not even in it. Now Each side in the council knows this and is only looking to score points within the worthless organization. The UN is just like it's earlier counterparts... and will never be nothing but a political name calling farce.

      Don't worry abouut Brown or Milbrand as they are just using politics as usual. There is no Christian or muslim values in any country so you can't us that. Look at the facts, religioin is the cause of most all wars accross the years of man's existence. If there was a god be he christian or muslim, do you actual believe he would look down and let this crap go on from his subjects. Man writes their book of god and goes to war for them what a load of crap.

      Their is no Axis of evil only evil men and they come in all sha;des and colors. Those are the ones who need to be destroyed... The ones that torture their own and or other countries peoples.

      • Posted By: abbreviate @ 01/07/2009 3:54:12 PM

        You are talking about Guantanamo Bay detention camp, right?

  • Posted By: forjustice @ 01/07/2009 1:10:44 PM

    Civilized world must uphold civilized principles, for example, not killing unarmed people collectively, but legally prosecute the perpetrators and then punish them if proven guilty. Otherwise, what is the diffrence between Isareli Army kiliing unarmed Gazans and Hamas launching rockets on Israeli civilians? Supposedly both are in self defense and with the intention of exterminating the other?

    • Posted By: gweg @ 01/07/2009 3:04:55 PM

      Israel is not sending missiles at innocent people they send missiles at Hamas members who are attacking them from behind the civilians. Human sheilds are a bad tactic but the sheep eyed people of the middle east refuse to look at what hamas is doing. Even Now Hamas has been caught and reported by Palistinians who saw and reported the militants firing from the street right in front of the UN site. Ap confirmed this also with the mobile phones from gaza.

  • Posted By: gweg @ 01/07/2009 12:14:05 PM

    People,Today we have more proof that Hamas is using the Palestinian people as human shields again. Witnesses have come forward and stated to AP by phones from the UN school site that they did. Does the Arab nations care at all. the answer is NO. Do they acknowledge it NO. Do they call that a so called war crime NO. Seems funny to me that the Arab nations only acknowledge what they perceive as helpful. another thing there is NO proportionate response in war times. there is NO time to stop and set up food lines either. In WWII people hid as best they could and took protection as well as they could for their families. Today we have HAMAS a TERRORIST ORG the Palestinians voted in to lead them HIDING in civilian clothes and from behind the civilians used as shields than publishing picture they take to make other unsuspecting sheep take up their side. People Don't be a sheep!

    • Posted By: abbreviate @ 01/07/2009 12:35:58 PM

      So, anytime terrorists use innocent people as a shield we should not distinguish who is who but just kill them all. Nice. I think you should be coauthor to Americanpatriot911

      • Posted By: brian12354 @ 01/07/2009 2:57:18 PM

        Maybe if Israel have used hand hammered rockets delivered by an elephant train from Pakistan so that the use of force would be more equal then everyone would be happy?

      • Posted By: shakeyjake @ 01/07/2009 12:50:02 PM

        abbreviate,
        The palestinians elected these thugs and agree to be used as sheilds, eradicate them all? Yes! and be done with them. You see it is the equivalent to having retards in the goverment. yes, they dont have the capacity to do so, their only objective is to figure out a way to destroy Israel. Remove them is the only solution.

  • Posted By: Rastafari7 @ 01/07/2009 1:07:33 PM

    ???Throughout history, it has been the inaction of those who could have acted; the indifference of those who should have known better; the silence of the voice of justice when it mattered most; that has made it possible for evil to triumph.???

    Emperor Haile Selassie I

    • Posted By: shakeyjake @ 01/07/2009 1:43:31 PM

      one world ,
      would'nt you police your border if your neighbors wanted to use children as suicide bombers to kill you?
      what are 5 yrs old, hamas wants to kill all of Israel. period.
      now you answer me. What is hamas?

      • Posted By: one world @ 01/07/2009 1:49:24 PM

        u are not making any sense...I like how you are believing everything u read about the little children that are being sent to blow ppl up....did u know santa is real right...LOL....whatever dude....try an education it helps.

        • Posted By: shakeyjake @ 01/07/2009 1:54:05 PM

          one world.
          Education or not, the palestininas are being pumeled to death as it should be because it's happening! they thought they would bring in hamas to fix things, what a joke! no peace. The machine is broken and it needs to be fixed! end of story.

          • Posted By: abbreviate @ 01/07/2009 2:43:56 PM

            obviously shakeyjake has only one brain cell in his head. Join the other authors of "New Mein Kampf"

            • Posted By: shakeyjake @ 01/07/2009 2:54:22 PM

              abbreviate,
              i won't take offense to your comment as you have that right as wrong as you are and you opinion is appreciated somewhere in the world, nevertheless it does'nt change the matter at hand does it? so kick back and watch the palestinians get cremed for the poor decisions theres really nothing you can do about it as for me im all for war without there can be no peace! the bigger the war the more peace can be acheived. you see throughout history war has solved more issue than any other factor. thank you..

  • Posted By: forjustice @ 01/07/2009 2:22:06 PM

    Religion is the most divisive thing among human beings. By definition, you blindly believe in your version of God. And since your belief nullifies other religions as "untruth", you end up with an extremely intolerant view of humanity and keep rationalizing all actions in the name of your "can vener be proven to be the true" religious belief. On this basis, I find it absurd that a modern democracy like Israel can be based on a religion (without any offense to the Jewish faith!). I do believe people of Jewish faith have historically been tormented but I am not sure why you need a Jewish state (people of Jewsih faith have done exceedibngly well in the USA and so have people of other faith including the Musilims). As a human being withiut prejudice, how can I buy the argument that "God" gave a specific piece of land to people of any particular faith; this claim cab never be proven right or wrong. If the claim were to hold court, then the natives should rule the USA as they could claim their God promised them the land of USA. In other words, states rooted in divine claims, like Isarel, do not make any sense to me. By the same token, the claims of Hamas that there cannot be a state with Jewish predominance in the land of Palestine, does not make any sense either.

    What makes sense is a state where the citizens are known not by their religion, but by their willingness to live together within a commons state, with mutual respect of course. So I propose that Isarel and Palestinian territories be combined into one territory (cal it Holy Land) and then Holy Land be a terrotory of the USA, like Dominican Republic.

    • Posted By: shakeyjake @ 01/07/2009 2:34:00 PM

      for justice,
      it's obvious either side see's thing "your way" and i see your point. but to the guys on either side they are standing by their beliefs and thats what this war is all about you cant make them understand, so just sit back and watch it all unfold. And your opinion is appreciated.

  • Posted By: ma.cormack @ 01/07/2009 2:25:04 PM

    Israel is a 'rogue state' which habitually violates International Law, possesses weapons of mass destruction and practises 'state terrorism'
    There has been NO CHANGE from the Tony Blair 'Cabal' which manoeuvred and manipulated for a criminal war against Iraq, colluded and was compliant in letting Israel continue the Lebanon War in 2006 and Gordon Brown and David Miliband have done similarly in their 'blocking' the two proposed UN resolutions so far to call for an immediate ceasefire! Gordon Brown and David Miliband's response to the crisis so far has been pathetic and wholly incompetent. Once again the British People's Christian Values have been Betrayed in this UNHOLY ALLIANCE with the other two parties in this AXIS OF EVIL the US and ISRAEL.
    Gordon Brown and David Miliband must be asked to resign!

  • Posted By: one world @ 01/07/2009 11:43:56 AM

    I am commenting to Drews post....retards out there....what are we 3 years old...we name call...ur scenerio is absurd...first of all its not like hamas is just sitting there lobbing missles just because they want to....they are being occupied...yes israel has left gaza...or have they...they still control the air, sea, and land...its a prison...they shut crossings, there are shortage of jobs, food, u know essential things....its hell for them.....b4 u start criticising ppl for speaking out why don't u stop lying to yourself about the realities on the ground and realize that israel is still the occupier....that is so funny that ppl blame the occupeid for this whole thing.....madness i say...pure madness

    • Posted By: DrewCAENG @ 01/07/2009 12:00:07 PM

      I understand what your saying one word, but understand that Hamas wont even allow their own citizens to speak out agaisnt them. You have to look deeper then just bullying vs civilians. Hamas refuses to accept Israel, how are they suposed to live next to each other? The Gaza prison as you call it ( with SOME justification) is a result of Hamas terror campaign agasint Isreal. Israeli people have been living in fear of rocket attacks daily for years is that okay too simply because they are innaccurate? AND Once again can you or anybody offer any other suggestions ... I didnt think so.

      And the name calling was a result of what was said to me first. History and facts help to reveal the truth not just sad images on TV

      • Posted By: one world @ 01/07/2009 1:57:02 PM

        here is the suggestion...........palestinians live side by side with israelis in israel proper. They live in Haifa for instance with no problems.....so what needs to happen is the 2 state solution or allowing the palestinians live with the israelis in israel...make the west bank and gaza part of israel. what I find funny is israel wants israel for israelis ONLY and claim that they are a democratic country...hmmmm how does that work....

        • Posted By: DrewCAENG @ 01/07/2009 2:14:13 PM

          Where is your evidence that Israelis wont live side by side with Arabs ? In 1948 the UN slcied up the country with two equal sides and Jersulem in the middle as an interntational city. The Jews agreed the Arabs didnt, plain and simple . Try reading some history smart guy! And how can you maje the statement that the jews wontlive with the Arabs when it is the Arabs calling for the destruction of the Jewish state? Your need a nice kick in the jaw to wake you up!

          And to the post below. Before rthe Arabs had Palestine they took it fom the Jews, Babalonians, Persians, etc etc etc it has gone back and forth for thousands of years. I

  • Posted By: one world @ 01/07/2009 1:44:34 PM

    that is so right forjustice....I am glad their are scholars in here!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse