Faith, Fear and the Wages of Columbine

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

Kirsten, 65, arrived in Littleton as a Denver Seminary student in 1974. He was asked to start a nondenominational evangelical church in the 1980s, just as the megachurch movement was beginning to take off. Today, West Bowles is a soaring modern building facing the Rocky Mountains where ministers preach a fundamentalist Christianity. "We rely heavily on scripture," says Kirsten, "and on the premise that Christ is the ultimate forgiver, the ultimate lover, and that only through him can we know the Lord."

The story of Cassie's martyrdom instantly became legend at West Bowles. In youth-group meetings, kids mourned that they could not be in heaven with her, says Craig Nason, who was a friend of Cassie's and is now the West Bowles young-adult pastor. According to Kirsten, the church's youth pastor at the time approached the Bernalls about writing a book on Cassie's life, her descent into sin and her acceptance of Jesus. "She Said Yes" became an instant bestseller.

As the months passed, new evidence began to show that it had not, in fact, been Cassie who "said yes." Another girl, sitting under another library table, had said she believed in God when prompted by Klebold, who let her live, according to Dave Cullen's new book "Columbine." Brian Rohrbough, whose son, Danny, was among the first to die that day, continues to believe that propagating the Cassie legend despite contradictory evidence exploits the grief of all the families in Littleton. "Cassie Bernall deserved to have a book written about her, but if there was reason to believe that it wasn't truthful, then it's a disservice to her memory and to the community."

But at West Bowles, the Cassie legend was not then—and is not now—a matter of debate. "People were missing the big point," says Kirsten. "She said yes with her life. So to have the entire credibility of it washed away, that hurt."

The further Kirsten got from the tragedy, though, the more he began to crack. He had survived a helicopter crash in Vietnam; two months later he had watched as fellow crew members aboard the USS Enterprise burned alive. "I pushed [the pain] down, and I did that again with Columbine. When you're in it and so impacted by it, you just don't think about the effect it's having on you." A buddy finally persuaded Kirsten to go to the VA hospital, where he was diagnosed as being 80 percent disabled with PTSD.

Marxhausen now lives south of Littleton in Highlands Ranch with his wife, and he ministers to a tiny, rural congregation in mountainous Idaho Springs. In 2003, Kirsten relinquished his pulpit, though he remains the senior pastor at West Bowles. Sunday attendance has declined from 2,000 in 1999 to about 1,100 today. Kirsten takes comfort in riding his Harley-Davidson motorcycle on mountain highways, and still goes to the VA hospital weekly for therapy. Marxhausen probably speaks for both men when he says the toll Columbine has taken on his life is incalculable. "I learned how fear can take hold of a community. You have to be prepared to hurt when you go into the ministry. But I never thought it would hurt that much."

© 2009

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
Al Gore's Climate-Change Evolution
Al Gore's Climate-Change Evolution

Using emotion to convince people to change.

Heaven Can Wait
Heaven Can Wait

A new book promises proof of eternal life.

The World's Biggest Foods
The World's Biggest Foods

Monster edibles from around America.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: mburgess1 @ 04/23/2009 12:43:30 PM

    as much as i dont want to say this i do believe it is true the police that day were absolutley useless they did absolutly nothing to save the children inside of that high school i live in colorado i was pretty young when this happened but looking back at all of the news footage and other videos related to this incident i feel like many peoples lives could have been saved if the police would have grown a pair and tried to actualy do something other than let the kids die.

  • Posted By: Insanabilis @ 04/21/2009 6:07:59 AM

    I feel that, unfortunately too many people are simply missing the point; The irony is, they feel it is them who aren't. Put simply, the comments I made a couple of pages previous are the facts and however you choose to view this, the truth is that bullying is far too widespread when it should be virtually nullified. Instead of focusing on purely religious matters or gun crime taken statistically, we should instead look to ourselves and the society we live in. Other than this, I feel it's sad that many here do not read comments made previous to theirs and endeavour to ascertain that which has been said. I can't say this enough, true evil can be found within ignorance and a despondent attitude. This is no time for despair and lashing out or talking politics. Please! People have already lost their lives in a tragedy that could well have been averted had the necessary focus and aid been given - and there are still those who feel that the answer lies in gun control or the aesthetics of a Fundamentalist line. We need more than a couple of charities and websites to get the point across, we need a worldwide solidarity on the matter and maybe then things might start to change - but, the more we do as individuals, the better still. The bottom line is we are all homo sapiens here, we are all equal and we all deserve to be treated thusly. There are no two ways about it.

  • Posted By: news555 @ 04/20/2009 8:41:15 PM

    So tired about the rationalization and defense from the status quo saying to us over and over the problem is "the victim mentality", well, wake up there are victims and unfortunately many do not have resources to get help or get attention. For instance, Foster Care children that are too often abused without hardly any compensation or caring, , or children in So. Am. being killed because they discourage tourism, or the hungry and deprived in Africa, and the Viet Nam Vets who were hardly given any benefits, and Native Americans and Blacks being treated as non humans and the list goes on. This attitude of blaming the victims is basically hiding from responsibility of the ones that are the status quo, and it prevents the process of solving problems. What makes this country more advance than others is that we are not static, we allow the system to change in order to solve problems that are presented. The ones that are irresponsible to others are the ones that insist in no change and they want the comfort zone of removing guilt from their deplorable acts. Two self center individuals in Columbian that had the audacity to cause hell to others without even having thoughts of guilt. They actually belonged to the status quo, who feel no responsibility to anyone but the almighty self and no consideration of the damage they would commit to others, and we cannot sweep victims under the rug and shut them up with clichés of ???victim mentality???, which makes the abused the culpable individual.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

My Take

Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage
to feature your favorite columnists.

Customize Now