MIDDLE EAST

Hamas and Its Discontents

Charges and countercharges about who's responsible for civilian deaths in Gaza.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: kraznet @ 03/07/2009 9:28:54 PM

    As the Wall Street Journal wrote on May 6th,
    "For reasons both telling and mysterious, Israel has become unpopular among that segment of public opinion that calls itself progressive. This is the same progressive segment that believes in women's rights, gay rights, the rights to a fair trial and to appeal, freedom of speech and conscience, judicial checks on parliamentary authority. These are rights that exist in Israel and nowhere else in the Middle East. So why is it that the country that is most sympathetic to progressive values gets the least of progressive sympathies?"

    it is therefore very strange that, because of their rabid anti Israel views, these progressives have turned into apologists for Islamic fundamentalists (such as hamas and hezbollah) who loath and despise every progressive belief that these folks hold dear.

    if peace were ever to exist, palestine or even worse the "one state solution" (which would result in the demographic destruction of the state of israel) would be just another arab cesspool, where women are despised and oppressed, other religions disrespected (and forbidden) and gay people murdered.

    in Israel gay marriage is already recognized and NOW,
    Overseas adoptions by gay couples get OK from Israel
    United Press International (4/25)

    To support the Palestinian Cause is to be anti women, anti gay and anti democracy.

    Finally, To focus so much attention on the Palestinians at the expense of the genocide in Darfur (Muslim killing Muslim), the Muslim on Muslim violence in Iraq, the executions of Muslim gay teens in Iran, the violence towards women in Iran--(just for showing their hair), the sentences of stoning or beatings for rape victims in both Nigeria and Saudi Arabia (where woman are also forbidden to drive), The burning to death of young girls in a school in Saudi Arabia, as the religious police would not allow male fireman to save them, because the girls were not wearing their burkahs, the epidemic of honor killings by brothers and fathers of young girls in both Britain, Canada and Turkey is not only morally reprehensible but indefensible.

  • Posted By: GirlAroundTheCorner @ 02/23/2009 8:10:49 PM

    Zoom out, guys
    9/11 is not over yet. All of us would like to get a better news, but, unfortunately, we should deal with the reality.
    We all should face the fact - fanatic islamists centered around Iran are building WORLD-WIDE CALIPHATE.
    This is a huge project and 9/11 is just a small part of it.
    Look around:
    11 March 2004 Madrid Spain train bombings consisted of a series of coordinated train bombings,
    killing 191 people and wounding 1,800. The official investigation by the Spanish Judiciary determined the attacks were directed by a muslim al-Qaeda-inspired terrorist cell.
    The bombings occurred three days before general elections which resulted in the defeat of the incumbent Jose Maria Aznar's Partido Popular (PP) party
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/11_March_2004_Madrid_train_bombings - SPAIN RIGHT GOVERNMENT WAS EXCHANGED BY LEFT GOVERNMENT IN A SINGLE BLAST!
    Islamists government took over in Turkey. Millions of muslims invaded Europe penetrating all democratic institutions which is the part of the plan. Many more facts could be mentioned, BUT:

    2 weeks ago Iran launched a missile and succeeded to get to the orbit. Thousands of Iranian centrifuges are spinning 24x7 enriching uranium - Iranian ambitions aimed to the nuke.
    Iran circles Israel with Hamas and Hesbollah which in fact are Iranian divisions trained, armed and fully directed by Iran.
    Would you feel safe with Iranian nukes with global ballistic capabilities? Fanatical Islam loves death, especially death of Crusaders and, of course, Jews. So, we - you and us - should make choices and time is limited.
    Political correctness hides the inconvenient truth, leftists prefer to be fooled by islamists who know well that the greatest lies said million of times will be taken as a truth.
    Take a look - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i08L09V0_sg

  • Posted By: GirlAroundTheCorner @ 02/23/2009 8:02:12 PM

    ISLAMISTS BUILD WORLD-WIDE CALIPHATE - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i08L09V0_sg

    ISLAMISTS GENOCIDE IN DARFUR - over 400,000 brutally murdered, over 2,500,000 people displaced refugees. More than one hundred people die each day; five thousand die every month - NOBODY CRYING..
    WHERE ARE YOU HUMANITY LOVERS?
    WHAT ABOUT THAT? - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYc7sXAUzCg

    SAME OIL MONEY FEED HAMAS - TO KILL JEWS AND TO SCREAM AGAINGT JEWS
    WHY? AS SCREAMING AGAINST JEWS HIDES THE TRUTH -
    ISLAMISTS BUILD WORLD-WIDE CALIPHATE - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i08L09V0_sg

    WHAT IS GOOD FOR ISLAM IS GOOD. WHAT IS BAD FOR ISLAM IS BAD

  • Posted By: DONGSKHIE @ 02/01/2009 1:02:43 PM

    To MS. JOANNA CHEN, THANK YOU !! Hope that this article will provide a crystal clear view of what transfired during the Israel Hamas war. And WHOS to blame for the civilians death,= innocent or supporters of Hamas.

  • Posted By: yusufbulbul @ 01/31/2009 4:24:42 PM

    Was it mistake to kill that many civilians, childrens ? Some kind of unfortunate side effects of the war as Rice stated.
    Or ultimate goal. You will not be able to able to believe when you read this link http://www.israelnationalnews.com/Articles/Article.aspx/8503 . If anyone would express this kind of sickness from muslims, they would be forever in Guantanamo. Please kindly read this article to understand the real motive behind IDF, Israel Government and the supporters.

  • Posted By: Sooriamoorthy @ 01/30/2009 8:28:36 AM

    This article is basically flawed;Israel never declared ,nor did it ever implement any ceasefire.Saying this is not tantamount to being pro-Hamas,or anti-Israel..Let's face the facts and the truth: Israel is an illegal creation, rendered possible by Britain mainly.
    the attitudes of both the Palestinians and the Israelis are understandable, except that Israel regularly acts as an aggressor and shamelessly argues self-defence.
    There can only be one solution, the one adopted by South Africa.Imperfect as it is , it is the lesser evil any intelligent person can opt for.

    • Posted By: Etiquette @ 01/31/2009 1:28:10 PM

      Thank God there are still honest people who can speak facts, reality and truth on the face.

  • Posted By: ross1972 @ 01/30/2009 7:29:53 AM

    ISTANBUL, January 27 (Compass Direct News) ??? After her arrest at Cairo???s airport on Dec. 13 while attempting to flee anti-Christian hostilities in Egypt, convert Martha Samuel Makkar was granted bail on Saturday (Jan. 24), but not before a judge took her aside and said he would like to kill her, according to her lawyer.
    Attorney Nadia Tawfiq said Judge Abdelaa Hashem questioned Makkar extensively about her Christian faith during the hearing. Makkar, charged with forging identification documents, explained her reasons for her conversion, avowing her Christian faith and repudiating the judge???s claims that converting from Islam to Christianity was impossible.
    ???Then he said, ???I want to talk with Martha alone,??? so we all left the room, and he said to her, ???Nobody changes from Muslim to Christian ??? you are a Muslim,?????? Tawfiq said. ???And she said, ???No, I am a Christian.??? He told her, ???If I had a knife now, I would kill you.??? [Makkar] came out crying and depressed, but at least he gave the decision to let her go free.???

    Courtesy Dhimmi Watch

  • Posted By: cangat @ 01/30/2009 6:23:07 AM

    The problem with Palestine is so complex that no party is totally right or totally wrong. Can you imagine how many Arabs are living in the world and in that region and how many Israelis? I don't think that any Arabic country, or at least their dictators, have any real intention to help to solve the Palestine problem. Even the Palestine leaders including Arafat have responsibility in todays situation and I don't think that they are really unhappy with that.

    Every regime needs enemies, and Israel should be kept as an enemy to keep their position and dictatorship. Mobarak in Egypt, Kaddafi in Lybia, the Sheichs in Saudi Arabia, Esad in Syria, Abdollah in Jordan, the mullas in Iran are happy today seeing the killings in Palestine.

    Israel would be right in defending itself, if they would accept the results of the free elections in Gaza and not have kidnapped the elected leaders of Hamas and keep the ambargo to the Gaza strip although they had promised and agreed on cancelling it. By the way, it was the one and only free election in the Arabic world!

    Can you imagine that you are trapped within several kilometers, don't have anything to eat and drink, unless Israel allows it? Cannot travel to any part of the world unless your neighbour country allows it, cannot get proper education, cannot get proper health service, most of your leader you have elected have been kidnapped by your neighbour country and nobody in the world is caring about this, nobody listens to you? What would you do?

    Imagine that, your land you have been living and planting has been taken by some imigrants, who come from different parts of the world, and nobody is listening to you, what would you do?

    Imagine that, the ones who occupy your land, which belong to your fathers ( I mean not the recognised borders, but the internationally recognised palestine land) have every weapon including nukes and you don't have anything but home made rockets and some small arms, what would you do?

    Imagine that your home is bombed by every king of ammonution, killing your baby, killing your wife although you don't have anything to do with politics just because your neighbour is a member of a party, what would you do?

    Imagine that you don't have anything to loose but your life and you don't see any future and your hate is growing and growing against the ones who you see as responsible for that, what would you do?

    If you can answer these questions independently of thinking about religion or race, than perhaps you can understand that it is not easy to define terrorism sometimes.

    I don't think that the killings will end there, and I don't see any peace in the future unless the world and especially USA gets involved. But keeping this problem as it is makes it also possible to keep the so called enemy, the islamic terrorism. And as I said, every regime needs enemies, even the western world.

    Peace V

  • Posted By: DavidBaltimore @ 01/21/2009 8:29:48 PM

    Lets look at the big picture here: what purpose does this attack serve? Did Israel get rid of Hamas? No! Will it stop rockets? No! Will it stop Palestinians voting for Hamas? No! Will Palestinians feel a deeper hatred for Israel because it destroyed their country and killed them? Yes. Then, what was the purpose of this attack? What goal did Israel achieve? Does Israel really want peace, or does it prefer constant low-level warfare with its neighbors?

    • Posted By: nilay5687 @ 01/29/2009 10:56:13 PM

      the Jihadis are like wild dogs. you can't even give them a state with a proper military and pure autonomy. They will just begin their plot to destroy the state of Israel. There is no Israeli incursion without Hamas firing rockets. What did they expect? They knew this is what Israel would do. Hamas will sacrifice their own people to villify the Jews. I read it earlier, there are three things that would give the Palestinians their own state, and they will not comply with ANY of them. The Israeli response was obviously disproportionate, but any country would do the same. Is it so hard to recognize Israel. A country the size of New Hampshire. You can call me a mouthpiece or whatever, but recognize that there are steps the Palestinian people can take to secure peace, but they will not take them. Ever heard of peaceful resistance. Worked for South Africa, worked for India against the Brits. Try it and you may sway public opinion, but as long as they suicide bomb and fire rockets on civilians they will continue to villify themselves

    • Posted By: nilay5687 @ 01/29/2009 10:55:39 PM

      the Jihadis are like wild dogs. you can't even give them a state with a proper military and pure autonomy. They will just begin their plot to destroy the state of Israel. There is no Israeli incursion without Hamas firing rockets. What did they expect? They knew this is what Israel would do. Hamas will sacrifice their own people to villify the Jews. I read it earlier, there are three things that would give the Palestinians their own state, and they will not comply with ANY of them. The Israeli response was obviously disproportionate, but any country would do the same. Is it so hard to recognize Israel. A country the size of New Hampshire. You can call me a mouthpiece or whatever, but recognize that there are steps the Palestinian people can take to secure peace, but they will not take them. Ever heard of peaceful resistance. Worked for South Africa, worked for India against the Brits. Try it and you may sway public opinion, but as long as they suicide bomb and fire rockets on civilians they will continue to villify themselves

    • Posted By: paranoid5687 @ 01/29/2009 10:53:23 PM

      the Jihadis are like wild dogs. you can't even give them a state with a proper military and pure autonomy. They will just begin their plot to destroy the state of Israel. There is no Israeli incursion without Hamas firing rockets. What did they expect? They knew this is what Israel would do. Hamas will sacrifice their own people to villify the Jews. I read it earlier, there are three things that would give the Palestinians their own state, and they will not comply with ANY of them. The Israeli response was obviously disproportionate, but any country would do the same. Is it so hard to recognize Israel. A country the size of New Hampshire. You can call me a mouthpiece or whatever, but recognize that there are steps the Palestinian people can take to secure peace, but they will not take them. Ever heard of peaceful resistance. Worked for South Africa, worked for India against the Brits. Try it and you may sway public opinion, but as long as they suicide bomb and fire rockets on civilians they will continue to villify themselves

    • Posted By: freeordie0512 @ 01/29/2009 10:52:10 PM

      the Jihadis are like wild dogs. you can't even give them a state with a proper military and pure autonomy. They will just begin their plot to destroy the state of Israel. There is no Israeli incursion without Hamas firing rockets. What did they expect? They knew this is what Israel would do. Hamas will sacrifice their own people to villify the Jews. I read it earlier, there are three things that would give the Palestinians their own state, and they will not comply with ANY of them. The Israeli response was obviously disproportionate, but any country would do the same. Is it so hard to recognize Israel. A country the size of New Hampshire. You can call me a mouthpiece or whatever, but recognize that there are steps the Palestinian people can take to secure peace, but they will not take them. Ever heard of peaceful resistance. Worked for South Africa, worked for India against the Brits. Try it and you may sway public opinion, but as long as they suicide bomb and fire rockets on civilians they will continue to villify themselves

    • Posted By: freeordie5687 @ 01/29/2009 10:50:47 PM

      the Jihadis are like wild dogs. you can't even give them a state with a proper military and pure autonomy. They will just begin their plot to destroy the state of Israel. There is no Israeli incursion without Hamas firing rockets. What did they expect? They knew this is what Israel would do. Hamas will sacrifice their own people to villify the Jews. I read it earlier, there are three things that would give the Palestinians their own state, and they will not comply with ANY of them. The Israeli response was obviously disproportionate, but any country would do the same. Is it so hard to recognize Israel. A country the size of New Hampshire. You can call me a mouthpiece or whatever, but recognize that there are steps the Palestinian people can take to secure peace, but they will not take them. Ever heard of peaceful resistance. Worked for South Africa, worked for India against the Brits. Try it and you may sway public opinion, but as long as they suicide bomb and fire rockets on civilians they will continue to villify themselves

    • Posted By: freeordie5687 @ 01/29/2009 10:48:43 PM

      the Jihadis are like wild dogs. you can't even give them a state with a proper military and pure autonomy. They will just begin their plot to destroy the state of Israel. There is no Israeli incursion without Hamas firing rockets. What did they expect? They knew this is what Israel would do. Hamas will sacrifice their own people to villify the Jews. I read it earlier, there are three things that would give the Palestinians their own state, and they will not comply with ANY of them. The Israeli response was obviously disproportionate, but any country would do the same. Is it so hard to recognize Israel. A country the size of New Hampshire. You can call me a mouthpiece or whatever, but recognize that there are steps the Palestinian people can take to secure peace, but they will not take them. Ever heard of peaceful resistance. Worked for South Africa, worked for India against the Brits. Try it and you may sway public opinion, but as long as they suicide bomb and fire rockets on civilians they will continue to villify themselves

  • Posted By: John43 @ 01/29/2009 12:04:12 PM

    Who is responsible for civilian deaths in Gaza? This is easy - George Bush. His policies created an environment where the only course that Hamas had was to fire rocket. They did this to get attention to the fact that they were starving and had no medical or other serves. Notice that 6 months of rocket firing and no Israeli's were killed, Hamas has been aiming at unpopulate areas. Bush set this up so his por-Israeli cronies could profit from weapons sales to the IDF, the munitions you saw on TV that were illegal phosphoros were of US manufacture. These were sent specifically by the Bush administration to torture innocent civilians, burning them to death with chemical agents. Obama immediatly called for the return of any unused weapons, and gave a speach about it. His words inspired Hamas and others, once Goerge Mitchell arrived in Daza all will CHANGE. The answer to all this Bush evil has arrived.

  • Posted By: KostasK @ 01/28/2009 7:42:29 AM

    @ Clear Thinking:
    1. Israel does surround them, why do you say that it doesn't? Israel never stopped the control of peope and goods in and out of Gaza since their "pulout" in 2005, or the control of the air and sea of Gaza. They even deny humanitarian access to Gaza by boat, through international waters! Moreover they control their water and energy resources. And this blockade and seizure of Gaza for 18months now is what brought the population to the brinks of starvation, before the Israeli December attacks.
    2.Let's suppose they want to "become citizens if they desire it". In which state? Israel? Well, Israel defines itself as a "Jewish state" and even bans Arabs from taking part in its elections. If that isn't apartheid combined with theocracy then what is it?. Or have you seen a Palestinian State, sovereign, with control of its land and resources were they can apply for a citizenship? This is, or should be, the goal of all peace efforts but how can it be implemented while Israel occupies their land (and kills them in it)?
    3. We blame Israel for what Israel itself has done and does and not for what the rest of the Arabs did or didn't.

    • Posted By: John43 @ 01/29/2009 11:25:36 AM

      Part of Gaza's border is with Egypt. They are about as keen to keep the Palestinians out as the Israelis are. Millions of Palistinians live in other Arab countries as refugees - no right to vote, living in squalor etc. Other Arabs see them as merely a stick to beat the Israelis with - note: Arabs nations that have made peace with Israel are the least likely to help the Palistinians. You don't see any of the locals, Egypt, Jordan doing anything to help them -they just want them to go away.

  • Posted By: carledgar @ 01/28/2009 9:15:45 PM

    Its a WAR, dude...........

  • Posted By: memo2 @ 01/28/2009 8:06:03 PM

    Killing innocent Women and Children is Wrong in this war you right but war is war we all know and any war is Wrong.
    but peoples mind is like that who is going to change it no one the only one can stop this is our Planet were we live if some thing happens then we all stop.

  • Posted By: ross1972 @ 01/28/2009 4:07:40 PM

    Muslims want you to make way for Islam, but Islam does not make way for you.

    The government insists that you respect Islam, but Islam has no respect for you.

    Islam wants to rule, submit, and seeks to destroy our western civilization.

    In 1945, Nazism was defeated in Europe. In 1989, Communism was defeated in Europe.

    Now the Islamic ideology has to be defeated.

    Stop Islamisation.
    Defend our freedom.

    ~Geert Wilders' "Fitna"

  • Posted By: tired and old @ 01/28/2009 1:05:11 PM

    COWARDLY TERRORISTS ( HAMAS ) ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE KILLING OF THEIR PEOPLE.

    HAMAS WILL ONLY CHANGE FOR THE BETTER , WHEN THEY ARE REMOVED FROM PLANET EARTH.

    ISRAEL SHOULD DEPEND ON SELF PROTECTION, ISRAEL SHOULD USE EXCESSIVE FORCE AGAINST CRIMINAL MURDERING COWARDLY TERRORISTS AT ALL TIMES.

    HAPPY ! TO READ THEY USED AN AIRSTRIKE AGAINST TERRORIST COWARDLY HAMAS AFTER BEING BOMBED TESTERDAY.

    KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK ISRAEL. HOPE YOU BOMB IRAN SOON.

  • Posted By: memo2 @ 01/26/2009 7:38:11 AM

    Just my comment:
    Hamas are responsible for all civilian deaths in Gaza, We all new this will be happen in Gaza.
    Why Hamas people push to destroy their City.

    • Posted By: newtral @ 01/28/2009 2:00:35 AM

      Who destroy gaza city? Hamas? Are you blind? Deaf?

  • Posted By: ClearThinking @ 01/27/2009 9:57:23 PM

    Why are these poor people isolated in camps? Israel doesn't surround them, does it? What have they been doing since 1967, or 1948? We have had many refugees from war come to the US and we don't put them in camps. We allow them to get education and jobs, and eventually become citizens if they desire it. It seems like their Arab hosts could have been helping them all along but they haven't. Why not? Why is it only Israel's fault that these people are disenfranchised?

    Wasn't it the Arab coalition that was preparing to attack Israel in 1967 the ones who forced the local inhabitants of the West Bank and Gaza to evacuate so they would not get in the way of the mighty Arab armies? It seems like the fair thing would be for those attacking countries to host the refugees in a civilized manner. But that is not the case. Is it really because these "moderate" Arab states also fear Hamas and other Iranian influenced extremist organizations themselves?

  • Posted By: ClearThinking @ 01/27/2009 9:57:11 PM

    Why are these poor people isolated in camps? Israel doesn't surround them, does it? What have they been doing since 1967, or 1948? We have had many refugees from war come to the US and we don't put them in camps. We allow them to get education and jobs, and eventually become citizens if they desire it. It seems like their Arab hosts could have been helping them all along but they haven't. Why not? Why is it only Israel's fault that these people are disenfranchised?

    Wasn't it the Arab coalition that was preparing to attack Israel in 1967 the ones who forced the local inhabitants of the West Bank and Gaza to evacuate so they would not get in the way of the mighty Arab armies? It seems like the fair thing would be for those attacking countries to host the refugees in a civilized manner. But that is not the case. Is it really because these "moderate" Arab states also fear Hamas and other Iranian influenced extremist organizations themselves?

  • Posted By: Ten10 @ 01/26/2009 9:23:24 PM

    I'm disgusted at the last comment. If anyone says it's terrible for the Israeli soldiers to shoot kids in front of their parents, people bring up the term "antisemitism".
    It now seems like Israels use this term to get away with murder..and that just is NOT RIGHT.
    FYI, Palestinians are from the race that is considered semites. What the Israelis are doing is considered antisemitic.
    Shame on those who label people as antisemites for saying cold heartedly murdering children is wrong!!

  • Posted By: khasroo29 @ 01/25/2009 11:21:26 PM

    Its not time to fix the responsibility on either Israel or Hamas for the useless killing of innocent people in Gaza. All should try their best to mitigate the suffering of homeless, foodless, sick people in Gaza. Think of hungry,malnutrited sick children and people spending days and nights in the open air.The hospitals are without medicines and facilities. Is it time for politics or the funny behaviour like that of BBC on if they can air appeal for help for the Gazan homeless people?

    The world is watching over TV the condition of the hapless people in Gaza. But vast majority of the watchers are helpless and powerless to do anything for them.

    The world powers too are watching and have known much more through their apparatus. But they have never been willing or interested to go to the deep of why this situation persist and resolve the dispute? The countries in the region have failed for more than 60 years to come to an understanding and as a result the poor innocent people have become victims of killing and suffering.

    Right and wrong & Justice and injustice have only one defintion. What is fair to you is also fair to others. So bad is bad for everyone. In the past we have seen the world was divided into two camps, the US and Russaia. But things over the years have changed and US is the only superpower of the day and it is now trying to regain the moral high ground lost over years. President Obama has appointed Senator Mitchel as mideast envoy. Hopefully the new administration is sincere in its efforts. It may not be out of context to organize a joint meeting of organizations like Vatican (Representing the Christians),OIC & Representing the Muslims) and the Orgnization representing the Jews. To all of them the region is sacred.

    I am a muslim and we beleive and have faith in Moses & Jesus are our prophet so does the Christians and Jews and to my knowledge Jerusalem is equally sacred to all the three faiths, Christian, Jews & Muslim. All we need to consider that we are human being first and Christian, Jews and Muslim later and are decendents of Adam and Eve. Why should we fight amongst ourselves, who is getting killed surely another brother and sister.?

    Is it not time forget the past and work for a better future when there will be no poverty, hunger and injustice.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse