Illustration by Josh Cochran for Newsweek
HEALTH FOR LIFE

Lessons In Survival

The science that explains why elite military forces bounce back faster than the rest of us.

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

In a laboratory, it's extremely difficult to study why some people are better at bouncing back than others because it's so hard to simulate the real stresses and strains of life. Scientists can show people scary pictures or movies to trigger their reactions and measure how they recover, but it's hardly the same as a mugger in an alley or a grizzly bear on a hiking trail. Dr. Andy Morgan of Yale Medical School set out to find a real-world laboratory where he could watch people under incredible stress in reasonably controlled conditions.

He ended up in southeastern North Carolina at Fort Bragg, home of the Army's elite Airborne and Special Forces. This is where the Army's renowned survival school is located. It's also where they believe in something called stress inoculation. Like vaccines, a small challenge or dose of a virus in your system prepares and defends you against a bigger challenge. In other words, they expose you to pressure and suffering in training so you'll build up your immunity. It's a kind of classic psychological conditioning: the more shocks to your system, the more you're able to withstand.

The toughest part of the 19-day training takes place in a secret location at Camp Mackall called the Resistance Training Laboratory. Translation: a mock prisoner-of-war camp where students have the chance to put into practice what they have learned in the classroom phases of survival school. Everything is modeled on real enemy encampments, including guard towers, razor-wire fences, concrete cells and metal cages. It's even got fake graves marked with crosses to scare you. The goal is to simulate hell on earth like the Hanoi Hilton in Vietnam or Al Qaeda's torture chambers. If they allow you to use the latrine, they make you relieve yourself in a hole in the ground like some do in the Third World. The camp itself is off-limits to outsiders, and what really goes on behind the concertina wire is strictly classified. I'm told by several people who have gone through this program that highly trained professionals serve as jailers and interrogators who put the prisoners through a kind of carefully choreographed chaos designed to disorient them and break them down.

While they're frightening you and wearing you down with sleep deprivation, blaring music and semistarvation, they're also interrogating you using enemy techniques copied from World War II, Korea and Vietnam. They claim that they don't use torture, but the sessions are known to be very rough.

For Morgan, POW school was the perfect place to study who survives the best under acute stress. If you think it's just training and the soldiers know they're not really in serious danger, consider what Morgan discovered. During mock interrogations, the prisoners' heart rates skyrocket to more than 170 beats per minute for more than half an hour, even though they aren't engaging in any physical activity. Meanwhile, their bodies pump more stress hormones than the amounts actually measured in aviators landing on aircraft carriers, troops awaiting ambushes in Vietnam, skydivers taking the plunge or patients awaiting major surgery. The levels of stress hormones are sufficient to turn off the immune system and to produce a catabolic state, in which the body begins to break down and feed on itself. The average weight loss in three days is 22 pounds.

Morgan's research—the first of its kind—produced some fascinating findings about who does the best job resisting the interrogators and who stays focused and clearheaded despite the uncontrollable fear. Morgan looked at two different groups going through this training: regular Army troops like infantrymen, and elite Special Forces soldiers, who are known to be especially "stress hardy" or cool under pressure. At the start or base line, the two groups were essentially the same, but once the stress began, and afterward, there were significant differences. Specifically, the two groups released very different amounts of a chemical in the brain called neuropeptide Y. NPY is an abundant amino acid in our bodies that helps regulate our blood pressure, appetite, learning and memory. It also works as a natural tranquilizer, controlling anxiety and buffering the effects of stress hormones like norepenephrine, one of the chemicals that most of us simply call adrenaline. In essence, NPY is one of the fire hoses that your brain uses to extinguish your alarm and fear responses by keeping the frontal-lobe parts of your brain working longer under stress.

Morgan found one very specific reason that Special Forces are superior survivors: they produce significantly greater levels of NPY compared with regular troops. In addition, 24 hours after completing survival training, Special Forces soldiers returned to their original levels of NPY while regular soldiers were significantly below normal.

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
Al Gore's Climate-Change Evolution
Al Gore's Climate-Change Evolution

Using emotion to convince people to change.

Heaven Can Wait
Heaven Can Wait

A new book promises proof of eternal life.

The World's Biggest Foods
The World's Biggest Foods

Monster edibles from around America.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: maskedfinancier @ 04/25/2009 9:49:42 PM

    Excellent post, which gives the lie to lots of "emotional mastery" BS which says that everyone can learn to handle stress. They can't - some people are much better and some are much worse.
    I work alot in the field of investing and once again this type of information is invaluable. People need to learn what their capacity for dealing with putting money at risk before doing it. Otherwise they are likely to get in over their head and get burnt - just like sending in a normal, volatile heartbeat GI in for a special forces mission.
    I've written about the investing link in more detail at my Texas Holdem Investing blog.

  • Posted By: jnhcube @ 04/20/2009 11:15:16 AM

    Wow this is a great article, I am an ex-army guy myself and the training that these guys are going through I can not even begin to fathom. The hardest thing I ever did when I was in the military was the 25mile Manchu road march in Korea through the Korean Mountains. 40 pond rucksack on your back for about 10 hours overnight in the dark, but its nothing compared to what these guys went through.

  • Posted By: heartmath @ 03/04/2009 9:01:22 PM

    The Newsweek article did not appropriately qualify the statement that low heart rate variability (HRV) is associated with better performance. It???s an interesting finding, but is quite context-specific. The HRV was obtained during an 8-minute period, with the subjects lying down, after they had just completed the classroom section of survival training and just before they were about to go into a very realistic ???prisoner of war??? or night time underwater navigation test that would result in either passing or failing the course. The participants were very aware of the unusually stressful event that they were about to engage in. It is becoming well-known that a persons ???overall??? amount or level HRV is related to future health outcomes, ability to self-regulate and so on; however, what is not typically appreciated about HRV is how context or state-specific it is. Our research shows that independent of the amount of overall HRV someone has, their current emotional state is reflected in the pattern of the HRV and/or state specific-related changes in the short-term amount of HRV. There are a number of states that lower HRV in the short-term context, but not the overall HRV. Active stress coping is one state that is well-known to do so, such as landing an airplane. Increased mental work load, mediation, relaxation (independent of deep breathing) all significantly lower HRV as well. Another important psychological activity that significantly lowers HRV (and can be to where it literally looks like a flat line) and the one that I suspect is in operation in the study, is inhibiting a response ??? the type of self-inhibition we do when someone is trying to tickle us, or when we are about to jump into a cold water. It is likely that the individuals who performed better were better able to inhibit their fear and anxiety prior to the upcoming event which was reflected in lower HRV. In addition, recording the HRV while lying down shifts the physiology into a low-HRV state (reduced sympathetic activity in preparation for sleep or relaxation) From this perspective, the findings are not that surprising. This point was discussed in the manuscript of the study where they mention the limitation of not knowing what the overall HRV of these individuals was and that their findings could be due to the specific manner in which the HRV was assessed, but I did not get the feeling they were aware of the magnitude of the effects that the current state can and does have on HRV.

    There are several studies that have now indicated that higher levels of NPY (as well as several other hormonal factors) are associated with higher resilience. So far, these have been short-term studies. We are currently conducting a study with the military in which we are assessing a wide range of hormones (including NPY), HRV, and cognitive functioning in a pre/post deployment study (long-term context).

    Rollin McCraty. Ph.D.
    Director of Research
    Institute of HeartMath
    military@heartmath.org

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

My Take

Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage
to feature your favorite columnists.

Customize Now