POLITICS

Stand for Something

A conservative strategist argues that the GOP governs too much like Democrats, and needs to give voters a distinct alternative agenda.

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

Republican soul-searching about their spectacular decline has been largely focused on the wrong questions. Are social conservatives alienating young and independent voters? Are moderate RINOs (Republicans In Name Only) diluting the conservative cause? Is the message being carried by Rush Limbaugh too mean? What is Twitter? And of course, the timeless old standby, Where is the next Ronald Reagan?

It's really much simpler than all that. In fact, it's largely a two-step operation. Step 1: Join the 21st century. The GOP is still largely running their political operations like it was 1980. While the Democrats have innovated, the Republicans have not. In the business world, small companies and entrepreneurs routinely beat out the lazy big monopolists and force innovation through creative destruction. It happens in politics too, and right now, the Democrats are Fed Ex and the Republicans are the U.S. Post Office.

 
Reinventing the GOP

Republicans face a daunting challenge in re-making and re-marketing their party. Who will shape that effort? Newsweek spoke to four leading Republicans:

 

Step 2: Stand for something. Independent voters and even the Republican base do not think the GOP really stands for anything, let alone the principles of small government, individual rights and liberty that they espouse. And when they do stand for something, it is often the opposite of what they tell the public they believe.

Liberals are chronic hypocrites, but compared to many Republicans they are at least consistent hypocrites. While bragging about fighting for the poor and middle class, liberals lavishly fund farm subsidies that make food more expensive for the poor and middle class. While forcing the poor into failing and dangerous public schools in the name of supporting public education, they send their own kids to good, safe private schools. In the name of "empowering patients" they propose to ration health care and empower government to make testing and treatment decisions. While making a noisy show of taxing corporations they pretend that this burden isn't passed on to the middle class in higher prices, lower wages and smaller retirement accounts. They stridently defend free speech—unless of course it occurs on conservative talk radio or a college campus. They fight tooth and nail for certain Constitutional rights, including some that do not even exist, except for those pesky 2nd, 9th and 10th amendments. They decry voter ID bills for intimidating voters but want to allow labor intimidation of workers voting to unionize. Once you get rolling on that list, it's hard to stop! But back to the GOP.

Republicans currently have a worse problem. While liberals pretend that government can solve a lot of problems (history is not their strong suit), Republicans proclaim government is not the solution, and then proceed to vote a lot like Democrats. They spend. They regulate. They tax. They grow government. Then they hold press conferences and send out constituent newsletters claiming credit for "doing something" to fix a problem, even if the solution exacerbates the problem or is diametrically opposed to their stated philosophy. To the average voter, and especially the Republican base, this makes them even worse than Democrats. This is why Republicans can lose to Democrats even when the Democratic Congress is held in such low esteem. If you are going to hire people who live in a fantasy world to solve problems, people will hire the professionals, not the amateurs.

Even governing like Democrats might not be enough to sink the GOP if Republicans had strong or even discernable positions on major issues, but they don't. For example, everyone knows that Americans are highly skeptical of socialized medicine, or if you prefer the utopian phrase, "universal health care."

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
NEWSWEEK's 20/10
NEWSWEEK's 20/10

Our decade-in-review project recalls the highs and lows of the last 10 years.

Obama's Promises
Obama's Promises

Is the new president fulfilling his campaign pledges? Or falling short?

The Decade in 7 Minutes
The Decade in 7 Minutes

Video: A fast-paced review of the best and worst moments. Don't blink.

Accidental Celebrities
Accidental Celebrities

From Levi Johnston to Elian Gonzalez, these people never expected to be in the spotlight.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: mtntexas @ 07/11/2009 7:48:14 PM

    Stand up and identify yourselves as the pond scum that you truly are. You are politicians, we expect that. I know it sounds absurd and too novel or unique to gamble on, but have you investigated this thing called TRUTH. Shock us. Go ahead and announce that your campaign promises are a result of polling and that you have absolutely zero intentions of honoring ANY of them unless it somehow suits your needs. Look the voters straight in the eyes (or camera lens) and admit that you intend to whore yourself out to billionaires, corporations, special interest groups... who ever carries the deepest purse. Stand in a crowd of women and announce that each on is the most beautiful woman ever to walk the earth. Say that you are totally against abortion but you can't get elected while opposing it, so you'll perform them yourself if necessary. Go on record as saying that you oppose same sex marriages but will keep an open mind based upon campain contributions and backing. say you DO think gays and lesbians are snappy dressers. take a chance and shock the nation. stand firmly behind our troops but mention that tyhe VA is overspending it's budget and you hope that more soldiers will integrate into industry and use their company provided insurance. Come right out and state that old people should expect to be sick and dieing isn't so bad, really. You may just find that this 'truth' thing could catch on in a starnge way.

  • Posted By: mtntexas @ 07/11/2009 7:19:45 PM

    We don't really expect you to stand for anything. We expect you to write a book before a campaign so that major contributors can avoid campaign donation laws. We stand for that. We expect you to take cash from Israel / their lobbyists in return for ignoring their aggression and appropriating U.S. tax dollars to fund their agencies spying on us. We stand for that. We expect your wife's dummy corporation and all of your friends and relatives to reap the benefits of war or peace or prosperity or economic recession. We stand for that. We expect voluminous bills laid before Congress hiding pork barrel spending and deals in your home states and those of your 'honorable' co-conspirators due to payoffs, blackmail, and just everyday politics. We stand for that. We expect you to wipe your tails with the Constitution anytime it stands in the way of a profit for the Corporations that put you and keep you in office. We stand for that. We expect long winded speeches about what's best for our nation and why you made an unpopular decision at the expense of tax dollars and civil & human rights while vacationing and planning your retirement at the expense of industry. We stand for that. What we can no loonger stand for is the fact that you act like we, the people, are blind, blithering idiots. We can no longer stand for that.

  • Posted By: wstephenjackson @ 07/11/2009 1:31:07 PM

    Translation: Big Government is bad ... unless it is controlled by Republicans, and then it is good. The National Debt is bad, that is why George W. Bush paid it down to zero .. no wait, never mind that one. The Constitution is Good, unless it interferes with our agenda, when it becomes bad (see cross reference - Democratic Party - Inverse). Immigration is good, as long as it means cheap labor to drive down the price so that we can make more money, and as long as they actually cost us nothing, then it is bad. Torture is OK as long as we are the ones doing it (when it is not torture at all, right?), then it is bad. Nationalized Health Care is evil, it prevents us from trapping our employees in low wage jobs so that we can make more money. Money is always good, as long as we are the ones making it, otherwise it is bad.

    DId I leave anything out? Oh! Yes! .... only specific interpretations of the Protestant Christian faith are good, and everything else is, by definition, the work of Satan. How are we doing so far?

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse