SPONSORED BY:

Slum Voyeurism?

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

For me, the slums were so extraordinary. This is something that's very difficult to convey. I think when you go, if you don't know the city, as I didn't, part of you expects abject poverty. And what you find, of course, is an extraordinary energy of life there. People on all sorts of levels are all working, doing bits of business. You sense a kind of resilience against all odds. It's really breathtaking. As a filmmaker, I wanted to try and capture that energy, as well as show the circumstances in which people are forced to live. But despite that [the people] are extraordinary. I hesitate to use the word inspiring because you would be foolish to use that word about it, but on a human level, it is inspiring. If we could all live our lives as resourcefully as people with so little do! Whereas we [in the developed world] live in such luxury, yet complain about things and moan about things. There are people who are making the most of themselves in very limited circumstances.

Do you worry that the movie will face a stronger backlash in India? Have you taken any legal precautions?
No, not legal. Our priority at the moment is the children, and what they've been exposed to.

The child actors?
Yes, the young actors, especially the two that come from very poor backgrounds. We are working hard to try to protect them both. We have been for a long time, in terms of their long-term educational plan, but also what's happening now with the press following them. I also worry about any kind of violence, anybody getting hurt. In terms of furor, criticism, debate, you realize that part of your responsibilities as a very privileged person, as a filmmaker, is to stand up and be counted if you're proud of the film. You listen to what people have to say about it, and I'm proud to do that.

How long did you spend in Mumbai?
I spent about a year there, and was there permanently for eight months: five months preparation and then approximately three months filming. As soon as you touch India, specifically Mumbai, you feel electric, in good ways and bad ways. A pulse just charges through you. That hasn't changed since we started the film. I feel more alive than I've ever felt in my career.

It sounds like India had a huge impact on you. Can you just walk away from it?
Well, you can get on a plane, but you can't walk away from it. It's always going to be with you.

Do you think you will make another movie set in India?
I would love to make a thriller in the city. We made basically a picaresque film with elements of a thriller, romance, comedy. But all the time you're there, you're thinking, this would be the most extraordinary place for a thriller. Some of my favorite films actually used that element of the city; my three favorite films are "Satya," "Company" and "Black Friday." So I would love to do that. I don't think I'll do it next—it probably wouldn't be wise for me to do it next. But I would love to do it. I've begun talking to a couple of people about that idea.

Do you have your Oscar speech prepared in case you win?
[Laughs.] This is a wonderful opportunity: because the film features Benjamin Franklin—he's in the bit where the kid gets the [$100] note—I can use his great quote, that "Nothing is certain in life except death and taxes." To which I would add, "and law cases and protests." We've had an extraordinary reception and been given some extraordinary awards. You have to make sure that you thank the right people, but that comes from your heart, really, rather than too much preparation. So, no.

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
Visions of a Decade
Visions of a Decade

From 2000-2009, one photo per month.

The Failure of Copenhagen
The Failure of Copenhagen

Why there could be a silver lining in a failed climate treaty.

Sex Scandals of the 2000s
Sex Scandals of the 2000s

From John Edwards to Mark Sanford, the decade's memorable affairs.

118 Days in Hell
118 Days in Hell

A NEWSWEEK journalist recounts his captivity in Iran.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: camilo3@msn.com @ 04/08/2009 8:34:24 PM

    I was totally surprised ! I never expected such a Great Film to come out of a City of Slum ! So realistic, yet so sublime ! I could not believe the raw impact of some of the magnificent and moving scenes from the movie, such as the jumping into the potty to come out full of ***, just to get the autograph of a Celebrity, and then the tragedy of having this inclredible feat be sold for a few ruppees by his own brother. I will never forget this scene as long as I live. But the formidable part of SlumDog is the way it show in total realism the life and death in the slums of Mumbai, all related and coming together in a seamless story of how by total coincidence he Knew the correct answer to all of the questions in the show because he had actually experienced each and every one of them. And I left the theatre thinking that in India's real life, no Millionaire winner would ever be left alive to enjoy the fortune, that he was so fortunate to be able to win.

  • Posted By: Holly deMello @ 03/09/2009 7:44:04 PM

    I went to see "Slumdog Millionaire" last night with my boyfriend. He had to escort me out of the theatre thirty minutes into the film. I was crying so hard, I couldn't bear to see anymore. Obviously, the director hasn't suffered like these children have. I know it is a fictional film, but those events are true because they do happen to a lot of children around the world continuously. Suffering is not a commodity. All or mostly all of the profit from this movie should go to the children of India. It is of no credit to anyone to have this movie praised unless it does something to help the children there now.
    To the director, unless you have lived as those children have or have grown up as they have, please don't say where they live is an exciting place. If you live there day in and day out, suffering continually, I'm not so sure you would be able to make this film so blatantly. Suffering leaves such horrible scars. If you have suffered even half as much as the children do there now, the injustices endured by the children would disable you from even filming ten minutes of your film. The emotion would be too much. Don't go into India, expose all of this and leave. Go back, take your millions and help them. It is one thing to have suffered like them and then write about it, but to take their stories and magnify them into a movie for the big screen is taking advantage of how they are forced to live.

    Do not walk away from what has been given to you. Practice true religion and that is helping those who suffer. Give what is rightfully theirs back to them so they can become all they were meant to be. Live their lives for a few years, suffer daily, and you won't even be able to watch your own movie, "Slumdog Millionaire." It would hurt too much.

  • Posted By: Commonsense13 @ 02/27/2009 4:07:34 AM

    you are one full of **it buddy. go back to the toilet and do the slomdug thingy or the 'trainspotting' thingy.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

My Take

Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage
to feature your favorite columnists.

Customize Now