Society

Generation Diva

How our obsession with beauty is changing our kids.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: asche @ 09/30/2009 9:18:43 AM

    What people are failing to realize is that all these products have CHEMICALS. These harmful chemicals, especially nail polish and nail remover, are dangerous when breathed in and can kill brain cells. Is this why there are so many students underachieving? Also, I dyed my own hair for 5 years. I now have sporiasis, and dry, caked, skin around my eyebrows and headline. It's terrible. I think it is directly related to dying my hair as I have used the same product. Also, makeup has particles. Some cheaper makeups have all sorts of chemicals. How do I know? I don't even have to test them. I have severe allergic reactions to most makeup now. If China was putting lead in toys, what is in our makeup that children and tweens are using? Think about it. You could be contributing to your child getting cancer later in life or acquiring severe asthma breathing in particles that they should not be. And hairspray is a whole other story. Stop allowing your children to play with makeup and unsafe products! Our country needs their brain cells... trust me... I know... I taught for four years and it seems that the intellect has plummeted significantly.

  • Posted By: kshortSD @ 04/02/2009 3:48:27 PM

    I'm expecting a baby girl in August, and this article is pretty scary. I was already nervous about the awful sexual messages that are being forced on girls today (the most sexually agressive girl usually wins the guy on reality shows), and now I'm nervous about this issue too! I plan on doing everything I can to teach her to value her intelligence, humor, and ability to be a good friend, but how can I help how the world treats her? I won't be buying her any makeup before at least 13, but what can I tell her if boys don't pay attention to her because she doesn't have bleached blond hair and fake nails? I believe that men are as brainwashed as women by the constant media flood of images of "perfect women", and can almost understand why girls and women are so desperate to keep up.

    • Posted By: adolan @ 06/09/2009 1:32:57 PM

      Hey kshortSD,

      Congratulations on the upcoming arrival of your daughter! I have an amazing 13 year old girl myself...along with a delightful 17 year old boy...and they are both dreams.

      YOU are the NUMBER 1 example for your children. Send them out into the world the people YOU want and expect them to be, and they will surprise you with how savvy they are about outside influences. My children are athletes, and they are both dedicated, funny, intellegent, well rounded kids. Neither one of them is involved in "diva dramas" though each of them has witnessed it...and both of them are very popular - precisely because they don't indulge in catty gossip, or rude commentary about their peers.

      They respect THEMSELVES and because they do, they also have learned to respect others. They don't judge, but they do choose wisely.

      I do admit to not allowing them to put themselves on Facebook or Myspace,,,so far, they haven't missed it.

      • Posted By: workingmomsaregoodmoms @ 09/29/2009 12:58:22 PM

        Don't let her watch commercials on television or look at fashion magazines. That will help too.

  • Posted By: workingmomsaregoodmoms @ 09/29/2009 12:56:47 PM

    This is one of the reasons that we don't have cable television and only watch dvds. At least while my children are young, I can try to shield them as much as possible from being brainwashed by the advertising world's messages that sex and consumerism are key parts of their identities.

  • Posted By: workingmomsaregoodmoms @ 09/29/2009 12:43:03 PM

    This is one of the many reasons we don't have cable television. I refuse to have my children brainwashed by the agenda of the advertising industry. I can't completely insulate them from it, but I can do everything I can to counter the message that appearance and purchasing crap is related to self-worth.

  • Posted By: ImaginaryCloud @ 09/04/2009 9:02:29 PM

    I'm 17 years old. I confess that I wear make up. I wear cover up, mascara, eyeshadow, eyeliner and lip gloss. I straighten my hair or wear it in a ponytail. BUT. I don't do my nails, I don't starve myself. (Although I don't eat much... but not because I want to be thinner, just because i'm a super picky eater.) I don't go get $50+ haircuts. I don't like my hair but I deal with it by putting it up. I hate spending money on my looks. I'm happy with my weight and I definately don't want to be skinnier. I hate all those skinny twigs. Their bones stick out and they have all had so much cosmetic surgery you can hardly tell they are human anymore. I also don't actually wear make up that often. I wear it when I go out, never at home though or on trips, and I have a feeling this is as much make up as I will have because I feel like its a mask if it's anymore. I'm afraid of surgery so that's out of the question for me. I don't want it anyways though. But I definately have seen everything in this article happening. Well... not everything but I worked at a Day Camp during the summer. I could tell their was girls who cared about their looks. Especially one girl. She came in with "diva" sunglasses, a sparkling pick tank top, and white short shorts with black flip flops. She had on hot pink nail polish. A good tan, pink eyeshadow, and pink lip gloss. She had dangly gold star earrings on. She was nine.
    When I was that age, I never saw that. I did however notice these changes when I turned 13. Make up, the haircuts, the clothes. Girls were changing. I didn't start wearing make up until the beginning of this school year.

  • Posted By: stephaknee @ 07/14/2009 3:42:10 PM

    What about this other newsweek article ( http://www.newsweek.com/id/206597 ) citing grooming and beauty as traits correlating higher success in school?
    Could an unconscious evolutionary effect reacting to that phenomenon be a factor to why girls are starting to primp at a younger age?
    Of course i think it is all spawned from media's warped self-image projections on people, specifically girls, and that is very sickening.

  • Posted By: George>.< @ 06/14/2009 12:20:01 PM

    To all concerned parents: I am fourteen and i dont wear makeup, i dont spend money on manicures, i dont have a boyfriend nor do i want one, i dont starve myself. Although i have. Please tell your daughters to learn from my mistakes, i took me 18 months to realise that throwing up everything i ate and plastering my face with makeup go me no where in life. The boys didnt notice me either, i just became another girl, who looked like the others. be your own person and people will appriecate you for it. oh, and spending your hard earned money on nailpolish is pointless: paint fades and wears off. i am saving all my money for student exchange and in two years i will be going to Brazil for 6 moths, that is something that will never wear off or fade. I dont know what to say to you, but just please tell them that it is not worth it. as corny as it sounds: being yourself is the best thing there is.

  • Posted By: calliope15 @ 03/31/2009 1:09:55 PM

    I have to confess that I get annoyed when I go to my local manicure place and I see a bunch of 6 year olds getting the same manicure and pedicure that I started getting well into my 20's. I think the message is that it is a harmless way for these little girls to " feel pampered" but at 6, or 8 or even 12, I think girls should learn other things, and graduate to beauty "chores" ( nothing I hate more than watching paint dry after a manicure or a pedicure, for instance) later in life. It is a question of priorities and degrees of relevance on one's life over the long haul. As long as we send a message to girls and little girls that what counts the MOST for a woman is her looks,we will continue to perpetuate the objectivization of females. As far as the way "fat" women are regarded, I am one of those, and I assure all you skinny malevolent bony b...ches that I am not lazy, irresponsible or stupid. I have spent my life battling a vey peculiar metabolism, that keeps the pounds creeping up and I am frankly sick of the skinniy B..es who judge negatively everybody that does not conform to their ideal of beauty. Truth is many of them, and my mom is a naturally skinny person, never dieted ( for real) one day in their life. I also find it interesting that disciminating and being very judgemental about people who are overweigh is the only and last form of tolerated discrimination: nobody will ever get in trouble for saying the things I have read in some of the posts, and yet if instead of "fat" you substitued the word with " black" or homosexuall, the same people calling overweight persons lazy irresponsible and ho, just so ugly, would be screaming at the top of their lungs.
    I hope there is really karma in the universe and all you thin people came back fighting for the rest of your lives with the scale and stupid people who think they know all about you based on the way you look.

    • Posted By: Calamity @ 06/05/2009 5:27:12 PM

      Don't know if this will make you feel any better, but I had low self-esteem growing up because I was so
      skinny and had no curves! I grew up at a time when Marilyn Monroe and Jayne Mansfield were the ideals.
      So it's not only larger women who have felt ugly and discriminated against.

  • Posted By: Long Beach Guy @ 03/31/2009 2:34:09 PM

    I am a 56 year old male. I think women are very competitive, this drives them to be more aggressive when it comes to an outward appearance. I feel it is my job to help my wife feel comfortable when dealing with getting older. If there are any guys reading this, take long walks together, enjoy an afternoon at the peer, take a lot of mini vacations together. This will all help her appreciate who she is.

    • Posted By: Calamity @ 06/05/2009 5:16:26 PM

      What a great comment! I am blessed with a great guy too; one that tells me, if I complain trying on last year's
      bathing suit, that I shouldn't compare myself to 20 year olds or airbrushed models. That doesn't mean we
      don't try to eat well, exercise and not be unhealthy weight-wise, but we accept that we're not 21 any more
      and we love so much more about each other than just our appearance, because we all get older. But you
      know what-- that respect and care has made our marriage so much more happy than any plastic surgeon and
      I still smile when he wants into a room after 40 years.

    • Posted By: public librarian @ 03/31/2009 7:06:54 PM

      Thank you, Long Beach Guy :) I love your comment so much!

      • Posted By: e_nyads @ 03/31/2009 10:15:57 PM

        Hey, thanks for that one, I totally agree with you and I will make sure my hub reads this one.

  • Posted By: Calamity @ 06/05/2009 4:59:17 PM

    I would have thought this article was just about a few and exaggerated, but you can instill this low self-esteem in your daughters even if you are poor. I grew up being told we should never answer the door unless we had our make-up on
    and hair combed. Believe me, it was so difficult the day I answered the door for the mailman "a mess" --now that was
    liberating! But that doesn't mean that I see anything wrong with combing your hair or wearing fashionable clothing and make-up, I still like to "dress-up" and look nice for myself! But what is wrong is when people go to extremes and do it at an inappropriate age. And if you think this article is shocking, I know a mother who told her daughter that her grades didn't
    matter because she was so beautiful, she can pose for PlayBoy; so sick and wrong! Who would want that life and all the
    immorality that goes with it, for their own precious daughter?

  • Posted By: malibu13 @ 06/04/2009 10:47:28 PM

    I am the proud father of 2 daughters, aged 9 and 7. We have had discussions about body image as both girls have totally different body types, yet both are perfectly healthy. It is hard with the pressure from school and their peers. That said, as a parent, I have a resposibility to raise my child... that means, I get to control what content they are exposed to at home, who they play with outside school, the activities they participate in, etc.... yet reading this article the author uses words that describe behaviors that will cause a negative consequence in our home; "insist", "demand". Or better yet, why would a child of 13 or younger be allowed to watch any of the shows mentioned by the author? My wife may like to read the newstand gossip magazines, however they are not read in front of the children and are not left around for their eyes to see. THEY ARE CHILDREN, not adults and if we are somewhere that these "beauty" magazines are displayed, they are not allowed to read them. If we as a society choose to be adults and parents to our children, we can filter much of the sexualization out. Don't let children surf the web unattended, don't let children watch PG-13 movies until they are over 13, don't allow then to purchase clothing that is inappropriate. It's a battle, but a worthwhile one to ensure our girls grow up with self esteem and love for themselves. It's difficult, but so, so worth it....
    I'm off my soap box now.

  • Posted By: mimigirl @ 03/31/2009 1:15:39 PM

    Sparkly, I find it interesting that the one thing that you didn't teach your "good looking" young men is tolerance of others, all others, not just heavset people. Great example you're setting. It's obvious by your references in your post that your very much enamoured of your own self and feel it necessary to make deragatory comments about the "cat group" that you work with that you're as shallow as a baking pan! You're advice to your nieces should have been more to the point that it doesn't matter what others think of you, finish school, go to college and try to be a decent human being, something that is missing in yourself. It's actually attitudes and prejudices like yours that promotes a poor self image amoung women rather than all the magazine.

    • Posted By: egentry @ 03/31/2009 1:39:35 PM

      I agree with Sparkly. If you are overweight, it does not mean your not a smart, talented, beautiful person...there are no excuses for treating people poorly due to their weight...skinny or fat. But, unless you are on a medication that makes you gain weight or have an illness which causes weight gain, being overweight probably means you are eating poorly and not exercising. What diseases and health problems are on the rise? What diseases and health problems have the most medical expenses in this country? Almost all cause by poor health and diet. And don't give me any blah blah blah about genes and heredity. It's caused by what you put in your body. Research. Inform yourselves.

      • Posted By: jjones770 @ 03/31/2009 2:03:25 PM

        egentry, it's funny that you missed these and the many other scientific studies out there while you were informing yourself:

        http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2009-01/icl-cor011609.php

        http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn9002-common-genetic-change-linked-to-obesity.html

        http://www.jyu.fi/en/news/arkisto/2009/02/tiedote-2009-02-05-09-41-50-900545/

        If you want to have the opinion you do about overweight people, that's fine. But don't back it up by implying how much more educated you are than everyone else, when you clearly aren't.

        • Posted By: LoverlyLady @ 04/22/2009 3:13:59 PM

          Read any biology or genetics textbooks. Even the one I am currently looking at coppyright 1976 says that weight is a product of genes and the environment. Also, I received treatment for and am currently beating Bulima Nervosa. I am now overweight because my metabolisim is wrecked. Going from a 0 to a 12 is a product of trying to be "perfect" not what I eat.

          • Posted By: tovef @ 06/04/2009 6:25:01 PM

            Loverly Lady, I so sympathize. My metabolism is destroyed as well - not from bulimia, but from being starved from childhood by my petite, small-framed, naturally thin mother, who was determined that I would weigh 118 pounds, even though I am over six feet tall with an extra large frame (size twelve ladies' shoe). As a doctor once told her, my bones and musculature weigh more than that - but still, years of 500 calories a day and endless weigh-ins. If the weigh-in showed weight loss, I was loved. If it showed a gain, I was despised.

            Now I have to work terribly hard to remain in the normal range of weight for my height and build. This is the terrible damage done by parents who push their children into "beauty". I won't even get into feelings of no self-worth, or the damaged relationship between myself and the parent who tortured me in the name of "beauty" for almost two decades. If I had been left to develop in a healthy manner, I would never have the weight problems I have now - and I would never have to endure the scorn, derision and abuse hurled at me by the skinnies who think they're so hot while I'm just a fat lazy slob who sits around all day eating CheeWees.

      • Posted By: shelby64 @ 04/22/2009 6:06:44 PM

        You know whats wroing with what you just said? Someone who is thin could very possibly still not be eating right or exercising but happen to be thin and have a high metabolism. But yet they will not be judged as being lazy or unhealthy for the pure fact that they are thin, not because they are taking care of themselves. A thin person can be just as unhealthy as an overweight person, and vice versa. People more often than not automatically assume thinness equals healthiness, and its not the case.

  • Posted By: rkblechman @ 04/29/2009 4:59:12 PM

    That women still want to wear makeup reflects a failure of the feminist movement in particular and the immaturity of our culture in general. Makeup is a mask that allows women to tap into corporate power. I don't mean corporate as in business, but rather corporate as in the power of the group versus the individual.

    Men achieve this power by actually belonging to corporations - whether they are lodge brothers or corporate raiders. Women counter by painting their faces. Hiding physical imperfections or accentuating certain features makes sense only if the result is more power for the individual, whether sexual, social, or corporate.

    Why makeup? The French anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss once asked a native informant why his people tattooed their bodies. "Because we are not animals," was the reply. That women still use makeup is a reflection of their continuing status as not-quite-human. To put it in a more Lévi-Straussian mode, women without makeup are still seen as "natural," while men without makeup are seen as "cultural."

    By acceding to cosmetic industry standards of beauty, women who wear makeup promote a status quo that says women are not equal to men. Men can be "cultural" just by showing up. Women, to participate in the culture, must put on a corporate mask. While a woman who uses makeup is considered "cultural," a man who uses makeup is considered absurd. Mass media meditations on masculine makeup -- like Some Like It Hot, Tootsie, and Mrs. Doubtfire -- are always comedies.

    Madison Avenue-driven cosmetic companies have made some inroads into the use of body fragrance by men, but they have not yet found the right inducement for men to paint their faces, highlight their eyes, and gloss their lips. My suggestion is that advertisers market tattoos as acceptable body paint for men. Invent a tattoo "makeup" that needs regular renewal but involves some pain to apply, and your fortune is made.

    • Posted By: brock7142 @ 05/13/2009 1:22:00 PM

      Biggest issue is women are involved in social crap.

      By that, what I mean is women are more concerned of what "Guys" think of them, and always feel they have to compete with every other woman to get with "that guy".

      Their self-esteems are already screwed up as it is, they constantly feel down, men (the good ones anyways) are always having to help bring their self-esteems back up.

      I find it severely ridiculous on how women get so obsessed with make-up, they don't even realize how gorgeous they actually are.

      Just my two cents.

      -Leonard

    • Posted By: brock7142 @ 05/13/2009 1:18:48 PM

      You have some very good points, I completely agree with you.

  • Posted By: Adaiga @ 04/25/2009 1:21:18 PM

    The parents in question of the current generation were teenagers in the 80's, an era of excess and over-sexed media. The beauty industry is evolving daily, creating the new product that we "can't live without", and the average mom is probably thinking, "If only someone had told me that I would look better with this in elementary school, perhaps those years wouldn't have been so hellish." For instance, if they treat their them to laser hair removal, their daughters can avoid a life of schick and gilette not to mention a year of teasing about a "mustache". And in this era of reality television which clearly construes the idea that the more beautiful, thinner, and polished a person is, the more likely they are to be famous and successful, can you blame them?

  • Posted By: ryrett @ 04/23/2009 12:12:40 PM

    everyone go listen to a new song called 'More Beautiful You' at myspace.com/jonnydiaz and see what you think about this article.

  • Posted By: youhavegottobekidding @ 03/31/2009 3:45:52 PM

    This is one of the dumest things I have ever read....I am just hoping to avoid developing diabetes, my dad and all of his bothers and sisters have it....it is in my family's genes....The moron who wrote this article should stop writing if this is the best topic you can come up with.

    Also, if you have a child who is interested in makeup it is not a sin to wear it on occasions....somedays I do some days I don't, but it does not define me. My focus is on better health and if you are healthy you naturaly look better.
    As far at the person who state she was 5'9" and 135#'s you a little nuts and go see a phycologist I believe you could use the help....because your statements toward your co-workers seem very hateful and mean....Translation you don't like yourself.

    I think it is time we as a nation turn off the idiot box and start doing our own thing...who care what jennifer or anglian is doing or who....if you are this interested in their lives you ovbiously don't have one of your own. Most of the time my husband knows more about who and who is what in holly wood than I do.

    • Posted By: LoverlyLady @ 04/22/2009 3:27:24 PM

      Your values really show. Your ignorant response matches perfectly with your apparant intelligence. Proofread next time please.

  • Posted By: monkeyknuckle @ 03/31/2009 3:42:51 PM

    This article is irresponsible hyperbole --- seeking to make a statement the author makes it seem like EVERY kid and parent is like this. Well, they're not.

    What Jessica Bennett describes is a freak show to catch first an editor's attention, then readers' attention. It's a form of "disease of the week" journalism and typical for this publication. But by no means is this anything approaching normal.

    Are kids more image conscious in general these days? Sure, but the image Jessica Bennett creates is pure sideshow, not the main stage. But then normal kids just don't attract readers, do they?

    • Posted By: LoverlyLady @ 04/22/2009 3:24:51 PM

      Do you have children? if so send them to school and ask how many kids would wear clothes from WalMart. In my (low income) highschool there are approximately ten of us who would share it openly. It is more common than you beleive. Cost and who wears it controls a lot of today's adolescents.

  • Posted By: egentry @ 03/31/2009 1:11:55 PM

    I totally disagree with this being a huge worry. In the grand scheme of things, this is a very small population of kids who get facials and obsess about wieght. Yes, I'm sure there are a lot of kids...but let's look at the total population of unhealthy kids and worry about that. Kids eat, eat, eat and the parents are not stopping them. THAT is indulging your child. If you're at the mall and they ask for a Cinnabon, you give it to them...if you're at the gas station and they ask for a candy bar, you give it to them. If they're bored on a Friday and they ask for a pizza, you give it to them. You put a pop machine in a school, they'll drink it. They aren't learning anything about nutrition and health! They think, hey, an adult is giving this to me, so it must be ok. There are FAR more kids and teens out there who are overweight and being fed so many processed foods that they are developing allergies and heartburn at age 9. Look at the rapid increase in ADD and diabetes in children. So many kids that never exercise or step away from the video games. So many kids who whine and cry because there isn't a video to watch in the car (what happened to "I Spy" people!). At least these "divas" are learning to take care of themselves and learning some discipline. I'd rather have this kid who grows up to be a health-conscious 20 yr old, than a kid who grows up with depression and a host of health problems.

    • Posted By: LoverlyLady @ 04/22/2009 3:20:35 PM

      You don't think these little girls will be depressed when they can't dye their hair every other week, wear their bikinis to the beach, and fit into that size 0 dress? People like you are setting them up for failure.

    • Posted By: summer4077 @ 03/31/2009 2:32:01 PM

      I don't see how getting mani/pedis and highlights makes you health conscious. I've seen many many heavy teens with the latest fashions and expensive hair. Being health conscious is about eating right and being active--not about getting your teeth bleached and tanning.

      • Posted By: LoverlyLady @ 04/22/2009 3:17:45 PM

        That is the issue. What these kids are doing isn't healthy or even for them. They do this to look the way they think they are expected to look. If people went for a jog as often as people paid for lifts, tucks, lipo, and augmentation we wouldn't be having this discussion.

    • Posted By: ferrferr @ 03/31/2009 1:32:51 PM

      Have you not seen the places dedicated to facials and spa days for the tween set? There's at least 2 in my town alone, and one has a bright pink limo to pick the kids up in. When I was 12 I was still outside playing in the dirt like every other kid my age, and I'm not that old. A child shouldn't be worried about a skin care regimen or mascara. They should be having to worry about things like homework and getting help fixing their bike that has a flat tire. You know ... things kids have done for decades prior up until this one.

  • Posted By: QuantumIguana @ 04/01/2009 5:01:39 PM

    This is not the new normal, it's a media-created abberation. Everything looks normal to you when you're standing right in the middle of it, as the author is. Exceedingly few people are entering their preteens into pagents. I don't see these *** spas, I don't see preteens getting made up as if they are much older. I don't doubt it exists in some places, but it's not even close to normal. It's just a media creation to convince people that the abnormal is normal to sell more stuff.

    As far as fat vs. skinny, look at the "sex symbols" of the past like Marilyn Monroe and others of her day: today they would be considered too fat. But they are the ones who turn heads in real life.

    • Posted By: LoverlyLady @ 04/22/2009 2:48:45 PM

      QuantumIguana, that is so truthful! Sometimes I don't understand why people can thinky curvy is fat and why soft is bad. Look at pinups, playboy, and every "sexy" woman of the past and it all comes own to curves. I find it ironic that the people who worry about being sexy concentrate on looks and brands that don't support it.

  • Posted By: shelby64 @ 04/22/2009 12:21:24 PM

    Sparkly you are right, it will never change because people like you refuse to change their views towards themselves first, so they therefore project their expectations on others. If we all would learn to value our inner beauty more, society would change little by little. But Im not naive, I know that won't happen.. and like I said, there is nothing wrong with wanting to look nice, but the extreme stuff in unhealthy, and I just wish people would realize it a little bit more and work to change it rather than just saying thats the way it is and going along with societies beliefs, and not only going along with societies beliefs, but also adopting them as their own. Change what you can realistically change, and accept what you can't change, and learn to love yourself as you are. We would all be happier, just sayin.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse