SPONSORED BY:

In the Grip of the Unknown

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

The principles of epilepsy surgery have been known since the first operations took place more than a century ago: identify the area where the seizure begins and cut it out, as precisely as you can. Obviously this excludes most patients with generalized epilepsy, since you can't take out an entire brain (although in rare cases, you can remove half a brain; the patients sometimes compensate surprisingly well). Werner Doyle is one of two neurosurgeons at the NYU center; he does around 260 procedures a year, there and at St. Barnabas. In contrast to Devinsky's holistic approach to patient quality of life, Doyle's discipline requires an obsessive focus on brain stuff, on the paper-thin margin between diseased and healthy tissue. Sometimes, he says, he can feel the difference with his dissecting instruments, which cut easily through normal gray matter but meet resistance where the tissue is scarred from repeated seizure.

Like many surgeons, he is matter-of-fact about the manual dexterity he deploys inside the skull. The intellectual challenge for him is to find the focus of the seizure and trace the networks along which it spreads, while also mapping the boundaries of the unaffected areas. The basic tool for that is the EEG, but the standard device, with around 20 external leads, is a clumsy instrument for mapping a three-dimensional brain. That has led to the adoption of intracranial electrodes, which are inserted into the brain and can sample as many as 200 points. Inserting these requires opening the skull and takes as much of Doyle's skill and time—six or seven hours—as the subsequent operation itself. Patients may stay in the hospital for a week or more, trailing a Medusa-head of wires, under continuous monitoring both by EEG and video, while the doctors wait for the iconic seizure. Then Doyle goes to work.

In contrast to many types of neurosurgery—for tumors, notably—epilepsy surgery is generally performed on healthy people, and the risks are not that high. But Doyle believes, and hopes, that the future of his field lies not in the relatively blunt procedure of ablation, or cutting tissue, but in augmenting brain function through electronic devices. The first of these, the vagal nerve stimulator, has been in use since 1997, and more than 50,000 have been implanted. Its purpose is to disrupt an incipient seizure by sending an electrical signal to the brain through the vagus nerve in the neck. Again, no one knows exactly why it works, but it often does. Deep-brain stimulation, which has been successful in treating Parkinson's disease, is meant to do the same thing, by delivering a pulse directly to the brain itself, but clinical trials for its use in epilepsy so far have been disappointing. The VNS, though, is a primitive tool, which delivers a small current for a fixed duration at regular intervals of several minutes. Researchers now are working to develop a responsive device that could be implanted in the brain and "sense when a seizure is beginning, to release a small amount of medication or electrical stimulation where needed," says Harvard neurologist Steven Schachter, president of the American Epilepsy Society.

The key to such a device will be the computer algorithms that can predict a seizure, ideally in the "aura" stage that sets in before it even begins. We are accustomed to the idea that computers can process limitless amounts of data, but the brain, with its 100 billion neurons, each linked to as many as 10,000 others, is pushing the limits of information theory. The effort represents an audacious assault on a devastating disease, just what Devinsky was dreaming of in medical school. To conquer epilepsy we will have to outwit our own brains.

With Sarah Kliff

© 2009

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
Visions of a Decade
Visions of a Decade

From 2000-2009, one photo per month.

The Failure of Copenhagen
The Failure of Copenhagen

Why there could be a silver lining in a failed climate treaty.

Sex Scandals of the 2000s
Sex Scandals of the 2000s

From John Edwards to Mark Sanford, the decade's memorable affairs.

118 Days in Hell
118 Days in Hell

A NEWSWEEK journalist recounts his captivity in Iran.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: donnabarajas @ 10/30/2009 2:31:41 AM

    Donna Barajas http://www.cbs.com/primetime/60_minutes/video/?pid=GQIzNJWFeZA3_UdBSl8JcB58XdIud78c

    This episode has some interesting info on a new procedure for people with siezures. My son has had seizures for over 20 yrs and part of his frontal lobe removed. He went 6 wonderful yrs without any siezures, until a year ago. They are back... This gives me hope again!

  • Posted By: donnabarajas @ 10/30/2009 2:30:35 AM

    my son was diagnosed at 5 yrs of age with siezures, he is now 31. He had apart of the right frontal lobe removed. He went 6 yrs without siezures and now has had them again for over a yr. They are the same, only thing is now he has no memory of them coming and going. Plus, he does not remember basic things for hours, He does not recognize things or people for hours. It is sad that this disorder has gone on with little awareness and funding to find a cure! It is a horrible desease and sad that the world still hides it and is ignorant to what it is! Meds, he was everything out there! Diets he tried them! Surgery did it! What is next???? oh, prayers all across the world in every domination! nothing has worked!

  • Posted By: starinajar @ 10/12/2009 6:18:40 PM

    THANK YOU Newsweek for publishing this article. Like many others who have commented, I believe that epilepsy is something that others are scared of because they are unaware of what it really is. I'm 21 and have suffered from epilepsy since I was 13 years old. I think it's somewhat genetic for me... there is a history of neurological conditions that affect my mom's family; her mom had Huntington's disease, and my mom's sister also had epilepsy. I don't like having to live with the fear of others labeling me as insane or 'possessed' if they are ignorant as to what epilepsy really is. I think it's time that the world should see epilepsy for what it really is, and treat it like any other condition... most people don't stigmatize cancer or heart disease..

    I've been lucky enough to have a generally mild case of epilepsy. I have only had a seizure once a year until two years ago, when I started adjusting my medication. I now take Tegretol 100 mg daily and it has made me hypothyroid and therefore I have gained quite a bit of weight over the years. The reason why I adjusted my medication was because of the side effects. Of course, the rest of the world automatically assumes that if you gain weight, you're eating too many sweets and fried foods. Unfortunately, I have not had the best luck with doctors. The very first medication he put me on was Depakote at 14 years old... Depakote is not to be used as the first treatment choice for women of childbearing age unless the case is more severe; mine wasn't. There are studies that show that Depakote can increase a woman's chance of getting PCOS by up to 50%. I am very, very thankful that I listened to my own body and got off of it within 2 months due to the weight gain. My neurologist didn't even mention this to me before putting me on it. It was only earlier this year that I confirmed this fact with my family doctor. I am glad that others who have more severe cases than I do can confide in better doctors who listen to their patients and really help them.

    During my last seizure in the summer, I fell on the corner of a raised platform made from bathroom tile. It dug out almost all the flesh in my knee. I had to get stitches to fix it, and while my knee looks normal (other than the scar), I can't lean on it without it being painful. Since then, I have seen a naturopath, who I really hope can help me control my seizures while I lower my dose of Tegretol.

    All in all, I'm just glad that this article has been published in a popular magazine so that others can learn about epilepsy and not fear it as they may have done in the past. Great job!

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

My Take

Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage
to feature your favorite columnists.

Customize Now