Michael Hirsh

Subscribe
Michael Hirsh

Stuck in '89
The fall of the Berlin Wall may seem like ancient history. But the economic debate has never moved beyond it.
November 2, 2009

One of history's great economic experiments ended 20 years ago. The odd thing is that we still haven't figured out what the results mean. The comparative experience of West Germany and East Germany during the Cold War was the stuff of terrible human drama. But it also added up to the closest thing that economists have had to a scientific trial with identical twins. The two countries provided the clearest measure of how well a "command" economy could perform against a market economy. Here were the same people from the same culture, starting from a virtual clean slate at precisely the same level of development after World War II—but under radically different forms of economic organization. On Nov. 9, 1989, the final test results were delivered by the thousands of East Germans who streamed across the border. One of the "twins" had produced the most vibrant economy in Europe; the other had become a place of darkness and dysfunction. Milton Friedman, the foremost champion of modern free-market thinking, later said that that the fall of the Berlin Wall was worth more than everything he had said and written. It was "undoubtedly the most influential action for the last hundred years because it put finis to an attitude," Friedman told C-SPAN's Brian Lamb in 1994. "The lesson from the fall of the Berlin Wall was that we have too extensive a government and we ought to cut it down." (Click here to follow Michael Hirsh)


(372)
Stuck in '89
The fall of the Berlin Wall may seem like ancient history. But the economic debate has never moved beyond it.
November 2, 2009
Converting the Preachers
George Soros launches a $50 million effort to purge economics of its free-market zeal.
October 27, 2009
thumbnail
Outside Looking In
October 24, 2009
Still No Watchdog
October 17, 2009
Too Hard to Understand
'Too Big to Fail' is one problem. But Barney Frank's loophole-filled derivatives bill has created another.
October 16, 2009
Thanks for Not Being Bush
The Nobel shows Obama is still popular abroad. But it doesn't help much if the U.S. is seen as a banana republic.
October 9, 2009

Cover Stories (12)
Cover Story
So Much for a Warm Welcome
John McCain is the presumptive GOP nominee for president. In the face of serious opposition, his campaign is reaching out to movement leaders and trying to make nice.
February 18, 2008
Cover Story
Where the Jihad Lives Now
Islamic militants have spread beyond their tribal bases, and have the run of an unstable, nuclear-armed nation.
October 29, 2007
Cover Story
The Gaza Effect
June 25, 2007
Cover Story
Rumors Of War
February 19, 2007

 
QUOTE FROM MICHAEL HIRSH
open quote...the Clinton visit still marks a big moment for Kim. It's the sort of recognition he's been eager to have for more than a decade. Bill Clinton has been all but absent from the news since Barack Obama took office and his wife, Hillary, became America's top diplomat. close quote