SPONSORED BY:
MONEY CULTURE

They Got the Wrong Guy

Why Congress' confrontation with AIG's CEO was a failure.

 
PHOTOS
What They Got Away With

A look at the CEOs who walk off with mountains of money

 
 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

The appearance by AIG CEO Edward Liddy before Congress on Wednesday was billed as an epic confrontation between the angry tribunes of a furious public and an arrogant Wall Street. Chris Matthews hyped it on MSNBC as "Watergate Redux." But the actual hearing—Liddy's appearance and questioning lasted barely longer than the two-hour preliminaries—was disappointing and misguided.

Roasting Liddy for AIG's manifold and expensive failures would be like putting Gerald Ford on trial for the crimes of Watergate. Edward Liddy isn't G. Gordon Liddy. Yes, he could have handled this issue much better. But he's not the villain. He's a genuine dollar-a-year man who isn't looking to make a quick buck on the bailout. (It's OK, he made gazillions when he ran Allstate.)

Watch Edward Liddy at a congressional hearing on AIG

The proximate cause of the hearings was the revelation that AIG had paid $165 million in "retention bonuses" to executives at AIG's Financial Products division, the tiny unit whose reckless bets and issuance of insurance on financial products blew up the whole company. Liddy acknowledged that it was "distasteful to have to make these payments" and explained that they were made not to people who sold credit-default swaps but to employees who were winding down other components of the business, some of which were profitable. He had asked employees of the division who received at least $100,000 to return at least half of their bonuses, he said, and some had offered to return all of it.

Aside from revealing congressional ignorance of all things financial, the hearing showed Liddy to be the wrong man at the wrong place—and it was yet another example of misplaced anger. There's no denying the horrific symbolism of these bonuses. But it would be nice if members of Congress—Republican and Democratic alike—displayed as much attention and outrage over the $80 billion-plus wound that AIG's implosion has already inflicted on the American taxpayers instead of grandstanding over a mere (irony intended) $165 million.

The failure of leadership at AIG was immense and catastrophic. But Liddy wasn't leading AIG when it blew up. He didn't get paid to make the disastrous trades, or to oversee the disastrous traders, or to oversee the people who oversaw the disastrous traders, or even to oversee the people who oversaw the people who oversaw the disastrous traders. It wasn't his idea for AIG Financial Products to insure billions of dollars in mortgage bonds, or to engage in "regulatory capital trades" or "balance-sheet rental"—insuring assets of European banks to allow them to move assets off their balance sheets. Liddy noted that at its height, AIG had between $350 billion and $370 billion of "balance sheet rental" insurance in force. (The figure is down to a mere $230 billion.)

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
Solving the Palin Puzzle
Solving the Palin Puzzle

See how well you can see Sarah from your house, by taking our trivia quiz.

The Failure of Copenhagen
The Failure of Copenhagen

Why there could be a silver lining in a failed climate treaty.

Dial 'A' for Accessory
Dial 'A' for Accessory

This season's top i-Phone add-ons.

118 Days in Hell
118 Days in Hell

A NEWSWEEK journalist recounts his captivity in Iran.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: I need help @ 04/02/2009 8:55:25 PM

    I have read most of the stories about AIG. I want my story told how AIG, has sold me a annuity investment that is all lies. If you are an employee of AIG these people think they are God. There is no one to stop them from ruining peoples lives. Now all of a sudden AIG is so concerned about the investor's. In order for me to get my money out of AIG I will have to pay thousand s of dollars. I need help from a Lawyer to help me. I have been fighting and arguing with this agent for almost fifteen years. I live in the Los Angeles County area. Please contact me at 909-860-4942

  • Posted By: kfbphoto @ 03/27/2009 4:55:38 PM

    From the UK. It is not only the USA that is suffering from the despotic actions of AIG. I had an nasty accident due to negligence last June in the UK. 60 witnesses etc. No contest. The Oil company responsible admitted liability within weeks. Since then AIG insurance ( UK ) have prevaricated and behaved abysmally, to the point of sarcasm.

    A judge in my extended family said they have no reason to delay. An insurance agent friend says they are crazy, just increasing their own costs. In such a clear cut case ( she went on to say ) any sensible insurance company would pay out quickly to avoid additional costs.

    I suggested a very reasonable settlement at the outset to help me and my business ( I could not walk ) This was ignored. Instead AIG London ( A Mr. Thompson ) told me to get a solicitor ( which under the circumstances was not needed, another £1000 ) Then AIG???s Mr. Thompson required me to see a specialist, even though all X rays and medical information was available free. This cost another £500
    My solicitors costs keep rising as AIG seeks ever more silly excuses. My business is ruined by AIG, not the accident.

    The costs keep rising, ( not just mine ) AIG prevaricates and the American Taxpayer is paying the bills. Or at least the bonuses. AIG is now living off Taxpayers money, stealing bonuses and looking after themselves financially. While not honouring their responsibilities and debts. Is that not public fraud ? So, while many people suffer ??? AIG fills its pockets. How many others have AIG cheated while they live off American Taxpayers money. How many others are they running up bills for and expecting others to pay these bills ? Complete arrogance, stupidity and greed. Bonuses, they should be on trial for fraud on a grand scale.
    I am now writing to The President Barack Obama for help.

    Kevin Fitzmaurice-Brown photo-journalist UK

  • Posted By: kfbphoto @ 03/27/2009 4:41:34 PM

    From the UK. It is not only the USA that is suffering from the despotic actions of AIG. I had an nasty accident due to negligence last June in the UK. 60 witnesses etc. No contest. The Oil company responsible admitted liability within weeks. Since then AIG insurance ( UK ) have prevaricated and behaved abysmally, to the point of sarcasm.

    A judge in my extended family said they have no reason to delay. An insurance agent friend says they are crazy, just increasing their own costs. In such a clear cut case ( she went on to say ) any sensible insurance company would pay out quickly to avoid additional costs.

    I suggested a very reasonable settlement at the outset to help me and my business ( I could not walk ) This was ignored. Instead AIG London ( A Mr. Thompson ) told me to get a solicitor ( which under the circumstances was not needed, another £1000 ) Then AIG???s Mr. Thompson required me to see a specialist, even though all X rays and medical information was available free. This cost another £500
    My solicitors costs keep rising as AIG seeks ever more silly excuses. My business is ruined by AIG, not the accident.

    The costs keep rising, ( not just mine ) AIG prevaricates and the American Taxpayer is paying the bills. Or at least the bonuses. AIG is now living off Taxpayers money, stealing bonuses and looking after themselves financially. While not honouring their responsibilities and debts. Is that not public fraud ? So, while many people suffer ??? AIG fills its pockets. How many others have AIG cheated while they live off American Taxpayers money. How many others are they running up bills for and expecting others to pay these bills ? Complete arrogance, stupidity and greed. Bonuses, they should be on trial for fraud on a grand scale.
    I am now writing to The President Barack Obama for help.

    Kevin Fitzmaurice-Brown photo-journalist UK

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

My Take

Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage
to feature your favorite columnists.

Customize Now
 
COVER STORY: ECONOMY

As consumers hibernate and investors hoard cash, the economy is withering. This new age of thrift is understandable. But for a recovery to take hold, Americans will need to start taking risks again.

 
 
PHOTOS
What About Us?
Wall Street's problems have captured the attention of Congress, the White House and the media. But on the country's Main Streets ordinary folks are wondering if anyone is paying attention to them. A look at how Americans are coping with the economic crisis.