I Can’t Believe I’m Still a Vegan

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: insuchaworld @ 03/26/2009 8:39:02 PM

    If you are tempted to give in to butter, just try Earth Balance instead. It tastes just like butter, and some say - even better.

    Congratulations on your healthy lifestyle - I have been a vegan for 2 and a half years now, and it was the best decision I have ever made.

  • Posted By: jodyki @ 03/24/2009 2:17:31 PM

    Earth Balance is the vegan 'butter' that is SOOOOO yum! - better than butter!!

  • Posted By: greeninpeaces @ 03/24/2009 10:06:05 PM

    I LOVE THIS!!! YAY NEW VEGANS!!! Good for you, while I am a vegan for ethical reasons, I appreciate anyone who moves into the fold, for any reason. Keep on rolling, your body and the earth community say thanks :)

  • Posted By: jodyki @ 03/24/2009 5:16:16 PM

    - to Qidisrupt, on the issue you brought up - abortion, one of the best comprehensive answers when this is brought up in regard to kindness to animals follows. It was written by a freind of mine in the Coravalis-Gazette (Oregon) Newspape. (I by the way am pro-life if this is of interest to you.):

    "I am a vegan in order to reduce suffering. I advocate for animals because they are powerless. They can???t protect themselves from us, or speak out. They are at our mercy. I believe that how we treat them is our fundamental moral test.

    I also keep my animal advocacy non-partisan. Compassion can be embraced by each of us regardless of our political views, religious affiliations or other beliefs.

    Whenever the subject of animal suffering comes up, inevitably someone says,??? What about human suffering???? or, ???What about abortion???? This deflects attention away from the animals. Regardless of a person???s view of abortion, we do not have a situation where every man, woman and child is having an abortion every day, 3 times a day, for their entire lives. There is no way to underestimate what we inflict on animals. Not only do we kill many billions of animals, but we subject them to terrible lifelong suffering. And there is nothing worse than prolonged suffering.

    No one ever need choose between compassion for people and compassion for animals. We all can help animals each day by making kind choices. [[Mr. Lilly???s]] last sentence incorrectly suggests that farmed animals are somehow protected. They are not. They are the most abused and forgotten beings on earth. Mr. Lilly and each of us can work on whatever issue we care about, and at the same time we can show compassion to the helpless animals."

  • Posted By: runreerun @ 03/24/2009 10:09:02 AM

    Mr. Noonan, there is such a thing as soy/vegetable butter and it is, may I add, absolutely delicious. A bit caloric, but no different in taste than the stuff that comes from cows. Trader Joe's sells them as well as Whole Foods.

  • Posted By: Qidisrupt @ 03/21/2009 6:05:03 AM

    02sunnygirl....you vegans are not the only ones trying help clean up our planet. I wasn't preaching....I was giving valid and concrete examples of some the hypocrisy and misinformation from people who claim to be 100% vegan....which, of course, is nutritionally impossible. You vegans need supplements and fortified foods from animal-based B12....so, why are you trying to convince me to get on board??? Get on board so I can condemn people for eating differently than I do??? No thanks!!! You talk a lot of crap....but, nothing that medical science research has been able to conclude. Guess what, without animal-based B12 supplements and fortified foods, you vegans could not maintain balanced nutrition....cut the crap and get honest. To correct you and many misinformed vegans, many of us people who enjoy eating meat in moderate portions make every effort to purchase local free range animal foods and organic fruits, veggies, and nuts and grains. I may be a freak to you, but at least I am honest and I don't try to present myself to be better than others, and I don't misinform. For more accurate information, it takes more processing methods for making B12 supplements and B12fortified foods....which is not as environmentally friendly as simply eating free range meat.

    • Posted By: dragondvm @ 03/24/2009 8:19:16 AM

      First of all the B12 issue is, pardon the expression, a red herring. If you could only get it from an animal source it would just mean that you should consume that amount of the source and no more.
      Thankfully, that is not the case. I just pulled down from the shelf my cheap carton of nutritional yeast (grown on molasses.) One serving contains 150% of the RDA of B12 and 310% of the RDA of folate.
      Problem solved.

    • Posted By: dragondvm @ 03/24/2009 8:18:44 AM

      First of all the B12 issue is, pardon the expression, a red herring. If you could only get it from an animal source it would just mean that you should consume that amount of the source and no more.
      Thankfully, that is not the case. I just pulled down from the shelf my cheap carton of nutritional yeast (grown on molasses.) One serving contains 150% of the RDA of B12 and 310% of the RDA of folate.
      Problem solved.

    • Posted By: dragondvm @ 03/24/2009 8:15:00 AM

      First of all, the B12 issue is, pardon the expression, a red herring. If you could only get it from meat, all that would mean is that you shoud eat adequate amounts of whatever source you need and then no more.
      However, that is not the case. I just pulled my cheap carton of nutritional yeast (grown on molasses) from the shelf and one serving contains 150% of the RDA of B12 and 310% of folic acid.
      Problem solved.

    • Posted By: dragondvm @ 03/24/2009 8:09:12 AM

      First of all, the B12 issue is, pardon the expression, a red herring. If you could only get it from meat, all that would mean is that you shoud eat adequate amounts of whatever source you need and then no more.
      However, that is not the case. I just pulled my cheap carton of nutritional yeast (grown on molasses) from the shelf and one serving contains 150% of the RDA of B12 and 310% of folic acid.
      Problem solved.

  • Posted By: fleur1991 @ 03/24/2009 3:43:12 AM

    I have been a vegan for a little over a decade. However, unlike David Noonan, I would describe myself as a "gourmet" and simply could not imagine living with one meal a week!
    That's what I find the greatest thing about a vegan diet- with its low fat and cholestrol content you actually can have your cake and it it too!

  • Posted By: zeroimpact @ 03/23/2009 6:09:49 PM

    thx for the fun article david. i'm surprised you find the plant-based diet boring though. i've lived a strict vegan lifestyle for about 8 years and i'm still discovering new recipes! not to mention all the ready-made options out there e.g.fieldroast grain meats, tofurkey brats, nates frozen meatballs and one of my faves, tastybite, boil-in-the-bag indian food (the punjab eggplant is to die for, seriously :) if you google "vegan recipes", you'll hit over 8 million options! .i also stumbled across this website recently - veggiebrothers.com - perfect if you don't want to cook, looks tasty! ! an easy way to start is to think ethnic; indian, thai, japanese style (dried wakame and sesame seeds thrown in a bowl of rice is a nutritious easy lunch... so much yummy food out there to try! good luck :)

    • Posted By: hotdice @ 03/24/2009 12:13:12 AM

      I agree zeroimpact, there are tons of great recipes out there as well as ready made meatless products that are much tastier than they used to be....just got to watch out for the sodium and hidden fats in the ingredients.

  • Posted By: hotdice @ 03/24/2009 12:07:58 AM

    I was slowly moving in that same direction myself then my bestest lifelong friend of 40 years had a heart attack. I speeded up the process following the Dr. Neal Barnard book Breaking The Food Seduction. Eggs were easy to drop. Cheese remarkably so as well. Meat, espy red meat, no problem. I may eat fish but mercury in fish scares me. Butter was tossed and I am flumoxed by the fact that even so called natural heart healthy substitutes invariably have palm oil and palm kernel oil, both killers. So I stick with olive oil on my bread and have my toast dry for now or with a bit of honey or almond butter. I also use Walnut and Almond oils. Tofu based meatless products are improving a great deal except they contain way too much sodium usually. My one indulgence in dairy is milk but I have managed to switch to non fat skim milk for coffee and oatmeal. I dont drink a lot of it. The transition has been sooth. I was bolstered by reading this article and the fact my heart attack buddy has managed to make similar switches altho he eats fish. He had three blocked arteries. One 99 per cent, another 83 per cent and a third 80 per cent. He had to have two operations and three angioplasties. A fourth artery is partly blocked by up to 70 per cent. Luckily there was little damage to the heart muscle so a recovery following a strict diet and statins will help preserve him a bit longer. It was a realy wake up call for both of us.

  • Posted By: tanya.seaman@verizon.net @ 03/23/2009 6:25:26 PM

    I applaud you for doing this. (I've been a vegan for nine years and will never go back.) So many people only make dietary changes AFTER they've been diagnosed with some disease. It would be far easier to be a vegan if it was a more popular choice. You wouldn't always be the oddball at restaurants with special orders. But there is huge variety out there, and I hope you can have fun with it.

  • Posted By: etherspin @ 03/23/2009 6:41:03 AM

    Im sorry but vegans simply don't eat butter, if this is a dietary thing then the writer is adhering only to a lacto-ovo vegetarian diet, an vegan excludes wherever possible, all animal products.
    there are no dietary vegans in the same way that a person who arbitrarily omits pork isnt a "dietary muslim"
    I'd love to see an article in newsweek by an actual vegan.
    sounds like the writer is *close* to being on a strict vegetarian diet.
    there are many many alternatives to butter on a baked potato.

    • Posted By: BettBee @ 03/23/2009 4:18:15 PM

      etherspin,

      This is a very positive article by someone who has made a huge change. I understand that it is tempting to rely on labels, but it is not helpful to nitpick or argue about semantics in this kind of discussion. If people take this article to heart just think of the greater good it will do. A dab of butter from time to time is not going to negate the benefit this article can reap.

      Also, it is probable that more "main-stream" people will hear this from someone not claiming to be perfect or, worse, "pure" - this writer makes a plant-based diet seem actually approachable, and good for him!

      • Posted By: BettBee @ 03/23/2009 4:32:32 PM

        etherspin,

        Actually this is a really good and very helpful article. It makes the idea of a plant-based diet very approachable by most folks, which is a good thing. Just think of all the lives that can be saved when more people become mostly vegan.

        And in anticipation of arguments against that last term, well, the word vegan is a label. It's been used and bruited about for so long now that it has already lost much of its original meaning. I think we should really use the term "strict vegan" to mean someone who eschews all animal products entirely (or as far as it is possible to do so and still participate in modern society) and allow the word vegan without the modifier to simply mean not eating meat, eggs and dairy. As such it then seems reasonable to think of the concept of "mostly vegan," which this writer certainly is, at least as usage has redefined the word.

  • Posted By: Qidisrupt @ 03/22/2009 2:19:43 AM

    The real concern for factory-type livestock is not "cruelty to animals", but the valid concern for everyone is that this type of livestock farming is not sanitary enough for top quality food production and to maintain a clean environment. Jodyki, as well meaning as you may appear, those B12 supplements came from animals. It is not a myth about the vital need for B12 in the human diet....these facts come from medical science research....gotta have B12 to activate Folate and gotta have Folate to activate B12....argue all you want, but the facts are valid. Take the risk and do without it if you want to, but the health risks are not worth it. I am completely aware that people can live just as healthy of lives eating meat or not eating meat....in the end, it isn't isn't going to matter. The 100% honesty of all vegans is that they still need animal-based B12 supplements or foods fortified with it. Jodyki, let's discuss kindness for all God's creatures....how about no cruelty and abuse of human babies that are unjustly aborted....yeah, I hear you on the kindness....I believe unnecessary abortions of human babies truly deadens the best of our natural instincts, such as love and responsibilty. Jodyki, I am aware.

    • Posted By: etherspin @ 03/23/2009 6:46:25 AM

      no , actually b12 supplements come from bacteria cultures.
      also lots of vegan foods are fortified with b12 so we get it just as easily as everyone else and we do it with zero cholesterol intake (cholesterol is not present in plants or fungi) and without the cancer causing HCAs you create when cooking meat

      • Posted By: BettBee @ 03/23/2009 4:31:40 PM

        etherspin,

        Actually this is a really good and very helpful article. It makes the idea of a plant-based diet very approachable by most folks, which is a good thing. Just think of all the lives that can be saved when more people become mostly vegan.

        And in anticipation of arguments against that last term, well, the word vegan is a label. It's been used and bruited about for so long now that it has already lost much of its original meaning. I think we should really use the term "strict vegan" to mean someone who eschews all animal products entirely (or as far as it is possible to do so and still participate in modern society) and allow the word vegan without the modifier to simply mean not eating meat, eggs and dairy. As such it then seems reasonable to think of the concept of "mostly vegan," which this writer certainly is, at least as usage has redefined the word.

  • Posted By: Susycav @ 03/23/2009 10:40:27 AM

    Awesome!!! I agree - I transitioned to vegan after 14 yrs of being a vegetarian and my goodness does my whole body look and feel better...and best yet, I'm saving a whole bunch of animals a cruel fate! Rock on baby, no belly fat for you...or me! =)

  • Posted By: skinnyminny2 @ 03/22/2009 3:26:41 PM

    Well done! Someone who took action and understood that being light and fit takes discipline--a complete lifestyle change.

    Know that there is vegan pizza.....or you can make your own. It's really quite good without all the greasy cheese; when I have it it's a whole grain thin crust with organic sauce and it is covered with vegetables and some tofu! Way yummy! Or try some of the non-dairy cheeses they have out there if you miss cheese. Don't forget that vegan doesn't mean boring, it just means seeking out different recipes and planning.

  • Posted By: ChosenHealth @ 03/22/2009 10:03:25 AM

    I am glad to see that you are promoting a vegan diet, but if you continue eating salads for lunch and roasted veggies for dinner, you're going to get sick. You need much more protein, carbs, and fat in your diet. I hope that the author is getting more protein/carbs/fat than he is reporting because those macronutrients are essential to a healthy body. Vegetables are great -- but you need to add some avocado or nuts to the salad, or some tofu or tempeh to your roasted vegetables. Otherwise you are not getting all of the amino acids you need. What do amino acids do? They form and repair our skin, muscles, tendons, etc.; they regulate body processes; they transport vitamins, minerals, and lipids around the body; they assist in fighting off viruses; etc. I know this because I happen to be a vegan nutritionist. I have helped countless people move towards a healthy vegan diet. For more info, please go to: www.chosenhealth.com

  • Posted By: 4mula01 @ 03/21/2009 11:24:48 PM

    VEGAN BY DESIGN ect.. see my messages at, flatrockspeedway.com click search then indycar01

  • Posted By: jodyki @ 03/21/2009 6:11:04 PM

    - to Qidisrupt, I have to apologize if I am sounding holier-than-thou because I am a vegan. I use to eat all of that stuff. I use to love meat, dairy??? I was not aware and I was a good (and unaware) person. Who was it Socarates? Plato? - who said the unexamined life is not worth living? I then learned firsthand - witnessed, what farming is (and this was on small free-range family farms in Wisconsin so please don???t be deceived by the - it???s the factory farms mantra). Livestock farming - on small family farms to factory farms, I learned is the most cruel and horrible nightmare for the animals and for the people as well who must have to deaden the best of our natural instincts - kindness for all of God???s creatures, who must have to deaden their heart and learn to turn a blind eye to the suffering of the innocent??? To try to help end this horrible cruelty is why I became vegan. I want to live in an honest and kind world.

    I am an eternal optimist - I believe in your potential Qidisrupt - and I pray for the ???awareness, truth??? which will set us ALL free. It is each individual???s responsibility to seek out the truth. Google ???Meet your Meat???, ???Earthlings???, ???Peaceable Kingdom??? -- seek out the truth and be courageous enough to do the right thing once aware.

  • Posted By: jodyki @ 03/21/2009 5:11:39 PM

    Speaking of misinformation to whoever spoke about the protein issue and to Qidisrupt on the B12 issue, I would suggest some further research. (I think it was unintentional, however you???ve presented misinformation in your posts which I am sure you would like to correct with the facts.) On the B12 issue, here is one good source - http://www.pamrotella.com/health/b12.html - however there are many more so please continue the research to your satisfaction.
    I???ve got a short excerpt from this link below, however please check out the link as there is much more???
    ???Vegans and the Vitamin B12 Deficiency Myth
    It seems there's always at least one tired old myth making the rounds about vegetarianism. Twenty years ago when I switched, it was the "protein deficiency" myth. Now that the protein myth has been completely discredited (human breast milk is only 5% protein, and it is estimated that adult humans only need 2-3% protein in their daily diet), these days the vitamin B12 myth occasionally surfaces. Usually it's only preached in places like very old doctors' offices or talk radio shows dominated by heavy recommendations for drugs and dairy products, but the question still comes up???.

    Deficiencies at Large
    A small number of people develop B12 deficiencies, most of them not vegans???

    ??? All of the Vitamin B12 in the world ultimately comes from bacteria. Neither plants nor animals can synthesize it. But plants can be contaminated with B12 when they come in contact with soil bacteria that produce it. Animal foods are rich in B12 only because animals eat foods that are contaminated with it or because bacteria living in an animal's intestines make it.

    The Cautious Path
    So what's a vegan to do for B12? Less rinsing of fruits and vegetables is a bad idea. Bacterial food poisoning is much less common with vegetables than meat, but it can still occur with vegetables. The body might produce enough B12 from its own bacteria and naturally-occuring bacteria on food (rinsing doesn't remove all of it), but I like to play it safe. Personally, I believe in vitamin supplementation for a number of reasons..."

  • Posted By: qzsue @ 03/21/2009 4:07:08 PM

    I am vegetarian. I hope to take the next step soon to become vegan. There are so many books and websites to help me take the next step. I look forward to checking out the firefighter's cookbook.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse