Slim Aarons / Hulton Archives-Getty Images
'Warrior Class': Lounging in Laguna Beach, 1957
THE CONSERVATIVES

You Can’t Go Home Again

Reagan called it the place where good Republicans go to die. But has the very idea of Orange County expired?

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

Something is not right in Orange County, though at first it's hard to see. In the morning, women with tight ponytails and yoga pants still walk briskly up the Southern California canyons. In the afternoon, high-school girls still fly through the Fashion Island shopping mall clutching lattes and their parents' credit cards. The smiling faces that fill the bars and restaurants in the beach towns at night are still almost exclusively white.

And, still, this string of suburbs south of Los Angeles, a birthplace of the modern conservative movement, is unmistakably Republican. On its front page, The Orange County Register announces a new arrival, John Yoo, distinguished visiting professor at Chapman University's School of Law. In blue enclaves, Yoo is reviled for his advocacy of torture during his time in the Bush administration's Office of Legal Counsel. At Berkeley, where he previously taught law, he clashed with "hippies, protesters and left-wing activists," he says. Orange County is different. Yoo loves the lifestyle, a "total change of pace."

But the Register itself, the nation's premier clearinghouse for Western conservative thinking, is losing money and readers. Cruising through the county on a summer Sunday last year, Barack Obama picked up a cool $1.2 million. In November, a place that fancies itself "the reddest county in America" gave the Democratic nominee for president nearly 48 percent of the vote.

At his law firm in an office park near John Wayne Airport, county Republican chairman Scott Baugh is unconcerned about his party's local pros-pects. Last fall was an anomaly, he says. The GOP was forced to play a horrible hand, and it strayed from its core beliefs. But Republicans shouldn't worry: "Every 16 years, the Democrats come to power and instantly overreach. In less than 100 days … that's what we've seen from President Obama." Faced with a "march towards socialism," he says, Republicans need only "be true to our old ideas."

This is the best hope for the Republican Party now—that the enemy implodes and the old magic still works. The 2008 election, the party faithful pray, was a misguided and momentary lapse. More desperately than ever, Republicans want to believe in the old idea of Orange County—that a suburban nation wants freedom and traditional values.

For half a century, this idea has served Orange County well. In the two decades after WWII, the county's population quadrupled, absorbing new residents seeking a piece of California's postwar prosperity. This wave was largely white, Midwestern, conservative— solid working folk who defined themselves in opposition to Eastern elites and the urban, ethnic muddle on the other side of the Los Angeles County line. As historian Lisa McGirr describes in "Suburban Warriors," they embraced a conservative ideology that spoke to their core beliefs, offered a coherent prism through which they could view their new lifestyle and provided a community that, in isolated suburbs, was not always easy to find.

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
Al Gore's Climate-Change Evolution
Al Gore's Climate-Change Evolution

Using emotion to convince people to change.

Heaven Can Wait
Heaven Can Wait

A new book promises proof of eternal life.

The World's Biggest Foods
The World's Biggest Foods

Monster edibles from around America.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: smithyj @ 03/28/2009 6:28:44 PM

    Its like a big liberal wet dream. Thank god this article was posted in opinion. That does lower the requirement for facts.. right? For instance, the mockery of orange county in fictional TV programs created in... Hollywood? Wow. Hard evidence. Then the claim Hispanics are changing the outlook of Orange County? With all undue respect Mr. Darman, you are an idiot. I was raised in a coastal community in Orange County 40 years ago and half of my secondary and primary school classes were, you guessed it, Hispanic.

    It seems that many liberals, like the author of this article, have gotten high on their own cool aide because of a landslide victory. I got news for you. Even those in America who are left of Fidel Castro re for widening the deficit by a trillion dollars so we can have socialized health care, If you really believe that conservative places like Orange County have suddenly socially shifted and are now in favor of such ideas, it might be a good time to but down the bong (or crack pipe) and get a grip on this thing most of us call reality.

  • Posted By: delilah001 @ 03/28/2009 2:48:01 AM

    I am a highschool student taking Governmnet/ Politics class at this time. Some of the things this artical said were related to an interesting class-discussion we had in class this week. The artical said that Republicans regain power every 16 years, countary to the conclusions of our discussioin. After about an hour of an engrossing discussion, my class came to a decision that a different political partie gains power every (about) 35 years. We had plenty of historic evidence to prove this. From 1897 to 1933 was a 36 years period of republican presidents, interrupted with only one democratic president. Then, it was time for the democrats to dominate. They dominated from 1933-1969, a 36 year period. From 1969 to about 2008 has been under republican dominance. We agreed that the high voter turnouts for Obama was a clue that the cycle will continue and democrats will retain power for the next about 35 years. At the end of the hour, we also concluded that the cycle is every 35 years because that is about how long it takes for social change to require governmental change. The releationship between social change and governmnetal change is interesting. If seen on a graph, social change would be a straight line going up from left to right, while governmental change is a steady horizontal line. A different political partie gains control every 35 years because as social change continues, governmental change is also necessairy.

  • Posted By: oclady @ 03/23/2009 11:32:39 AM

    Whoa! It was obvious from reading the article that Mr. Darman had a ax to grind with Orange County. Sure enough,
    his bio states he lived in Los Angeles at one time. You can just bet he had an unpleasant experience down here!
    We have lived here for 35 years, living in Fullerton, Newport Beach, Costa Mesa and Huntington Beach. It has its'
    problems like every other place in the U.S., but most people are hard working people who abide by the rules. Mr.
    Darman, is it so wrong to want to have as little crime as possible and not be rediculed for going to church every
    Sunday? AND shows like "The O.C.," Laguna Beach," and "Real Housewives" were created in HOLLYWOOD,
    not Orange County.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

My Take

Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage
to feature your favorite columnists.

Customize Now